It makes me sad to write a (very long) review like this because Fish used to be one of my favourite go-to places in Paris, but after my last two experiences I won't go back. I would give them one star actually, if we hadn't had a number of lovely evenings here in the past. The standards unfortunately seem to be really different these days, which is disappointing because Fish used to consistently be good.
I came in a few weeks ago to make two reservations because I had two sets of visitors coming to town, both wanting good food in a cute place, so I thought this was the perfect restaurant. I saw the server write down my reservations in the book, and thought it would all be ok. I turned up for my first dinner here on a relatively not-busy Tuesday night with my cousins to be told that no, I didn't have a reservation. Which was impossible because I saw the woman write it down in the book for that night. Anyway, I got a table thankfully because it wasn't too busy, but would have been really bummed if there had been nothing available because I came to the trouble of physically coming in to make sure my reservation would be taken into account. The food this evening was ok- nothing amazing, but fine. Had an ok piece of fish with very few vegetables, but I think my cousins had good food. The server we had was really not friendly, barely checked on us (Fish usually has more attentive service than your average French resto), and overall was just kind of unpleasant. Before leaving I made sure to double check my reservation for the following week, and they said they had it marked down.
So I came back on Pentecost for dinner with my mom, grandmother, and boyfriend, and maybe because it was a holiday things went wrong, but honestly I don't think that even excuses the food or service of this evening. It was somewhat of a disaster from start to finish. My starter of potato soup was ok, but my mom and grandma apparently really did not enjoy their mackerel (it had no taste, and they both added a lot of salt), and my boyfriend said the same thing about his clams. Then the main courses came- my mom and boyfriend both had an ok sea bass, I had a baked fish (supplement 8 euros to the normal menu) which was ok, but my carrots were rock hard and I could barely cut them, but overall things tasted ok. My grandma ordered the lamb, which was really really tough, and she couldn't cut through it (we all saw it, she could not get through the chop), so we told our server and she apologized profusely and took it away. Then she asked if my grandma wanted something else, so she said fish. A few minutes later, she was brought another plate of lamb by a different server (maybe he was the manager?), and was asked which piece she had trouble with, and then was told that it was probably the bone she was trying to cut. The three of us saw her struggle to get through the meat, and it was most definitely not the bone, but a piece of meat with some gristle or something all over it so she couldn't get through. She was so embarrassed at this point, to be told that she was probably trying to cut the bone- actually we were all embarrassed because it just wasn't ok, and she was quite upset, to the point she wasn't hungry anymore. This was such a bummer because we were there for our "nice" evening out in Paris, and the whole experience was just so bizarre with that comment, as well as the mediocre food. At least they took her menu off the bill, and offered her some wine, but still, it was a comment that should not have been made, especially somewhere where we have known the service to be really good. read more