Very tasty handmade pizza made Subway style to order at your request. Locally owned and operated generally one of the owners is either helping out or managing staff. The atmosphere is very clean and simple and you get to refill your own sodas which I like. They only have one slice of pizza and it's cooked in a Woodfire oven with a rotating stone at 1200°. So it only takes about three minutes to actually cook the pizza after it's built. They have lots of topping options as well as a lot of recommended pizzas that you can order off the menu. They also do salads and chicken wings, which are very good. For dessert they have a few items, including cannolis and hand, scooped ice cream. I'm really sad. They got rid of the cup pepperoni just recently. But otherwise everything I've had here is excellent and they make one of the best. Margarita pizzas in town. Highly recommended and support local. read more

See all

One of the best pizza experiences we have had! They were on time, pizza was delicious. They have creative toppings and lots of options.

Stopped in again while in Casper for an amazing crust. Excellent customer service and probably the best pizza in Wyoming. Keep up the good work! read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - Pineapple, basil and vegan cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Food was great. We are pizza people, white brick oven is my personal favorite. Theirs did not disappoint. The true star of the show was the wings though. They came without sauce which immediately sent red flags. However the seasoning was delicious! We came to town for a graduation and had car trouble so we did delivery. Food came fast and tasted great. Will likely grab again before leaving town! read more

Wonderful crew and amazing food! The flavor of fire grilled food is the absolute best!!!

We came 3 deep for lunch today and as usual the pizza was delicious, now the service.... The teenage boy who took our order was a challenge to speak with as he had zero communication skills, but again the pizzas was good, i know how hard it is to get good help and that is why i still have left 5 stars but seriously this needs to be better. read more

See all

The food was incredibly delicious. The pizza was particularly amazing. We also ordered wings, which were generous in size. However, the pizza truly stole the show! I'm planning to return to try out their other pizza options. read more

The staff is friendly from the moment you walk in the food is always served fresh and hot . Definitely the best pizza in Casper read more

See all

Delicious pizza, good customer service and quick. We will be back if we are ever back in Casper. read more

We liked you get an individual pizza and that it is wood fired. Easy to find location with plenty of parking.

Similar in concept to Mod pizza chain. Order at the counter. Fast food ambiance. Good place for pizza and a salad.

The folks here are super nice, friendly, respectful and all the good and lovely things about humans. We very much appreciated the service and engagement and that is worth noting when younger people are managing. Too often I experience untrained, teen-aged staff as dismissive. These kids are alright! The ambiance though left a lot to be desired, feeling very much a typical strip mall vibe, lacking any notion of character. Really though it's the food that draws locals (and us travelers) to its doors so let's get to that. Pizza, generally, is almost always good, and that's the rub with Firehouse. The pizza was *only* good for a place with such high ratings (the reason for our detour). It is mostly unremarkable in presentation and taste which, based on the principle that there is no bad pizza, means yes go here and eat pizza - most will not be disappointed. Not sure I would come back if say Dominos or Pizza Hut were more convenient (being a cheaper alternative to only wanting a good pizza). The biggest improvement to satisfy my palette would be the crust. It was undercooked (on both traditional pizzas we ordered), doughy, and needed some decent proving and a bit longer bake. I think that may help this thin crust style pizza (traditionally notable for a crispy-ish bite) achieve at least another satisfying star from me. 2 stars read more

Always a good, quick place for pizza. Service is a bit hit or miss but the food always makes up for it.

Best pizza in town! Hot honey is a must try!!! Pasta, garlic bread, and all the pizza is really good

Great place we found driving through! Wings were fantastic! Gluten free pizza was not the best- but other than that- service and other pizzas were fantastic. read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Absolutely wonderful. Fast and friendly, fresh ingredients as well as many choices. Will be back.

Firehouse pizza was great. My daughter and I stopped here traveling through town. My daughter had the margarita pizza and I had the backdraft pizza. The crusts were very crispy and thin. The toppings were very good quality and both pizzas tasted fantastic. I really enjoyed their spicy sausage and pepperoni on the Backdraft pizza. The service is also very good. They are friendly and welcoming and happy to serve. My daughter also had a cannoli, which she said was tasty. The restaurant is very clean and sort of a Nuevo cafe. I highly recommend this pizza place if you are in Casper Wy. read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - Backdraft pizza spicy sausage and pepperoni. Margarita pizza in background. - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

Best pizza we've ever had! We were traveling from California to South Dakota and needed a place to stop for lunch. The people working here are very nice and the pizza is amazing! If you're in Casper I highly recommend this place. read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - Pizza Firestorm - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Holy smokes! In Casper for work, and happened to find this place. Freaking great pizza! Quick service & the prep/cooking didn't take long at all. Wood fired pizza definitely is some of the best! I got the chief pizza (May have the wrong name..) and it had Whole milk mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta, aged sopresso, pepperoni, basil and honey drizzle. Honey may sound weird to some, but holy cow it is the perfect touch the compliment the cheese and meats! Will definitely return! read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - The chief pizza (I think that was the name) - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

Great pizza and experience. I had a hard time finding what I wanted on the menu on the yelp app. I ended up ordering 2 pizzas and an order of garlic cheese bread for kids. I asked them not to make the cheese bread too garlicky since it Would be for kids. The pizzas were delicious and my kiddos loved the cheese bread. Food was ready to pick up in 15 minutes. They even have a 20% military discount which is very much appreciated! Thanks for a great experience. read more

I've been craving build your own personal pizza type of places like Blaze and Pieology so I decided to check this place out. Placed an order online and order was ready in a timely manner. I decided on the Pizza Firehouse and Pizza The Chief. Both pizzas were really delicious and definitely worth the price which isn't bad at all. I will definitely be coming back for more pizza. I think next time I'll build my own pizza and try the lemonade and/or dessert. read more

Great pizza!!! Super place to stop when you are traveling between Phoenix and Las Vegas. The crust was thin and crispy and the toppings were all fresh!!! read more

It would be like if round table threw a wood fired oven in and didn't change their ingredients. The honey hot wings were disgusting as well . If this is the best pizza In Casper then I suggest you might want to venture out. Then the owner messaged me saying that they would like to fix whatever my problem is but they can't understand my English . I stated what my problem was the hot wings were fucking nasty and you use subpar ingredients in your food. I think my English is pretty clear smart ass read more

Best pizza in Wyoming , great service and the environment inside is great. Love seeing my pizza bake in the oven. read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - The Chief - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Best pizza in town. Great service. Great restaurant and clean and fun. I don't think there's another pizza place that compares in town.

Some of the best pizza we've ever had - the Jevin Backon is our favorite. Yes they have smaller pizzas, but two of them happily fed our family of 4 with left overs. read more

Best pizza in town. They are always friendly. Pizza is quick and tastes great. Dining area is always clean and tidy!

We've twice now had pizza delivered from this establishment by Windy City Delivery and it's been great both times. Crust is amazing and toppings are fresh and delightful. We ordered more than we needed the first time and even properly reheated it was delish! Definitely our "go to" delivery pizza place in Casper! read more

Delicious food!!! Friendly staff! Quick service! Pleasant atmosphere! I really enjoy this restaurant!

Best pizza in town hands down. Mike, you don't know what you're talking about with these guys. The pizza the chief is off the chain and the mango habanero wing sauce is mother effing delicious. read more

Amazing pizza and great service. Quick oven baked as well. Thanks Firehouse, we'll be back!

Their cheese is not without rennet which is baby cow stomach enzyme. I checked and complained. They said they would keep the non animal rennet cheese, the cheese they use to use on hand. I went clear over there around the time the owner said that and they didn't have it. Also they are very stingy with their basil and i think that is dumb. I wanted it on my dessert pizza and they are always trying to up charge me. And to the guy below, I already talked to the owner before. In addition i told them about the basil. read more

Ordered the NY 11" pizza $9.95 with extra basil for 50 cents. I was amazed when they called our name, because we were only sitting for about 5 minutes. But the pizza was absolutely dripping with oil. I would have taken a picture of our plates and napkins, but thought it would look suspicious to take a picture of our food after it was all gone! And there was barely one basil leaf torn apart on our pizza. read more

Wood fired pizza is delicious. We did carry out. The staff was very friendly and helpful.

Hands down...one of the best Pizza Joints I've ever been to! Professional, courteous, and helpful staff....and food is to literally "die" for! The Chef is what I chose and the cheese melted in my mouth as the spicy sweetness of the hot honey, the best pepperoni and just the right crust....brought my tastebuds to a new level...in my book, this just became #1 in my list for pizza!!! A must have if you swing thru Casper, WY!!!!! read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - Last bite! - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Easy, quick and good. One topping pizza special was a great value at $3.97. Made to order, hot and good. Lots of choices or build your own. My $5.97 salad was good. Restaurant overall was clean, well lit and had a good flow from ordering to paying. Table tops could have been wiped down as not too many people in the restaurant at the time but four behind the counter. Three of available tables were dirty. read more

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired - One topping build your own. Pepperoni on this one. Out in five minutes. Special tonight at $3.97. - Pizza Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Consistently the absolute BEST pizza, incredibly quick service, and such pleasant people there! It's always very clean as well. So thankful for such excellent pizza at great prices in Casper!!!! Thank you!!! read more

The pizza here was very good and the people making the pizza are very friendly. It was nice to just go in, order the pizza and take it back to our hotel room. read more

Ed knows his stuff! Dough is amazing and cooked to perfection. Great sauce both red and white. Fresh mozz on top and you cant go wrong. Would recommend the Margherita pizza paired along any beer or wine. read more

Great, innovative pizza and menu. Quick service. Enthusiastic staff. Food is consistently good. Salads are great too! read more