The worst goodwill in NY. The whole place is messy and unorganized and dirty. I've been to other goodwills in NY where they have it organized by size and have one price for things not matter the brand. Here they price everything individually and most of the prices are ridiculous. Now as of Monday they stopped doing the tag color of the week is 50% off and they stopped doing the $2 tag color on Sundays (use to be $1). Now there is no tag color sales at all and they are trying to make it seem like a good thing. Will not be coming back read more

Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center - No more sales or discounts - Thrift Stores Near Me - Middletown, New York

PROS: The staff here is very friendly while everything is clean. They have a huge selection of clothing, picture frames, and media as well. There's plenty of parking and the hours are good CONS: The bric a brac is scarce and most things are overpriced with the average item being $6 while other goodwills the average price is $2. Most of the stuff on the shelves are also messy OVERALL: If you're in the area than come to this goodwill but don't go out of your way for it read more

See all

The pricing on used items is much higher than it should be. The items are donated and the prices on many garments and housewares outpace what you can get new. This is more like a consignment boutique when it comes to pricing. read more

This is a pretty new location. It had this new fresh feel plus it's a nice sized place. Everything here was very clean organized. The clothes were clearly color organized and it was a quick in and out for me. I actually found this place very late in the day and they were closing. I am definitely going back when I am in the area again. read more

Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center - Thrift Stores Near Me - Middletown, New York

Customer service & better attitude from employees. Employee actually yelled at me on the watch out to see if i took something. Told him that I'm complaining to corporate. read more

While I am happy to see larger thrift stores actually opening up in the Hudson Valley when so many have closed in recent years, this location does absolutely nothing for me. The Middletown Salvation Army will continue to be a solid go-to for their treasure trove of ratty old clothes and the odd vintage suitcase score, but this place basically sucks on all levels. First of all, it's hidden in the back of some kind of strip mall wasteland that extends off NYS Rt. 211 about two or three layers deep so finding it isn't that easy, even with GPS, and when you do finally find it, it's in some nice, clean strip mall sandwiched between a Home Goods and a Michael's, which doesn't bode well for good thrift store finds. Once inside, it's basically all fleeces and boring button-downs and crap that came out of Kohls within the past five years. If you're looking for anything with that vintage thrift shop flavor, don't bother. This place is a bust. read more

I love thrift shopping but there is not many options in this area. Very excited to have this new addition. I have found some really nice items here and you can usually find plenty of things that are brand new. The only thing that this store leaves to be desired is the kids section. The kids section is very small one small wall in the back of the store. read more

See all

Not worth the trip. Media had no clear pricing and the section was almost nonexistent. Most of the store was uninteresting clothes. VERY limited selection of anything else; no cool older electronics, no VHS, not even a DVD player. Never going to try this one again. Watched a guy steal some comics off of the media shelf and stick them in his jacket after hiding in the frames section. That's Middletown for you. read more

I been a loyal customer at goodwill in Elmsford, But They are never opened the showroom! It's been 2 weeks and still Not open ! I'm So Frustrated! read more

My favorite goodwill store I always find good stuff her. I moved into my appointment four years ago and this is my to go place to find goodies. read more

I stopped going there because they keep raising their prices. People donate to help those in need...people buy because they need....and the prices keep rising. ???? read more

I used to love coming to this store because every now and then I find pieces I really like for a great price. I stopped coming this summer and when I came back I was shocked just how much they upped their prices on some items. A $29 winter jacket? Some $29-$39 used shoes and bags? It is ridiculous considering all items they get are donated/free. Every week they run a color of the week sale. When they started out (newly opened) you'd find a lot of items in those colors. But now I noticed I hardly see an item with the color tag on sale. Is it a common practice now for employees to remove those item before the sale starts to change the tags? Cause I've seen these in other Goodwill I've been to. It's really pretty shady. Most employees are nice here but some can get really snarky when you ask them a question. read more

I randomly ran into this store and i was pleasenlty suprised. This store was organized, clean and staff was pleasant will visit more often.

I was surprised and disappointed to hear that a person with noted disabilities was not permitted to use the lavatory facilities and that the manager did not assist this person. Shame on you and your employees. Don't you have to be ADA compliant? read more

Do not go to this store if you have a disability . Not accommodating and down right rude !