The winery was cool. Nice ambiance Great wine tenders! We love sweet wines so lots to try The cave was slightly disappointing. We were crammed in at the end of the group. Our guide was soft spoken and the tour ended in 5 min.. We were so disappointed with that portion that we forsake the wine tour. We've been to numerous caves -- Monmouth bring our favorite---- it's the guides that make the trip read more

See all

We had a good time. The people are great! I'm not drinking right now and there were the most delicious grape juice options for me. If you haven't tried the pink grape juice, you're missing out. The tours came with a wine token. The crystal cave is not what I expected, but did not disappoint. We really loved it. The wine tour was also fun and informative. It's a cool place. I'm happy that we went. read more

Heineman Winery - I'm intentional not posting pics in the cave, because you must see it for yourself. - Wineries Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

Was a bit surprised that my glass of Corot Noir was chilled but it brought the tastes out! My next glass was the Pinot Noir which was much more enjoyable!! Very friendly staff. Expansive gift shop. Very touristy. read more

See all

We had a nice time at Heineman Winery! The wine itself was okay- nothing mind-blowing- but enjoyable, especially at the incredibly affordable price of $3.75 per glass. Most of their wines are on the sweeter side, which may not be for everyone, but I appreciated trying something different. I also really enjoyed the Catawba juice- I'd never seen it before and, as a fan of Catawba wine, it was a fun surprise. The $12 tour was definitely worth it. You start by heading down into their cave, which is inside a geode--super small but very cool. Just a heads-up: there are quite a few steep stairs to get down there. Afterward, they take you upstairs and walk you through the wine-making process. Our guide was knowledgeable and made the tour interesting and informative. The tour also comes with a token for a glass of wine or juice, which was a nice touch. A couple of downsides: all wine is served in disposable cups, which was disappointing, especially for an island destination. It takes away from the overall wine tasting experience and feels a bit careless environmentally. The staff was mostly friendly, and there's a ton of outdoor seating in the back, which makes it a nice spot to relax post-tour. All in all, a fun stop with a unique charm, some great educational value, and unbeatable prices. Just don't expect high-end wine or a fancy tasting room vibe. read more

Heineman Winery - Geode - Wineries Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

The wine was delicious. We enjoyed sitting in the sun in the outdoor wine area. Enjoyed hearing the family's story of how the winery survived prohibition. Didn't go to the caves but will next time! read more

Heineman Winery - Giant chair out front. - Wineries Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

This place had such great wine! Two of the workers were very quick to help us and give recommendations, but one of them seemed to want nothing to do with us as far as customer service goes. All of the wine was great though, we tried 3 of the sweet wines, two of the dry, and one of the medium. The sweet wines were the best in my opinion! The place itself was gorgeous, especially the garden! read more

Heineman Winery - Wineries Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Super cool experience especially for the price. Went to Put In Bay for the first time over this past week and was not disappointed. This crystal cave is a must see and is breathtaking in person. The tour guide was super fun and was very knowledgeable about the history of the cave. If you're in the area I recommend checking it out - you might even get "cave kiss"! Also the winery is very neat and you get a grape juice or wine sample included in the crystal cave tour price. read more

See all

Take the tour! If this is your first time to the island or winery I highly recommend taking the tour. The tour includes the crystal cave, winery tour and glass of wine for a very reasonable price. The tour is even kid friendly with an offering of grape juice and a lower price. Tickets can be purchased inside the gift shop. We were able to buy tickets and start a tour within 15 minutes. The first part of the tour consists of the crystal cave. Basically like walking into a giant geode. My kids loved this and it was very cool to see up close. Then you will be instructed to wait by the winery tour door and a few minutes later your guide will take you through the manufacturing part of the process and discuss the history of the winery and how the wine is made. Lots of opportunities for questions. Lastly you get to choose a glass of wine of your choice. They have a great outdoor area with a patio and picnic tables. It was calm and peaceful. It was a great experience and we felt it was well worth the money. read more

We loved the longevity and history of this family-owned winery. The Crystal Cave is cute, but it's really small. Don't expect a grand tour - but worth checking out. The wine is sweet. The grounds could use some updating, but the people were nice. read more

See all

Good counter-service wine and nice outdoor seating. The most delicious grape juice you've ever had! We shipped a case home because it was so good! read more

I have to admit I was disappointed in this winery. The facilities are dated and the decor was not very modern. It doesn't have a typical winery feel. Things were some simple and primitive that we didn't stay long to enjoy the wine. Apparently the state of Ohio says that Heineman needs to charge $3.50 for a sample. Unfortunately you don't know which wine to pick since you have no idea how the wine tastes. Therefore you just guess and hope the wine is digestible. On this occasion we picked the Cabernet and Sauvignon Blanc to try. I have to admit that these wines were not very tasty or appealing to my palette. The wines tasted very plain and a "waxy" after taste. read more

See all

The customer service was great! And I bought a Put-in-bay winery shirt for only $5! Love this! The ambiance was nice, and I felt welcomed there overall. read more

See all

The real draw for us here is the Crystal Cave. It's really fascinating to stand inside one of the largest geodes in the world and examine the celestite crystals. It also has a neat history - giving tours of the Crystal Cave helped keep the winery afloat during Prohibition. I wouldn't mind a few extra minutes down there, but we enjoyed our visit. When we came back up, we headed out on the tour of the winery. The process is described, and they go through all of their wines and discuss the flavors/notes. Both tour guides were very personable and informative on their respective tours. At the end, you are taken into the tasting room, where, if you have purchased the tours, includes a sample of either wine or grape juice of your choice. There is also a small gift shop onsite. read more

I went to the crystal cave gift shop and let me just say it is a 10/10!! i am a big crystal girl and the stuff in this store was AMAZING!! not to mention that the workers were so helpful!! the guy who helped me was so patient with me and wrapped all my stuff up so nicely for me:)!! you NEED to check this place out. read more

Three couples went into this winery on Wednesday. ordering our bottles of wine. one of the employees start shouting at us that dogs are not allowed inside. we certainly understand that and was finishing ordering or wine to take outside, when this employee started screaming again about needing to leave. he ended telling one of the husbands to F** off. when we were outside another employee along with the belligerent man came out and told him to leave being very rude. we are not young kids making trouble, we are customers in our 60s and was very disturbed by this. needless to say, we will never be back and will tell anyone we know not go patronized your business. NOT PET OR PEOPLE FRIENDLY!!!! read more

Wonderful experience at the winery and caves. The price per person was $12, which included a cave tour, a wine tour, and a glass of wine or grape juice. The staff was friendly and courteous. read more

See all

For $11 this is quite a stop! The crystal cave tour is interesting & really informative. It is definitely something we had not experienced before. The winery tour was more thorough than expected ... it's a working winery so we say the process in action - very cool! All grapes come from within 10 miles of Lake Erie! It was very enjoyable and frankly a great deal for the experience. read more

See all

Rude! Asked about tour time and were told 4:30 when it was 4:05. Went to get our complimentary wine and at 4:10 told we had to go early. Tossed the wine which was no better than the tour. It's all about their day, not your holiday. read more

Winery was fun for the whole family. Nice outdoor seating was very nice. Grape juice for kids and wine for the adults! Crystal cave/ winery tour was good but don't expect brilliance . You did get a free tiny cup of wine or grape juice with your tour so that's a plus. Cheese cubes and meat sticks were delectable. read more

Great island wines. Landaker meat stick are the chef's kiss. My nephews soda exploded coming out of the vending machine and hilarities ensued. read more

We went here on a Sunday afternoon and did both the wine and cave tour. We were shocked at just how busy it was for an early Sunday afternoon. There was enough room to park since everyone was driving golf carts. When we got inside there was a bit of a line but it moved quickly. For $11 we got a drunk token and a pass for both tours. They have you line up for the cave tour first. They make it very clear that there's 42 steps going down and 42 steps coming back up. It was cool to see the difference geodes and the sizes they are but the cave itself is only about 30' wide. Trying squeeze a bunch of people down there and calling it a tour is bit excessive. It was too tight to move and it's really just a tight walk around a staircase. I can't say I'd reccomend doing this part. The last leg of the tour was the winery and it was great!! There was tons of information about the process of wine making and what it entails. I really enjoyed that part. The wine tasting was pretty good. The Niagara and Belle are great. We enjoyed hanging out in the back are and relaxing. It's was a good winery. read more

Cute tour; but a bit pricey. Should offer a discounted price for non-one drinkers. We did the wine and cave tour and then got some grape juice. It was all good, but t nothing was great. read more

See all

This is a must see on a trip to Put in Bay, Fascinating tour of the cave which is actually a giant geode found years ago when digging for a well. It had amazing crystals covering the walls. The "cave" was large enough for around 30 people to gather. I wish my rock hound Dad could have seen this! The winery was like most and the wine good. We met some locals who were so friendly. The grounds of the winery was a pleasant setting to enjoy a bottle. read more

Went on a tour of the Cave and the Winery. The cheese plate was good and all of the employees were Great! If you are going to buy some crystals or fossils, the prices are much here and a better selection than the shop across the street. Jacob did an Awesome job of packaging our purchases for the ride home! read more

See all

It was neat to see the crystal cave but it's more of a room than cave as it's pretty small. The staff was friendly and we had a nice time but the place could use some updates. The wine and grape juice were good and it's nice that they produce wine from only local grapes. The winery tour was informative. If on the island, a pleasant hour or so diversion. read more

We came here for the cave tour. I personally loved all the kitschy old signage and decor that some people are calling "dated" - I'd call it history and character. While the cave itself was really awesome (you're inside a giant geode!) the way they handled the tour was not. The cave is not very big and they cram way too many people into it. Basically once everyone is in the space they give you a history of the cave and then you walk through a small opening and go back up the steps. Our cave guide was very unenthusiastic. It was difficult to appreciate the cave because it was so crowded - you couldn't see much aside from what was right next to you. We also went on the winery tour that came with the cave tour because - why not? This part was surprisingly interesting and the guide was much more enjoyable than the one in the cave...but the whole point of it was just to try and sell you wine at the end. We cashed in our free wine and grape juice vouchers. I preferred my son's grape juice to the Pinot Noir. read more

Heineman Winery - Waiting to enter the cave. - Wineries Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Always loved coming here every time I came to the island until yesterday. They have an extremely rude male employee working at the bar section that made my friend and I so uncomfortable yesterday we had to leave. Ruined my whole afternoon and definitely ruined all the good memories I've had there DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND GO TO THE OTHER WHINERY read more

Horrible wine! First there are no free samples, Which is fine but they could still do like a 1oz shots maybe even three for five dollars or something but one glass for 2.75 and the first glass. wasn't even good I would've loved to of bought a bottle but unfortunately it wasn't good. read more

A wonderful place to relax and enjoy a bottle of wine and a plate of cheese and meats. Their wine selection is good. There is something there for everyone. read more

I think the wine isn't so good but then again I don't really drink wine. We just buy the concord that tastes like grape juice. Going here is tradition. No trip to PIB is complete without it. I love sitting in the "wine garden" sippin the sin juice and people watching. And the watching is good! Get the cheese and cracker plate just for giggles. It's a good time! Also do the tours at least once. You might learn something. read more

I love love love the whole vibe of this place! We didn't dine in it make any wine purchases, but the building and property are lovely and we did spend quite a bit of time in the gift shop. The ladies working the counter were so sweet and they had so much cool stuff! They had very low cost/reasonably priced souvenirs as well as a wide selection of rocks and so many cute gifts. I came with a group and I think we all ended up making purchases there. Would definitely love to go back again and try the wine :) read more

A fun stop that breaks up a visit to South Bass Island. Heineman's is centrally located on the island, away from the hustle and bustle of Put-in-Bay. A fun atmosphere with friendly hosts. Sample some wine. Heineman's seems to specialize predominately in sweeter wines, Catawbas, and their grape juices. However, if you're looking for something different, try the Watersnake Noirette. The capsicum finish has a peppery bite you'll find unfamiliar to most other wines. It was so unique, I had to take home a bottle. read more

Awful experience. Wine wasn't terrible, but serving it in those tiny translucent Solo cups seemed like they were catering to know-nothings with bad taste. The charcuterie option? String cheese and Slim Jim's service on a styrofoam plate. I kinda like that it was a bit of a destination on the island, but it just kept getting worse. The manager was poor, the service was lousy, and the staff were bitchy at best. I think some people love this place because it makes them feel fancy for drinking wine. MUCH better quality place on the island for wine. I'd be willing to go back if they improve just about EVERYTHING about this place. read more

I was very glad to know that there are two wineries on this island, since wineries are our thing and it gave us another reason to visit Put-In-Bay for the first time. The building does not really feel like a winery to me, which can be okay if everything else is right about it. It felt more like a VFW hall with a little gift shop on the side. I understand it's a touristy island. You make wine and you probably don't have to work that hard toward anything else and people will come over and pay to drink the wine. But I feel as if making wine is all they had going for them. Did the wine taste good? Not particularly. I can drink dry, sweet, and everything in between. But I didn't find anything I really enjoyed here. I felt like I was just finishing off the samples because I didn't want to waste them. My wife could not finish hers. The sweetness actually made my throat feel like it was coated in sugar and my stomach was queasy. FYI, I usually like sweeter wine. I also had a really bad vibe from our server. We went to the bar and asked how it worked, looked at the menu, asked some more questions about the wine, and maybe she was coming off of a long hard day at work, but she was clearly not interested in serving or helping us. She put her time in, but we did not feel welcome. I think I'll give this place another shot next time we're on the island because well, I really want any winery to do well and I don't know if I've ever been to a winery that didn't have a flavor I enjoyed. I also acknowledge that people have bad days and you can not based your opinion of an entire business off of your interaction with one single employee. It does seem like it'd be fun with a group. I saw a group having a blast out in the backyard, which was a neat space, and I could see doing that here. Maybe when you're in that mode, you're a little less picky on the taste of your alcohol? read more

Heinemans Winery and Crystal cave was a great way to hide out and kick back for a couple hours. We got tickets for the crystal cave and winery tours which went off without a hitch and were really interesting as well. The winery has been on the island for 130 years! They shared history of the winery and the cave and answered plenty of questions along the way :) We went to the back bar and got a pitcher of Sangria and a bottle of Ice Wine. I'm not a huge fan of sangria but THIS Sangria I could drink all day! Fruity and delicious!! The Ice Wine was also a sweet finish to the day, light and sweet and was well worth the price. Can't wait to come back and bring others with me! read more

See all

This winery is very nifty and a must see if visiting Put-in-Bay! It is home to the largest Celestite geode in the world! You can take a tour and walk in and around the geode underground. The cave was found while the owners of the property were looking to build a water well! I truly enjoyed the experience and the wine /wine tour was lovely too. The Sweet Belle was my favorite wine​ I tasted, but you can't go wrong with any one​ of them. Sean the bartender was very knowledgeable about all the products and was quick to serve. read more

Heineman Winery - Inside the geode cave. - Wineries Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

Nice local winery with a bonus cave tour and wine tasting. Interior and back patio needs updating.

The crystal cave was basically a catfish scheme. Pictures online were farther more interesting than the "cave" itself. Steps were super steep & the tour guide wasn't as informative as we thought given the history of the winery and cave. Not very spacious for large groups. Very quick tour, like 5-10 mins, rather than the 50 min tour advertised on the website. read more

Upon our first stop, we were virtually ignored at the bar while trying to sample their wines. We decided to give it another shot later in the day. This time, we purchased the cave & winery tour, which gave you a glass of wine at the end. After the ticket purchase, the lady announcing the departures had zero personality or hospitality skills. The Cave tour was decent if your expectations are moderate. It's basically a walk in a circle while inside of a giant geode. We were then led on a 10-minute tour of the winery where our guide was quickly pulled from the bar and gave a mediocre. Memorized speech that did nothing to enhance our experience. Now, we went back to the bar and had to wait for a third bartender to arrive. She seemed disgruntled at her fellow bartenders and didn't show any thought of hospitality to her customers. While this could be a very unique spot, I believe that they are being run by "the old guard" and just don't know who they really want to be - a winery, a tasting room, a cave tour, or something else. Needless to say, we didn't purchase any bottles there and can not recommend anyone to make the stop while on the island. read more

A stop while on golf cart tour of put in bay . Some very good horseradish dip with crackers- was it worth $10 probably not - but it WAS good. $2.50 for a thimble size glass of wine . Decent back area to enjoy the day at a picnic table . read more