Honestly will never stop raving about this place. I love how they have rotating flavors so it never…read moregets boring. I come to Mattituck every summer so it's always a treat to come here for ice cream. My personal favorite flavors are Cookie Monster, Lots of Stuff, and Krispy Kreme. They even have pints to take home and treats for your pet!

I've been coming to Magic Fountain since I was a kid, and for good reason! They have delicious ice…read morecream from a rotating menu of flavors that has so many interesting concoctions. On my most recent trip, they had Dubai Chocolate and Spicy Mango, both really fun and delicious in their own way. I ended up getting a scoop of the North Fork, and it was delicious. My friend got a vanilla milkshake and gave rave reviews as well. There's usually a line snaking out the door (the inside isn't very big), but they've got a good system for keeping things moving, so don't be dissuaded. If you're driving to/from the North Fork, make the drive even better with a stop here!

Love Carvel! Best soft serve ice cream and now they offer different flavors. I love the pistachio!!…read moreA small costs about $7 and it's a rather big serving so I can't imagine what a large would be like.

Went here for dessert. Food, service and ambiance is good. But they don't have a restroom. No…read morechairs inside too. U just hope to find a bench outside or eat it while walking. Got Reese ice cream and a carvel cake ice cream with walnuts and almonds. He put too much toppings to my liking. I was hoping for just a sprinkle but it's ok.

Such great if you arrive at Montauk late at night, their burgers in front of always hit even my dog…read moreapproved and she's picky but seriously nine out of 10. Recommend been going here for years.

This place has unbelievable ice cream. Long lines. But goes fast A place you have to go tooread more

Run, don't walk to these croissants. Both the jelly and the cream filled were so amazing we had to…read morego back a second time and get more to take home with us. Can get busy in the mornings. We did wait online that was outside, but it moved quickly and we were glad that we did personally wasn't a fan of the bacon, egg and cheese. The cheese was not melted at all, but the pastries and the fresh juices were definitely worth it.

Lots of options in this grab and go bake shoppe. I've only tried the sweet items- none of the…read morebreakfast items, but we've enjoyed the things we've got. The cinnamon swirls are good but lean on the dry side without a ton of frosting. The apple crumb cake is delicious. Boston crème donuts from here my boyfriend always loves. Chocolate chip cookies lean a little thinner crunchier- like tates. I also tried their empanadas recently- plaintain and cheese- very greasy and not a lot of flavor. Service is prompt at the counter and they're always pretty well stocked. We'll be back for more sweets this summer.

Maple donuts- though I shouldn't post this or everyone will know. In the summer you can't get any…read moreafter noon -- they're sold out. (Sometimes even earlier. )The other donuts look great too (my husband likes the chocolate cake one) but I love the maple donut so much I don't try them. And excellent chai latte, I might add. And a staff of just terrific people.

There are no prices listed anywhere. Living out here has become so surreal. Is it that hard to add…read morea price to the huge board that lists doughnut flavors? I guess I'm the first person to actually ask how much the doughnuts cost. They're 5$ a pop, btw. That said, not a bad doughnut.

Delicious iced coffee, but the donut fell flat. You can tell from the picture that the icing was…read morepretty dried out on top. The donut itself didn't taste too fresh so that was a bummer, but it was still a nice treat (and the perfect topper to my iced coffee!). Very friendly and hardworking staff are running this place, and there was a small selection of things to look at before ordering. Super cute spot!

Breakfast sandwich was below average in size, quality and care. I would not recommend you get it…read more they should call it a slider. this is for $12. Hard pass.

Gourmet Sorbet currently has a stand at Dekalb market, and I am reviewing it because they served me…read morethe most delicious pistachio frozen dessert. This sorbet-(dairy free) is somehow is actually better than any pistachio ice cream/gelato/or spumoni I have ever had. It was ridiculously creamy and flavorful without being overpowering and the addition of salt sprinkled on top had me salivating for me. I kind of couldn't stop telling my friends how I couldn't believe how good it was, and despite the price tag, $3 for one (tiny) scoop and $5 for two I would gladly make the trip to Dekalb Market just for this indulgence and want to share it with everyone I know. They offer sample tastes and my friend was very satisfied with the vanilla bean (cook crumbs sprinkled on top) and I tried the lychee with ginger topping. I think this is a mini-miracle and can't wait until they offer this product elsewhere. Until then, don't forget to stop by and check them out!

Hubs and I visited DeKalb Market for the first time and met the adorable proprietors, who'd just…read morewhipped up a little "Sun Tea and Sorbet" goodie. Hot day. Steamy pavement. Cool, unsweetened, perfectly brewed iced tea. Sliver of lemon and some mint leaves, and a gorgeous, smooth, creamy, sweet-tart dollop of their lemon sorbet. Summer in a glass! Brought back midwestern rootbeer-float memories! Seriously, ladies. Patent it. Right after I serve it to all my friends and claim it as my own. :-)

What an adorable chocolate shop run by the most friendly,lovely owner Nancy …read more This was my first time here and found the vintage old time feeling very appealing . The shop is small and packed with lots of delicious sweets and decorated with an old fashion vibe . Since it is so close to Easter there are chocolate bunnys galore ! Besides the chocolates Nancy makes herself she also offers other sweets as well. Nancy offered us a full size sample , so generous! I purchased some dark chocolate almond bark ,raspberry cream dark chocolate dipped candy and milk chocolate pretzel bark ... all so delicious! We will definitely be back the next time we are in the area .

Amazing! You will feel like home as soon as you walk into this small quaint shop. Nancy feels like…read morea family member and is so friendly! A joy to do business with. And, she offered us full-sized samples! The shop is small but adorably decorated and has all of the great staples of a chocolate shop, plus more. Be sure to make a stop here!