I do not like NY style pizza if it's not done well, but I wanted to give Goodfellas a try, and I was pretty happy with their take on it. The only disappointment was not the pizza itself but the selection; the only vegetarian slices available were plain cheese and cheese with tomato slices, not even a mixed veggie pizza. It looked like they weren't fully stocked on the meat pizzas and breaksticks either, so I wonder if it's just because I came between peak meal times at 2 pm (but the lunch special runs until 3, so I would have expected them to be better equipped for lunch at this point). I went with the tomato slice, plus a breadstick and cannolo. The slice was tasty: not too greasy, which is the most common pitfall of any pizza, with the perfect amount of cheese. My particular breadstick was kind of hollow inside, but this wasn't a bad thing because it was so big that there was still plenty of bread around the edges, and the cavity was great for scooping up sauce. Both the pizza and the breadstick seemed bigger on my plate than they looked in the display. I would've skipped the cannolo if I had fully understood how big the servings were, but I had already bought the thing and knew it wouldn't travel well so I ate it there even though I was getting full and ended up not really regretting it because it also great. The shell was crispy and the filling had a very pleasant texture. The staff there were friendly, the service was prompt, and the eating area looked clean. I would return, but I'll try to go earlier if I'm looking for lunch to see if the selection is a little better. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Tomato slice, breadstick, cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

My husband and I stopped in after attending a show at the Auditorium, hoping for a quick bite before our drive back to Indianapolis. Unfortunately, this visit fell short of expectations. Only cheese pizza was prepared, which was disappointing. We ordered a couple slices and breadsticks, trying to make the best of the situation. When we asked for beer, staff told us no one working was old enough to serve alcohol. On a Friday evening, this staffing choice seemed like poor planning. The food quality was the biggest letdown. Grease pooled on top of our slices in visible puddles. We poured off the excess oil before attempting to eat. Even after doing so, the slices remained too greasy to enjoy. We had only a few bites before giving up. The breadsticks were no improvement. They were bland. We ate half of one breadstick out of hunger, but eating something so tasteless was so unsatisfying. Based on this experience, we won't be returning. Between the limited options, staffing issues and poor food quality, there are better choices for pizza in the area.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Cheese slices after pouring grease off - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Delicious, huge, amazing, NY boss status, love them just wish they did DoorDash or delivery lol read more

See all

I love stopping into Goodfellas on Mondays for their 50% off small pizzas (size in the pictures). Ordering fresh is my preference here, but a lot of people like going in to just get a slice and a giant breadstick. The inside is meant to remind you of all the mafia films you've ever seen, with pictures from the films on the walls. The employees are always super nice and the food is good. I recommend trying it! read more

See all

I've been here a couple of times, and they have really tasty big pizzas. The service is nice and they will get you your pizza in less than two minutes. But the place is kind of small and the company has the opportunity to make their locations bigger. Other than that, this is a really good place to just casually buy pizza. read more

The pizza slices are very big. Well worth going I am not a fan of pizza and I liked it. Service was great. read more

See all

Goodfellas is a Bloomington staple that I have wanted to try for a while now! I am definitely happy I went. Went here around 11 at night with a couple of friends. Got two chicken bacon slices and they were both great. Service was quick, and the atmosphere is great for grabbing a quick bite, especially at night. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Chicken Bacon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

If you're not stopping to see Roberta and the team on Kirkwood Ave... what're you doing? BEST pizza in Bloomington.

Employees were very friendly! Pizza was delicious, crust was perfect and cheese pull was on point. Prices are great! Look at the size of that slice!! This was our first visit but it won't be our last! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Goodfellas? I think you mean Greatfellas! Because this Goodfellas Pizzeria in Bloomington is superb. The food, service, price and even the organization of the restaurant (yes, I notice those things) were excellent. They serve the lunch special every day from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. The lunch special is a slice of pizza, your choice of a side (a breadstick, a salad [caprese, pasta or lettuce salad], or a dessert [cheesecake, chocolate chip cookie, black-and-white cookie or cannoli]) and a drink for $9. I need to talk about the breadsticks here first, because they are enormous. They're about the size of an adult tibia. The breadsticks come with a dipping sauce (marinara or nacho cheese), and honestly, a breadstick and a sauce would make for a nice little lunch. The breadsticks are that huge. The pizza slices are also huge. My children had to hold them with two hands. We compared the slices to their heads, and I think the pizza slices might have been slightly larger than their heads. Huge, people. I don't mince words here. I love a place that sells pizza by the slice, and this place does but does it to the max. Oh, and the pizza was great. It had a crunch to it, but it was also soft around the edges, and the sauce and cheese were just the right amounts. It's the kind of slice you picture in your mind when you think about getting a good slice of pizza. Goodfellas is located close to Indiana University, so just know that it might be difficult to find parking. We found lots of parking in a lot that was behind a building that was across the street from Goodfellas. Parking was free on Sundays, too, which was a bonus because we visited on a Sunday. read more

Stopped by for a quick slice, and was not disappointed! It's a perfect pizzeria for that college town! read more

Really good! The dough was awesome as was the entire pizza. The people were really cool and they have an awesome deal. Big slice + drink + side for $10! All over that and really enjoyed it. Top flight pizza. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Pizza Deal. - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

We ordered a tomato onion pizza slice to go. The pizza slice was dry and lacked the flavor. Slice was 6.49 and not worth the price.

Today we left to get lunch without a place in mind to eat. As we were walking down the road, my sweet boy asked me if I had ever had "Goodfellas", to which I said nope ! And he goes, well that's about to change... We went inside a small restaurant with barely enough sitting room. There was a counter where you could see the pizzas they had available. We ordered the lunch special which was $8 for a slice of pizza, a side, and a drink. I got a cheese pizza, bigger than my face ! And an 8ft long breadstick ! They were both delicious. I was not at all disappointed. The pizza is a New York style, so expect thin crust. Definitely recommend visiting ! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

See all

would put 4 or eveN 5 stars but I've had both entire pizzas and slices with gooey dough on more than one occasion... However, when it's NOT GOOEY this is hands down the BEST pizza in town. Perfect crisp/crunch to it; solid ingredients everything comes together to make a truly delicious slice. One of my go-to spots; despite the whole gooey dough thing Notes: 1) sometimes there are really outlandish and completely undesirable combos on the premade pizza slices; at which point I just leave to spend my dollars elsewhere. @ whoever is in charge of that quit doing weird shit; would much rather see margarita pizza as a regular staple. 2) a bit overcharged esp considering you run the risk of encountering gooey dough pretty much every other time... this is a college town and 2 slices of pizza should never ever cost the same as an entire pizza; regardless of topping count. Other pizza by the slice joints are $3... they charge double or more. 3) would like to see the half off Monday pizzas go back to including the bigger ones too. 4) ranch. stop charging for it. read more

You really can't beat the fact that they have $4.50 cheese slices. Everyone that I've come into contact there that works there is incredibly nice and willing to have a conversation. Too often I go to places where people just want to stare at their phone and not be bothered to have a decent conversation with a patron. Here though, it's great conversation about whatever game is on the tv, the job, etc. Having family in New York City (along with all the other Burroughs) and having been to multiple pizza places (shout out to Di Fara Pizza, and Antony's Pizza), this is as close to home you're going to get in Indy! Give it a go for a great NY Slice, and for lunch add a side and drink.... And all that for $10 and some change... in this economy.... It's simply bellissimo read more

The slices are huge. The pizza wasn't bad. Not the best I had but decent. I had the bacon chicken with ranch. Staff were real nice, college students. Late night read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Chicken Bacon pizza w/ ranch - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

$9 for a slice (giant), a side, and a drink??? What a lunch special! We had stellar service. The woman who checked us out correctly inferred we were splitting a slice and offered to cut it for us. The breadsticks are about half the length of your body, so plenty filling! The pizza was yummy. Thinner style, flexible, and not super saucy. read more

Awesome slice. Huge breadsticks. And 1/2 small pies on Monday. How can you beat it. Great selection by the slice. Love the jalapeño slices they make. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Pepperoni and jalapeños. - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Ordered for pickup, so I haven't actually been inside. We got a 2 topping pizza, calzone, cannolis, and bread sticks. Without a doubt, the food tastes terrific, and the big slices reminded me of the pizza I grew up with. The calzone and bread sticks were gigantic! The pizza was nicely sized also. The toppings were delicious, but a bit sparse and sort of strangely placed. Because they used extra large pepperoni, there were very few on the pie, and sausages were placed directly on the pepperoni. I'd definitely order from them again, even if just to see if the pie I got was a normal one or not. This place is a welcome addition to the local pizza game! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Sausage and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Good place great food/pizza nice portions fresh vegetables friendly staff it's a great after bar hopping too

Really good vibes here; the employees are always really kind. Pizza available almost all day and always tastes good and fresh. I love how thin and crunchy the crust is. They even made me a pizza with no cheese since I have dairy sensitivities so that was cool. Slices are really big and filling. Breadsticks are fire too. Overall I like the flavor of this pizza and how unique it is; not the type you'll find just anywhere. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Custom pizza w no cheese and breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Biggest pro: fantastic value for money. I got a very sizable slice for $4.50, which was also good quality. A nice, crispy crust, delicious cheese and sausage. A solid experience overall. However, the pizza I was served could have been much better if served hot. The employee didn't heat up the slice because, as he said, it had come right out of the oven. Based the pizza being room temperature, I am skeptical that was the case. Overall though, I enjoyed the slice I had. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Sausage and onion slice. - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Just saying, this place has some fun people, with some really good pizza. Come here just to see someone but get some goods while i'm here. Food is delicious, People are awesome, Music there was also great picks read more

I was drunk, I wanted food. I ordered a sauasage and pepperoni slice. I watched the man put said slice into the oven. After a nice conversation with the woman behind the register, I paid for my slice, she handed it to me and we exchanged pleasantries. I walked home in the snow, absolutely giddy at the thought of first bite. When I opened the box, it was a cheese slice that met my eye. I was disappointed, but it was still a good slice. 3/5. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Molly is an amazing worker !! Love her personality she gave amazing service ! thankyou so much

Very good NY style pizza. Crowded on a Saturday night. Pizza had good chew, nice tomato sauce. Could have had a pit more pepperoni. Would go back. read more

Perfect college town pizza joint. Online ordering convenient (although we weren't able to use our gift card to purchase online). Order ready on time and well-packaged for carry-out. Needed a bad for salads and dressings to make even easier to transport. Aptly located on popular downtown street, so parking is expectedly hard to find But worth the effort. Charming upbeat ambiance and hard-working friendly staff. read more

Breadsticks are wonderful when they are soft and chewy but are too often over baked and are then crunchy and hollow. Please address this as I would like to order them often but I have to avoid them now. The cheese bread is always great! It's a nice place with good ambience read more

Quality NY crust, crispy and light. Dog friendly patio and friendly service. Good location on Kirkwood full of energy. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Green and red pepper slice. Quality crust, not overwhelmed with cheeses and they have a dog dish out for dogs. - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Love it here, so caring and understanding and genuine the general manager was. So sweet and caring and she was so personable to us and made us feel right at home. read more

I have to say, being from New Jersey and having the pleasure of having some the best pizza in the country near by, you guys make some really good pizza. Keep up the good work, capish? read more

where do i even begin. for starters, i asked how the calzone was. she replied "it's pretty good." i like it when restaurants set their own expectations. the calzone is a cool $10 on the board above the oven. i happily said "i'll take the calzone then." i place my order: pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, roasted garlic. i'm eager to pay, and then i see the total came out to $19.44. what? turns out, toppings are 2 dollars each. i'll be honest, there is zero justification for a $2 topping on this calzone. i could have gone to upstairs on a tuesday and gotten more value than paying $2 for 5 banana peppers. after my shocked-self taps to pay, i'm informed the calzone will take 20 minutes, which is fine, but would've liked to know before. at least, in my mind, i'm going to get a perfectly cooked calzone, right? wrong, bro. so wrong. i get home, take a bite, and it's noticeably chewy. chewy? a calzone, chewy? this can't be, right? it wasn't cooked all the way through at all. some of the toppings were not even lukewarm, and there was still pizza dough that hadn't been cooked. if i'm going to wait 20 minutes, i at least want a fully cooked 'zone, yafeelme? RIP my $20, and RIP my future of ever going to goodfellas again. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - this is dough from the ole 'zone being stretched - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

EMMY IS THE BEST PERSON EVERRRR!! BEST PIZZA EVER!!. Saw her late at night on a Saturday and she was the absolute best register worker ever considering how busy place was!! She deserves her a raise and some recognition for how well she served my friends and I. read more

Ordered takeout from here and walked home at 11 PM to satisfy a late-night pizza craving and Goodfellas definitely hit the spot. I wasn't the biggest fan of the cheese, the sauce was above average, but the crust was amazingggggg. Crunchy and would be so good to dip in their cheese sauce. Definitely agree with other reviewers who commented on freshness issues, but I didn't expect much at 11 pm. For less than $3.50/slice and an amazing location next to the bars, you can't go wrong here. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

See all

Very tasty!! Ordered the calzone, didn't expect it to be the size of a small pizza. Only trip up is the price of the toppings added. They say you get 4 toppings, but they are like 1.50 each. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Goodfellas is more then GOOD! If your looking to stop in for a New York style slice, this is your place! Goodfellas has a City feel and a excellent taste. Offering full pizzas, pizza and bread sticks by the slice and you can watch these massive pizzas being made upfront and personal. Main concern for me is the sauce and they hit home with a tangy marinara that is unique yet traditional. Enjoyed every last bite of my goodfellas slice and we can't wait to be back! read more

Go to get a slice no slice. Employees are rude. If I'm ever back in bloomington I will not get pizza there. Especially when I'm paying for a full athletic team for dinner. I went to Mother bears. Wonderful people great pizza read more

Awesome pizza! Large slice, crispy, and soft ! I'm from NY and it definitely gave me NY vibes.

Hands down best breadsticks in town!!!! I can't stress that enough. I'm extremely impressed with the pizza too! Pricing is great you get a good bang for your buck! The interior is super cool to! They've got some fun music playing to listen to while you wait!!! Great job Goodfellas Pizzeria! You guys officially have a regular!!!! Other local pizza places better watch out. This place might become the best pizza in town! read more