Bake shop is for take out only. The coffee beats anything on the Montauk strip in the morning- lots of customers, so always fresh pots served. Pastries were very good AND a bit expensive. The service is slow due to a great assortment of goodies and customers who have to get their own coffee for the first time in their life. As long as you are OK with takeout, great place to go! read more

A true gem in montauk! That coffee is great & the pastries are even better. We got a glazed donut, cranberry scone, pecan cinnamon roll, and every flavor of rugelach. Food was so good we forgot to take pictures. Staff was friendly. A must visit! read more

Run, don't walk to these croissants. Both the jelly and the cream filled were so amazing we had to go back a second time and get more to take home with us. Can get busy in the mornings. We did wait online that was outside, but it moved quickly and we were glad that we did personally wasn't a fan of the bacon, egg and cheese. The cheese was not melted at all, but the pastries and the fresh juices were definitely worth it. read more

See all

Lots of options in this grab and go bake shoppe. I've only tried the sweet items- none of the breakfast items, but we've enjoyed the things we've got. The cinnamon swirls are good but lean on the dry side without a ton of frosting. The apple crumb cake is delicious. Boston crème donuts from here my boyfriend always loves. Chocolate chip cookies lean a little thinner crunchier- like tates. I also tried their empanadas recently- plaintain and cheese- very greasy and not a lot of flavor. Service is prompt at the counter and they're always pretty well stocked. We'll be back for more sweets this summer. read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

Cute little bake shop in Montauk Village! Upon walking in, I was greeted by who seemed like the owner. He recommended me the jelly croissants (which were sold out) and the cream croissants. I got a cream croissant and a crumb cake. They also had a huge variety of cakes and cookies, no Ice-Cream though (I checked the freezer!) The cream croissant was good. Flakey on the outside balanced with the perfect creaminess on the inside. The cream reminds me of Bavarian cream inside donuts. Must eat the day of so it doesn't leak onto the crispy outside. As for the crumb cake - one of the best I've had. It was still good the next day when I brought it home. What caught me by surprise was the amount of bees hovering over the pastries behind the counter. Thankfully, they were not flies. I also got one of each of the Montauk iced teas to try. I have not seen them anywhere else in Montauk. There are about 5-6 different flavors. Will definitely be back for the cream croissants, crumb cake, and to try other baked goods! Great service! read more

See all

Excellent! So good we returned before we left Montauk on Monday morning. Yummy breakfast wraps (# 3 & #5) plus delicious jelly stuffed croissants & latte! JC (Juan Carlos) was wonderful. He took our order to go over the phone and the pickup was easy & smooth. Very busy line both days we were there but they're efficient, lots of employees taking orders so it went fairly quickly. Worth the wait! read more

Only tasted there's cookies and they weren't unforgettable. The place was packed and not a lot room to sit down. Service was friendly. The prices steep. read more

I came here for lunch with my family on a Saturday. It seems to be the best bakery and really the only bakery in town. We ordered their focaccia paninis (All American, Chicken BLT, Turkey Avocado). It does take a while to prepare the sandwiches but it's worth the wait. They do give you a beeper so you can come back to pick them up. The sandwiches were giant and the bread tasted fresh. They also have doughnuts, cookies, cakes, and even Dubai chocolate bars. I would definitely recommend for the sandwiches! read more

A bakery that does sandwiches well. $16 for a hero or foccacia pressed is big enough for two. Having tried the All American, Turkey Avocado, and the Chicken BLT, the BLT was the best. read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - Checkout - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

This bakery used to be phenomenal. I have certain favorites there that I have been getting for years when I come out to Montauk. However, as of somewhat recently, this establishment is under the management and the baked goods are not nearly as good. You can absolutely taste the difference, particularly with the jelly and custard croissants... they now have a much more deep-fried flavor than they previously did. I used to drop a lot of money at this bakery when I would come out here and always bring a ton of stuff home when I left... the bakery really isn't worth going to anymore. read more

NO to the jelly croissant. Was excited to try the local town bake shop so I asked the attendant to recommend the most popular pastries and she did. She was kind and patient. Unfortunately I tried two "stuffed croissants" -- one with cream filling and one with a jelly filling. I would certainly ONLY get the cream filling one as the other was crunchy and sugar-dusted on the outside and not good. I couldn't finish it. It was too hard, had no wow factor, and was just sweet. Maybe my palate prefers subtle pastries. The cream-filled croissant however, was very soft and the cream, subtle/not overly sweetened. I wouldn't go out of my way or stop if walking by to get either one though. Unfortunately they were unremarkable. Looks like a lot of other great options though!? read more

See all

Moldy bread, spotty service. Bought a loaf of bread and when I got home saw that the bottom was covered in mold. Must have been sitting at least a few days to become like this. You would expect bread from a bakery to be 1-2 days old at most. Consistent with past reviews about moldy cakes. read more

You must get their jelly crossiants! 50 years in the making. I got a full box of goodies and was not disappointed. I've tried their plain crumb cake, blueberry crumb cake, BB muffin, rainbow cookie cookie, chocolate cookie scone. All were great! read more

See all

Came here on my last day in Montauk with my wife because she wanted a jelly croissant. This place is well known for their jelly croissants and I had a bite, which it was very good, but I got an egg sandwich. I got 2 eggs sunny side up with bacon on a roll and it was perfection and the roll it was on was amazing. Great spot for bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and pastries. I def recommend this place for excellent breakfast. Can't wait to come back! read more

Amazing and timeless. The fish and lobster cookies are a must have in montauk. They've been making them the same for decades

The jelly doughnuts seem to be what they are famous for and when in Montauk it has become a vacation food tradition. They do otherwise have a great selection of other sweets to choose from but those lobster and fish shaped cookies could probably give up the shelf space to something more attractive. For those that need their coffee fix this is the go-to place as well. Why the signs about cell phones not being welcome in the place I am really not sure. The service is somewhere between rude and bad, but the lines move quickly. Why five stars with this kind of service? To me, it is an odd part of the charm of going here. To some degree, like Durgin-Park was in Boston (RIP after 200 years of service), this place wouldn't be the same without the quirky service. The place is also small to the point where it is sometimes hard to navigate the people waiting to place their orders and people waiting for their orders. Yet, having to make this comment tells you it is still a must-visit if you are in Montauk. read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Breakfast in Montauck. The bake shoppe has so much to offer. It's tucked on a side street with a few other breakfast choices. I'm a sucker for bakeries so we went here. SO and I decided on breakfast sandwiches. His had sausage egg and cheese on a bagel; I had the bacon egg and cheese on a croissant. Choices are a plenty when ordering. Don't want a sandwich? No worries; so much was available if I were here for a week, you could come in every day and get something different. Coffee was delish! Don't want breakfast? Come back for dessert. So many choices. Cake? Cookies? Filled Croissants? Sweets aplenty. Staff are quick and efficient. Prices reasonable. I can see parking could be a problem during high season. read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - Croissant sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

Donuts, breakfast sandwiches, lots of really nice pastries and the scones were massive a bit pricey but well worth it!!

People who work here are nice but, unfortunately and without any doubt, the worst ham, egg and cheese I've ever had in my life. It tasted like it was fake eggs and microwaved. I might as well have been eating the bag in came in. read more

Customer service is excellent! Their bakery items are fresh, delicious and prices are reasonable. I've enjoyed their hot oatmeal for breakfast and I love their coffee. Their most popular items are their jelly and custard filled croissants. Yummy read more

Must have when in Montauk. They are famous for their jelly filled croissants, which are mouth watering. If you see a line, it went fast for us. We happened to walk by a second time a saw no line and hopped in for a second round of the jelly filled croissants. read more

They have the best fried jelly croissants. Yes they have them at other bakeries but for some reason i find these to be the best. They aren't cheap with the jelly filling either. If you are out in Montauk make this one of your stops for sure. read more

See all

The jelly croissants are great- when they are fresh. Too many times this summer. I found them stale when I got them home. Don't know how many days they hold them if they don't sell the first day but too expensive to take any more chances. read more

We stopped here because we heard they had wickedly good jelly donuts. The bake shoppe is a small store front right in the middle of busy downtown Montauk. We stopped in and we were overwhelmed by the number of things that looked good to us and our kids. The donuts looked tasty, the cookies were attractive, and it smelled great. The man who helped us out was super friendly and polite. We got a bunch of stuff and enjoyed it all. The winner was probably the cream filled croissant, which was crunchy, sweet, soft, and really excellent. This is worth a stop if you are looking for a baked good for breakfast or a snack. read more

See all

Stumbled upon this place while friends were getting food elsewhere. I got lucky ordering from here! Name led me to believe it was strictly bakery but they have a great selection of sandwiches. I ordered the Cecilia Rose. It was delicious! And a sizable sandwich so I had lunch for 2 days! You of course must try the baked goods! They have a jelly "donut" croissant. Amazing! Be careful biting into it though because it's overflowing with jelly, which I'm not complaining about!! The jelly is the right level of sweetness and being it's a croissant there's not too much dough, just light fluffy layers. I also had a standard jelly donut and they're good as well. Can't see myself not coming back here for baked goods when I'm next in MTK! read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - The Cecilia Rose Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

I found this cute little bake shop on yelp when I was planning a trip to Montauk. The food is bad. I ordered "avocado toast" .. the bread isn't even toasted. It was a bread sandwich with avocado mashed inside. It was terrible. The sausage egg and cheese was mediocre too. All around disappointing. I ordered a couple baked goods and they were not great. I was kinda shocked. When you walk in to the bake shop Everything looks so Good. But the pastries don't taste great and the breakfast food is terrible. read more

See all

What happened to the best darn Almond Croissant on the East End? This isn't it anymore. Once a special bake shop. Today new owners are friendly but bakery is generic and not close to its former self. Flat soggy likely pre frozen croissant. Geez. Nothing tempted. Montauk prices Always willing to try again and see if I missed some great things. Can't believe only gave 3 stars all those years ago. Looking back so fondly now. read more

I'm back to being a fan after my most recent visit for lunch. I tried a turkey Avocado sandwich and it was so big and filling that I split it with my wife and we were both full afterward. And it was tasty. By Montauk standards, their lunch sandwiches are almost a bargain. And at 130 on a weekday there was no wait and they had all of their usual bakery items. read more

Very friendly and helpful staff, knowledgeable on the products. Jelly croissant is a must have here. Good amount of fillings, croissant is soft and moist, the texture is similar to donuts, covered in sugar. Really good. The cruffin is another specialty here. It's a muffin with crumb cake topping and cream cheese fillings. Really good, it has strong nutmeg flavor on the crumb topping. They have sugar free muffins too: blueberry, apple, banana walnut. The sunflower seed bread is really good too. Fresh, moist, and has a good crust on top. Baklava is delicious. It's fresh, it stays intact with enough sweetness. Not too much but fillings. Rugelachs are decent. Apple danish looks delicious but it turns to be doughy. read more

See all

Really needing something sweet my friend and I stopped here to fulfill our need. I got a piece of crumb cake and my friend got an almond croissant. Crumb cake is often dry and this one did not dissuade me from that opinion. But it usually has some nice chunks of sweet on top. The topping was begrudging at best...just a wee sprinkle of powdered sugar. My friend's croissant was not a croissant. It was kind of fluffy baked something that was curved. The almond filling was negligent but the lack of even one layer of pastry was appalling. The texture was like a Pillsbury Crescent Roll. You would be better off with an honest Entemmans than anything from this bakery. read more

The filled crescents are the best. Coffee is okay. Line is usually pretty long but moves quickly. Worth a visit when you are in town. 5 stars read more

Went her to get sandwiches and coffee as we headed to the beach. I ordered the grilled chicken focaccia and a medium iced mocha., what I got was a Caesar salad wrap and a small iced mocha. My daughter ordered the Buffalo chicken wrap with no tomatoes and a medium iced caramel latte, her wrap was correct, but they gave her a medium caramel iced coffee. When my daughter asked how come there was no milk in her latte the girl said "you ordered an iced coffee not a latte" and you have to do the milk yourself. I asked her why was my coffee smaller than my daughter's and she said because I ordered a small and my daughter ordered a medium... again wrong. So after waiting 10 minutes for the sandwiches, I decided to check and make sure the order was correct and of course it was not. I went back inside and told the girl that I was given the wrong sandwich and she decided to argue with me. I said do you not remember me asking you what kind of nut was used in the pesto and you said I don't know. So why would I ask about the pesto and then order a chicken Caesar salad wrap? Needless to say, I'm disappointed in the fact that I had to tip upon payment using the credit card, and gave a 20% tip. That's why at a restaurant you tip after your meal is over and you enjoyed your service. Disappointed in the service and then when we got to the beach, the wrap and the sandwich were both sooooo dry! read more

The best coffee in town! The staff is super friendly and helpful. The jelly donuts seem to fly off the shelf. They even had SOURDOUGH bread that I needed to make lunch. I paid in advance but left town earlier than expected so don't forget me because I'll be back to get my loaf read more

It used to be our go to- not anymore. Egg sandwiches were always amazing- gone downhill sad to say. Canned, wet mushrooms make for wet bread sandwich. Coffee is good. Stay away If you have peanut or hazelnut allergies, it used to be peanut free. They have a big stand of nut cookies right on the counter now. Weird and unsanitary read more

Nice quick stop to grab a cop of coffee. Came here during the Montauk Clam Chowder fest the Saturday of Columbus Day weekend. It was windy and cold, but inside the bake shop, the smell of fresh pastries and coffee fills the air. Now, space is limited, standing room only at this joint. You peruse the display case as you wait your turn to order-- and be sure to keep it moving! On our visit, we got the Egg on Croissant w/ Swiss (big for a croissant, but flavor was plain), Jelly Croissant (flaky and sweet, bursting with jelly--- have those napkins handy), and coffee (they keep many pots hot and percolating. While most everything was spot on, I felt the prices were kind of high (but on par I guess for a resort town), and there was nowhere to stand/move when things got busy. Since it was a festival day, it was very crowded in the shop, but only 3 staff behind the counter and in the kitchen, making for quite the back up. Outside the shop are picnic tables & benches, and they will give you your order through the take-out window. Will remember this place if I'm in town again, was still a convenient spot to grab a cuppa. read more

See all

Ordered a half sheet carrot cake Gluten-free and vegan. The cake was okay but was very expensive. $282.00 read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - Half sheet cake $282.00 - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

This looks one of the more popular places in town for breakfast. It is a small shop so not many can fit in there at one time especially with Covid. I really liked the jelly croissant which is famous apparently. It is the best thing I had there. It is covered in sugar and tasted freshly made unlike some of the other stuff. Cinnamon swirl, plain crumb cake, and almond croissant all were definitely a day old. No shot they made them fresh and I could tell. Maybe next time I will ask what is made fresh that day instead of guessing. I will say the hot food was solid. The egg and cheese on croissant was good. I also tried the same sandwich on a roll and it was also good. Something that was a little offputting was that there were bees in the store and on the pastries. That seems to be normal in montauk since I saw that in some other shops. Not the biggest fan of that and it kind of bugged me out. There were some good things and not so good things. I'm not dying to go back. read more

See all

Avoid this place by all means... It has to be the worst breakfast spot in Montauk. 30 minute wait for a bacon egg and cheese sandwich and when I got it it was cold... It was freezing out and there were groups of ppl waiting outside for food to come. Also... $17 for a crappy sandwich, a roll, two coffees. If you're going to charge that much you should make it worth it. Check out Joni's instead! read more

Montauk Bake Shoppe - Egg on a Bagel with bacon and cheese - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

First time in Montauk and I absolutely needed to come here for breakfast! The Pecan Bars are amazing came back for more before heading back to the city. Key lime tart is impeccable . And the bacon egg and cheese on a crossaint was delicious as well. Definitely will be a staple for our next visit . read more

Love this place! Excellent baked goods and friendly staff :). My family comes to this bakery every time we are out East!