Simply iconic. You must eat the taco pizza. It's insane. So good. And the shack sticks!!read more

Forever the best. This place has always had the best pizza. The crust is amazing and I'm so happy…read moreto taste that it's still the same! The Louisiana hot sauce tradition is alive and well and the place looks great. A little nostalgia & the best pizza in the world (I've checked.) I would drive hours just to get this pizza and really appreciate that it still lives up to the goodness of my high school and college years 20 years ago! Thank you all so much, my hometown needs the Pizza Shack and I'm so glad it's still there and still yummy!

Heartbroken to discover this cafe was closed four years ago. I have great memories of this place in…read morethe early '90s when I was a college student in the area. RIP plate sized cinnamon rolls!

off to a rough start with staff harping on bad behavior by a common acquaintance while I waited to…read morebe sat and again to order... the cafe is kind of a big place across from the motor inn and attached to a service station; dates back to when people travelled by car and these cafes used to plate good food at good prices for locals and the motoring public. I got coffee, asked for hash and eggs and waited a little more, but at least I had coffee :-) I like when my food fits on one plate, especially if it's a really big plate: whites weren't quite set on three eggs up, potatoes were browned but not quite crispy, corned beefs hot all the way through but still too moist... half a minute longer on the heat and everything would have been excellent... btw: two rye toasts were lightly buttered and perfect.

I really enjoy Pagliais. It is a friendly family welcomed atmosphere…read more The pizza buffet is a great price. If there is a particular pizza you would like to try or to cater to your specific dietary needs, they will prepare it & bring it to your table to give you 1st slices before putting it out. I start my buffet with a predominately Spinach based salad. There is a variety of toppings as well as dressings. Next is the spaghetti & mac & cheese. Both are very good & the little ones really enjoy it. The cheese bread is awesome & the pizza's are usually out in about 6-8 different varieties. It is simple, but good. This family run business has been a round many years. Hire's the college kids. The people/kids that work here enjoy their job & each other... You can see it in their behavior & performance.

Just what you want from a small town, family owned pizza place. We were there during the week and…read moreenjoyed their nightly buffet. They kept the drinks full and our stomachs even more full!

I'm not sure who was working the evening shift on Mar 14, 2025, but my order was absolutely…read morehorrible. I just ordered a super supreme and a small personal, so not a complicated order, but it was really really bad.... I have gone there for years and it has been pretty decent most of the time. Definitely NOT 5 star, but usually 3 or 4. Tonight I'm only giving it a 1 star because I can't go any lower.... The pizza was cold and for some reason tasted stale.... Even the personal pizza I got for my kid was terrible. So, bland crust, zero salt... It only had half of the amount of toppings and cheese it should have. And over all tasted horrible. Unfortunately because there are not a lot of options in a small town, places like that tent to not care about quality or service.

They had a great buffet and salad bar. The pizzas were fresh with a variety to choose from. The…read morestaff was friendly and attentive. Best pizza I've had in years!

Got this taco pizza for around $23 ish…read more Pricey but very good! There buffet needs serious help! Very, very few options. Tried several times. Most of hot side half empty or very old. Salad bar sad. Very limited. No good pre-made salads (potato salad, slaw, pasta salad etc.) Places could be a gold mone for buffet but Chinese place a few doors down, way, way better.

Great pizza. Very proud of their pizzas. Expensive food. Love the pizzas but wont pay those prices…read more Businesses need to stop raising their prices if they want customers and to be successful.

The guy Quez with the long dreads who work register very intelligent man I come in every night he's…read morealways greeting me and my kids great customer service love when he's working

We ordered a pizza through the Casey's App, and were told the order would be ready by 1:53 p.m…read more I arrived on time, and gassed up before going in to give them a few more minutes.. when I went in I assumed my pizza was ready because the kitchen was quiet (I work in a local kitchen myself). Not only was my order not ready and waiting, it hadn't even been started. On top of that there was a fella waiting (patiently & being ignored by kitchen staff) ahead of me and his order hadn't been started either! Thennn the kitchen sprang to life. Replete with attitude, and excuses. To make things even worse, a Grandpa came in with his two granddaughters & come to find out he had actually ordered before me! The first fella couldn't wait, and frustratingly cancelled his order. Grandpa and I talked while we waited. He was in town visiting family from Kansas City and was understandably surprised by the fact that a slow, small town Casey's was having trouble getting a few orders out, when much busier stores in his neck of the woods preform far better. I agreed and shared my experience working in a fast paced, very busy pizzaria during college. Our conversation ended with "good help is hard to find" of course. The only employees that seemed to care about our situation (by now two more families had come in and were waiting as well), were the cashiers on duty. I didn't catch both of their names, but the most helpful of the two was named Ashley. They genuinely wanted, and tried to help. Model employees both. My order was finally ready around quarter after two. I realize that 20 minutes longer isn't an extremely long period of time to wait, when a place is busy, but it of course wasn't. Not when I arrived and caught them slacking anyway. A piece of advice; if you're not ahead in a kitchen, you're already behind!

My hubs and I had a great experience at Il Lazzarone! The Neapolitan pizza was new to us. It's…read moredifferent than anything we've had. The waitress did a great job explaining and her recommendations were spot on! We started off with the bruschetta. It was very fresh and layered with flavors! We then ordered the Salsiccia Italiana (Mozzarella, Sausage, basil, olive oil, sea salt) and the Crepa (Mozzarella, bacon, basil, garlic, balsamic glaze, olive oil, sea salt). We both agreed the the Crepa was our favorite but they were both very good! The Italian sausage was very flavorful. We ate half of each pizza and saved room for dessert. Our waitress recommended the S'mores with added cookie dough. It was so yummy and worth the calories! We love supporting these type of specialty restaurants in St Joe. We will definitely be back!

Super cute and intimate place with delicious food. I think it would be really cute for a date…read more We came with a party of six, got six different pizzas, and two appetizers. Not one item disappointed, everything was delicious. My favorite items were the Burrata, the Greco Formaggio, and the Margarita D.O.C. The server was great and the restaurant smelled wonderful. And since it's so intimate you can see your pizzas getting baked in the epic oven. This restaurant is an hour away from my home but I will definitely be coming back.

All new management. All new owners. Food is 10 times better. Buffet runs all day. Can get any kind…read moreof pizza you want just by ordering a Buffet Your Way. Best chicken, salad bar & buffet in the Midwest! Cleanest most comfortable restaurant in town.

Pizza Ranch is a favorite for us! Staff are always kind and professional when we visit, which is…read moremore than I'd like to admit. The pizza is delicious and well stocked, as well as the chicken, salad and dessert bar. One of my favorite things about pizza ranch-they are a Christian company and have Christian music on each time we go. It's always clean as well.

Great food! Homemade everything! It's been an age since buffets were a thing so we were surprised…read morewhen we walked in Ham, prime rib, fried fish all fantastic! Desserts that bring back memories of my childhood...there are so many choices it's kinda impossible to have it all lol but my goodness, it's so delicious you can't help but try! (You can also order from their menu, I saw an impressive looking cheeseburger on a nearby table ) The staff is efficient and super friendly! Evenings can get busy but they keep the food refreshed and there's no significant wait. We were traveling through the area a couple of years ago and kinda stumbled upon this little spot since we were staying nearby. We never miss it now when we come back!

It's like Golden Corral 2.0, nothing gourmet or home cooked…read more Possibly refried or warmed over?. Pretty much out of the Sysco or Ben E Keith box reheated places on the steam table for the Goy. You serve yourself just like the sign says "family style, serve your damn self".