Fudge n stuff is a placr I always have to stop at when we go down to Montauk…read more I always look forward to their rainbow cookie fudge but sadly they haven't had it the past 2 times I went. This prompted me to try the mint chocolate fudge which tastes like an andes mint. It was just perfect! The woman who owns the shop is lovely and she is passionate about making delicious fudge. I always have a great experience when I come here. Highly recommend stopping here when you are in Montauk.

Gonna go with 4 stars…read more Ice cream sundae is as real good - cherry vanilla with hot fudge and gummy bears. Little awkward when I asked for gummy bears as a topping and the woman started weighing them on a scale? She runs a tight ship! Convenient location and reasonable (for Montauk) prices.

This is an old school ice-cream-only place in Mattituck - out on the North Fork of eastern Long…read moreIsland. If you are in Riverhead or touring some of the vineyards on the North Fork, you should hit this place. We drove by on the way back from afternoon golf on a Friday. From the size of the crowd, I thought it was a Beatles Reunion Concert or something. The locals told us that it is REALLY GOOD, but evening waits can easily exceed an hour. Parking looked tough. We dropped by the next day around lunch time. No line, easy parking. The menu board has over 40 flavors, which include some intriguing ones such as honey cinnamon, honey lavender, blackberry ginger, avocado coconut. I did the cinnamon, the wife opted for the lavender. They were REALLY UNIQUE AND REALLY GOOD. My daughter has some food allergies, and we were impressed by the careful listing of potential allergens on the menu list. Next time I'm out on the east end of Long Island, I'll be going there again and getting some quarts to go. I just advise you to either go off-peak, or be prepared to hob-Nob with a lot of locals for a while in line.

By far the best ice cream on the North Fork. I'm still licking the butterfat from my lips.read more

Love Carvel! Best soft serve ice cream and now they offer different flavors. I love the pistachio!!…read moreA small costs about $7 and it's a rather big serving so I can't imagine what a large would be like.

Went here for dessert. Food, service and ambiance is good. But they don't have a restroom. No…read morechairs inside too. U just hope to find a bench outside or eat it while walking. Got Reese ice cream and a carvel cake ice cream with walnuts and almonds. He put too much toppings to my liking. I was hoping for just a sprinkle but it's ok.

The burger and Cookie Monster ice cream add Oreo and sprinkles are incredible…read more The burger and Cookie Monster ice cream add Oreo and sprinkles are incredible

Good ice cream and milkshakes. Quick and friendly service. Prices typical for area. Parking…read moreadequate at least in off season. Cash Only.

Bake shop is for take out only…read more The coffee beats anything on the Montauk strip in the morning- lots of customers, so always fresh pots served. Pastries were very good AND a bit expensive. The service is slow due to a great assortment of goodies and customers who have to get their own coffee for the first time in their life. As long as you are OK with takeout, great place to go!

Run, don't walk to these croissants. Both the jelly and the cream filled were so amazing we had to…read morego back a second time and get more to take home with us. Can get busy in the mornings. We did wait online that was outside, but it moved quickly and we were glad that we did personally wasn't a fan of the bacon, egg and cheese. The cheese was not melted at all, but the pastries and the fresh juices were definitely worth it.

Gourmet Sorbet currently has a stand at Dekalb market, and I am reviewing it because they served me…read morethe most delicious pistachio frozen dessert. This sorbet-(dairy free) is somehow is actually better than any pistachio ice cream/gelato/or spumoni I have ever had. It was ridiculously creamy and flavorful without being overpowering and the addition of salt sprinkled on top had me salivating for me. I kind of couldn't stop telling my friends how I couldn't believe how good it was, and despite the price tag, $3 for one (tiny) scoop and $5 for two I would gladly make the trip to Dekalb Market just for this indulgence and want to share it with everyone I know. They offer sample tastes and my friend was very satisfied with the vanilla bean (cook crumbs sprinkled on top) and I tried the lychee with ginger topping. I think this is a mini-miracle and can't wait until they offer this product elsewhere. Until then, don't forget to stop by and check them out!

Hubs and I visited DeKalb Market for the first time and met the adorable proprietors, who'd just…read morewhipped up a little "Sun Tea and Sorbet" goodie. Hot day. Steamy pavement. Cool, unsweetened, perfectly brewed iced tea. Sliver of lemon and some mint leaves, and a gorgeous, smooth, creamy, sweet-tart dollop of their lemon sorbet. Summer in a glass! Brought back midwestern rootbeer-float memories! Seriously, ladies. Patent it. Right after I serve it to all my friends and claim it as my own. :-)

These donuts are so good. Get here early if you want the full selection they tend to run out,…read moreespecially the powdered sugar donut holes. You don't want to miss those.

There are no prices listed anywhere. Living out here has become so surreal. Is it that hard to add…read morea price to the huge board that lists doughnut flavors? I guess I'm the first person to actually ask how much the doughnuts cost. They're 5$ a pop, btw. That said, not a bad doughnut.

Awesome local candy shop in the heart of town. Tons of verity, and charm! They even had the old…read moreschool dot candy on paper that brought me back 30 years to my childhood!

Always a friendly face when visiting! Our family always makes a quick visit to the Candied anchor…read morewith each visit to MTK. Unique selection, great beverage selection including specialty ice coffees to sip while you savor your favorite hard to find childhood and international candies! Try it you'll feel like a kid again!