Craving a dense, thicker-style crust pizza, I knew I could count on Good Guys Pizza to satiate it! I placed and paid for my pizza online around 4:15pm for a 5:00pm pickup on a Saturday. I arrived closer to 5:15pm to a packed parking lot. I wish the parking lot was a little bigger but, somehow, I still managed to find a spot! I walked in and was next in line and after giving my name, my order was brought out and I was out of there, quite literally in and out, which was probably a good thing as I had a good parking spot. For my order, I ordered a small (13", six slice) cheese, pepperoni, sweet pepper, and mushroom pizza. This pizza was just as delicious as I remembered. I really love how Good Guys Pizza cook their pizzas with more cook time on the bottom, making their pizza a bit sturdier and golden on the underneath. And that thick, crispy, crunchy crust, *chef's kiss*. Good Guys Pizza is VERY generous with their toppings, each slice I pulled out had awesome cheese-pull, and there was plenty of red sauce. A note about their red sauce, if the typical-Buffalo "sweet" style isn't your favorite, I think you'd be good with Good Guys Pizza's red sauce as it comes across a bit more balanced, with maybe a slight lean towards "spicy". There was plenty of pepperoni buried beneath the heaps of mushrooms and sweet (green) pepper slices! I added a drizzle of hot honey and I thought it was an awesome complement! Good Guys Pizza cooks up a thicker-dough pizza that satisfies the biggest appetites, which this pizza was no different, but I appreciate it not being greasy, it sat well. The price I paid for my pizza was very reasonable, especially seeing how much prices everywhere have risen in 2026, a nice treat for my wallet. Good Guys Pizza retains one of the top spots in my favorite pizza shop list! They've been a favorite of mine since 2018 and it really impresses me how consistently good, they are - The quality, the portions, the prices, the customer service, all of it is great! The only reason I don't come here more is the fact it's so far from my house, but, once in a while, I have to just make the trek and get my Good Guys Pizza-fix. read more

See all

Love the pizza here! Lots of dough for my carb addiction. They do not skimp on toppings, ever. Service is fast and friendly.

Made a stop at Good Guy'S pizza. We ordered various pizzas and also a fish sub. Delicious food not skimpy on ingredients, not cheap but I guess you get what you pay for. read more

See all

We order here whenever we are in the area. I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni with lite sauce and 20 wings medium x-crispy. This is the only pizzeria that stays consistent with their food. Pizza is always delicious and wings are cooked to perfection. If you are one of the ones who haven't tried Good Guys you need to soon. They do not have indoor seating. The staff are always friendly. read more

Best pizza around, top notch service. Got a half tray chicken finger pizza was cooked to perfection chicken fingers were perfectly sauce with a blue cheese base sauce and dough was cooked with a nice crisp and good crunch on the handle. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

Best pizza in Buffalo. Toppings are very generous. Crust is amazing. If you haven't tried it you are really missing out. Prices are very reasonable....get one today!!! read more

The pizza is always consistently good. They do not skimp on the toppings and this has become our new favorite pizza. This place is serving really great pies. The sauce and dough are top notch and the toppings are also fresh and good quality. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Small pepperoni with sausage and xtra cheese - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

Good Guys has the best specialty pizzas! Turkey club wrap is delicious as well. If anything is ever messed up, they are quick to make it right!!! read more

Pizza is outstanding and service is good. I wish they had some tables to eat there but only take out.

My favorite pizza place in WNY, toppings on top of toppings, all the ingredients have top notch flavor. Years ago, our fav place was Pizza Junction. When they closed many were upset that such a good place was gone. But luckily the people who worked there opened Good Guys, carrying over their methods / ingredients. They saved North Tonawanda from becoming a desert wasteland. Personally, I'm not a fan of how much sauce is used. But it's so good I still give it the 5 stars. read more

Small cheese & pep 10/10 Absolutely love how thick the cheese is. I like that they use regular pepperoni instead of your typical Buffalo cup and char. The sauce is just slightly on the sweeter side, which I love. I'm not a crust person, but the crust is also pretty good if you have some blue cheese to dip it in. Delicious pizza! read more

Good Guys Pizza - Cheese & Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

Ordered two sheet pizzas for Halloween for a teacher lunch in my classroom and everyone was raving on how tasty this pizza was. I pre-ordered the two sheets because I know Halloween is a busy day for pizza. Good Guys had the two sheets ready to go on time and even gave us some paper plates. You can tell this pizza is good quality and the toppings are fresh. My favorite is the pepper & mushroom. They don't call "Good Guys Pizza" for nothing! Order from Good Guys and you won't be disappointed. If you feel extra adventurous try their chicken Greek pizza which is delicious!! read more

Good Guys Pizza - 2 sheet pizzas for Halloween teacher lunch! Hit the spot! - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

A 1/2 tray is 12 slices. 12 slices were 6.5 lbs with the box. Half pound pizza slices. Seriously. I'm Sicilian, so I'm all about the crust. This one has the crispy edges and bottom, plus the chewy inside edge. Sauce is a little sweet, but not overly so. I'd say this is as close to pizza perfection I've found in the area. We ordered regular cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom. The order was perfect, timely, and the service was friendly. read more

Good Guys Pizza - 1/2 lb slice. - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

Gotta love a good cheese and pepperoni slice and mozzarella sticks. The staff are very friendly. Not a sit down place but definitely my favorite place for takeout pizza. read more

OMG!!!! If your into cheesy pizza with a thick crust. Then you have to come here, and enjoy this deliciousness. Every bite was a enjoyable one. I really like the slight sweetness of the crust. Even the sauce was just right, not to bitter and not to sweet. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

Best pizza in North Tonawanda! The sweet sauce is incredible! There's never any leftovers as I just can't stop eating it whenever we order from there! read more

My go to place for lunch. 2 slices and a 20oz pop is under $10.00, and the slices are large and LOADED with cheese and toppings. Sauce is delicious! Always friendly staff, and service is always quick. Get there for your slices! IMO you won't be disappointed. read more

NY Style Pizza was Fantastic, being able to preorder was awesome, and pick-up was perfect!!

I'm gonna go as far as saying this is the worst pizza in all of WNY. I hate to be a jerk but damn! We're talking 1/2 inch thick cheese ( I literally measured) falling off the under seasoned, under cooked dough... then on top of that it's got a gallon of basic can sauce flying all over the place. I think toddlers may be making these pies. read more

This place used to have the best pizza around. Unforunately, I noticed something was off. The sauce isn't what is used to be. I did move away for a few years but it is not the same sauce as they used to use. I will be looking for a new place. read more

I ordered a 5 piece chicken finger, plain. This is what I was given. I feel so ripped off. Some of the pieces were not even edible. I think they gave me the discarded pieces from other orders. Very dissapointed to say the least. read more

Good Guys Pizza - 5 piece chicken finger?? - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

A well-known local pizza place, and it's really earned it's reputation The pizza sauce is a little sweet, but the cheese and pepperoni complement it well and it's just a delicious, reasonably priced pie ! read more

Subs are the bomb wings are good the pizza has gone down hill since the new owner has taken over tho but it's still good with large crust and a lot of cheese. read more

Everything is always great quality pizza is cheesy sub are large and quality ingredients chicken wings are always great

Was up in the area and got a recommendation from a friend that this is their go-to pizza place and I can see why. Ordered online and it couldn't have been easier. Placed the order for a specialty pizza and went to pick it up about 45 minutes later on a Friday night. Not that I didn't love this chicken finger pizza, it was just a lot of cheese and if I go back to Good Guys Pizza I'll be trying something a little lighter. A classic Buffalo style pizza, heavy, very thick, but overall that's exactly why one would expect for chicken finger style pizza. Small is definitely the way to go if you are ordering for 2 or 3 adults as it's a 6 cut with big slices. Pricing was certainly fair for the quantity, total came to around $25 with a tip. They do have a lot of choices for specialty pizza so I might have no choice but to make the trip back to North Tonawanda to try a different one soon! read more

Good Guys Pizza - Small Chicken Finger Pizza (hot) - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

As everything and everyone city's back, shrinks sizes they stick to what has made them the best. Even as cost and prices increase their customers continue to be loyal and faithful because they know they are getting their moneys worth. No matter what you order on the menu you will walk away happy and telling all your friends that you need to go to Good Guys. read more

While I was visiting a friend in the neighborhood, we needed to grab some food for the night. It was suggested to order subs; nothing fancy but I'm always up for a good sub. We ordered turkey subs and some sides and the sub was stacked! For "just a turkey sub" there was so much meat and cheese packed into it. The mayo was good with fresh vegetables on it as well. Really tasty and I would definitely get other food from them again. Note: the parking lot is pretty small and being on a corner intersection can make picking up food tricky if s a busy night. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Fully stacked turkey sub - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

Good Guys is one of the best places around. I am hoping their quality and customer service stays up to par, or better, because other places have gone down the tubes. read more

Best of excess!! Their regular pizza is everyone else's double cheese, double pepperoni!! It's delicious!! One of the best pizzas in WNY in my opinion. read more

See all

Any Gen Z writing a Huge Delicious Pie review this doesn't apply to you! You weren't around for the good Pizza! You wouldn't understand. What the hell happened to good guys pizza. When I moved out of NT I would drive one hour round trip because the pizza was just that good. I would fly the pizza all over the country because all the locals that moved away from NT couldn't get pizza that good where they moved to. It's not an uncommon theme just like Teds hot dogs, Platters chocolate and Webbers mustard. You could Always count on Buffalo comfort food until now. The pizza I grew up on at Pizza Junction that became Good Guys has turned into either undercooked or overcooked slop! The pizza was always heavy which is what made it great but the dough was amazing. After Covid things went down hill quick. I don't know if they changed the dough recipe or are using cheaper ingredients or just don't care anymore. There is no consistency. You just never know what you are going to get. They can't even cut the pizza so I'm going with don't give a shit anymore! It's sad to see this happen but it's just not worth the drive anymore! The blue cheese is still good so at least they have that going for them. read more

If you're looking for a nice thick slice of pizza with good dough and great cheese. This is the place to go! All of the food they serve I a large portion and just tastes right! Don't u hate getting a sub and u taste roll over what u ordered. Not here u get the taste here! Chicken wings are cooked just to the crisp! But I can say this place is one of my favs. read more

Every year for Super Bowl we go to Good Guys Pizza. My family and I love it. Both my parents grew up in the TNT area, so to us this is what pizza should be. Everything on the pizza is thick. The dough, sauce, cheese and toppings are always loaded! The cheese is almost like getting twice the cheese (or more), but you still taste everything on it. Most people cannot eat more than 2 slices. I usually like less sauce, but the way they make it, it all blends together perfectly. We also ordered wings. They were similar to most places. They were not very crispy, but were saucy and huge. We did get our order on probably the busiest day of the year for them, so maybe it was the day. Next time though, I would ask for them to be crispy. Only downside, is they do not deliver (I saw they joined door dash, but we had a gift card) and that the parking lot is rather small. They also are on the pricier side - but you get huge portions. The pizza is definitely worth your trip and they serve single slices as well if you just want a piece or two! read more

See all

You want a huge delicious Pie? Order here/ Great size for the money and the homemade sauce is so good!

If you were a fan of Pizza Junction back in the day, then this a must try. They are run by the main group of people who made Pizza Junction a staple of WNY. They don't skimp on portions, and the prices are reasonable given the amount of food you are getting. I have been the Philly and I for one would say that their steak and cheese sub is as good if not better than the Philly Cheesesteak you can get in Philly. read more

Easily one of my favorite pizza places in the buffalo area. They put a ton of every topping on their pizzas, the customer service is always very good. Oh and by the way they have my favorite wings in the area as well. They're always crispy with plenty of sauce on them! read more

A pretty good pie, with A LOT of cheese. When I say a lot of cheese I mean the cheese was thicker than the crust, that much! You will definitely have to eat about half the slice with a knife and fork because the cheese will slide right off. With that said however the pizza itself was very good, sauce was tasty and the crust was good and the pie had plenty of pepperoni too. read more

I'm a Buffalo native that moved to Cleveland, OH 10 years ago. Let me just tell you that this is my go-to pizza place EVERY time I come home. If you love sweet sauce and mounds of cheese, you'll love this pizza. Crunchy crust too! read more

Not sure how I never reviewed Good Guys. My favorite pizza and second to none. Absolutely amazing pizza. Some of the other offerings (subs, wings, fries) are very good but can't compare to the pizza. What to order: cheese and onion half sheet. Huge junction style slices, blows away the large pizza. Two slices and you are full for the night. I have recently had the wings again and they are better then I remember. Ordered the gold wings (honey mustard) and they were amazing. Highly recommend. Place your order ahead of time, this place gets busy. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Takeout. Cheese and onion half sheet (best offering there), bbq, mild and honey mustard (amazing) - Pizza Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

Came back home looking for the best Buffalo pizza. Found this gem and it was perfect. Got a basic cheese pizza and beef on weck pizza. Lots of cheese and toppings. Can't wait to go again when back in Buffalo. read more

Great pizza shack that was transferred over from a few workers at Pizza Juntion who opened their own joint. Food has always been on the pricier side but at the end of the day, serving size and quality makes up for it. Open for take-out only. read more