We went for a friend's birthday dinner and had a great time. The food was delicious, the service by Natalie was excellent, and even though we were earlier than our reservation we were seated right away and ordered cocktails. We shared a loaded nachos appetizer plate (huge portion!) and then decided on the Lasagne, Steak Sandwich, and Turkey Pesto sandwich entrees--everything was plentiful and tasty. We will definitely be back again. The restaurant has an outdoorsy ambiance. read more

See all

Food is consistently good over many years of experience. We came at a quiet time of day recently and service was quick. Favorite finds at Good Company are the cheese curds, burrito (probably one of the best I ever had), and ribs. Cool ambiance. So very unique. read more

Great Drinks,fast service salmon was good loaded baked potato only bad thing was they brought my salad after the meal. Offered to give me a to go box. I just ate it read more

Worst hostess experience ever. We were told 30 minutes to an hour wait. After more than an hour, hostess said she wouldn't be able to seat us for dinner. WTF. Bartender was very accommodating and we ate in the bar. Food was good. read more

Made reservations for 6 pm 2 weeks ago. arrived at 530 pm and was told they didn't have our reservation, but said we would be seated with in 30-45 min. After our third attempt to ask about when we could be seated they finally sat us down 645. We waited 10 minutes just for the waitress to arrive and explained to her we had to be Preforming Arts Center at 8:0O We all knew what we wanted off the menu because we all looked at the menu while waiting at the bar. The waitress said she would put in a RUSH order and apologized. It was not her fault At 7:25 we all felt we had to leave to go and our food still hadn't arrived I asked to speak with a manager and after 5 minutes, began walking out when we were asked again if we wanted to speak to a manager and responded yes if they could do it now. The hostess said she couldn't guarantee when the manager will make it down. Upon leaving another large group was entering and we heard the hostess tell them it would be an hour and a half to an hour and forty five minute wait to be seated. We told them our situation and the hostess said we didn't have reservations. Bottom line, we had a 6 pm reservation, arrived at 5:30 and left the restaurant close to 7:30 without having any food. Unacceptable to say the least. That explains your overall rating on Yelp. read more

THE GOOD COMPANY WAS IN FACT NOT GOOD! We came in a group of 31 so we knew what we were getting into. We had two servers for our two tables, one was absolutely fantastic she had a smile on her face the whole time but the other one was either having an off day or is bad at her job. She forgot about one of our meals and the cook was not happy. The food was mid... personally I had the French Dip which was one of their specialties (not done right). Some others in the group enjoyed their steaks and wraps. We were told we couldn't do separate checks by the one waitress but the other was not on the same page because she was ready to split for our table. One positive to add... the desserts were AMAZING! read more

Good Company - Cookie Skillet - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

This is a local place that's been in business for a long time. The building is huge. We sat in the French Quarter themed area. The ceilings were very high, and sound echoed some. But with so much space, they've kept the tables spread out, and though we were seated near two groups of 10-12, the noise level was ok. Service was good, starting with a very engaging and friendly hostess. Our server seemed very new, but did well. The food was really good pub grub. I had a bacon cheeseburger with fries and my wife had French onion soup and a baked potato. All was very good. The kitchen was doing very well, the two large groups ordered before us, but our orders came quickly. The group's food all came out together, and looked great. We'll be back to work through some more of the menu. read more

Food was better than expected, service was nice prompt, being a full house they did well. Ambiance is amazing old fashion- did not expect the inside to be so full of character. Mia our server was wonderful!! read more

See all

Highlights/Lowlights 1. Friendly Service 2. Average Food 3. Good/Basic Menu with a Lot of Options Stopped in at Good Company on a Sunday afternoon for lunch. We did not have a reservation but there were plenty of tables available for seating. Ambiance is cozy and a little dated which makes it charming. The space is really big with several dining rooms, a big bar area, and an events room. Our server was friendly and pretty quick to get our order in and get us drinks. The menu is big with a good selection of soups, sandwiches, salads, appetizers and entrees. This is a good menu for picky eaters as there are a lot of very basic pasta/sandwich/entree options. We ordered wine first. The wine list is very average/grocery store wine varieties. My friend and I split the queso dip and added beef. The appetizer was average. Queso was pretty good, chips just tasted like your standard grocery store variety. I had the California Chicken Salad for lunch. Again, this item was very average. You could definitely tell the chicken was pre-cooked/frozen as it had that slightly rubbery texture but not inedible. Overall, I enjoyed my time here and would probably visit again as you don't need a reservation and it's centrally located. The food, unfortunately, is not the star of the show here. read more

Good Company - Queso Dip with Beef Added - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

We visited twice while in town for a bowling tournament. The menu has many options and we enjoyed all of our entrees. The cheese curds were good, and our servers both times were very attentive and friendly. The building is really neat. We sat in the French Quarter and it was charming. We would come back. read more

I'm not sure if they are short staffed or what but I came in around 645 and it seemed like they didn't have any waitstaff and the few girls were way overwhelmed. Can't tell if poor service or management but probably won't be back. read more

Great ambiance with quirky decor and a maze of rooms add to the dining experience. The food was good but unremarkable (above average pub fare). My wrap was very good, but I could not taste the avocado that was listed in the menu description. The French Dip was tasty. The French Fries could use improvement. My Brandy Old Fashioned was well made (our pleasant server politely steered me away from the cocktails that were premixed) - I ordered a second one! Good service and reasonable prices. Good Company is also a great wedding venue (they have separate rooms to accommodate wedding parties). I observed a wedding ceremony during one visit here. read more

See all

A good place to go for large groups. There are a lot of options on the menu. The food is decent and the service is efficient. The best part about it is the cool ambiance/decor. read more

I ordered the rings and chicken. Both the ribs and chicken were great. The chicken was perfectly moist yet dry wile the ribs flavors were complemented greatly by the sauce. The service was great and friendly with the waitress checking on us every so often. The ambiance was relaxed with a calming feel. read more

Good food but you could possibly die of thirst. Ordered on with at able of six others on a early Friday evening. I just had a tap water as my beverage. After being just about through with my entrée the server asked me if I wanted a refill, no, that's wrong, I had to ask her. After about 10 minutes the water never came, we paid the bill and left. The takeaway from all of this? Maybe bring a couple of bottled waters for yourself if you go there. read more

Great food and atmosphere. The building and architecture is just beautiful. Convenient location.

Walking up the wood ramp Where the concrete and wood Butt up the wood is decaying And could break and a person Could fall thru and get hurt ( (very unsafe The food is good Hope this gets replaced read more

This was our first visit to Good Company, we plan to return. We found the prices to not be out of line, even reasonable for the times. Our food was delicious and hot when served. Our server was very new, and although she needed a bit more training and support, she was very pleasant and personable. We enjoyed the historic focused decor. I selected -1 star as the lasagna only had cheese in 1 layer, with meat sauce between the rest. read more

Good Company - Lasagna - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Service was nice, seemed to be a lot of younger wait staff, some still training (glad to see they are recruiting successfully in the legit shortage). My tenderloin was awesome and they let me add the "loaded" option to my mashed potatoes. There were fairly busy for lunch but everything was timely. I'm eager to sit in the bar just for drinks sometime as I've never tried any while dining. Never a bad experience read more

Good Company - Blue cheese and horseradish tenderloin. Side of cream cheese/chive mashed potatoes, loaded with cheese and bacon - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Had a nice gluten free menu. Attentive waitress. Food was great! The gluten free bun was pretty good compared to others I've had. My husband loves the Cajun salmon. The queen and chips made a good appetizer. read more

Good Company - Gluten free menu- you need to ask for it - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

This appears to be an older restaurant. When you arrive at the place the appearance outside makes you wonder what's inside. You are greeted by the host and she was very pleasant. It's really hard to tell if the place is clean or not because it is so dark inside. Our waitress greeted us and she was very pleasant but never cracked a smile. I ordered the French dip sandwich. Our food came out quite quickly and the sandwich was delicious! I was very happy with that. I had French fries with my sandwich and they were way too salty and I LOVE salty stuff. The bathrooms are dirty. That always makes me question the food when there are dirty bathrooms. I consider this an average place to eat in Appleton. Nothing I write home about lol read more

Good Company - Just sat down for lunch - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

An Appleton staple. This historic place has been nestled in the corner of College Ave and Richmond St for decades. I come here and typically sit in the bar area. And always order a Bloody Mary. This is the place that first introduced me to a beef stick in the bloody. They also add a crunchy piece of bacon, cheese and the other usuals. I like the garnish but the actual drink is delicious. Served with a mini tobassco bottle. You get to spice it up as much as you want. And the bottle is adorable! I have not had any bad food here, but I know people who have. Ask the waitstaff about the ghost in the basement and you will have some entertaining stories. The decor has a European feel in the main dining room and it's a place you can be comfortable in jeans and tee or you can be dressed up and make it a special place for a romantic night. Not far from Appleton's nightlife, this is a perfect pregame place. On your way out don't forget to turn the knob on the candy machine by the cashier. No coins needed. Their after dinner chocolate mints are a favorite. read more

Good Company - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

What was once a a fun date night stop for my wife and I isn't what it used to be. We enjoy the unique dining atmosphere Good Co provides, but the menu has changed (removing my go to NY Strip). On our most recent visit, we were seated for 20 mins before my wife walked up front inquiring about our server. A few moments later, our drink order gets taken, nearly half an hour after we were seated and we still hadn't received our drink orders. Ultimately, the service was poor, my wife's food was "fine" and my $16 chicken tenders were tough and bland. read more

First visit to this restaurant. You can tell it's well established, and has probably looked the same for 30 years. Friendly staff and I was seated right away. They had a Friday fish special, and I chose the broiled haddock. It came with a salad, roll, and potato. Fish was cooked well and the potato had been baked in foil and was also good. Next time I think I will add a side of vegetables to the meal. read more

Good Company - Broiled Haddock entree - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

The food was amazing, but our waiter was super slow and we ended up getting a whole new waiter who was AMAZING, the environment was really cool, we were in an old style room. read more

Good service, expansive menu, good beer selection. Large portion sizes. Had broiled haddock, rather bland, huge.

I went here for my birthday dinner and got the chicken tenders. I got food poisoning from them later that night and thank god my friends couldn't sleep over because it was a week day because I vomited everywhere. I threw up probably over 20 times. At one point it got so bad I had nothing left in my body that I had to drink water so my body had something to throw up. I was dry heaving chunks and also shit in my bed because I was far too weak to get up. read more

Food server was not attentive to even refill coffee. My chicken salad was wrong. Food was not up to par.

Very cute and appealing location that was full of nostalgia. Looking at the menu was like a wave of nostalgia, too, and not in a good way. Just way too many options. Anyone who has watched a Gordon Ramsey's Kitchen Nightmares would give the advice to pare down the menu to fewer choices and focus on the quality of those. The burger the menu promised as "fresh never frozen" ground beef was clearly a pre-made patty that could not have been fresh. Spinach dip was very mediocre. read more

I mean its bar food and standard at that. I stopped in during Mile of Music. It was a strange vibe in there the whole time. Our waitress came to our table maybe two times to check on our drinks and drop off our appetizer. The quesadilla was greasy and I wish it was packed with more filling. It reminds me of a local Applebees if you want to compare it to anything else. The food did come out quick at least. It was hard to pay our bill and leave though. read more

Good Company - Quesadilla. - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

We had a group of eight without a reservation and were seated right away. Very nice atmosphere in the indoor courtyard. Staff was friendly and on top of everything we asked for. Food was great. read more

I used to come here all the time when I was in College, and returned with my family for a pre-Mother's Day dinner. I always remembered it being an A-OK experience, and this recent visit was the same. It was busy, so we put our name in for the wait (we were told about 45 minutes for a table of 5). We went and grabbed a table in the bar area (thankfully they have free popcorn, because we were all starving!). A server told us we could just order food in the bar area, but we wanted to wait and have the full sit-down experience. As we waited, the bar filled up, to the point where it was noisy and hard to move around (people trying to get to the table behind us kept elbowing me in the back). It reminded me of a popular bar on a Friday night in Chicago, and that's not a compliment! We were seated after about 50 minutes of waiting (I had just gone up to check on our seats when our table was magically available). Once we were seated, it was an okay experience. I had the cod with a salad, and both were fine. The salad is your standard starter salad you'll see at any mid-level restaurant, nothing special. The cod was good, they give you lots of pieces and it was flavored and breaded nice, but when they served us they told us that the order was short one piece (the server joked that the cook got hungry and ate it, um, okay . . .). They did bring the piece out once it was cooked, it was just kind of weird. Service was okay, not great, but not horrible. Prices are fairly reasonable, you do get a lot of food for what you pay for. Truly an A-OK experience in my book. read more

Food was mediocre- I had the Philly- the bun was barely toasted and the cheese was barely melted as well. Cheese curds were wonderful however. My boyfriend enjoys the atmosphere but I feel it's dark and dated. Walls were dirty by booth with sauces on it. server was kind but very very shy, so made it for a bit awkward of an experience. read more

I have been to this establishment many times only b/c friends wanted me to meet me there. Look Yelpers, my daughter worked here. I went there 1 weeks ago to meet a close friend and I got coffee and a French dip. Sorry no pics. Here is my issue with 'Good Company' my daughter who by the way is extremely successful and has way graduated from using her dad's cell phone plan and has a great job in upstate NY... well she called this place to work for 'BAD COMPANY'. She said while working there, the owners were rude to her. Totally snubbed her. She told me "Dad, no one there is happy". I did not believe her. But I always felt a 'low vibe at this joint so I got what she said' So I went there when she said that.... I remembered back to all previous visits and yes: no one does look happy. And most recently: there apex 2 weeks ago and did not take any pics: it took a long time to get my French dip. 35 minutes. Also noted: the prices really are not that great. They are actually on the expensive side. My friend footed the bill as we had not seen each other in a long time. He invited me there and insisted on laying. That was nice of my bro. He used to always go there. Born and raised in Appleton. Well he had a real-estate apnt and kept looking at his watch. He literally asked the waitress "Ms, we have to leave soon. I have a very important appointment". Now I will say the food was kinda hot. The bun for the bread was dry. But it wasn't anything special. And with tip and stuff I know my buddy shelled out close to 40. Easy. I had a coffee. He has a beer and ice water. I had a French dip and friends. He has a VERY small side salad and a burger and fry. Noted: I don't like cold fries. Fresh fries I do like. What I notice about this place that is good. It's big. What is sad about this place, it is empty at the busy time and SLOW for service. They really are understaffed. Trust me when I say when my daughter got a diff job after college, she was very happy to give her two week notice. I will not go into details. But this is why I 'Yelp' ... High prices. So so food. Completely too dark in this place of business and the service was slow. I can't give this place in good conscious more than one star. Look I am fair. But the food was so so and not warm. And slow. And well, the fries were u salted and cold and bla bla bla. Much better places to spend your money and if u are in a hurry and it is lunch time don't go here. You will thank me later for telling u so. Until the next Yelp, Yelp-Steve-O, out read more

It had been a while since we ate here. I had the French dip and my wife had a burger. Both very good. Interesting atmosphere and friendly staff. I'd come back read more

This place is disgusting. The salads are plastic wrapped and stacked in a fridge, the croutons were soggy and tasted awful. Nothing seems fresh, probably brought in frozen. Great place for old people without tastebuds... read more

I was hesitant to try this restaurant because of some of the negative reviews. I'm glad I put those aside and had lunch here. The chili is delicious! I also had the fried cod also amazingly tasty and a large portion. Could easily feed two petite eaters. My server was very attentive. The establishment claims this turn of the twentieth century building that use to house a paper company is haunted! I don't believe in ghosts, so you know, I just prayed a blessing over the building! I love the history none the less. There are many antiques throughout and many secret rooms and passages. It would be cool if tours were offered! Do yourself a favor and plan a meal here. read more

Good Company - A bit of history about Good Co. - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

This was the only place open on Easter and we were in town running work and building homes errands. We called to make a reservation for 12:30. Not sure why they required that since the restaurant was basically empty when we walked in. Anyway, we were immediately seated in the way back of the restaurant which was bizarre since there were plenty other nicer spots to sit. Like booths in the bar and 4 booths right off the bar. We sat down and a short time later our waiter appeared. He asked if we wanted anything to drink, I had the bloody mary and hubby had a limon and soda. From the picture I posted of the bloody mary you will be astonished. Who is the bar manager here? A beef stick, that's all you get for garnish I guess. How disappointing. No pickle, no olive. Unreal. Anywho, ordered the baked potato soup, was hot and ok. Sort of reminded me of campbell's from a can. I ordered the potato skins and hubby ordered the cispy chicken, bacon and cheddar sandwich. Both were very good. I had to ask for napkins and silverware. Why should I have to ask for the standard tableware? Odd. Anywho, the waiter was pretty green. Service nothing to write home about. But food was decent. Nothing remarkable. Got some good pics tho. read more

See all

Broke a golden rule.... Read the Yelp reviews as I was sitting in the restaurant!!! There is a reason that after 42 reviews this place gets a 2.5! The few points might be for semi quick service or the cool atmosphere but I would be surprised if it is the food! I had below average "loaded" potato soup... Warm (at best)and a few lumps of potato and some fake bacon bits. Bland and blah. My Rueben simply sucked! The sandwich was only warm enough to slightly melt the cheese. The meat was processed sliced corned beef... No flavor at all except the thousand island sauce and toasted bread! Too bad, this seems like it could be a fun place to eat. The staff should have some pep to make the décor. Our waitress brought no enthusiasm to the table whatsoever. She would have fit in better at the local diner slinging hash. Everything about Good Company is lukewarm... the staff, the soup and the sandwich. read more

This placer is a staple. When I was on my college visit during HS the football coach took my family and I here. The ambiance is cool with multi levels of charm. The food is above average but I never left without feeling satisfied. Just stick to the basics--burgers, fries, sandwiches. This isn't the place to get fish or pastas. Great for groups. read more