Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fudge N Stuff

    3.7 (41 reviews)
    InexpensiveCandy Stores
    Open 10:00 am - 6:00 pm

    Fudge N Stuff Photos

    Fudge N Stuff - Ice Cream - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - a closed for the season sign - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - a person holding a bowl of food - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - There's a lot of yum in that tiny box - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - a display of various items - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - a woman behind a counter - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - Fudge time for my friends back home - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - Fudge n stuff (and my dad and my brother) - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - a variety of popcorn boxes - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - a variety of chocolate bars - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - Candy - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - Bespoke candy - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York
    Fudge N Stuff - Left to right: pistachio, dark chocolate sea salt caramel, chocolate amaretto - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York

    +21

    Fudge N Stuff - Fudge - Candy Stores Near Me - Montauk, New York

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fudge N Stuff

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Retna S.

    The lady who owns the store is super friendly. I could sample a lot of fudge. My favorite is the one with cappuccino. The red velvet is pretty good and so is the rainbow.The have reduced sugar version too but not as good as the regular kinds. Everything is great. Highly recommended it. Cash only.

    a display of various items
    Mariah B.

    Came here on our recent trip to Montauk for a nice fudge fix. They did not disappoint! Fudge was excellent. I purchased chocolate, rainbow cookie, red velvet and vanilla, although they offered plenty of other options. Each slice was super fresh and soft. Prices were affordable. Fudge N Stuff also offers candy and freshly popped popcorn. Check this place out!

    Bespoke candy
    Daniel B.

    What is a summer beach town without a good sweets shop for the kids? Fudge N Stuff fits the bill nicely. In a town not known for modest prices on anything, this place delivers with a $2.25 kids sized ice cream cone, a gazillion packaged candies, and chocolates by the pound (or fraction thereof). But clearly, the coup de grace is the cotton candy. Not just cotton candy... cotton candy made to order. I can't even get cotton candy made to order at most carnivals, circuses or fairs. They are all pre-made these days and shoved into bags, hours before you buy them. Can't blame the vendors per se, because making the stuff is such a mad sticky mess. BUT, Fudge N Stuff sells the real deal. And you can pick red or blue. Granted, the blue isn't terribly blue... but that's probably for the best. When you go, just be prepared to wait. And to be yelled at. Not in anger, mind you, it's just hard to hear above the roar of all the sugar-high kids.

    Cotton candy with gummy worms
    Mike N.

    My favorite ice cream place in Montauk. I have the ice cream taste of a 6 year old so I love getting a dish of cotton candy with gummy worms. Also gotten cones, sundaes, etc and have never been disappointed. Their fudge is great too. It's not a vacation in montauk if I don't stop in here 2-3 times during the week. Great spot.

    To go box.
    Lourdes M.

    Visiting the town is a must when you go to the East End-the Montauk. On this town , Fudge n stuff is a place that you should swing by especially for the fudge affectionates. Various flavors are available, original recipe of the owner, homemade , had a take out of the quarter pounder cream and butter for $4.95, smooth, sweet and creamy . It includes a mini-knife in the packet. The place sells ice cream, sundae and regular and old fashioned candies as well. Cute and charming small shoppe.

    Left to right: pistachio, dark chocolate sea salt caramel, chocolate amaretto

    See all

    Photo of Ele W.
    0
    12
    6

    10 years ago

    Got their 15 minutes before closing and the woman was super friendly. We ended up getting fudge and a shake. Mmmm.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Fudge N Stuff

    When does it close???????????!?

    They close every night at 11 pm

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    Candy Shop

    Candy Shop

    3.6(14 reviews)
    22.2 mi
    $$

    Cute little candy shop! Self service so you can choose as…read morelittle to as much as your sweet tooth desire

    The Candy Shop in downtown Mystic is a true delight for anyone with a sweet tooth. Located right on…read morethe dock next to the drawbridge, it's not just a candy store--it's an experience that blends nostalgia, variety, and handcrafted quality! -Selection & Variety * Over 200 different types of candy, ranging from chocolates and fudge to classic confections and nostalgic favorites. * Handcrafted fudge is a standout, with 16 flavors made fresh daily, including specialties like dark chocolate caramel sea salt and cookies & cream. * Beyond fudge, you'll find hand-dipped caramel apples, pecan and cashew clusters, and pre-wrapped chocolates and taffies that make perfect gifts. Atmosphere & Location * The shop is family-owned and operated, adding a warm, personal touch to every visit. * Its location on the Mystic drawbridge makes it a charming stop while exploring downtown. The interior is quaint, clean, and filled with the irresistible aroma of fresh sweets. * The nostalgic vibe brings back childhood memories, making it fun for both kids and adults. Service & Experience * Staff are friendly and knowledgeable, happy to guide you through the wide selection. * The presentation of the candies and fudge is inviting, with colorful displays that make browsing a joy. * Many visitors note that the shop feels like a "sweetest place in Mystic", thanks to its combination of candy, ice cream, and fudge under one roof. Whether you're picking up a gift, indulging in a caramel apple, or just reliving childhood favorites, this shop makes every visit memorable. Cheers

    Photos
    Candy Shop
    Candy Shop - Whistle Pops

    Whistle Pops

    Candy Shop - Chocolate Nonpareils Yummy!

    See all

    Chocolate Nonpareils Yummy!

    Fudge N Stuff - candy - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...