Still don't get it. 2 pizzas and small salad $50 carry out. Wouldn't mind paying for it, but 1 person can eat a pizza. The pizza is very thin, with cheap cheese and very finely chopped toppings on it. read more

The pizza was ok. Quality ingredients but not over the top tasty. I liked the very thin crust texture but wished it had been tastier They have been in business for decades so I'm sure the locals find them to be the best. You can't stay in business otherwise. I'm Chicago so I'm spoiled rotten on pizza. Nice people working there, convenient drive-up pick-up window. Fairly priced at $21 for a 16in. three topping. read more

Great thin crust pizza. Been coming for over 40 years! Always crowded so come early or later to avoid the crowds. read more

The pizza is OK, nothing special. My veggie with no black olives arrived with soggy crust and quite a bit of black olives. The delivery minimum is ridiculous, it's more than the cost of one pizza, so you are forced to get either a large pizza or more than 1 just to meet the minimum. The pizza arrived on time but with no crushed red pepper or cheese, which left it fairly tasteless. Not bad, but I won't order from here again. read more

This place is fantastic! We ordered the BBQ pizza and tortellini. The portions are huge, the prices are super reasonable. Our server was so friendly also. I definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone in the Springfield area. read more

This is a family owned pizzeria. Been established for 50+ years. We went from a recommendation from friends who felt this is the best tasting pizza in Springfield. We had a sausage pizza with vegetables. It was very bland. No flavors popping out. Super disappointing. I think there was no sauce or very very light on the sauce. However we had deep fried mushrooms and they are the best I ever ate. read more

I am only giving a 3 star review because the food is awesome, but the entrance, low ceilings and the way they pack you into the place is a death trap! The wait staff is wonderful and again, it's the best pizza, pasta and appetizers you could ask for, but for me, I was nervous about the inside of the place. If there is ever a fire there good luck with your escape. I will still buy food there and they have a pick up window, but will never eat inside. read more

The staff was extremely warm and friendly. We had an half order of fried mushrooms, and they were plenty for two. The batter was really good and reminded me of fried chicken batter. It was delicious. For the entree, we had sausage,mushroom,onion and gr peppers. The crust was very crispy without being charred. The ingredients were plentiful and good quality. If you've ever had the chain pizza from Monical's, I'd say it's comparable, with Gabatoni's besting Monicals by just a bit. read more

Gabatoni's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

See all

Not somewhere I'm going to crave, but decent. We got a medium pizza with garlic cheese bread for $31. I'm sure COVID's messing everything up but they are only allowing drive through, so you can imagine the wait without offering carry out. Overall I found it similar to any decent bar pizza but more expensive. My wife did not like it. read more

Gabatoni's used to half cook the sausage and then cook it through on the pizza which made them the best in town hands down. They stopped doing it that way and now it is still good pizza but just not great pizza. I can remember getting so excited when mom would pick up the phone and call in an order for the greasy goodness. We would pull up to the drive through and she would let me hold the hot delight on my lap. It was served in white paper with a man on the paper holding a steaming hot pie! Ah the good ol days! Still a superior pie in the field! read more

On the rare nights when I was a kid that my father would let us sit in front of the tv all night and order food in, we almost always got Gabatoni's - it was as much of a treat as actually being allowed to watch tv. Very good pastas (I've always been partial to their lasagna, my sister, the ravioli) and thin crust pizzas. The standout feature of the pizza is the crust - cracker thin and very tasty. It is really hard to stop eating it, as it is rather light for pizza. Of special note - while I generally don't enjoy sausage on pizza, the sausage at Gabatoni's is very, very good and, my stepmother tells me, home made. Ask my pants how much I like this pizza, go ahead... they'll tell you what I'm too embarrassed to - that I like it so much I generally have to unbutton them before I'm done. I think my pants are laughing at me. read more

The place looks a little suspect from the outside!! It's right next the a railroad crossing and the parking lot is very dark. But the food makes up for all of that!!! The best pizza I have had outside of Chicago!! read more

Gabatoni's Restaurant - The darkness!! LOL - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

The service was disappointing. The pizza arrived 30 minutes late. The guy was not apologetic when he got there. Opened up to a less than lukewarm burned pizza. Taste was good-for a cold pizza. read more

Gabatoni's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

This place is extremely over priced. I payed $13.48 for quite possibly the smallest pizza I've ever seen. When I picked my pizza up after the 25 minutes they told me it would take to prepare, it was already cold. They took my credit card and had me wait 10 minutes before I could finally sign the receipt and leave. The crust was greasy and partially burnt and the cheese had congealed. Not only am I never getting food from here again, I'm never trusting Yelp for Springfield restaurant recommendations. read more

Gabatoni's Restaurant - Tiny, overpriced ($13.48), burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

I lived here most of my life, and now come back once a year to visit friends, see the State Fair, and reminisce on some iconic Springfield foods to include Gabatoni's Pizza. My first Springfield pizza choice used to be Vic's, but after their closing, Gabatoni's is mow my #1 choice. Tonight we got the extra large sausage, mushroom, onion, and green,pepper as we have on the past, and it was horrible. The only thing familiar to me was the crust. There was hardly any of that sweet tomato garlic sauce. There were barely any ingredients other than onion. The cheese had an odd rubbery texture, almost making me think it was fake cheese. Overall everything tasted very bland. Even my local friends I stay with agreed the pizza was not up to what we all remember. To the owners, stick with the quality ingredients you used to use, and make sure your pizza makers know what they're doing. I'll be back next year to try again with hope it's the pizza I remember. read more

Downtown Springfield shuts down on Sunday. Seriously, I couldn't even get room service in my hotel at 1 pm. So, my husband and I are spending a lazy, rainy Sunday in our hotel room and decide we need food. Now. This is a much harder task than you would think. Most delivery places have no website, or the ones that do, don't deliver to our downtown hotel. FINALLY, we click on a Gabatoni's menu and decide to place an order. Wow, $35 for a small pizza, some cheesy bread, and a few small wings? Oh well, desperate times call for desperate measures. The most positive thing was that the food was delivered about 20 minutes earlier than their estimate. Points in my book 'cause I was HUNGRY. The food was all just "meh". Not the absolute worst, but far, far from the best . Kind of a disappointment after having to work so hard to find a place to get food from, and all the decent reviews on yelp. It put food in my belly, but I certainly wouldn't seek it out again. read more

This was a pleasant and wonderful shock when we walked in last Saturday. We were in town for an event taking place nearby. We had wonderful service, huge portions, and reasonable prices. We had the toasted ravioli (actual, breaded deep fried ravioli!), onion rings on a huge platter, Alfredo tortellini, SMALL chef salad that was more like a portion for three people, a cup of chili in a gigantic bowl, and a 7" pizza. Not going to lie, if you look at the building and the surrounding area, it's a little sketchy. However, the food and the service absolutely made up for it! Our waiter was fantastic and was able to get us the food in a hurry because we only had 45 minutes for lunch. We will definitely be returning and having more from their menu! read more

Staying at a local hotel I ordered a pizza,breadsticks & chicken wings. Overpriced at $36. The food was cold and tasteless. It will be a cold day in hell before I order from here again. Zero stars. read more

I like gabatoni's food quite a bit but I just think that they're overly priced but the food is good

I was passing through Springfield on my Route 66 Trip. My brother told me about Gabatoni's. I am glad he did. I had the pizza and it was really good. The crust was very thin and crispy with just the right amount of brown around the edges. I had a sausage pizza and the sausage was very good. There was just the right amount of sauce and cheese for this thin crispy crust. The people were very nice. The place had an older look to it, but was very clean. Next time I'm in Springfield I will be stopping by here again! read more

Our "go to place" when we are in Springfield. Have gotten great pasta, excellent service and generous portions. No disappointments here! Coming back for sure. read more

Gabatoni's Restaurant - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

See all

I love the old school no pretense atmosphere and attitude about this place. The food is traditional, and really good. Pizza, pasta, tamales - yes tamales - hoagies, and 2 tvs in the oval shaped bar. The bar stools have backs! There are also a few salads on the menu. Tall tables in the bar to have food. Tables in the dining room are regular hardtops. The staff is friendly and helpful. And right now they've got lots of great Halloween decorations. read more

Gabatoni's Restaurant - Pizza n Stag - nothing better - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Sorry, Can't eat a Pizza that has consistently Burnt Cornmeal on the bottom of the Crust. I don't know why this can't be done.

A favorite of our family. When guest are in town they remember Gabatoni's too. A variety of pizza's, large menu delivery and good service keep us coming back. read more

Packed on a Saturday night!! Had pizza and toasted ravioli and both were outstanding. Long wait but excellent service once we were seated. This place never disappoints!!! And now they apparently take reservations - outstanding!! read more

I feel bad because this is a local business but I'm just being honest their pizza is mediocre. I've tried twice with the pizza and it's been blah. Tonight I tried their spaghetti, salad, and garlic bread. I live by there and just trying to go local but it was so mediocre! Honestly fazolis tastes better. Their spaghetti was awful, garlic bread wasn't good and I was just so disappointed. Like actually upset I spent the money on it, I would've been more satisfied with a frozen pizza. Again I feel bad because it is a local business. And everyone there is very friendly and gives great service but the food is really sub par; I honestly will never go there again because the food is so bad read more

This place is AMAZING!!! Their pizza is sooooo good an addicting! They have been here for many years and well deserved. The must orders are EBA, toasted ravoli, and their garlic bread! I have never dinned in the restruant so i can't speak on the svc inside or how clean it is but i can say when I have called in they were always friendly and my order is always at my house when they say it will be there. Out of all the years i ordered from them my order was never incorrect which says a lot about a company. This is one of the true gems still in spfld ill and my prediction is there will have another 50 years of svc! read more

What a great experience. I was in Springfield on a business trip. I asked around where I could go grab something to eat. I was told Gabatoni's was the best pizza around. Well they did not disappoint. The staff is so wonderful and friendly. The food was delicious, and they have home made pies. Great place. I'm glad I had dinner there. Thank you. read more

Best toasted raviolis and pizza in a 500 mile radius, affordable great place, i recommend 100%. read more

The pizza is absolutely amazing but the way the manager speaks to her employees is just way out of line. Hey lady that is a wood wall not concrete between you and the customers. I would love to come back but won't support how you talk to people. Sad to know I won't have the delicious pizza again but more sad that's how you treat people working hard for you. read more

Great thin crust and good toppings and cheese. Sauce was kind bland. Overall good pizza.

We had a later lunch there so we had the whole place to ourselves. I'd love to go there at a busier time to see this place in action. I loved the atmosphere, very nice and clean. Our waiter was very attentive and helpful with the menu since it was our first time there. The food was hot and steaming when it arrived at our table. Everything was perfect. I had the overstuffed beef ravioli and it was spectacular. The garlic bread had assorted spices and maybe a cheese on it and it was amazing. This is definitely a locally owned restaraunt that I would highly recommend to anyone looking for down home authentic Italian Cuisine. Don't let the appearance of this place fool you. It's a little sketchy from the outside but inside it's very nice and feels just like home. read more

Well this is my second trip to Gabatonis in the past three weeks and service has not improved. We had reservations at 7:00 arrived 6:45 and finally were seated at 7:15. I am not sure what has happened in the management of the restaurant however it has gone downhill. I will not sit in the bar area anymore as service is horrendous. read more

Chicken Alfredo pizza is so amazing here definitely something everyone should try. I like how they cut it up in little squares!!

The cheese ravioli here was delicious. The pizza was a bit too cheesy for me, but overall the customer service more than made up for it. We had the best waitress and would come back just for the great service. read more

Great spot!! First visit for me as I was in the area for business - obviously a very popular place with the locals. Great pizza!!! Great, friendly service too! Wish I had this place in Phoenix! read more

Our experience with family is great here. The food comes out hot, maybe too hot to eat right away but I'm not complaining better hot than cold. Servers there are awesome. Well most of them. Thank you for the best pizza in Springfield!!!!! read more

ETA pizza took me back to my childhood. Loved it.Great topping. Everything was fresh in the salad and the old fashioned garlic bread was yummy. read more

Did a drive thru tonight. Very disappointing and a huge rip off. Way overpriced. Formerly was the best however no more.

Homey atmosphere. Nice service. Apps were just ok. Pizza was amazing. Got the veggie special and added jalapenos and garlic. Spicy! Crust of pizza is spot on. Not too cheesy or sauced. Would like to go back to try their other pizzas. read more