Awesome local candy shop in the heart of town. Tons of verity, and charm! They even had the old school dot candy on paper that brought me back 30 years to my childhood! read more

The Candied Anchor - Party Supplies Near Me - Montauk, New York

Always a friendly face when visiting! Our family always makes a quick visit to the Candied anchor with each visit to MTK. Unique selection, great beverage selection including specialty ice coffees to sip while you savor your favorite hard to find childhood and international candies! Try it you'll feel like a kid again! read more

The Candied Anchor - three children sitting on a bench - Party Supplies Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

This is a super sweet & adorable shop with all kinds of yummy, unique, specialty and retro candies from all over the world. The place is small and can get crowded quickly but boy, is it chock full of options! They even serve "Mermaid Tea" which is basically just bubble tea. There are a good number of bulk candy along the walls and packaged candy in the middle & some shelves. Behind the counter are individual chocolates and truffles. Some of the types of bulk candy they offer: Pale blue chocolate drops Chewy strawberry lobster claws Chewy cherries Raspberry cordials Assorted chocolate balls All around the rest of the store, there are: Chocolate bing cherries, champagne bubbles, gourmet flavored marshmallows, milk chocolate malt balls, peach rings, lollipops, Kinder Joy eggs, Pocky sticks, popcorn, taffy, Cadbury chocolate bars + other British brands, Charleston Chew, Oh Henry, Turkish Taffy, honey, colorful rock candy, smarties, gum and much more, including cute little trinkets. I bought the following: Tropical punch yellow, blue & red gummies from Spain - These were delicious! Delightfully chewy with awesome fruity flavor Chocolate with caramel & marshmallow center - Gooey and delectable! Cherry Fun Dip - A sugary retro classic I also ordered the "Mermaid Tea," choosing the Chocolate Almond flavor with pink, blue, orange, green, white and yellow sprinkles on top (for an additional 50 cents). This drink is made with powder flavoring and without dairy products. It was smooth and quite chocolatey... There wasn't much taste of almond at all but it was still enjoyable and the tapioca pearls were of decent quality. The ladies at the shop were very welcoming and answered all questions about the different kinds of candy with ease and expertise. I would definitely come back and stock up on more candy if I am in Montauk again. read more

See all

Candy shops seem to be the go-to place in Montauk. Unfortunately, you cant go in the store but you can order some stuff at the door. Damn Covid... They have every candy you could possibly think of. It brought memories back of my childhood and I wanted to try everything in the store! I ordered the milk chocolate cookie dough, milk chocolate brownie bites, and some gummy bears. All were very nice and served by weight. The lady who was helping us was very nice and we were happy to support the local business. The prices are typical of Montauk and so expect to overpay for basic candy but its ok. We were on vacation and wanted to indulge in some treats. Check it out! read more

See all

Take a step back in time for n this retro themed sliver of a candy shop. For a tiny place, the Candied Anchor is jam packed with tons of candy and chocolate. You can find the retro treats of your childhood along side some delicious contemporary modern creations. My son adored the chocolate covered caramel popcorn and the chocolate covered Swedish Fish! Candied Anchor also sells baked goods and party supplies. It's hard to resist passing by and not trying something! There is also a Southampton location on Job's lane. Will have to take a look next time we are visiting. read more

See all

Jillian, the owner of Candied Anchor is a well established business woman of Montauk. The atmosphere she creates in all her spaces comes from her special touch of creativity. When she commits to a job or project, she is all in and really embodies all aspects of what the client wants and executes it effortlessly. She is a wonder to work with and I highly recommend hiring her for your next event if you really want to WOW your guests. ALSO SHE HAS THE BEST CANDY IN TOWN. You heard it here first!! read more

You definitely have to stop here if you visit Montauk! Located right on the Main Street it's the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth! They have all sorts of different sweet treats and even a few unique candies! read more

The Candied Anchor - the outside of a candy shop - Party Supplies Near Me - Montauk, New York

Wonderful selection of imported candy and chocolate, friendly staff, open year round as well !

It's my kids' favorite stop in the town with all sorts of varieties to choose from. The owner with the rocking pink hair is always so patient and caring to help them fill their bags. I also love the sour strips! Can't want to return for some stocking stuffers inspo. read more

Such a cute store. I was able to find some of my old time favorite candies. So much good stuff! Lots of fun gummies and chocolate treats of course. read more

This was the most unique selection of candy I have seen in a while. A charming family owned shop with interesting drinks, mochi and fantastic candy & gift options! I am a huge candy store visitor and this was one of the best I've ever seen! read more

yay! Candy! Great selection - even had a few favorites of mine - like allsorts and chocolate covered marzipan. Great place - just a bit TIGHT so don't bring big bags in with you. read more

Bummed we couldn't go in - we ordered from the door, but the options were vast. Kids left happy - tons to choose from including old favorites. Adults were able to enjoy fresh, homemade chocolates as well. A very sweet spot not to be missed while in town. read more

I can't believe no one has mentioned the cranky, mean lady who runs this place. I'm pretty sure she just doesn't enjoy children and didn't realize that being around kids comes with owning a candy store. We stop here when we come out to Montauk, and bought $30 worth of candy yesterday, but the way she rushes us away (when no one else is waiting) and is so cold in general will make it the last time. read more

The BEST candy shop on the island!!! Totally worth making a trip out for! They have candy from all over the world! It's like a childhood dream and the women who work there are are just so kind and fun! We drive all the way from Queens to pick out new candy to try and to replenish on our favorites! Don't be afraid to ask for recommendations on the candy, they always pick out great things! read more

Great candy and the owner is a sweetheart. I recommend the coconut clusters. I tried going back twice to get more before I left, but she wasn't open :( read more

Way too small and cramped candy shop in Montauk has a tiny selection of chocolates and candies. Interestingly, they have a small selection of English and Japanese candies. Very small selection of assorted truffles as well. Want to fill a bag with goodies, I found the $6.25 for a half pound to be reasonable. Only problem, such a small selection. Nice place to stop by but too small. read more

See all

The Candied Anchor is my new favorite spot in Montauk. Jillian (the owner) has an awesome aesthetic, as well as great taste in candy. Try the gummy grapefruits and the rum filled chocolate balls! I also started following her on Instagram @candiedanchor. Her pics are the best little moments of candy, color, and happiness. They brighten my day every time! read more

Yum. Dark chocolate pretzels with Carmel. Lots of interesting chocolate choices and friendly service. Nice layout and clean. Epitome of perfect candy store. read more

The Candied Anchor - Chocolate, salt, crunch, swallow, repeat...... - Party Supplies Near Me - Montauk, New York

Delivered a beautiful gift box for my friend's birthday. Presentation was gorgeous and same day delivery!

I can't believe I've never written a review on this place! The owner is very charming and friendly. The place is very nicely decorated and located. Lastly they have the candy you want. Just like I want tortellini soup on every menu in an Italian restaurant is the same as I want to see original Astro Pops in any candy store. They have it and more!!! Go get your sugar on read more

Delicious and fresh candy. A hidden gem in the corner of Montauk's town. I love to come here every time I'm in town. I came in today and all of the gummy's were fresh. I love the owner's array of foreign candy, those are always my favorite because not only are they delicious but she travels all over the world to get the candy. The chocolate bees from Germany are my favorite! I also love that they are open during the winter Friday-Sunday! read more

Come and enjoy the whimsy of Willie Wonka's Chocolate Factory combined with the class of the Hamptons. The owner is lovely and made our children feel welcome. Located right next to John's Pancake House, it is in the perfect location and I have no doubt it will be a Montauk landmark in no time. The selection of candy is impressive beyond the standard variety and the prices are reasonable. Welcome to Montauk. Anchor's away! read more

Love this place! Jillian, the owner, is a Montauk local and is the absolute sweetest girl. She's got super cute party supplies as well as a fun assortment of candies. They also have different signs outside for the holidays that you can stick your face in for a nice Montauk memory. I'll definitely be back!! read more

Cool candy spot in Montauk, pretty sure the only one. A little pricey for candy but hey its Montauk!

I love candy! I love this store! I love all their cute things!!!

We wandered in here today because the outside was so pretty- The owner did an amazing job at merchandising and sourcing really interesting and delicious candies. This is a great addition to Montauk! read more

Literally sweetest shop in town! It's a must visit in Montauk. They have every kind of candy that you could want from all over the world and all through time! My favorites are the crunchie bars from Ireland and the caramel coconut crunchies. The girl who was working was super helpful and answered any questions we had. Will definitely be back read more

"OH MY GOD THEY HAVE ICE CUBES!" --quote from my mother, who hasn't eaten Ice Cubes since she was young. I spend part of the year in Montauk with my family and this past Thanksgiving weekend was the first time we were there since this new store opened. As a girl with a huge sweet tooth, this place definitely met and succeeded all my expectations. First off, this is the most adorable little store. Another review here calls it a "candy coated pinterest board" and yeah. It pretty much is. The woman we talked to was very nice and helpful as well, and there were lots of options for people with allergies/food issues (gluten free, sugar free, certified nut-free, etc.) I, trying to limit myself, only bought a fancy chocolate bar but given the opportunity I would try anything and everything in that store because they all looked great. (The chocolate was delicious, by the way.) I remember there being two other stores in the same spot (an ice cream store and then a barber shop) that did not stick around for particularly long. I hope The Candied Anchor does, though, because I'll look forward to visiting it when I'm in Montauk for many years to come. read more

Finally an amazing candy store in MTK so we do not have to travel to EH to go to that "other" candy store! Jillian (creator/owner) is beyond lovely. Candy selection and ice cream amazing! Selection of extras (pinatas, banners, etc) also amazing and can be customized. And the space itself adorable, cheerful and aesthetically pleasing! Candied Anchor is my 8 yr old daughter's new favorite destination....even if just for one gummy shark! ha. Thanks Jillian for creating this MTK gem!!! read more

This place has the freshest candy! It just tastes way better than anywhere else! I complimented the owner on the freshness of the candy and she said that b/c they have no storage she re-orders four times a week as she runs out of items...which means that the candy is always fresh. Cute and unusual packaged items, gifts, etc. I really love this store. The owners are very nice. Reasonable prices (50% less than Dylan's). read more

If you choose where you shop based purely off of aesthetic, this spot is great. Overall, unoriginal. Small shop, expensive prices for the product even in Montauk. Better off getting a bag of candy from the supermarket. Tastes exactly the same but costs half the price. read more