Pagliai's has definitely been great the last several times we've visited and ate from the buffet. Don't forget to eat a monster cookie for dessert. The servers are always kind and attentive and it's clean! read more

Just what you want from a small town, family owned pizza place. We were there during the week and enjoyed their nightly buffet. They kept the drinks full and our stomachs even more full! read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maryville, Missouri

We were in town visiting family. We went to Pagliai's for dinner with two of the grands. We all got the buffet and it was great. The salad bar was fresh, nice and cold, and had lots of options. The pizzas were a great variety and we all enjoyed them. Their cookies for dessert were so good, chocolatey and chewy. Many of the reviews say folks had to wait for a table, but we didn't. Our drink orders were taken and filled quickly. We would definitely go back. read more

Enjoyed a lunch while watching our daughter in the MIAA Conference track meet. All the items on the buffet were excellent.

So I travel quite frequently for work, and get the chance to experience all the local sights. This place though has to be top tier. The service is outstanding. Almost guaranteed to leave fool and satisfied. The food is pretty phenomenal as well. With an excellent salad bar that really gets the job done. The atmosphere is definitely small town which is not a surprise. Overall I give it a 8.8 out of 10 read more

Was the best buffet pizza place I have ever had. It was legit pizza the service was great! I would definitely go back again probably two times a week! read more

It's a good pizza for a town with limited options. The crust is a bit thinner than I prefer, but it was overall good.

Pagliai's is a hometown favorite for a reason--food & service are consistently timely & pleasant. Buffet allows opportunity to try favorites like their homemade spaghetti (the buffet version is spaghetti already mixed in sauce; personally, I prefer the spaghetti there served as an entree, versus the buffet version). Salad, cookies, cookies & cream cool whip, hot chocolate cake, cheesey garlic bread, garlic bread, speciality pizzas, single topping, etc. ALL available on their buffet. If you've never been here, TRY it. You'll be back read more

Everything was really clean. People were superfriendly. The food was great. We had the buffet and tried a whole bunch of.. All of them were good. read more

Was right after they reopened. All orders were for out the door which meant the buffet had absolutely nothing on it. We tried to order food to take with us and was informed it was too long of a wait for them to take. Needless to say we paid full price and left hungry. read more

best pizza in a 200mi radius. If you don't see what you want on the buffet, ask and they will make it and give you first dibs on a slice.

Food is pretty good, especially for the price and variety. Where this business excels is in service! Even when busy they will have somebody check on you regularly. I even requested a dessert pizza for the buffet and they made me my own mini pizza! Excellent staff, overall welcoming people. read more

Do you guys purposefully disconnect your phone so you don't have to take over-the-phone orders? Maybe lazy workers? Do better.

The spaghetti is great here! I normally will NOT eat spaghetti at a restuarant but this place is the exception! It is soo yummy! And of course the pizza is super yummy! All kinds and soo good! The buffett is yummy and cheap...well actually most everything on the menu is priced nicely and you get a lot for your money! And if you're a little child you get pizza dough to play with while you wait for your order! How great is that!? read more

Ok, 5 stars, people. 5. Stars. Here is why you should believe me: --My mom's family is from Maryville and I've been eating at Pagliai's Pizza since I was little. --Lots of my family members have worked here and know the best kind of pizza to get. --Pizza is my desert-island food, so I know good pizza. Yeah, super great pizza. Thin crust, delicious sauce, and good toppings. PLUS, their spaghetti is to die for. Seriously. They're not overly cheap, but it's better than Pizza Hut or Dominos and you're supporting a local business, so that's okay! p.s. The absolute most amazing pizza there is green olive, bacon, and onions. Do it! read more

I really enjoy Pagliais. It is a friendly family welcomed atmosphere. The pizza buffet is a great price. If there is a particular pizza you would like to try or to cater to your specific dietary needs, they will prepare it & bring it to your table to give you 1st slices before putting it out. I start my buffet with a predominately Spinach based salad. There is a variety of toppings as well as dressings. Next is the spaghetti & mac & cheese. Both are very good & the little ones really enjoy it. The cheese bread is awesome & the pizza's are usually out in about 6-8 different varieties. It is simple, but good. This family run business has been a round many years. Hire's the college kids. The people/kids that work here enjoy their job & each other... You can see it in their behavior & performance. read more

For a while Pagliai's really let me down. I have been eating there for 15 years and they kind of let it go down hill (my opinion was the put to much energy into their buffet). However, as of late they have been getting back to what makes them good. Pizza. I don't know what they did but I am becoming a fan again. They have a great house special and their cheese bread is out of this world. I would recommend it as the best pizza in Maryville by far. read more

This is a really good local restaurant with great food and good atmosphere. You have a good option of food but I it can be a little pricey. The only big issue with this places is seating there is not enough room you could only seat about 50 people but I do recommend stopping by if you have time. read more

It's an ok pizza. Not great. Best in Maryville. Tomato sauce is very plain. It's better than the other choices. read more

See all

A Maryville classic. Just as delicious today as it was 20 years ago! There is something for everyone with fresh salads and pizzas with tasty crust and just about any topping you can imagine. Our server was fantastic and handled our large group of 30 with patience and a smile. It's a must stop every time we visit Maryville. read more

I grew up on Paglias and absolutely love this place. The Buffett is the way to go! Macaroni, spaghetti, pizza, salad! Yum!

This pizza restaurant has a great buffet. I love their spaghetti and salad. The pizza is wonderful. If you leave this restaurant still hungry it is your own fault......great any time. read more

Stopped in based on yelp recommendation and I was not disappointed. I showed up at lunch and surprised by an excellent lunch buffet. Lots of good food other than pizza (which) was hot fresh and abundant! read more

This local pizza joint is awesome! My wife grew up with this place and I was lucky enough to experience when I went to college. We now make it a ritual to come here every time we are in town. The pizza and spaghetti buffet are the best deals. The spaghetti has its own unique flavor that is irreplaceable. When kids come they let them play with a ball of dough to make shapes and characters then nibble on a bit. The kids area always offered a little toy or trinket on the way out. This place covers all angles and always leave with a full stomach! read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Amazing pizza Greg made!!! - Pizza Near Me - Maryville, Missouri

I ordered a pizza to be delivered last night and had a terrible experience. The first hint I should have seen was when the guy answering the phones didn't know ANYTHING. When I asked him a question, he had to ask someone else. Also worth noting, that their menu attached above isn't their menu. The guy had no idea when I asked about ordering fettuccine alfredo. This could have been understandable, except when he said 20-25 minutes and the delivery guy showed up an hour later. When he showed up, I was expecting the total to be $13 (as the guy on the phone said), but he told me $15. It would have been nice to know there is a $2 delivery fee tacked on. Now to the food... I've had better pizza before, and this defiantly doesn't rank in the top. If you want any pizza, go to Casey's General Store. They have great pizza (although I haven't tasted it down here, I'm sure that it is similar to the one in my home town). read more

This summer they did a little bit of remodeling. Opened up the place a little so it doesn't seem so crowded. Changed the decor and updated the seating. Much needed improvement. Pizza is still the best in town. Recently added their own thick crust pizza to the buffet. read more

Great buffet, if you want to add a pizza to the buffet, all you do is ask and they will bring it right over to your table first to give everyone a slice before putting it on the buffet line. Great pizza, always fresh. Salad bowls were huge and I made the mistake of putting way too much lettuce in the bowl. No tomatoes at the salad bar which was usual. All veggies tasted fresh and flavorful. The ranch dressing was yummy. Dessert: must try the chocolate brownies on the buffet - to die for!!!! Oreo salad is like a moose with Oreo in it, a must have too. I didn't have the dessert pizzas but other there said they were excellent. read more

Great pizza. Have the buffet so you can try all their pizzas. Spaghetti was great too.

Came to Maryville to attend a funeral and stopped in based on other reviews! Great buffet for a decent price. The dessert pizzas were the best I've ever eaten! The pizza crust was fabulous! A crust between hand tossed and thin! My 15 year old loved the bacon pizza - my favorite was the taco. I wish we passed through town more and believe it might actually be worth a trip from Kansas City just for the pizza. Nice job everyone! read more

Of all the pizza places to choose from in Maryville, Pagliai's is the best! Their buffet is always stocked with warm, fresh pizza and when you don't see something you like, they are happy to make specialty pizzas by request. For the price, there is simply no better pizza place in Maryville. read more

It is basically a hole in the wall, but clean enough. The staff is exceptionally friendly and the buffet is beyond delicious. I am not a fan of thin pizza but this is really good, The desserts are to die for. Worth the time to find and price is great for what you get. read more

Okay...I want to start out by saying, Pagliai's would've received 5-stars if they would just expand onto the building, they are very popular in a Maryville (POP:10K) and to go in on a weekend is torture, it's so crowded. Ahhh. small price to pay for the best pizza in Nodaway County. I highly recommend their bacon strip pizza. I grew up there and every time I go back, I make it a point to stop in. read more

Lived in the 'Ville for a total of 16 years ... this has been my favorite pizza ever since. Haven't been back for longer than I can remember and it is still as good as always! Nothing has changed and that's a good thing! read more

The buffet was stocked with hot pizza that was full of flavor, and fresh vegetables for salads. The whole staff was very friendly! Affordable, and is a great pizza place to be a part of a college town. read more

Visitor to Maryville for a couple weeks. Ordered a medium house special delivered to my hotel last night. Opened it and pizza was folded in half and toppings were stuck to bottom and top of the box. Appears it was thrown around. If you get delivery make sure to check the pizza. Also didn't like the fact that the pizza had no crust. Thin crust with toppings all the way to the edge. read more

Best thin crust pizza anywhere in the world. Great buffet, reasonable price, and everything including salad bar is always fresh.

Great place. When I visit my grandmother its a must stop. The spaghetti is fantastic.

Pagliai's is the best pizza in Maryville, which isn't saying much. Monday"s is best time to eat here, this being pizza buffet night, which is always crowded with college students because of the cheap price. The place is a little small for the amount of tables they stack into the dinning area. But other then that this is a pretty good small town pizza joint. read more

I delivered pizzas when I was in college. Brown was a great boss. The food is great. All the high school kids hung out here. It was a great first job. Its a Maryville icon!!!! read more