On the website, it says that they're closed at 10 me and my friend arrived at 9:08 exactly and we…read morewalk up to the door and all the workers are still inside and they just stared at us and I was like I thought it closed at 10 and they didn't even say anything and we didn't get our ice cream and it looked disgusting inside.

ew. All the tables were dirty and I mean all of them. I would normally just wipe it off but the…read morestains were so caked in, they wouldn't budge with an ordinary napkin. The employees were literally just standing around doing nothing even when there was a line of customers waiting to order. Mine was staffed with two teenage girls who looked dead behind the eyes. And then they had the audacity to ask for a tip at the register. Girl, I had to wave you down from whatever trance you were in. Told you twice what I wanted and you still got it wrong the first time. I am not giving you a tip for that bum service. Honestly I don't blame them. They're probably underpaid kids, this is a managerial issue. Two employees behind the counter, not one cleaning. Some weird 30 year old guy eating his takeout on one of the tables inside. Normally I don't care about bringing outside food in but when there's an outside area, bro take it outside. As for the ice cream, it's baskin robbins. You'd have better luck just going to the rouses next door and getting a couple pints of bluebell. It'll cost you about the same. I would be happy to see this place shut down, and I've been coming here since I was a kid.

Great ice cream and service across the board! The staff here are so sweet about accommodations and…read moresampling. I also love that they are open all year and don't close down like other shops!

I'll start off by saying that the ice cream is really good! I love that it's homemade. However, the…read moreservice is usually not great. That being said, they are usually teenagers who probably don't want to be working after school & such. It's up to you what you're willing is accept for decent ice cream! If you want good service AND ice cream, go to Benny's. This place definitely works in a pinch though.

Tonight we tried the new Smasher Burgers at Sonic. Neither of us have been real smash-burger fans,…read morebut it's growing on us after tonight. Petunia got the double, but me, I got the triple. I definitely recommend the triple; the patties are super-thin and crispy - which is terrific on the burger, I just liked the extra meat. We ordered them like they came; cheese, onion, pickle, Smash sauce on a potato bun. With the crispy salty patties, creamy cheese and sauce, plus the crunchy pickles and pungent onions, this was a really nice flavor experience - kudos to Sonic for this one, I liked it as much as the garlic butter burger. - First-date tip: hold the onions! They were super delicious, but very strong flavored, and I wouldn't have even wanted to kiss myself after eating them. :) The Groovy Fries were, well, GROOVY. And not just the crinkle-cut, they were extra crispy, but not overcooked, and are going to be my new go-to as long as they last. Tots are king, but when these fries are visiting, I'm grabbing 'em. The Groovy sauce wasn't our favorite. Eh, it was creamy and a little spicy, but there was something in it I didn't care for. No big deal, of course, I keep some CFA sauce on hand for these kinds of emergencies. Finished up our order with a couple of giant drinks, mine with lime and cherry. I really enjoy squeezing the lime into what's left of the ice, then chewing it up with the cherry. It's like the dessert you didn't order! Speaking of ordering, we used the app tonight. Man, that was cool - placed the order from the warmth of our home while the car heated up, got in for the short ride to the store and checked in...seconds later we were on the way home with our hot food and the memory of a perfect smile from our lovely carhop.

I'm only putting a 4 star because of the great service we received from the carhop. Unfortunately,…read moreI didn't catch her name, but she was great. However, after asking if yall were busy (we had a pretty long wait time for our food), I was stunned to find out that she was the only person taking out food, and that the manager had just up and left. I feel so bad for that poor girl, and I hope she can find a better job. Treat your workers right, they're the backbone of your entire store. Other than this, service was great.

Very disappointed to walk in the door at 8pm and be told, "oh sorry. We're closed." We didn't…read morerealize it closed at this time, especially as it is summer. A favorite ice cream stop of ours. We wish the employees would be better aware of never turning a customer away - there were still customers sitting inside eating their treats, and the ice cream nor toppings had been put up for the day. They had not even begun to break down. Maybe offer something to go next time.

very dissatisfied walked in at 1:00 pm and they were sold out of everything and they were very…read morerude, they did not even close, even when out of everything, they can't ever get new shipments, they should close and never reopen.

For some reason I really wanted a coffee milkshake, and it turned out they're harder to find than I…read moreexpected. Nostalgia has a whipped coffee sundae, so I decided that I had to try them. It was good! The place was cute - pretty standard "Instagramable" aesthetic, but still - and the menu had a number of unusual, refreshing options. I will return to try some of their other treats!

On Tuesday we went here to get ice cream after go to eat Paco Tacos. This was my wife & mine first…read moretime to eating ice cream here at Nostalgia. It was truly delicious, it is a hidden gem.

The turtle Is amazing. I asked the server if they were told to put less chocolate and caramel and…read moreshe said yes. I get them way too much so I could tell. It's a sign of the times; everything goes up in price and you get less.

Well, I can't say too much for the custard. I just don't like the flavor, but the staff was very…read morewelcoming and friendly. I can't wait to come back to eat one of their hotdogs or one of their fresh made sandwiches.

Love the owners. Very nice…read more It always seems clean. The snowballs vary in quality from year to year. I think the ice could be finer. They could probably sharpen the blades of the shaver. Location is excellent, right in the center of Madisonville with short walk to restaurants and the river. Good amount of syrup and okay prices. Not my favorite, but it will do if you have a craving.