The BEST Special Sub! Great Spaghetti & Meatballs! Perfect House Special Pizza! Love the service! read more

Georgio's II Famous Pizza - Sub - Italian Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

Amazing philly steaks and variants of it!! They have like 5 different takes on the philly and all of them are top notch.

Decided to try this place for their lunch buffet. I have ordered pizza here to go and it was good. But the buffet wasn't worth the money. The pizza was cold and I waited 30 minutes for them to bring some hot fresh pizzas out with decent toppings and they never did. They had an onion pizza, a ham and pineapple and a cheese. None of which I like. The owner was cursing and throwing a fit with one of workers. Which was uncomfortable yo hear. When I went to check out the waitress said rudely you ready at that point I figured there was no point in complaining. If you want pizza don't do the buffet. read more

Georgio's II Famous Pizza - pizzas on the counter - Italian Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

No longer open on weekends ?? Very disappointed wanted there pizza so bad on Saturday night and they were closed

A very welcoming, friendly place! (We dined here twice recently and had the same server on Sat. evening and Mon. lunch, but didn't catch her name.) Our first trip here we ordered the house pizza, garlic cheese bread and baklava which was very good! We came back a few days later to try out the lunch buffet. We had pizza, stuffed peppers and salad. It was all delicious! If you're looking for a casual family atmosphere with great food and service, we'd recommend! read more

A lot of people like this place but I am not a fan. The food is ok but overpriced and you don't get enough for what they charge.

Fantastic old school everything made from scratch everything prepped in house pizza restaurant. They just don't make them like this anymore folks! It is absolutely delicious. The weekly lunch buffet is a local's favorite. The place is clean, the staff are Fantastic everything is perfection. read more

Georgio's II Famous Pizza - Yummy perfection - Italian Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

The food is fresh and tasty. There aren't many Italian restaurants here but this is worth a visit!

It's still good food, just not as good as it used to be. Fast friendly service and it's pretty clean usually.

The Gyro Pizza is the best!! Service is always great, and food always fresh. Great family owned business, and will always support them before corporate crap! read more

I recommend Georgio's. The food here is great! The staff are always friendly. The tables are wheelchair-friendly. Pizza is always great. My wife and I both enjoy Georgios! Ample parking! read more

The Pizza is really good here, this is the only place I go for New York Style pizza in Sumter.

First timer. One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten. It was the combination pizza. Lots of meat and fresh veggies. Great! I'll be back.

Stopped in for lunch with my 1 and 7 year old. We were delighted to find they had a buffet for lunch. I don't usually opt for buffets because of the germs and poor heating. However this place was super hot food and the entire restaurant was very clean. We all three left happy and full for $20. read more

This is a family run and owned business, which is always nice to see. I tried their gyro and my coworkers tried their buffet. The food was delicious, but the staff was very grumpy. For a family owned business it surprised me how impersonal and short the wait staff, and female owner were. Maybe I went on an off day? I would definitely try this restaurant for the home cooked food and family owned business... However don't expect happy staff. read more

Georgio's II Famous Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

Usually this place is pretty good. Unfortunately they don't have a pizza bar on the weekends so my wife got Ziti pasta. Bad day for the cook as the pasta was watery...but we will be back on salad bar days since that seems to be their best menu item read more

Georgio's II Famous Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

I had high hopes. When I got home, my pizza was undercooked and missing 2 ingredients. The salad was a basic house and not the one I ordered that was supposed to have meat and cheeses. The cheesecake was great! I loved the cinnamon flavor in the graham cracker crust. Not sure if I will generate the courage to give them a second chance. The rookie move I made was not checking before I left. read more

Usually great service at this restaurant, but tonight was HORRIBLE. Ordered 3 entrees where 2 of the entrees were sub sandwiches. Sandwiches came out and 10 minutes later my spaghetti and meatballs was no where to be found. Furthermore we ordered chessy garlic bread and it never came either. When I highlighted that I was missing my entree you could tell that they had no clue. Such POOR service and no apologies. I didn't mind paying for our meal that we took to go but the lack of acknowledgment of their mistakes was disappointing. read more

The owner treats his employees and customers with great disdain. Yesterday, my husband and I were aggressively addressed as soon as we entered with our newborn. "I wanna talk to y'all" he said. He told "you had a problem with the wings last time so don't order them again," which was offputting and embarrassing. I said, "we weren't, they weren't the same last time. He proceeded to tell us that "everyone else is eating them." Mind you, we had gone with my mother in law and newborn son the day before thanksgiving (almost a month prior to this encounter) ordered two orders of wings (enough for all of us) and they were disgusting. The wings were flubbery inside, mushy, and were not the same wings we normally (happily) pay $11 for 6 of. We showed the waitress who agreed they didn't look right and shouldn't be eaten. Jimmy instructed her to put them back in the fryer, so she did. They came out no different. She was flustered from being berated and cursed at. She takes them back and apologizes and is very kind. She serves us all the time! We know her. We had actually discussed how he's probably deduct it from her pay because that's who he seems to be from what we've observed in the two years we've been going there. Well yesterday Jimmy continues to go on and on about how we "always have a problem" and how if we "don't like something don't order it." He says, "it was you and one of your mothers." I said, "yes, the day before thanksgiving." There was a line of people waiting on their take out and he made a scene in front of all of those people. My husband and I looked at each other in disbelief. My husband told him, "they were really fatty that day" and Jimmy again defends his food saying "they were not fatty" my husband laughs and says "they were, she brought them back here to show them to you" and Jimmy says, "no, they were juicy." Over it all, we just walked out. As I put the baby in the carseat my husband went back inside to let him know he's lost customers who've spent hundreds of dollars at his establishment. Jimmy says "yeah right" and proceeds to tell my husband how we "always complain" and that's "not the kind of customers he wants anyway." Interesting. We've literally eaten at Georgios at least once every 10ish days since we moved to this town. My husband let him know he didn't know what he was talking about and he must have his customers confused but Jimmy just kept running his mouth. I am not surprised to see him berating his employees or having the women cry in the corner over how they're spoken to. That's something I've seen many times. He's disrespectful and nasty but the food is good. It's my favorite place to order pizza. Now we'll be ordering from Sambinos. They're not rude or disrespectful. We've never heard any employee being belittled or disrespected. I think the most upsetting part is that he could've spoken thoughtfully and not lost two loyal customers. My husband assured me we'll never be returning there after that exchange and I 100% agree. What was that?! He could've easily waited to see if we ordered wings (which we wouldn't have based on the last order) and said hey we are using the same wings as last time and you didn't enjoy them so you probably won't feel any different today. That approach would've been reasonable, even for someone who doesn't care about the quality of the food being served to customers. We didn't receive an apology for the messed up wings when we brought out of towners with us. We let that go. We overlook his demeanor and the negativity he projects on everyone. However, this won't be overlooked. I've never seen a small town business owner with such little regard for relationships with employees or customers. I'm going to miss the pizza but that will be all that is missed. He told my husband it's customers like us that are the reason he's losing money... yet it is clear that it is him. He's the reason. read more

The baked ziti was awesome. I will definitely order it again.The service was great they were very nice and helpful .

Great Pizza!!! Consistently good. Great local business. Usually order carry out but I have heard the lunch buffet is also good. Glad this restaurant is in Sumter. read more

Georgio's II Famous Pizza - Large House Special Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

The absolute worst service EVER! The man that was there when we sat down literally said he will take care of you and he left! That was the end of any person to talk to us! While the pizza was delicious the service SUCKED! read more

Georgios has a salad bar. The selection was fairly limited, but exceptionally fresh. Great pizza. We had an (almost) vegan with us, so we ordered a half vegetable and half meat lovers version all with extra cheese. Service was good and everyone was happy with the food. read more

Best restaurant ever!!! Love the subs, love the pasta, love the pizza!! Have totally enjoyed the Buffet!! Love the Staff and Owners!!

Haven't tried the pizza yet, but the calzones and gyros are amazing!!! Had them 3 times now and excellent take out service and food every time. read more

My husband went in to get our order, I checked it before pulling out. The calzone we ordered was a pizza. He went in to have it corrected and the lady was rude. We will never order from here again. read more

So this just happened. Against my better judgement, went to pick up dinner because my husband was "craving" Georgio's pizza. Decided to give them a second chance considering what I experienced the last time I was there. The owner is a very angry man! Apparently he can't handle bad reviews. Nor can he talk to another adult without yelling. He began yelling and cursing (all in front of his other customers) at me about my review and actually grabbed my arm as I tried to walk away. Luckily his grasp slipped and I was able to leave but not without him making a complete scene. Good grief! We will NEVER go there - EVER! If you are a person who patronizes his location, pay attention how he treats his employees. That's what my previous review was about. If a boss doesn't have respect for his employees he certainly won't for his customers. read more

The food was great and service was excellent. I got the chicken parm and it was fantastic. They have a great red sauce. Will go back when I visit Sumter again. read more

Great for what it is--a family Italian restaurant/pizzeria. New England/New York style pizza and excellent hot subs. Also delicious pasta, lasagna etc. read more

Always good food and done in fresh way. Best Italian sub in the county. Try to be very accommodating to everyone. Good pizza. The bread is always so fresh even after twenty years or more I have never been let down. Not even once. read more

Was looking for a pizza place other than the usual Dominoes, etc.. found this little place! Awesome staff, welcomed as we came in the door. Very small family feel... the cheesy bread was amazing! I am picky about marinara and it was so good to dip both the pizza and the bread in! Made our own pizza to share and was able to take half home. 14" was enough for two of us! Our waitress was so sweet! Will definitely be coming back here and making it the place I go for pizza in Sumter. read more

At first look it's a hole in the wall place, but definitely a lot of locals here dining in and take out. Salad bar was weak, but a typical salad bar with shredded lettuce. The house special pizza is basically a supreme. The meat lovers is great. Good tasting crust. I would come back again. read more

See all

Fabulous pizza and subs!!! Wow!! I highly recommend this place. Their lunch buffet is great, but right now during Covid, they are continuing serving curbside. Clean and courteous!! They even made my husband a vegan pizza and added extra seasonings. read more

Incredible service during this Covid-19 time. The food is delivered to you piping hot and delicious! All fresh ingredients and perfect seasonings. Pepperoni and Italian sausage today hit the spot and if you need a sweet treat, try the homemade baklava! Support this small business here in Sumter, SC. read more

Horrible pizza, everything loaded with onions and the pizza itself was doughy and undercooked. Truly the crummiest pizza I have ever eaten. I understand the owners are Greek, and perhaps that is why it is just cannot seem to make a decent pizza. Truly, even the chain Papa John is better. Save your dough (heh heh) and try DeMarco's. Not a bad pie there for the price. read more

I am addicted to the Mediterian Pizza! Love the Gyros! Great Food, good service! I would absolutely recommend!

Ordered lunch from there and 2 of the three orders were incorrect. We had one replaced and the sub was bread with 4 pieces of ham and 3 shreds of lettuce literally! Spaghetti was awful with mostly chunks of tomato and lots of cheese and noodles hardly any meat. Prices are outrageous for the amount of food you get. I will not be ordering from there again or going back! read more

We love this restaurant ! Need a quick pizza because you forgot dinner? This is your place! So delicious and our house favorite! Christos makes you feel like family, we will always choose Georgio's! read more

Absolutely love their sandwiches and calzones. We've ordered lasagna and baked spaghetti for large groups a couple of times, it's always been a big hit. All of the toppings and ingredients are fresh and delicious. It's a small local family owned business, so service is always great! read more

We always enjoy the pizza and full dinners. Their to go ordering is always fast and they offer curb side pickup during this COVID crisis. The staff is always friendly and courteous. Our go-to pizza place!! We love GEORGIOS II! read more