These bagels are coming with me to Los Angeles because my co-workers requested them and love them and are unable to get them where they are. Great bagel store with great people and they're pretty quick and efficient when handling crowds. read more

Heartland Bagels 2 - Two dozen bagels will be coming with me out to Los Angeles. That is because my coworkers love them and they cannot get great NYC bagels. - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The food is good yet the location is very narrow and very hard to get in and out of.. it has a tremendous parking lot yet the lines are very long and am my opinion the store is just too small. Staff is very friendly and the bagels are really good read more

great food, friendly fast service, always Fresh! big selection of hot & cold sandwiches, made daily ny bagels, BEC BLT read more

Heartland Bagels 2 - 25. Classic Italian - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Staten Island has no shortage of bagel stores. The problem is sometimes they're too big and too doughy. Not the case here. The bagels were just the right size. They were just the right amount of chewy. Flavored cream cheeses are a little on the pricy side, so maybe just go for the plain schmear. Pro tip: buy them buy the dozen and freeze what you don't use SAME DAY. read more

See all

Damn good bagels from this second generation Heartland shop in Rossville, Staten Island. So happy they were open at 7 am, as we drove back from LaGuardia Airport. Their onion bagel was a plump, airy, creation, with a load a crunchy onion flakes top and bottom. A nice smear of light veggie spread and I was in business. Just so happens that I visit number 1 shop last year. It was also very solid. They had some good looking donuts, too. Service was friendly and fast. Prices very reasonable. Strong java pour finished well. read more

Heartland Bagels 2 - Bin Dreaming - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

All Im going to say is that when the young kids are left in charge, my order is never right. Its always missing something, or my order is wrong, or its sloppy. However, when you have some of the other guys working there, everything comes out perfect read more

Once again a beautiful catering for Mother's Day! Everything was fresh and perfect ... please patronize this gem you will not regret it! read more

See all

Ehh. Just moved to the neighborhood expecting the same menu as heartland village. Ordered baked salmon and got lox. Tried to explain that lox and baked salmon are not the same but they were convinced they were right? Lox is not baked? Lox is not cooked? I understand you are working behind the counter but just because the tag shows baked salmon doesn't mean you served me baked salmon. read more

I always pass by this place in the morning on my way to Miggy's and the line is always out the door. I often wonder if everyone knows how amazing Miggy's breakfast sandwiches are and their bagels and bread! Today I decided to give it a shot..what a disappointment! There is no welcome, the manager is barking orders at frazzled young workers who are literally running into each other trying to get the orders done. I got egg, turkey and swiss on a whole wheat wrap, my usual at Miggys where I would only be able to eat half. Well just look at this disgrace!! If you are going to use a wrap the size of a pizza pie at least use more than 1 thin piece of turkey! Never again..Miggy's is it for me!! read more

See all

Bad Customer Service! Ordered Breakfast platter declined the hash brown and cheese included wanted a plain roll instead of toast they wanted to charge me for the roll on top of it all I always leave a tip? Lost a Customer due to this interaction read more

The worst employees i ever seen, multiple times I've had to go back because they've messed up my order. KIDS shouldn't be running a bagel store... owner no where too be found EVER! Horrible store thats never kept consistently clean, I honestly try too not go here , but i keep thinking id give em a shot , how hard is it too mess up a bagel! But they figure out a way! ZERO STARS !! The place should be condemned read more

We were heading home to south jersey from states island on a Sunday when a lot of places are closed and we were so lucky to find this place. The bagel was so fresh and the sandwich was delicious! The line was long when we got there so I knew it had to be good, but it moved really fast! read more

Heartland Bagels 2 - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

What a waste of a tasty bagel. The most incompetent staff ever assembled. Orders never come correct no matter how simple it may be. Old man is the worst of them all. Understood why he works at a bagel store at 60 years old read more

This place has the best breakfast and lunch food in Staten Island. They have avocado and other toppings most don't have. Superb!

Heartland Bagel II (HBII) is my favorite bagel store in Staten Island. Almost every time I go there, I get hot bagels that are crusty on the outside and moist and chewy on the inside. I love that contrast. I normally have a whole Wheat everything with tuna fish. The tuna Fish salad is very tasty on the warm bagel. In addition they have the freshest doughnuts and cakes on their shelves. I never had a complaint. It is true the lines are long on the weekend, but it does move fast and the service is always good. The fully deserve a 5 Star rating. read more

Bagels are not fresh, tomatoes taste like a month s**** old and employees are little kids that can't take the order. What a f waste of $15 for a bagel, never step my foot back in read more

Same great bagels, but customer service has declined drastically. Staff is slow and doesn't pay attention to what you ordered. Get it wrong even after you repeat your order. Little to no cream cheese on bagels sometimes. read more

the bagels are made beautifully and they have a great variety of menu options. prices are great and worth it! if you need a new bagel store to come to, check this one out! also the staff is great and kind. read more

Awesome is an understatement. Like many people know there is no shortage of bagel stores on Staten Island. Just in my own neighborhood there must me at least 10 stores. I drive three towns over to buy them here. The coffee is always on point and the bagels are always just right. Try the doughnuts too. Sometimes they have a French toast doughnut, to die for. The grill is a very popular option on the weekends with frayed eggs and bacon sandwiches coming off nonstop. Be prepared to wait but it's worth it. The line is long but I am always patient because it's so good. Remember I drive out of the way to get my bagels here. read more

My 1st time visiting. Bagel is good. Waiting on line needs to be improved. Waited almost 15 minutes before it was my turn.

Well well,this might just be the best bagel I've had in a long time.Line can seem long somtimes but it's deceptive looking seeing as the store is very small .Usually line moves quick but sometimes especially on weekends it can be hectic.I always get a sausage/egg/swiss - on buttered salt bagel ahhh bliss.im getting hungry talking about it. Good Job Girls (and guys)!! read more

This bagel store has been rapidly declining over the last few months. Their bagels are not fresh and hot anymore, not even at 7am. I recently went in to grab some lunch a couple weeks ago around noon and they only had a couple bagels left. I said how come you only have a few bagels left they said it's because their bagel machine broke. My husband grabbed half a dozen bagels this morning and they're just not fresh how they used to be. Hard on top, and just old tasting. I'm guessing they still have not fixed their broken bagel machine. Ill be looking elsewhere for fresh bagels. read more

I loveeee this bagel store! The bagels are great, the store is clean, and the staff is nice. It's always super crowded, but it's worth it for the good bagels. They have French Toast bagels too! read more

Yummmmmm yummmmm and yummmm ! Consistent all these years and drool every time I think of a bagel & lox

Best bagels on this side of the island. Go early to avoid the line. The bagels taste great and always fresh. Sometimes they have amazing peanut butter and jelly donuts. Yummm read more

If theres a line at your bagel every Saturday & Sunday morning you know your doing something right !!!!! Not too too big but not small they are just right the usual flavor ( sesame, everything, etc....). Good cream cheese selection. Great local bagels period !!!! read more

I ordered a half pound of bologna. The kid was RUDE and then gave me the bologna thick as hell with the PLASTIC ON IT STILL. MY KID ALMOST CHOKED. read more

Poor cleanliness standards. Owner not present in business and it shows. Employees use bare hand or same gloves which they use to count money to prepare food. Hair net not worn. Garbage can overflowing and bottled water used as door stop. read more

Good food. Ability to order online and have good delivered. The only drawback is that the delivery can take a long time. Last time after waiting over an hour for delivery, I left home without breakfast. One bad experience will not deter, will order again. read more

If not knowing what you are getting until you get home is your desire then this is the place for you. Getting cheese that I didn't want, ketchup that I don't want, sandwiches on the wrong bagels are all their specialty. When you bring it to their attention, no apology - you are made to feel like you are inconveniencing them. Sadly, writing down orders is not an option for them either. In an industry that is interchangeable there are many other local choices that are better for you to spend your money. read more

Yummy! My go to deli before work. Sometimes the line is long, but the people there are pretty fast and always cheery in the morning, which I appreciate. Amazing French toast bagels, BLT with FATA$$ sauce, and they take the time to burn my bacon when I ask, which I really appreciate. I wish they had more of a juice selection (random) but that's usually the only complaint I have. read more

Words cannot describe how amazing this bagel store is. The owner Maria is a complete sweetheart and she's picked some amazing people to work there with her. But this review isn't about the store itself. You NEED and I truly mean it. You NEED to try the NUTELLA CRUMB DONUT. Yes I like the store and the people. But this is hands down the best donuts on the island. Some other deli's have tried to do this donuts with no success. I don't care what you go in the store for. Make sure you get this donut also. I promise you will not be disappointed!! I moved and I drive across the island every weekend just to get their breakfast and a Nutella crumb donut. read more

Best Bacon Egg and Cheese I've ever had! So fast & convenient. They even deliver. Open 6am-6pm

Back for some more bagels few days ago, and this time i am much happier!! Their bagel is fresher, and I am also glad that they took my suggestions. read more

First off I wanna say that the management at heartland is on the ball. They corrected the problem, followed up and made good. This morning I gave them another shot and it was a complete turn a round. Food was done exactly as I ordered, arrived hot and fresh and the gentleman on the phone was knowledgeable and professional. I will certainly be ordering here again and I am very glad I gave them a second chance I guess everyone has an off day. They also sent me a few bagels for free with the order. Keep up the good work. read more

I once got a peanut butter and jelly donut and felt like I was in heaven, always friendly faces and cleanliness behind grill

There isn't a thing on the menu that isn't amazing! Best bagels on the south shore. My fave is onion bagel with chicken salad or just cream cheese ! I usually have a problem cs I'm pocky w my egg sandwich.. I like the yolk very drippy but the white well done with very crisp bacon and the grill guy always gets it right!! There's a reason there's lines out the door most days. Some of the best donuts around especially the jelly and cake batter. Great service with a smile. Oh and the frappes! !!! Cookies and cream, better then any other place I've tried! read more

Pros: The bagels in here are delicious It's close to the Rossville residents located in Rossville plaza. The tuna salad is out of this world ! I usually get it in a container as have it with crackers. Yummy! Always fresh baked goodies too. Cons: They are always crowded at the most obvious time like mornings. And lunch too. Which is good business. But this is not so much a con because it is worth the wait ! read more

Cheapest bagel store on island they will literally put the cheapest amount of cream cheese/butter etc. To save momey...i guess. They either get the order wrong or do that, oh and the prices went up. NEVER going back. read more

Best bagel I have had in a really long time.. Not only are they delicious they have a large variety of all different kinds that I never seen before! Plus the owners are so nice and accommodating! A well needed bagel store in Rossville! read more