The Candied Anchor

Fudge n stuff is a placr I always have to stop at when we go down to Montauk…read more I always look forward to their rainbow cookie fudge but sadly they haven't had it the past 2 times I went. This prompted me to try the mint chocolate fudge which tastes like an andes mint. It was just perfect! The woman who owns the shop is lovely and she is passionate about making delicious fudge. I always have a great experience when I come here. Highly recommend stopping here when you are in Montauk.

Gonna go with 4 stars…read more Ice cream sundae is as real good - cherry vanilla with hot fudge and gummy bears. Little awkward when I asked for gummy bears as a topping and the woman started weighing them on a scale? She runs a tight ship! Convenient location and reasonable (for Montauk) prices.

See all

There's a lot of yum in that tiny box

Chapel Sweets

4.0(16 reviews)

22.3 mi

Candy prices are commensurate for a chocolatier in a tourist area. The girls filled up on exotic…read morecandy. The owners were very helpful. This shoppe was spot on spotless. We tasted the fudge, ummmm!

This review is for their ice cream only. After wandering in and out of shops I decided to treat…read moremyself to an ice cream before heading back to the ferry. I had tried other things ice cream shops on previous trips to BI and found them very good. So I thought I would try Chapel Sweets. The bright fluorescent color of most of their ice cream varieties should have been a warning to me but I continued on and ordered the bright pink strawberry and the bright green pistachio. I guess I should have asked for samples before ordering. Both had very strong flavors (not really strawberry or pistachio). The texture was kind of gummy. It was more disappointing than horrible. I did finish my cup but it just was not satisfying.

See all

Sundaes On Main

4.6(9 reviews)

19.9 mi

On our way back from visiting the Montauk Light House and Museum our route took us through…read moreBridgehampton, Suffolk CountY NY II was around 5:30 so traffic was slow I spotted some cute pink chairs and what looked like giant lollipops and ice cream cones so I pulled over! My granddaughter had just mentioned she never had a sundae really what luck! This ice cream shop is very cute and you get to make your own sundae or whatever you desire ! The Ice cream is fresh and delicious , the caramel frozen Yogurt tastes just like the best ice cream you've ever had!! The mintiest mint flavored ice cream!! Everything is So delicious I If you like a long drive or possibly spend the weekend in Bridgehampton or Montauk you won't be disappointed ; there's plenty of places for dinner but I only recommend Sundaes for dessert !! AND don't miss the candy room in the back yep your kids will love this place and so will you!! They have a large variety of ice cream flavors delicious so many choices !! Topping are sooo good and you won't believe the selection from sprinkles to chips and more! I must mention the friendly staff and they also sell cute headbands ( little ice cream cones print) made by Katie B Boutique Shop! Made in the USA!

The store has a great selection of frozen yogurt and ice cream, along with rows and rows of new and…read morenostalgic candies. It's a shame that some people feel the need to leave a bad review because they got caught eating the candy in the back room. There are signs all over the place that say "no sampling" and that people will be asked to pay for the sampled candy. Eric shouldn't have been surprised. Go to Sundaes on Main! As long as you pay for the candy first you won't be disappointed.

Sundaes On Main

See all

After you choose all your ice cream and toppings they weighed it and that's how you pay!!

The Candy Box

3.1(9 reviews)

19.6 mi

Cute little candy store around the corner on the end in watch hill. Love the vibe and the tastes…read moreeven better. We stop in every year when we're visiting RI to get fudge and other sweets.

after reading the reviews (both positive and negative) we decided to check it out. selection is ok…read morebut found the employees somewhat rude and entitled as though they were doing us a favor by being open. maybe a lesson in customer service might be helpful.

Inside

A wall of sweet treats.

See all

Gumdrops & Lollipops Candy & Ice Cream

3.6(110 reviews)

23.8 mi

Dang the portions are generous - I mean really generous…read more Like -- wow Ok ok Extra napkins for sure Delicious all around

This is a great stop for some ice cream. This is a great area to sit down and look at the water and…read moreenjoy what the River has to offer. The service was enjoyable and they did very well. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone who is in the area that would like a good ice cream stop. Thank you for listening.

Interior

See all

Back side of the building where you order the ice cream. Nice pictures if they can get your order correct.

Blocks of Fudge

4.2(26 reviews)

22.3 mi

I wish I bought more!! The bourbon maple bacon was soo good . I was skeptical at first as I stick…read moreto a simpler flavors, but wow!! The bacon was crispy and the two flavors of fudge complemented each other nicely. I will definitely come back to get more when I'm in the area.

I love blocks of fudge. The people that work there know me very well because when I go in the…read moresummer, I stock up until next time.

Turtle fudge with a chocolate base, filled with caramel and nuts

Start filling your bag with a wide assortment of candies

See all

PEZ selections

Hauser Chocolatier

4.0(15 reviews)

22.7 mi

Amazing chocolate. I would highly recommend this place to anyone that loves , a premium chocolate.read more

Very customer service oriented! We love that! The quality is excellent! My go to when I'm not in…read moreCT at Munsons!!

Map of what's inside the box

Hand picked truffles. If you let them know that you're going to mail them then they seal the chocolates in.

See all

Truffles a la carte

Candy Shop

3.6(14 reviews)

22.2 mi

Cute little candy shop! Self service so you can choose as…read morelittle to as much as your sweet tooth desire

The Candy Shop in downtown Mystic is a true delight for anyone with a sweet tooth. Located right on…read morethe dock next to the drawbridge, it's not just a candy store--it's an experience that blends nostalgia, variety, and handcrafted quality! -Selection & Variety * Over 200 different types of candy, ranging from chocolates and fudge to classic confections and nostalgic favorites. * Handcrafted fudge is a standout, with 16 flavors made fresh daily, including specialties like dark chocolate caramel sea salt and cookies & cream. * Beyond fudge, you'll find hand-dipped caramel apples, pecan and cashew clusters, and pre-wrapped chocolates and taffies that make perfect gifts. Atmosphere & Location * The shop is family-owned and operated, adding a warm, personal touch to every visit. * Its location on the Mystic drawbridge makes it a charming stop while exploring downtown. The interior is quaint, clean, and filled with the irresistible aroma of fresh sweets. * The nostalgic vibe brings back childhood memories, making it fun for both kids and adults. Service & Experience * Staff are friendly and knowledgeable, happy to guide you through the wide selection. * The presentation of the candies and fudge is inviting, with colorful displays that make browsing a joy. * Many visitors note that the shop feels like a "sweetest place in Mystic", thanks to its combination of candy, ice cream, and fudge under one roof. Whether you're picking up a gift, indulging in a caramel apple, or just reliving childhood favorites, this shop makes every visit memorable. Cheers

Whistle Pops

See all

Chocolate Nonpareils Yummy!

The Newport Sweet Shoppe

4.4(38 reviews)

45.3 mi

You know that perfect dessert sweet spot of decadent but not too heavy? That's Newport Sweet…read moreShoppe's cupcakes and cookies. So decadent and indulgent, moist and flavorful, but not cloyingly sweet and heavy. I forgot someone's birthday cake and stopped in last minute to see what they had. Not only did I pick up the cutest and most delicious cupcakes, the guy there was also kind enough to stick sole birthday signs in them! Saved my whole day! I also got two of their sea salt chocolate chip cookies to cope with my guilt of forgetting a cake (haha!) and they were insanely good. Chewy and chocolate-y with the perfect amount of thin, flakey sea salt. My favorite cupcake was the hot fudge sundae cupcake. So so good. Now I just need to go back and try the homemade Twinkie I keep hearing about!

I was so excited to revisit and enjoy some of the baked goods I'd loved before. The gentleman…read more(presume owner) said they stopped selling those items last year. Very disappointing because it was a high point of Newport. I purchased some of the cutout cookies but otherwise it's a normal candy store. Bumme

Cutout cookies. Cute but not the Twinkie.

See all

Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel, Lemon Raspberry, Sundae

A La Mode Shoppe

4.6(15 reviews)

13.5 mi

The A La Mode Ice Cream Shoppe in East Hampton offers both dairy and non-dairy flavors…read more Try the Salted Carmel, Sprinkle or the Partly Cloudy. The service and ice cream is top notch. A special Thanks to Andrew for your hospitality.

Lemon ginger sorbet. Yum. The chocolate with the marshmallows in it was creamy and delicious too.read more

Front of shop

See all

The flavors

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jamie R.

17

11

4

12 years ago

Walking into Jillian's shop is like walking into a candy coated pinterest board. The owner's aesthetic is spot on. She has a great mix of classic candies (best gummy bears ever) and new local delicacies (goats milk caramels!!). If you have a birthday or a special event and need a quick gift, try one of their candy grams. She stuffs a colorful suitcase-esque box with your choice of candy, ties on a balloon or two, and delivers to your door! Ordered a candy gram for one of my friend's birthday and she LOVED it. read more

Kat T.

0

1

0

12 years ago

This store is absolutely AMAZING !!!

The Candied Anchor - partysupplies - Updated August 2026

People who viewed The Candied Anchor also viewed

Happy Bowls

3.3

(36 reviews)

The food here is absolutely delicious. It's always fresh and super healthy. The staff is super…read morefriendly and the decor is really cool. In my opinion happy bowls is a "must visit" when out in montauk because it's a very unique concept and you can get a delicious snack without feeling guilty! The only reason why I gave it 4 instead of 5 stars is because it is pretty expensive, but that is to be expected when you're out in montauk. Also cash only!

Tried the poke from here. The portion was a little silly considering 22$ price. It made my stomach…read morehurt but that may have just been me tbh. Have had way better poke for less. Wouldn't go back.

Sundaes On Main

4.6

(9 reviews)

On our way back from visiting the Montauk Light House and Museum our route took us through…read moreBridgehampton, Suffolk CountY NY II was around 5:30 so traffic was slow I spotted some cute pink chairs and what looked like giant lollipops and ice cream cones so I pulled over! My granddaughter had just mentioned she never had a sundae really what luck! This ice cream shop is very cute and you get to make your own sundae or whatever you desire ! The Ice cream is fresh and delicious , the caramel frozen Yogurt tastes just like the best ice cream you've ever had!! The mintiest mint flavored ice cream!! Everything is So delicious I If you like a long drive or possibly spend the weekend in Bridgehampton or Montauk you won't be disappointed ; there's plenty of places for dinner but I only recommend Sundaes for dessert !! AND don't miss the candy room in the back yep your kids will love this place and so will you!! They have a large variety of ice cream flavors delicious so many choices !! Topping are sooo good and you won't believe the selection from sprinkles to chips and more! I must mention the friendly staff and they also sell cute headbands ( little ice cream cones print) made by Katie B Boutique Shop! Made in the USA!

The store has a great selection of frozen yogurt and ice cream, along with rows and rows of new and…read morenostalgic candies. It's a shame that some people feel the need to leave a bad review because they got caught eating the candy in the back room. There are signs all over the place that say "no sampling" and that people will be asked to pay for the sampled candy. Eric shouldn't have been surprised. Go to Sundaes on Main! As long as you pay for the candy first you won't be disappointed.

Fudge N Stuff

3.7

(41 reviews)

Fudge n stuff is a placr I always have to stop at when we go down to Montauk…read more I always look forward to their rainbow cookie fudge but sadly they haven't had it the past 2 times I went. This prompted me to try the mint chocolate fudge which tastes like an andes mint. It was just perfect! The woman who owns the shop is lovely and she is passionate about making delicious fudge. I always have a great experience when I come here. Highly recommend stopping here when you are in Montauk.

Gonna go with 4 stars…read more Ice cream sundae is as real good - cherry vanilla with hot fudge and gummy bears. Little awkward when I asked for gummy bears as a topping and the woman started weighing them on a scale? She runs a tight ship! Convenient location and reasonable (for Montauk) prices.

The Fudge Company

3.1

(29 reviews)

•$$$

An absolute Southampton classic & a must for not only delicious ice cream but for their fabulous…read morecandy selection !!

Very delicious and flavorful ice cream, consistent over the years. The Fudge Company is my choice…read moreall year long for ice cream, real milk shakes, candy and fudge.

Amazing Flavors

4.4

(24 reviews)

Love this place and their ice cream! A go to whenever we are in Greenport. They have a ton of…read moreflavors and a few tables both inside or outside so you can eat with the family. There can be a line but it always moves quick!

Cute shop with arcade games and a carousel in the back (parents beware!!!) they serve Hershey ice…read morecream as well as soft serve and lemon ice. A good option for a sweet treat but def disappointing that their stuff isn't homemade!

Yummylicious!

3.2

(28 reviews)

My husband liked his ice cream, but my frozen yogurt tasted "off," and I did not feel well later…read morethat night. My fault, I shouldn't have eaten it! Of course, can't be certain my not feeling well was from the frozen yogurt - could be from anything, but it's certainly possible. At any rate, tasted bad, so I wouldn't return.

Yummylicious is a awesome ice cream store in Downtown sag Harbor. They offer speciality ice cream,…read moresorbet or yogurt. Try out a few samples. The mango and the cotton candy flavors are amazing.

Tuck Shop

3.8

(31 reviews)