Gemelli Gelato

1048

397

968

3 years ago

It's not a summer without Gemelli Gelato! Just how I remembered it. The chocolate was smooth and creamy. Can't wait to go back again! read more

Gemelli Gelato - a sign in front of a building - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you very much for this great review! We will be open on May…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Danielle P.

620

870

914

2 years ago

This place was a let down. After driving by Gemelli and never stopping in multiple summers in a row, I finally made it a point to come here just to find that what they're serving is not gelato. It's overly sweet and the consistency isn't what traditional gelato should be. That said, it's still good. But is it $6.75 for a small cup good? Wait on a long line good? Cash only good? No, it's not. The ambiance of this place is really nice. It's all outdoors on a giant long with seating and games to play, so a great place to take the kids and let them run around after hopping them up with sugar. I don't have kids ...but can only guess this is what you'd do with them. It's kind of a shame that we don't have any other ice cream spots available in the immediate area, but I'd drive to Snowflake and brave that line over this place any day. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maria G.

49

226

391

3 years ago

Nice seating area outside You can take nice pictures infront of the place Friendly staff gelato was pretty good read more

Gemelli Gelato - Parking sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kim K.

66

385

693

3 years ago

Gemelli Gelato is a fun little gelato spot. Packed interior funnels you in and out and you can e joy your gelato in Adirondacks or a picnic bench on a spacious lawn. Cash only. Did not notice but don't think they had a restroom. Good variety of gelato flavors - not overwhelming but enough to make you consider your choice. Samples are available to help you decide. I liked the fun little scoop shape cup and baby cone topping. My gelato had excellent texture and was not too sweet. I would add this to your list of must visits in the area. read more

Gemelli Gelato - Community Board - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Kim!! Have a great rest of the Summer!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Debra M.

35

65

0

2 years ago

Adorable place ! Bring cash .... Fair prices ! More like ice cream , nice flavors..... Not Italian rich gelato ! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jamie M.

14

34

9

2 years ago

Yummmmmmmmmyyyyy! This place is yummy but cash only! Be prepared! I love the little cone with the dish option. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lauren J.

15

41

0

2 years ago

Horrible. Just horrible. Ice crystals on gelato. Terrible flavors. Go to carvel instead.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bloss C.

867

1447

3639

4 years ago

Cash only is the only downside of Gemelli Gelato I can think of. Great quality gelato, nice seating area outside with adirondack chairs to sit and enjoy your gelato. Price wise it was very reasonable, we ordered seven small cones/cups for about $45. I had the salted carmel and wished i had ordered a large. I would stop by again when in the area. read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much for this AWESOME review. We are so honored to have…

Helpful 6

Thanks 0

Love this 5

Oh no 0

Jeannie L.

13

91

35

2 years ago

This place had the best gelato and I have been to Italy!! Owner is the sweetest and you can tell he puts his heart and soul into this place. They have alot of great flavors to choose from and you can sit on a comfy Adirondack chair and enjoy your dessert. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mercedes C.

Elite 26 All-Star

41

2201

20492

6 years ago

When it comes to gelato places, I'm really not sure who are the dominant players in the Hamptons. Even if I missed a couple of places, it was 8:30pm already when we decided to get some and wouldn't have given us time to get to before they closed for the night. But on Montauk Hwy in Hampton Bays, this was just a 10 minute drive from our hotel. Gemelli Gelato has a sprawling space. And talk about social distancing protocols- Adirondack chairs were set up in two's on the lawn more than 6' apart! Additionally, picnics tables on the perimeter were also spaced out accordingly. We happily popped the trunk instead- just because I can't see anybody wiping down all those chairs. Gemelli Gelato has their shop a bit away from the parking lot, so I hoofed it a bit. The owner was helpful but rushed us folks on the line too. Granted it was almost closing time. Plus he had asked me and other folks if we preordered and I nodded 'no'. The shop is clean, small and he was just letting one person in- or a family at a time. AND there was only one scooper girl- so can you imagine her scooping out "gelato" to a family of 4 let's say??? Got a small Vanilla topped with walnuts for hubs and a small strawberry for me topped with Chocolate sprinkles. Damage for those? $12- too much in my opinion. I'm not surprised if food coloring and "strawberry" artificial flavoring was added. I know what natural strawberry ice cream, gelato, heck...even a Mexican strawberry "paleta" tastes like- and THIS wasn't it! On top of that, hubs said his vanilla had the texture of frozen milk! Am I missing something because this place tops the charts here? Not sure- but this isn't what I call great gelato. read more

Gemelli Gelato - Looks Good- (But My Strawberry Gelato Tasted Mediciny) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

In tough times as these we appreciate your review very much. It is…

Helpful 24

Thanks 0

Love this 19

Oh no 0

Amy M.

424

293

1516

6 years ago

Excellent! We've been here twice and both times we had absolutely delicious gelato. It tasted magnificent. I had the Chocolate Marshmallow Chip today and my husband had the Coconut. The service was superb. We had to wait outside for a few minutes due to the new safety regulations and one guy let us know the wait wouldn't be too long. Once inside the guys behind the counter -- both wearing masks as appropriate -- were so friendly and helpful. I appreciate businesses that are being extra hygienic and careful during these times. I wouldn't hesitant to return for more yummy gelato! It was a nice addition to our holiday weekend and a great way to sit and relax and enjoy a lovely afternoon treat. I highly recommend! read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much the the awesome 5 star review. We appreciate it…

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Rachel T.

0

6

2

2 years ago

Excellent gelato. Only downside is they only take cash but luckily i had some on me. If i was in the area i would return.

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you Rachel. We appreciate your review very much. Have a great…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sha S.

37

159

346

4 years ago

Definitely get gelato from here if you take a trip to the Hamptons! It's so refreshing on a hot summer day and they have chairs all around their gigantic lawn so you can order and chill and watch the children and dogs play around. They sometimes have a line but that just shows how good they are. I'll definitely be back this summer. read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much for your review. We really appreciate it. Great…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Merilyn A.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Amazing Gellato and refreshing place to be at I recommend Pistachio mixed with Nutella it creates a good flavor read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Merilyn. We appreciate your review very much. Have…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Art C.

308

2818

1928

5 years ago

They make a decent scoop. We biked here, scored a few scoops from a nice selection, claimed a couple of chairs on their expansive lawn, and lived the good life (which of course includes ice cream/gelato- don't be stupid). Nice people doing the scooping too... read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you for your review. We are happy you enjoyed the shop. We work…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kimberly C.

269

183

1231

6 years ago

Had to stop by now that it's summer, this is one of our favorite spots! I love how they are taking extra measures to make sure we are all safe during these uncertain times, by limiting access to people by enforcing social distancing. It's nice to see the workers constantly cleaning and sanitizing. My husband got the "Chocolate elephant" amaze balls. It has peanut butter ice cream with chewy brownies and chocolate chips, yummy! I went with the "The lemon sorbet" which is so refreshing on a really hot day like today. And the best part it's made with real lemons that they squeeze themselves! Something about fresh made just makes it taste that much better. My son got "blue berry basil". It has fresh blueberries and fresh basil Blueberry in a purée. The employee was so knowledgeable they were able to answer all our questions as described above, we asked about almost every flavor lol. Thanks again for the great experience as always! read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Kim for taking the time to notice our health…

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Steven T.

301

369

2618

8 years ago

Tonight we visited Gemelli Gelato. We live in Hampton Bay's and seer it all the time, they are next to Buckleys Inn, one of our favorites. We just saw Gemelli's featured on News 12 East end and figured that it estas time for a visit. You arrive at the location where they have their oversized gellato cones on the front lawn. You walk up a long path to their quaint little structure with outside seating only. Their are lawn games to play for the kids as well. Inside, they are all staff with a young and happy crew ready to greet you and help you decide which selections are right for you. They have small spoons for tastings. We both ordered the caramel and pretzel gellati....awesome and I your mind with the sicilian cannoli gellato which as great! I will make it a point to visit there often. read more

Gemelli Gelato - The front ambiance. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Gemelli Gelato - Choices - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Gemelli Gelato - Sicilian canoli! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Gemelli Gelato - Delicious always! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Hey Steven, Thank you for the 5 stars. We take pride in always…

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julianna H.

123

35

98

6 years ago

We love the flavors at Gemelli, and the kind people there. Their portions are large which is great. They also do not use egg in their gelato (as most places in America do), so their gelato tastes like low traditional and authentic Italian gelato. I love the outdoor seating area as well. read more

Gemelli Gelato - 2 size-smalls - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Hey Julianna…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Genesis B.

Elite 21

227

113

81

6 years ago

WOW!!!! Really love this gelato place. It taste so fresh and the flavors are delicious! (I had Nutella & it was to die for) Must go if you are in the area. read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Wow. That is such a great review. Thank you so much Genesis. We…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Pax M.

0

35

63

6 years ago

Highly recommend Gemelli Gelato! Super friendly staff and beautiful outdoor seating area. Pet friendly is a big plus! Bought pint of vanilla and chocolate gelato! Yum yum! Will definitely return! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Our pup can't get enough of Gemelli gelato! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much for the Paw-some review. We appreciate it very…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jonathan K.

51

130

289

6 years ago

Another must-go in Hampton Bays! Outstanding, fresh gelato. Easy parking in adjacent lot. Great friendly staff. read more

Gemelli Gelato - Parking for Gemelli Gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Jonathan. We appreciate the review very much. Stay…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom E.

Elite 24

428

349

2689

7 years ago

Really cute place. It's oddly situated on the backend of a huge open yard/park in the middle of town. The building itself is quite small. I can see how it might be easy to miss, but I'm happy we saw it. There's a good amount of flavors of ice cream for such a small place. I gravitated towards the chocolate marshmallow chip after my tasting. Ended up loving it so much. Rich chocolate ice cream with a marshmallow or chocolate chip in every bite. Also tried the espresso chip and the rum raisin. Both great as well. They have delicious looking brownies, cookies, and chocolate covered fruit too that I wish I had tried. The man that helped us was very friendly. I'm pretty sure he was the owner. I showed him that we checked in through yelp to get the free water with a purchase of 20 bucks or more and he didn't even know about the offer but gave it to us anyway. The park out front is really cute. Great place to take your family during the day. I can definitely imagine coming here to walk my dog and stopping by here for some gelato on a hot day. I will definitely come back when I'm in town again. read more

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Hey Tom,…

Helpful 10

Thanks 0

Love this 6

Oh no 0

Rachel S.

1

12

1

3 years ago

This gelato was so delicious and authentic! I tried hazelnut, pistachio and Nutella. Highly recommend coming here. Nice sitting area outside but nowhere to sit inside. Also cash only. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Melissa P.

181

608

1385

5 years ago

I'm really not sure how this place has such great reviews. When going to a gelato place you expect the flavors to be rich and have quality ingredients, but I can say that I found the gelato to be far from that. I got the chocolate with marshmallows and chips as well as the strawberry and both flavors tasted so bland. The chocolate was not rich and the marshmallows they used were the mini ones in the bag as compared to melted marshmallow and the chocolate was mini chocolate chips rather than chocolate chip chunks. The strawberry also just didn't have a strong strawberry flavor. It almost tasted like vanilla ice cream with a little strawberry flavoring. My husband did like the black cherry though. Oh and they only take cash and it was $20 for 1 cup and 1Red velvet cone. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Debra J.

0

56

0

2 years ago

The smoothest gelato ever! Making this our go to place for a sweet treat! All the flavors looked delicious !

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Debra. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Have a great…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ger I.

0

13

12

4 years ago

Oh Yum! My friend has never had gelato. She is a huge fan now! :)

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much. We are so glad that the first time she had Gelato…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Suzanne F.

368

463

1327

8 years ago

We went here after seeing them on restaurant hunters on FiOS. A nice hot day nothing better than some fresh gelato. They have an assortment of flavors and different types of waffle cones. Gelato and cone hit the spot. They have a huge lawn with lawn games and picnic tables to just hang and enjoy the weather. The only downfall is there cash only. And one other thing they don't have bathrooms. So my suggestion would be take out and bring your cash. read more

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Hi Suzanne, thank you for coming in to our shop. We wish you had a…

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Aina B.

Elite 23

105

267

57

6 years ago

Yum! A fantastic gelato and friendly service- I had two scoops, each different flavors-- one hazelnut and one espresso chip. The hazelnut was delightful and I'd gladly go back for more, but couldn't quite taste the espresso chip as strong as I would have hoped. The only thing that disappointed me, and I noticed this across the Hamptons, was that the scoop sizes were tiny! Like, itty bitty spoon size! For $5+! I guess it's the local custom but I wish places would give just a little bit more for the price! I'd still go back for their lemon sorbetto, it looked very enticing. read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much for your review. We hope you have a great Summer!…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mikey D.

2

20

11

6 years ago

We follow them on Instagram and Facebook and saw them on News 12. It was really great to see a business who is so nice to make it to the news. Good luck Gemelli. See you in May! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Flavored Waffle Cones - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Gemelli Gelato - Enjoying Gelato at Gemelli in the front Lawn! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Hey Mikey, thank you so much for the photos and the kind words. We…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley Z.

0

26

10

4 years ago

Amazing staff, kind and helpful. Gelato is amazing, would return over and over again. Perfect dessert to end the day with.

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Ashley. We really appreciate and value your 5 star…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

E. N.

1

126

11

4 years ago

Very very hit or miss for me. Loved: affogato over chocolate ice cream. Tasted strachatelli, it had nice crunchy bits of chocolate. Did not like.: raspberry and mango sherbets tasted very similar but different vivid colors. Super sweet. Pistachio is not pistachio tasting green ice cream. I threw away my sherbets, waste of calories. Beautiful lawn and chairs in fron of the shop, but many flies. Everything is sold for cash. You do not see that too often. read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thanks for the review. All of our Sorbetto are made with fresh fruit…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Braden W.

22

40

15

6 years ago

Great gelato place. Fresh rotation of house made flavors daily and a beautiful lawn to sit and relax on! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Beautiful lawn - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Gemelli Gelato - Espresso and chocolate with marshmallows. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Braden for your kind reviews. We appreciate it very…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

A C.

16

15

0

3 years ago

Really great location and good ice cream. Pretty outdoor area and nice staff. Only reason not 5 stars is that it's really more traditional ice cream rather than gelato. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Josie T.

Elite 25

9

63

85

6 years ago

I absolutely love this place! I like going there in person but recently I've been using UberEats to get my fix. They sent me the cutest little cones with my order! I definitely recommend the Nutella gelato it's unforgettable. read more

Gemelli Gelato - Nutella gelato and a tiny cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much Josie. We appreciate you always ordering and being…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dana P.

0

4

0

5 years ago

Very good! If you were wondering what exactly gelato is, I couldn't tell you, but I do know that it tastes like ice cream and is tasty. They've got a cute grassy area with chairs and picnic tables to enjoy said gelato. You can even do two flavors in a size small! wow! a nice treat on a summer night. Thanks Gemelli read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

J H.

4

40

16

6 years ago

Amazing service and gelato! The staff was so welcoming and we absolutely loved their recommendations ! Will totally be coming back!! read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Thank you so much. We are so glad you loved our shop and our gelato!…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Reed S.

0

7

2

7 years ago

Was definitely worth a 45 min drive ! Amazing gelato and employees are all so welcoming. read more

Business owner information

Gemelli G.

Hey Reed, thank you so much for the great review and the perfect…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 4

See more reviews

More info about Gemelli Gelato

139 W Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bays, NY 11946
Directions
(631) 594-5600
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://gemelligelatohamptonbays.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Gemelli Gelato open?

Gemelli Gelato opens at 1:00 PM on Monday, Saturday and Sunday.Gemelli Gelato opens at 2:00 PM on Friday.

What time does Gemelli Gelato close?

Gemelli Gelato closes at 8:30 PM on Monday.Gemelli Gelato is closed on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.Gemelli Gelato closes at 9:00 PM on Friday.Gemelli Gelato closes at 9:30 PM on Saturday and Sunday.

Mon 1:00 PM - 8:30 PMTue-Thu ClosedFri 2:00 PM - 9:00 PMSat-Sun 1:00 PM - 9:30 PM

Payment methods

Does Gemelli Gelato take Bitcoin?

No, Gemelli Gelato does not take Bitcoin.

Does Gemelli Gelato take credit cards?

No, Gemelli Gelato does not take credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Gemelli Gelato have catering options?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato does have catering options.

Does Gemelli Gelato have a drive thru?

No, Gemelli Gelato does not have a drive thru.

Indoor Amenities

Does Gemelli Gelato allow dogs?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Gemelli Gelato have bike parking?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato has bike parking.

Does Gemelli Gelato have outdoor seating?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato has outdoor seating options.

Does Gemelli Gelato have parking?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Gemelli Gelato wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato is wheelchair accessible.

Does Gemelli Gelato have free WiFi?

Yes, Gemelli Gelato has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Artisan Gelato & Sorbetto, Beautiful Outdoor Seating, Lawn Games, Italian Drinks, Specialty Waffle Cones, Chocolates, Espresso, Shakes and much more ! Ask about our Gelato Cart Catering Service! We do not accept credit cards. Thank you Gelato Catering Available for Long Island!! Thing to do in the Hamptons Ice cream Gelato

History

Established in 2014.

Our Gelato Shop is glad to be open for our 5th Season. We have brought new drinks, waffle cones, Gelato, Sorbetto, and Lawn Games for everyone to enjoy. Please come and enjoy our Outdoor Seating. Feel free to ask for Samples of any Gelato you would like!!

Meet the Business Owner: Charlie F.

Our story starts back in 2004 when we started working at an Italian Caffé in our old neighborhood. Over the course of 11 years Charlie & Anthony learned the Gelato trade from a man known as Mr. Joe. Mr. Joe was born in 1927 in Santa Ninfa, Sicily. After coming to America, Mr. Joe owned and operated several Italian Coffee Shops. In his "Bars", Mr. Joe served espresso, cappuccino, croissants also known as "Cornetto" and Cannoli's with homemade ricotta cream and not to forget his Gelato. Mr. Joe had much pride and dedication for his business working seven days a week. You rarely came for your shot of espresso without seeing him. Local Italians would gather daily to socialize, most of the time speaking Italian while drinking their espresso. Charlie & Anthony were two Long Island born Italian boys. From a young age they would always pass the caffé on their bicycles wishing one day they would be able to get a job there. The boys were both ambitious and eager to work, so they went inside an

You might also consider

Carvel

3.0(19 reviews)

0.6 mi

I love their cake batter and cherry vanilla. Consistently good. But train your new staff to say…read more"you're welcome" instead of "yup" and to fill up the entire cup with icecream rather than flat top it. $8 for a medium with tax for a cup is not cheap, when u can get a lot more for the same at grocery stores. Plus, your icecream is somewhat melted so it fills up the cup easier and you're not really getting the full scoops.

Buyer beware... Posted prices are not accurate. They have "raised their prices" but have decided…read morenot to let customers know! I think that's illegal!

See all

Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe

4.7(364 reviews)

8.6 mi

Service is great and everyone that works the re go out of…read morethere way great service Ice cream is the best around

Outstanding service, flavor selection, and delicious ice cream. I ordered the pistachio cherry and…read moredad got cherry vanilla.

Storefront

Crochet Ice Cream Cones

See all

The ice cream shot.

Sundaes On Main

5.0(4 reviews)

12.6 mi

Great icecream. They take fire department discount. Super yummy. I got chocolate and Mary Jane.read more

loved the flavors... different and delicious. Great selection of candies in the back as well.read more

Sundaes On Main

See all

Sundaes On Main - Main Street, Bridgehampton

The Sweet Spot

4.0(10 reviews)

18.8 mi

Nestled in the heart of East Hampton Village, The Sweet Spot Ice Cream is a delightful, quaint shop…read morethat serves up delicious frozen treats. A friendly staff offers a wide selection of ice cream flavors and an array of tasty toppings. Customers can also help themselves to self-serve soft serve ice cream and yogurt. Though the shop can get quite crowded during the busy summer season, convenient street parking is available.

Refused service by the cashier on Augst 29, 2025. She would not take my $10 bill because it was…read moretaped and would not take my $100 bill. Her comment was I did not need to purchase the ice cream. Never experienced such rude and unprofessional customer service from an employee in such a quaint shop. Cannot comment on the ice cream because I never tasted it. Will never set foot in the shop again.

My creation

See all

10 flavors available

A La Mode Shoppe

4.6(14 reviews)

19.0 mi

The A La Mode Ice Cream Shoppe in East Hampton offers both dairy and non-dairy flavors…read more Try the Salted Carmel, Sprinkle or the Partly Cloudy. The service and ice cream is top notch. A special Thanks to Andrew for your hospitality.

Eh, followed the reviews here and wasn't that crazy about it. Read all about the Party Cloudy…read morecotton candy ice cream with marshmallows, but it tasted kind of flavorless - like cold sugar and milk in a cup. The banana caramel flavor was delicious too, though tasted a little synthetic. Wouldn't come back but glad to try it and enjoyed the people-watching outside and the adorable kids clothing shopping inside.

Front of shop

See all

The flavors

Shock Ice Cream & Dessert Cafe

4.0(46 reviews)

7.5 mi

Shock Ice Cream is such a fun spot with amazing ice cream. The flavors are creative, rich, and…read moresuper fresh, and you can tell they use high-quality ingredients. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is great, and the portions were generous too. It's the only ice cream place that my kids will go to! Definitely one of the best ice cream places around.

What a charming little ice cream shop hiding behind an alleyway that is lit up at night in such a…read morecute way. Follow the path to some truly delectable ice cream. My current favorites here are the Cappuccino Crunch and the Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk. I enjoyed them so much that I'm not sure I can change on my next visit. But I will definitely be back during the summer nights.

See all

Southampton Carvel

3.6(21 reviews)

7.4 mi

Love Carvel! Best soft serve ice cream and now they offer different flavors. I love the pistachio!!…read moreA small costs about $7 and it's a rather big serving so I can't imagine what a large would be like.

Went here for dessert. Food, service and ambiance is good. But they don't have a restroom. No…read morechairs inside too. U just hope to find a bench outside or eat it while walking. Got Reese ice cream and a carvel cake ice cream with walnuts and almonds. He put too much toppings to my liking. I was hoping for just a sprinkle but it's ok.

Sizable small pistachio soft serve with rainbow sprinkles

Vanilla soft-serve

See all

Delicious! Couldn't resist...

Magic Fountain

4.5(284 reviews)

7.5 mi

•$

I've been coming to Magic Fountain since I was a kid, and for good reason! They have delicious ice…read morecream from a rotating menu of flavors that has so many interesting concoctions. On my most recent trip, they had Dubai Chocolate and Spicy Mango, both really fun and delicious in their own way. I ended up getting a scoop of the North Fork, and it was delicious. My friend got a vanilla milkshake and gave rave reviews as well. There's usually a line snaking out the door (the inside isn't very big), but they've got a good system for keeping things moving, so don't be dissuaded. If you're driving to/from the North Fork, make the drive even better with a stop here!

This is one of the best homemade ice cream shops on the Island, yes it's on the East End in…read moreMattituck but so definitely worth the trip. They have over 50 flavors and priced right for your enjoyment. Great store where you wait in line until they call you in, there are benches outside where you can sit and a lot of people start talking to one another... the power of ice cream, highly recommend and they make ice cream cakes as well.

Butter pecan

Oreo cup

See all

2 scoop ice cream: Kulfi and Rainbow Cookie

John's Drive-In

3.5(301 reviews)

32.3 mi

Was not expecting it whatsoever and had one of the best cheeseburgers of my whole life.read more

Love John's ice cream. Usually don't visit in the fall so was excited to see the pumpkin flavors. I…read moregot a large with pumpkin Oreo and raspberry chocolate truffle, which is what I usually order. The pumpkin Oreo was so good I wish I just got that since it's not a flavor you can usually get.

Pumpkin Oreo

See all

The line

Caffe Italia

4.4(130 reviews)

42.4 mi

•$

If you think you've had great gelato, Caffe Italia will make you question everything you thought…read moreyou knew. The man behind the magic is Mike, the owner -- and he is the real deal. Born in Italy and trained by the best, making gelato isn't his job, it's his calling. You can taste that distinction in every single bite. Mike is constantly developing new recipes, hand-picking fresh fruit at the market, and importing specialty ingredients straight from Italy when he can't find what meets his standards locally. This is a man who simply refuses to cut corners. My family and I have been loyal customers for nearly 8 years, and what's remarkable is that it's just as mind-blowing today as it was the very first time we walked through the door. That kind of consistency is rare -- and it speaks volumes. Over the years, we've brought roughly 40 friends and family members here for the first time. Every single one of them has raved about it. That's not a coincidence. That's excellence. If you're visiting for the first time, do yourself a favor: try the rainbow cookie gelato. You can thank me later. And while many people get it to go, I suggest having it there. The shop is tastefully decorated, it's clean, it's comfortable. For fifteen minutes you'll think you're in Italy. Caffe Italia isn't just the best gelato in the county -- it may very well be the best you'll ever have. Don't walk. Run.

I liked this place but his prices are out of control. I paid $17.00 for a cone and small cup of…read moregelato. I was just in Rome, Italy and paid €7.00 for 2 cones of the most amazing gelato by the Spanish steps in a touristy expensive area. We shouldn't be paying these prices in deer park. It's not nice, it's not Manhasset. Also, weirdly, the owner only employs Ukrainian women and screams at them like they are peasants. Price gauging and abusive employer. Nice.

When you're here, you're in Italy!

Strawberry and cookies and cream gelato with a wafer on top

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Charles F.

0

8

0

6 years ago

Gemelli Gelato was one of the best spots we stopped by this weekend. We tasted their new flavor Graham Central Station and it was delicious. The staff was very friendly and they were at the door opening and closing it for each customer so they did not have to touch it. At the end of the night we also saw the younger kid with the yellow shirt on cleaning and hosing down the chairs and tables. We had a small convo and he said they do this three times a day and offer customers side texting wipes throughout the day to wipe down the chairs before they sit. They are on top of their game! Thank you Gemelli! read more

Rebecca G.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Stopped by on Sunday because we saw them listed in Newsday as one of the best places to get Gelato on Long Island. We quickly knew the reason for that article. We tried the Nutella and the Hazelnut. It was super creamy and it was delicious. My friend has the Affogato with Hazelnut Gelato. It was very tasty and refreshing. We are glad we stopped by. We took a few photos and tagged the shop in our post. They reposted them on their Instagram. It was a very cool experience. Thank you Gemelli! read more

Rosario S. C.