Very good! If you were wondering what exactly gelato is, I couldn't tell you, but I do know that it tastes like ice cream and is tasty. They've got a cute grassy area with chairs and picnic tables to enjoy said gelato. You can even do two flavors in a size small! wow! a nice treat on a summer night. Thanks Gemelli read more

Really great location and good ice cream. Pretty outdoor area and nice staff. Only reason not 5 stars is that it's really more traditional ice cream rather than gelato. read more

Amazing service and gelato! The staff was so welcoming and we absolutely loved their recommendations ! Will totally be coming back!! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Was definitely worth a 45 min drive ! Amazing gelato and employees are all so welcoming. read more

Gemelli Gelato - . - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

We ended up at this place after deciding we wanted ice cream while driving down Montauk Highway. It was 20 minutes before we came across any place which happened to be here! There was also two ice cream chains but we decided to try something different and I'm glad we did! This gelato is SO good! The Pistachio was delicious & I also had a scoop of Chocolate Marshmallow Chip. It's a little pricey, but I think it's worth the treat. Employees were very nice and you are welcome to have a sample of any flavor you'd like to try. It's cash only, so come prepared. They have beaches out front on a big lawn to hang out and eat which is nice especially if you come with kids. I'm a little sad it's so far because I'd love to go here again! I'll just have to find something near me. read more

See all

Great gelato. Best thing on a hot day. Loved the trio favor. Service was great! Followed GPS from ferry. Worth the trip. Thank you to Gemelli Gelato. read more

Adorable little shop with a gorgeous lawn set-up where you can enjoy your gelato! Tons of flavors of both gelato and sorbet, and the owner is so patient and friendly. Have a kid with food allergies, and he was happy to answer questions. We will definitely be back! read more

Walked into gemelli after a nice hot day of fishing. They were eager to let us try the flavors and the staff was extremely kind and courteous. Overall I dont think their gelato tasted like gelato. More like regulation ice cream average run of the mill. Maybe I should've tried one of the fancy cones. I would definitely come back and try another flavor with a special cone or waffle. I got the strawberry gelato. read more

If your in the area it is worth a visit. Outdoor seating area is great gelato is very good.

AMAZINGGGGG!!! Seriously so delicious, my whole family tried the sorbetto and it was fantastic. Highly recommend tasting the blood orange flavor WOW so freaking good!! read more

Wonderful place! Different varieties of fresh, real gelato! I loved the strawberry flavor, it was fantastic! I also picked few other flavors, I guess it was dumpster and peanut butter chocolate one, and liked it as well. It has a great outside picnic area (tables, chairs, games) so you and your family could relax and enjoy delicious ice cream. read more

The gelato was delicious, and the owner is so nice. We will definitely be coming back here!

i love gemelli gelato so much i actually pee myself every time i go the gelato is always peak and the little cone that comes with the cups is so cute like ong whoever thought of that needs a raise asap i love gemmie :3 read more

O.k. so I gave this place a second try and had a much much better experience the second time around. For starters the gentleman behind the counter was very nice and actually bothered to ask me what size gelato I would like, unlike the last time. It actually took me more than two bits to finish. This time I tried totally different flavors and all of them were much better than the previous experience. Toasted marshmallow is definitely a favorite. I'm beginning to like this place. Too bad they are closing soon because the season is almost over. Oh well, there's always next year. read more

This is by far the best ice cream place in all of the hamptons!!!! The flavors are soooo good and unique and well priced too. I won't go to any other Hamptons ice cream place and come from southampton to go here read more

Gemelli's offers a great selection of homemade gelato. Delicious! A friendly atmosphere. Enjoy sitting outside while eating your gelato. Lots of places to sit you will never be rushed to leave. Great place, a must. read more

Super friendly service and cute atmosphere. Gelato was nothing to rave about, average but not spectacular. Somewhat bland, and wasn't creamy or rich. Not 100% sure it is homemade by them, if not may want to consider different supplier. If so, may want to up quality of Ingredients. read more

We had Gemelli Gelato come to our Wedding to surprise our guests! They all raved about the gelato (which I knew they would, being a Gemelli Gelato lover myself). It was so unique and fun! We chose our 5 favorite flavors: Lemon Cookie, Peach Almond Crumble, Chocolate Elephant (which has peanut butter and chocolate in it), Mint-Oreo, and Pistachio. read more

Gemelli Gelato - a cart of gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Ok here's the scoop, see what I did there, anyway the gelato in this place was fantastic, very creamy and delicous with lots of flavors to choose from. The service was also fast, pleasant, and patient they let us try multiple flavors. It's the little things that are appreciated in life. read more

Gemelli Gelato - Look at all the delicous flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Espresso chip, lemon, hazelnut are our favorites, but really, we've never had a flavor we don't enjoy. To be able to sit at their picnic tables or on one of their Adirondack chairs and have the best gelato in the Hamptons is one of the real highlights of our summer, every summer! read more

I love this place! Everyone here is very friendly and welcoming. The line moves fast and there is a ton of outdoor seating. They always have featured flavors that are definitely worth trying! Last time I was there I got mint chip and cookies and cream, it was so good. I live over an hour away but it's always worth the drive. If you're in the area and in the mood for some gelato definitely stop by! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Seating area - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

No flavor , I never had worse gelato in my life and I have no idea why this place have so many good reviews ... seating on the lawn is nice but that's it.... read more

Absolutely love Gemelli Gelato! Not just an ice cream store, but a place to spend some time with the family. The owners and staff are friendly and helpful, offering samples of any of their 24 flavors, which rotate throughout the summer! My personal favorite is the Chocolate Elephant in a flavored waffle cone. There are a few dairy free sorbettos available, as well. There is a selection of chocolate, including Oreos, pretzels, fudge, and bark. Or, you can just grab an espresso or Nitro Cold Brew coffee! The best part is spending some time on the huge lawn playing corn hole, or chatting at the picnic tables. I lucked out with live music one of the nights I stopped in! Don't let the size of this shop fool you, it's perfect, and you will NOT regret waiting in line for homemade gelato! My only complaint is that they aren't open year round! read more

See all

I love that you can drive to get ice cream! It's just too easy. My husband and I came here for dessert after a meal nearby. They have so many flavors and will let you sample flavors to make your choice. The staff were really friendly. I settled on one scoop of hazelnut chocolate in a cone. It was really tasty!! I would be back there all the time to try all the flavors if I lived nearby. read more

Gemelli Gelato - Hazelnut chocolate! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Best place to get gelato in the area. Plenty of parking and yard space to hang around and eat. I nicked off a star because some of the flavors taste very artificial. read more

The family stopped by the shop this past Friday night and was welcomed by a young man at the front door. He explained the flavors to me and made a few suggestions. We ended up listening and got the chocolate elephant and a scoop of espresso chip. 2 smalls for under $11 was very reasonable and we enjoyed the stay very much. My wife ended up getting a nitro coffee after and it was very refreshing. We sat in the Adirondack chairs and the young man provided us with paper towels and windex to wipe them down. We noticed they got the parking lot repaved and it was really pleasant to park in. They had this cool mini truck on the front lawn and they even offer catering for events. What a great idea! read more

Open M-Th 2:00-10:00pm and Fri-Sun 2:00-10:30 Phone: 631-594-5600 24 Gelato Flavors Belgian Waffles Milkshakes Cappuccino Expresso ...yummy!! Great Gelato, Great Prices! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

AMAZING!!! From the wide array of flavors to the staff this place is top notch for a cool summer treat. There are chairs on the front lawn to socialize as you consume your dessert. I highly recommend stopping by and staying for a bit...maybe grabbing two flavors. read more

My first time visiting here was during the early stages of reopening after Covid had shut everything down. I must say that the precautions they took for Covid make you feel so safe! The owner is the nicest guy & always there making sure you have the best experience. The gelato is AMAZING!! You HAVE to try this place. 10/10 everytime we have visited. read more

Gemelli Gelato - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Beat Gelato Ever , absolutely same taste as in Italy!! I was amazed, that flavor is not an ice cream any more , that taste , reminds you, your childhood!! read more

Excellent service and gelato! The shop is always clean and everybody is super friendly. A large ice cream is $7 which is not too expensive considering its enough for 2 people. The best flavor is definitely the hazelnut. Will definitely be back! read more

Gemelli Gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Awesome place. Great place to eat outside and very efficient and friendly staff. Great Gelato and great selection.

I have been to Italy many times & have tasted authentic gelato! Gemelli's is by far my favorite gelato on Long Island. Charlie has a true passion making it & it shows. A delicious must tty! Nocciola is my fav read more

Great experience. Unique location. Really enjoyed the gelato. Long line but hanging out in the park that surrounds it, was a great weekend

I went there once years ago the gelato is good don't get me wrong but it's so expensive that's why it's only known as a tourist place to locals. read more

Love this place goood cute good deal loveeeeeeeee it make sure you goooooooooooo have fun nice

Service is fast, fun place to go for a treat. Will pass up Carvel every time for a gelato. The coconut flavor is ridiculously good. Lots of parking and seating. Wish this place was open year round!!! read more

Our families favorite place to go for real Italian gelato. My favorite is coconut in a lavender cone. There are tables and nice chairs as well as picnic tables and yard games for everyone to enjoy. The owner is very friendly and will give you samples of any thing you'd like to try. read more

This is the perfect summer spot to get some ice cream and have some laughs. My and two if my sisters went here last sunday for a review on my instagram @sundaeonasunday. There is a huge front yard that has corn hole and open space for children to play tag or soccer. They also have a ton of comfortable loung chairs outside and a section outside thats under a canopy. The gelato itself was really good and tasted very much like the flavors they were advertising. They had about 20 flavor options as well as a memorial day americano special. We tried the chocolate elephant- amazing- and the cookies a cream- very good. I would totally recommend this place for a nice night out to get dessert if you are in the Hampton area. Theres not to many other spots in the area for dessert other then carvel or similar franchise dessert spots! Def go check it out and follow my instagram please! Need all the love I can get on @sundaeonasunday! read more

See all

Have been going there since first opened, I take my mom and my friends ice cream is delicious! Great service!