Ordered Margherita and a Pepperoni pizza. Both had very good flavor and the crust had a good bite, crunchy but not dry. Ordered a salad and drinks to accompany the pizzas. Salad was good and came with two containers of dressing. Yes! The surprise? FSP included cups of ice for the drinks, how nice. Driver was very friendly. Thanks for the experience. read more

I ordered for the 1st time while traveling in Amarillo. I ordered a small pizza, a blue berry dessert and wings. It ran me $50 and although the customer service was great. I would not pay the same price again. Great customer service read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Fireside pizza small - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

First time here and Sam delivered these beautiful pizzas! They were amazing honestly and not "heavy". Thank you Sam!! Can't wait to come back!! read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

First time trying this restaurant from a recommendation. Not sure if this was a one time thing, but our pizza was awful. Very, very thin with little to no ingredients in spots . We picked up the pizza and the box was so lite we had to make sure there was a pizza in it. The taste was not good either. We've definitely had better cheese bread too. Dry bread with a little melted cheese and a few flakes of seasoning. For the cost we expected a better pizza. Most likely won't return. The restaurant did have a great ambience and staff was very friendly. read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Goodfella Pie - Large 18" - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

My husband and I LOVE Fire Slice Pizzeria! We come here regularly because of their many unique pizzas (jalapeño popper being our favorite), as well as their great wine list. It's always warm and cozy inside (for someone who freezes in restaurants, this is a great plus), and the wait staff is always friendly and welcoming. If your in the mood for pizza (or pasta), we highly recommend them! read more

Finally tried Fire Slice. Sam made me the best Margherita Pie in Amarillo on Pi Day. Will be back soon!

First time eating here and loved it Our Server Sierra was the sweetest and so attentive! Great service and enjoyed the atmosphere Can't wait to go again for brunch on Sunday! read more

This place is our favorite, it's crazy there's not a line out the door because it's that good. Best pizza and brunch in town. Best friendly and knowledgeable servers Matt and Sierra. Owners Gina and Cody make us feel at home. We feel like more people should know about our secret favorite place!!!! Get the crème brûlée French toast and the spinach artichoke mushroom frittata with blueberry sausage, you will love it with some yummy mimosas! We go often after a round of golf and love it! read more

Food is excellent--pizza, calzone, sandwiches, among other things. Good wine list at excellent prices. Good Sunday brunch, too. Service is always excellent. Pleasant ambiance. read more

Ignore Apple Maps, it's behind the shopping center. Great ambiance, welcoming and friendly to everyone. Went on a. Friday around 6pm, lots of families which was nice. Great pizza, I enjoyed my cider and the pink lemonade was good too. read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Citrus seasonal beer recommended by our waiter- so good! - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

My first time there. My sister and nephew used to go frequently years ago and recommended it. We each ordered a small pie and shared; we all took a few slices home - small was not that small. The food was great. I was full, but desserts are $3 on Tuesdays. read more

We had Fire Slice provide the meal for our company Christmas party. We had so many compliments on the food from salad to the spaghetti and meatballs to the lemon bars for dessert. Very pleased!! read more

Always good. Go at lunch time. Price is right. Heard the wine selection is great! I'm a soda drinker.

We want a friday night with some friends, even though it was a packed house, we still received good service, the food was delicious and the ambiance was great. read more

Great pizza and salad. Awesome service (Sierra, Matt and others)! Place is a hidden gem.

The Pizza was Great and we had an Amazing Waitress named Sierra...me and my family will be returning :)

My son and I decided to grab a pizza and some wings. We love to find local places to eat when we are out of town. We pulled up and my son said this place is Sketch because it's in an alley on the back side of a strip mall. Places like this tend to be amazing and they did not disappoint. The service was great and our waiter Matt was fantastic. The atmosphere was Italian dining meets homestyle kitchen. At 7 pm there was no wait but most of the tables were full. We ordered a small cheese pizza, a small Honeybomb pizza, and some traditional BBQ wings. The food came out hot but a tad slow. The bbq wings had a dry rub, not a wet sauce, but the flavor was good and the skin was crispy. The flavor of the honey bomb was perfect. Great marinara sauce, the 3 cheese blend was sharp and smooth, and the jalapenos combined with the sweet hot honey added a sweet hot explosion on the back end. The 3 cheese pizza was very tasty as well. The thin crust was cooked well and had a firm chew that I quite liked. Overall I liked everything about Fire Slice and would definitely recommend a stop here if you have the chance. I will be back next time I'm in Amarillo! read more

See all

I ordered takeout from this location while having an overnight business trip in Amarillo. I think it would've been cool to actually eat there as the place was inviting and the bar looked lively. Overall, the pizza was good, I appreciated being able to split half of it between two different styles. I had the Hula which is essentially a Hawaiian pizza and the other a hot honey pizza on the other. Couldn't really taste the honey but the toppings were generous and overall it was a good pizza. probably would not have ordered a salad as a takeout again as one pack of dressing didn't do the trick. read more

Delicious food. Better than expected. Outstanding service!!!! Peach cake is worth the calories read more

We got seated immediately. The food was okay nothing super special. But not bad. The marinara sauce was really sweet and the ranch dressing had something in it that made it pinkish. read more

See all

Fire Slice Pizzeria is literally my favorite restaurant! We have been eating there regularly for years. The service is exceptional! Matt is extremely friendly and so service oriented! Eric and Melissa are great as well! The food is wonderful from their entrees to the pizzas. The desserts and appetizers are great as well! We highly recommend the spicy cheese curds! The out of the way atmosphere is so welcoming - it allows us to step out of the hustle and bustle of everyday life, reconnect and enjoy each other's company over good food. When we ask our adult children if they want to go eat, it is their number one choice of restaurant as well. Highly, highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Like another reviewer stated, I often travel between OK and NM for work, as well as spend time in the TX panhandle. I discovered Fire Slice about eight years ago, and have made it my go-to spot for Pizza in Amarillo. The food is always well prepared, and the service is always on point. I will never get tired of the green chile cheeseburger pizza. What prompted me to write a review after so long was how Fire Slice went above and beyond for me today. I am on my way home from Albuquerque, and wanted a good pizza for lunch in the worst way. I wasn't going to make it to the restaurant until 5 minutes before they closed for the afternoon. They were happy to let me call my order ahead of time and make sure I could pick it up even if I was a minute or two late. I then had the pleasure of chatting with Cody, the owner for a while as I was eating some of my order at the bar, which sure beats eating off of the tonneau cover of my pick-up! I cannot say enough good things about this place. Please show them some support if you get the chance. You'll be glad you did! read more

After bailing out of another local place due to very bad service, we went here to have some comfort food. Their pizza was great! It's a hole in the wall, but worth finding if you want a good, thin slice! read more

Great service, great pizza, not far off the fwy. Located down the BACK ALLEY! (I missed that part and had a little trouble locating.)

The best lasagna I've had in a long time. And I've been to Italy multiple times. Service was great. Wednesday is half price wine read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Lasagna and Blackberry Bread Pudding to go - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

My husband and I were passing through Amarillo at lunchtime. I found Fire Slice thanks to my friends on Yelp. It was helpful to know the entrance was in the rear. Melissa was our friendly waitress. This was our first visit. The room was cool and inviting. I had a side salad and The Honeybomb. My husband had The Americana. We were both very pleased with our food. The pizza crust was crispy, chewy. The dessert menu had several selections but we were too full to try one today. We will be returning and saving room for dessert next time. read more

See all

We went at 11:00 Saturday morning for my brunch group. It took a long time to get coffee! The majority didn't really like their meal and it took way too long to get it. For ordering pizza, it's probably a great place. but brunch, not so much ! read more

Very delicious pizza here and they offer gluten free if I remember correctly. Fun atmosphere that has live music at times and nice employees. Only left a star off because while still good, many of the times I came, the crust was a little burnt on my pizza. read more

We went back in September of 2023 while visiting our son. Great pizza! Cool atmosphere. Good people with great service.

Loved the Cajun Bone in wing haven't had good wings in a while. The pizza was amazing

This pizza is SOO good! I've dined in and taken to go. Fav is called Combo. Small can feed two people with no leftovers. read more

I have been eating at Fire Slice for years! The owners are super friendly and attentive to providing great selection and prices! They update the menu offerings regularly with new items and also have specials monthly and quarterly which are fun. You get to try new things that chain pizza joints never provide. The atmosphere is more quiet and enjoyable than most restaurants and that is a plus when entertaining friends or just wanting to have a nice conversation over your meal. I am a business man and give nice wines to clients and friends that I purchase at Fire Slice. The owner Cody is a level 2 Sommelier and has a deep knowledge of wines and how to pair them best. His wife Gina is well known and loved in the community. Together they are a powerhouse couple who really know how to give back to the Amarillo area people. Great food, great wine, great times....That's what you get at Fire Slice! read more

I'm a traveling Electrician throughout NM and Western TX, and this is one if the best pizza I've tasted in awhile. I ordered the Honey Bomb and I wasn't disappointed! read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

First time in Amarillo, decided to visit this restaurant. Got lost, the GPS took me all around. Ended up finding it behind the plaza by the alley. I really liked their original wing sauce. The Calzone was not go my liking it needed more cheese. read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

Best pizza in town IMHO. Good pasta dishes too but a limited selection. Salads are fresh and delicious. Nice choice of beer and wine (full bar). It's clean and inviting and the service is always excellent. We love this place. read more

Great service pizza exactly how we wanted it. May be the best pie shop in town. Had a cozy table after being seated promptly. Excellent.

Excellent service and th pizzas are phenomenal. I have been there twice and it was amazing both times. The salad was fresh and we ordered our pizza extra crispy and they delivered. Can't recommend this place more than to say, I will always eat here in Amarillo. read more

Was passing through town and wanted pizza so we decided to try out Fire Slice! Ordered online and had it delivered to our hotel room and everything was great! We ordered the jalapeño cheese curds, hot mama pizza, and BBQ dry rub wings. I'm not a fan of cheese curds but my family is, however I do have to say these were some of the best ones I've ever had! I loved the spice and the sauce and the cheese was perfectly melted and creamy. The hot mama pizza was great with just the right amount of sauce. The wings were quite delicious too although I didn't really get any BBQ flavor. read more

We went to a wine dinner here for Bella Glos wines and it was outstanding. Maybe the best wine dinner I've ever been to.Cody paired amazing pizza with the wines and we just had the best evening. Great atmosphere!! read more

Really good service waitress was really nice. The food was really good. Had very good desert. I had an amazing experience.