I almost don't want to share my feedback as we had the most delicious dinner ever!!! Dont want this place to become even more well loved and populated. Went here last night to celebrate my own and my daughter's birthday. Our waiter was fantastic! The atmosphere as always is top notch too. We started with the most delicious pop overs, only complaint would be they should be priced in a group of 4 instead of charging $4.00 for one more. I had the parmesan walleye, OMG best walleye I have ever had, the waiter said it was also his favorite item on the menu. My fiancé had the minute chicken and it was enough to feed I think 3 people easily. My granddaughter ordered a burger from the kids menu and she even raved how nummy, I tasted and it must agree best burger ever. Since we were there for 2 birthdays we each got a birthday dessert and they were also plentiful and flavorful, I had bread pudding and my daughter had chocolate ganache. I am so excited to be moving to Lakeville next month so we can frequent this place more often, I want to try everything on the menu, we saw some pot pies get delivered to table next to us and they looked fabulous too!!! Good job Garys! read more

See all

Back happily back! Yummy drinks food service is like times gone by professional super friendly lovely people who truly care about your experience read more

See all

We went here to celebrate my birthday and had a great time! I loved the atmosphere inside, and the staff are all really friendly and attentive. Our waitress brought me a complimentary brownie and ice cream for my birthday, which was delicious. For entrees we ordered the halibut risotto and strawberry pecan salad. The halibut risotto was delicious, but for $44 I would have expected a little more halibut on it. The strawberry pecan salad itself was really good and I would get that again, however we did the optional add-on chicken and were shocked at how dry it was. I've honestly never had such dry chewy chicken at a restaurant before. Besides the chicken we were overall very happy with the food. They also brought out a little board with pickles, gummy bears and nuts on it while we waited for our food which was nice. read more

See all

Inside is very modern classy feel. I got a nice dinner out with the parents feel. I did feel like the youngest customer there( I'm 30yrs old). The menu seems to have a primary focus on seafood. We were seated right away on a Saturday for lunch and it was fairly busy. We started with the prime rib egg rolls. It comes with two rolls cut in half and au jus and horsey cream for dipping. They weren't bad. I would say average tasting and what I expected. For lunch I had the halibut over a creamy risotto with mushrooms and asparagus. It was really tasty and I loved how cheesy and creamy the risotto was. I wished the halibut was a little more crispy, it was better eating it separately from the risotto. I enjoyed my lychee tini with my meal. Service was standard without issues. Prices were also pretty standard and fair read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Prime rib egg rolls - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

See all

I have driven by this place a million times on my way to my parents house in Owatonna, MN... I had visited 11 years ago with a sales rep I had traveled with... Decided to give this another a week ago with my sister and it did not disappoint! Firstly, for a random Thursday at 5:30pm it was packed!! You walk in abd the atmosphere is so great! Very modern with a supper club flair (you can get pull tabs!) . I ordered a salad because I wasn't overly hungry but the coconut shrimp we had was AMAZING!! And the fries WOW! I think I found a good spot to meet up with family in the future!!! read more

See all

Gary's has a great happy hour and one of the more fun patios in the suburbs. The short rib nachos, Cajun steak bites, and cocktails are all worth ordering -- the smoked old fashioned in particular was excellent. The Nashville hot chicken sandwich, though, missed the mark. The bun was soggy and the chicken came out dry. Overall, still a solid spot for drinks, apps, and patio hangs, especially in the south metro. Service is good but can be slow. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Chicken Caesar Salad - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

My husband and I treated ourselves to a nice dinner out for our wedding anniversary. We reserved a table online, and when we got there we were sat right away. They brought out a complimentary relish tray. The pickles were delicious and made in house! We enjoyed some cocktails (a pineapple doli and smoked old fashioned), along with an order of freshly made popovers with honey butter. The star of the entire night was the oyster rockefeller. We don't have a lot of seafood options in the area like I was used to on the coast, but these definitely were it! Sooo good. I highly recommend them if you like something similar to charbroiled oysters. For my main entree I ordered the drunken coconut shrimp which were also amazing, served with a side of sweet pineapple habanero marmalade. My husband ordered pan seared halibut, sauteed wild mushroom risotto, lemon basil beurre blanc, grilled asparagus and fresh shaved parmesan. We finished off the night and shared a warm brownie sundae for dessert. It was a wonderful evening spent together then we sat by the fire pit outside for a few minutes! Next time I'd like to try the lobster roll. I hope to go back for brunch sometime soon with our son since I seen they offer that as well. Gary's is great spot to have close by to us in the south of the metro. read more

See all

Went to Gary's just before Christmas. Always wanted to try it out. We went for dinner on a busy Sunday night. Nice crowd and a great vibe. We were greeted immediately by a nice host and sat quickly. Our server greeted us and let us know she was working with a couple of other tables but wanted us to know she saw us. I like that communication a lot. She did return and took drink orders and explained the menu. Very professional but friendly. My wife had the Chicken Pot Pie and I had the ribeye. Both entrees were delicious This is a cozy well designed restaurant. We will be back!! read more

Definitely will go back! I had the lobster bisque and it was awesome. Very relaxing vibe! Our server was attentive. read more

See all

Let's jump in! Plenty of parking and this place is right off highway 35! The hostess and server were both very friendly and personable! The kind of service you would expect at a nicer restaurant! The vibes: This place feels upscale and is definitely a gem of Lakeville! This would be a great place to have a date! The food: Highly recommend the steak (filet) was absolute perfection! The crème brûlée also stuck out as a winner! We were not fans of the bread pudding, as you could still taste the alcohol and the popovers were over done with "honey butter" that had very little flavor. Overall, I would recommend this place! read more

See all

Always great . We loved the salads to the sandwiches. Always stop our way home from the cities . The food is always well prepared. The service is good . And the vibe is old school steak house with the lobster tanks as you walk in. I love the French onion though I'd like more onions imo. Don't sleep on this pace but quality comes with a few extra dollars . We'll always be back . read more

See all

Ok, I've chatted with a lot of friends and found out they haven't been to Gary's Supper Club! If I lived closer to Lakeville, I would go more often! This was my 3rd or 4th time here and it always impresses. Make sure to make a reservation or you will have to wait/ might not get in. I went for my birthday a couple years ago, then Mother's Day brunch with my mom and MIL and then just for fun since I was nearby. It keeps getting better. We started with cheese curds and they also had a complimentary "relish" tray with homemade sweet pickles, nut mixture and gummy bears. How cute! Love this all! My go to entree has been the Halibut, but it was a little different this time with risotto... I decided to order something different! The Tuna Nicoise since I noticed it on the menu and needed some greens. I haven't had this salad for years and a restaurant near me took off their menu. If you have never had one and enjoy tuna (beautifully prepared - I trust their seafood) and also enjoy green beans, potatoes, hard boiled egg, olives and a vinaigrette. Crave-worthy and fresh! My other half got the Cajun chicken pasta which has been a staple on their menu. It was a hearty portion and he even took some home! We took home the key lime cheesecake (sorry... forgot to take pics) and it was decent sized/ circular and creamy/ not too tart. I would get again. Oh yeah... I dunno how they make their dirty Grey Goose martinis soo good and filthy (I asked for it extra olive juice and shaken longer- smoother) but it's my favorite place to get them at! Blue cheese creamy and they go down easy. My boo got a seasonal apple old fashioned. I told him I was thinking spring and not fall/winter, so this wasn't my favorite. Haha Overall, you should all go to Gary's! Maybe even try one of their holiday brunches and don't miss out on their cheesey potatoes and lobster Benedict! I'm sure it wouldn't take much for me to talk my family into going for brunch again soon! Thanks Gary for the amazing consistency in your food and the love you share. read more

See all

Fantastic food and great service Always great specials and the Lobsters are fresh . read more

I have eaten at Gary's several times, always constantly great food and service. It is our go to place. Thanks for being you!!

Visiting in town for a wedding, but also had a birthday to celebrate. This was a great choice! We were able to get same day reservations on a Friday night for 6 people at 5:30. The restaurant was packed! Our servers were friendly, efficient and knowledgeable. Our party ordered a variety of dishes: Lobster roll (good, but a bit plain), medium rare prime rib (yum), jambalaya (hard to believe, but as good as if ordered in New Orleans), medium rare New York strip (a little more on the rare side, but tender and flavorful), beef short rib stroganoff (very good, but too many mushrooms for my taste) and chicken cordon bleu (another winner). The restaurant is a bit on the pricey side, but we enjoyed the food and the casual, supper club ambiance. Our daughter made a great choice for her out of state family birthday dinner! read more

See all

Popovers were good and hot. Not sure what the relish try is that others write about. Our table did not have a relish try. Wine glasses were cloudy. I ordered the lobster and it was the chewiest and stringiest lobster I've ever tried to eat. Not a very large lobster tail. It was so chewy that I ate both sides of the split tail one bite each. I ordered it boiled and when I picked it up it drained and incredibly large amount of water. The baked potato was not warm enough to melt the butter. Water glasses were never filled. The table was a mess and not attended to as we ate. My guest had the salmon Oscar and said it was good. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Empty water glass. Plates picked up but lots of garbage left behind. - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

"Really good espresso martini--smooth, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Highly recommend!" read more

Gary’s Supper Club - "Really good espresso martini--smooth, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Highly recommend!" - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Made a reservation for a Sunday at 9:30 AM and they had the table all set with waters already poured when we walked in and menus at each chair for our party of 6. Waitress was very attentive and did get all of our orders correct and was pleasant. The atmosphere was great with lovely lighting and candles on each table as well. The French toast was delicious and had extra caramel to dunk every piece into which was delightful. My son had the loaded pancakes and said they did taste good but maybe a little bit too much chocolate as it was more of a chocolate melt vs chips. Would recommend for large and smaller groups. Portion size has been perfect every time I have ventured here. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Deep fried fish for Friday fish fry. Comes with side of coleslaw and tons of delicious fries cooked to perfection!! - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

See all

This supper club is one of our favorites. Nestled just south of the Twin Cities, right off I35, Gary's Supper Club is one of our family favorites that we've dined at several times over the years. It's what I consider a Midwest supper club, but with a speak easy feel, boasting a beautiful bar and cozy dining room. The open kitchen design allows you to see the grill lineup, and prompt service has never been an issue. We've eaten our way through their menu, but always favor their steaks. A fresh glass of water and a platter of snacks come before a server greets us. We love their little boards of complementary, pre-dinner snacks; gummy bears, pickles and mixed nuts, it's exactly the snack that excites the palette before a big meal. Mile 88 Red Wine: we had two bottles of this for our last trip, and we loved the wine. Their cocktail menu is extensive, and everyone found a drink they enjoyed. Filet Mignon: cuts like butter, thick cut and super tender, and the 8oz portion is just right. Coupled with a green vegetable and potato choice, this meal is heavenly for the lean steak diner. NY Strip: typically my go-to choice here, I love the seasoning and the 12oz cut is always cooked exactly to temp. I don't love their waxy, slightly bland green beans, and usually opt for broccoli or asparagus. And I sure love me a butter and sour cream baked potato, with salt and pepper. Mmmnnnnn. Ribeye: I've had this one as well, and it's delicious. Lovely marbled fat, a nice and thick cut, juicy and tender, and always seasoned just right. What I love about all their steaks is that they're simply seasoned; no heavy gravy or sauce, just a light seasoning to accent the cut's own flavors. This is a heavenly 14oz's of succulent cow, no mooes about it. Potato Au Gratin: cheesy potatoes are so good, I usually stay away from these simply because I eat too much and then I'm stuffed before I dig into my meal. Coconut Shrimp App: these large, coconut and panko crusted shrimp, pre-marinated in coconut rum, come with a tropically side of pineapple marmalade. One shrimp is just enough, so you can save room for their melty cheese curds! This app makes me want to be on a beach, with a pina colada in one hand and a book in the other. Beer-battered Cheese Curds: we get an order every time, large enough to share, and always piping hot. We love that the breeding isn't crumbly but, instead, a smooth batter that lets us enjoy the Ellsworth cheese. Yummy! Lobster Tail: I've gotten this a few times and it's always good, served with clarified butter and a lemon wedge. Caesar Salad: one of the better Caesar dressings around, this is a clean and simple salad. And we love it, so many gross Caesar salads out there in the world! Side of Mushrooms: I did not love these, not because they weren't a beautiful pile of perfectly sautéed mushrooms but because I cannot stand truffle oil and tasted a hint of. I should've asked, as more and more places use truffle oils nowadays. If it wasn't for the truffle oil, I would've devoured this side dish. Cheesecake & Creme Brûlée: loved the cheesecake, the crème brûlée was just so so. We also love their bread pudding and brunch time cinnamon roll. we've eaten ourselves through their menus and keep coming back! Their breakfast french toasts and eggs benedicts are also exquisite. Basically, we love it all here. If you're around the Minneapolis area, especially if you're heading north on I35, make yourselves a reservation and enjoy a beautiful meal at Gary's Supper Club in Lakeville! -- at Gary's Supper Club. read more

See all

First time here this week. Table of 7 and, for the most part, everyone was satisfied. Except, one person in our party ordered a medium rare filet and the center was beyond blue. Granted, this might be how a thicker cut looks. However, had them cook it up more and barely did anything. Then, cooked a new one and cooked it exactly the same as the first, very blue in the middle. The manager came over with a scoul on her face. I looked up online how it should look/how the person in our group wanted it and showed it to the manager. Explained also that maybe that is how medium rare looks but this person in our party clearly didnt want it raw/blue in the center. Instead of explaining something like, "sorry about that. Our filet done medium rare does look like this, would you like me to tell them to cook it medium?" The manager says in a snotty tone, "I know my steaks" and walked off. Never came back to check in or apologize. I dont care how wrong the customer might be, the manager should have explained and confirmed what was expected and make it happen without attitude. This was horribly unprofessional of the manager. Our server was ok but never refilled our waters or asked about drinks once we were eating. Not sure how I feel about this place. Seems a little pretentious and rude. Would give higher rating, but the rudeness of the manager was just unacceptable. read more

There was plenty of space to find parking in the lot. We met up with some friends for dinner. My order was good. My friends order was messed up twice, but she didn't say anything about the second time because she was hungry and everyone was almost done with their meals by the time hers arrived. The server was friendly. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Lobster roll and fries - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Our server was fantastic. The hostess was not there when we entered and than was eating at her station when we left! Never seen that before. My filet was a very lean cut and cooked perfectly! The drunken shrimp were amazing. Weird to give gummy bears as part of a complimentary app tray before your meal! The prices overall are higher than what we felt they should be, especially drinks. The atmosphere is nice but not spectacular. We will give it another chance as the food was very good. But will go elsewhere for pre or post dinner drinks. read more

Great dinner spot with wonderful food. The service is friendly, especially when you belly up at the bar. The restaurant is swanky and feels nice and fancy throughout the decor. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Steak bites - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

We went here for Father's Day. We sat outside in a beautiful outdoor patio and it was the perfect day for it. I thought the service was great, we had two people that were constantly checking in with us, and it was obvious that they cared about every detail in giving us the best experience we could have. For appetizers, we had the drunken coconut shrimp, which with the accompanying pineapple sauce made it one of the best appetizers I've had in recent memory. I remember making the comment if I only have those, then I was going to be satisfied with my experience there. I had the walleye dinner which was impeccable. A couple at our table had the lobster roll which they said was good, but both said they wanted more lobster in the sandwich for the price. Another in our party had a prime rib sandwich, and because of our conversation, she did not get to it right away, but it seemed to be a delight as well. Crème brûlée was very good and with the strawberries made it very refreshing. All in all, we thought this was an amazing place, and we will be back. read more

I believe this is very close to the Capitol Grille. The food was great, and the drinks were to die for Excellent service, very attentive here Overall great experience Meek reservations early, and it gets booked fast!!' read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Salmon - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

See all

Good food and great service. Enjoy this location. Prices are reasonable. Will keep going back.

This was my first time coming after the renovations and turning into Gary's! Not your traditional supper club vices, definitely more upscale. You do still get a fun little relish tray with pickles, gummy bears and some nuts. Our group ordered some cheese curds to start because they were on special, very good. Crunchy and cheesy! For my main meal I got chicken parmesan. You can tell the sauce was very fresh. It was good, but I'll try something else next time. The rest of the orders were prime rib, lobster roll and jambalaya. The lobster roll was pretty small and not much meat, flavor was there though. The star of the show was the jambalaya. Incredible. Very spicy but filled with meats. We are excited to go back and try some other things. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Relish tray - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

The service was fantastic! Our server was very polite and personable. The food was very good too. I would highly recommend the prime rib egg rolls. The old fashioned was very tasty but $17 for a drink is a bit steep for me. Overall, we had a great experience. My only complaint is the prices. Drinks were much too expensive and the entrees were a bit over priced too. Will consider coming back for a special occasion but won't be returning regularly. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Prime Rib Egg Rolls - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Always great quality food and friendly service. There are items on HH menu that are not on the regular menu, so get here before HH pricing ends at 5:00 pm read more

See all

Excellent lunch and service. Had the coconut shrimp appetizer converted to a full lunch - coleslaw and fries. Very fresh and tasty. Large shrimp. Enjoyed tres leches and amazing coffee for dessert. Checkout the patio dining. It's a ten. Stunning lighting and plantings. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Outdoor dining - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Our first experience at Gary's was great. We had reservations for a Saturday night and were seated immediately at a half-moon shaped leather booth. It was good for conversation but also fun so see the activity of the restaurant. I ordered an app as a meal, coconut/panko shrimp. I asked for a veggies instead of the fries and was able to get steamed broccoli for an up charge. Everything was very good. The shrimp would have been better with a bit less coating, but still good. Veggies were nice and fresh. All others loved their meals. We started with the popovers which were delicious. You get three and there were 4 of us so had to share. Service was excellent. He was efficient and we never felt hurried. Love the vibe of the restaurant and supper club feel with dark wood and leather. Lots of other meals I want to try so we will be back. read more

See all

Disappointing. Would have been happier with entrees that were half the size and twice the quality. The menu and recipes are screaming for improvement. And maybe fewer frozen Sysco products. The gummy bears in the relish tray were mildly cute, but how many people actually eat them? Not worth a return visit, although none of us ordered any big hunks o' meat; maybe they are better at that. If so, that's probably where they should concentrate their efforts. read more

This restaurant is a love/hate place for us. We love the staff and when the food is good, it's really good. The past couple experiences have not panned out. From the Over-Sous Vide NY Strip also under charred. Too long in a Sous Vide makes for bad texture. This trip, it was the rotting asparagus and the embarrassingly small overcooked portion of Halibut. The halibut has been one of my favorite meals here. I think this time they tried to compensate with 2# of risotto. I will mention again the drain flies at the bar. Nearly every time I am there for over 4-6 months. If the problem is that persistent, it might be time to get a new exterminator. Nothing wrecks a meal like getting buzzed, especially when it's cold out! Please improve. Train up your kitchen staff. If there is not enough halibut say "we're out". If the Aspargus is rotting or looks like weeds, offer an alternative. I work hard, $50 for what is shown is sad. Would rather eat a filet of fish. read more

See all

This place is awesome. The bald guy with the glasses who stands up front when you walk in is great at his job. Such a friendly guy. The atmosphere and food are wonderful. read more

Food was ok. Ordered scallops. Too much hard asparagus. Second entree was salmon. Perfectly cooked. Way too many hard string beans...and a mound of mashed potatoes. Busy place...more sports bar atmosphere vs. supper club. Service was decent....received food fairly quick. Tried the lobster guacamole....very good-definitely recommend. read more

This was our first visit to Gary's. We'd been to the location years ago under a different owner but the decor now is quite upscale. We enjoyed the special Thanksgiving feast which was far more food than two could eat. (All leftovers were packed up to go.) The food was very good; especially the sweetened, caramelized yams. We thought this was an exceptional meal for the price. A special nod to Jordan B., our server. She didn't miss a beat, and was friendly and knowledgeable. Btw, the restaurant was packed but ran like a well-oiled machine. We'll be back. read more

Gary’s Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

See all

Expensive and the food was unimpressive. Bad value for the price. Would be a lot higher rated if the portions were ao small and prices too high for the food size. read more

Gary's Supper Club is a wonderful restaurant right off I-35. Tuesdays lobster is $35:) We try to go at happy hour 2-5pm for half off appetizers too. The server was kind, well informed of all the questions we asked and as professional as they come. I love the new look inside, it very much lives up to the supper club vibe. read more

See all

Randomly visited for Father's Day 2025 and for my fairly picky parents (not picky eaters but picky about quality) they both found something they liked. The avocado toast I had was delightful and I wished I could have taken it with me for leftovers. I ended up coming back a few months later after picking up a friend from the airport and we stopped for lunch and once again both enjoyed our dishes. It seemed like such a random location off the highway (and I won't lie, "supper club" kind of gave me weird vibes at first) but it's great! It definitely has more of a moody, restaurant-bar vibe but is family friendly (I've seen plenty of children) and there is a large outdoor seating area for good weather days. read more

Food is very expensive, 12 oysters are $48.00/ 1/2 price on happy hour? Service is very good, but you should expect that at those prices! It's a Special Occasion Destination for most People, when Entrees are $35-75, or more, tack on Tip, and Taxes. Nice ambience in the evening, but location looks like a Mac Donald's after thought next to a Walmart! I've bet there a Couple times but it's not the Vibe I enjoy. Looking out the window at a parking lot leaves a lot to be desired! read more