January 9/2025: Lunch with Val…read more This was a really good lunch at the F&C spot. It's chef/server owned so maybe consider supporting your locals. I have the Halibut & Chips ($14.99). Generous serving size as well as perfectly fried French fries. Meal came with delicious coleslaw & we had a gravy on the side. All of it very tasty! It's a small restaurant but has a great feel to it. Authentic is how I'd describe it. I think this is a do-over.

Never tried this place but now never will…read more I tried to place an order over the phone but the person who picked up was EXTREMELY rude. He was rushing me while I was telling him my order because he said he was busy, he kept getting my order wrong and talking over me - when I tried to tell him the correct order, he rudely said I was wasting his time and started yelling at me. I was so shocked I just hung up on him! Then I went to write a google review and they deleted it!!!!! Horrible customer service, and probably horrible food. You can find better in Caledon, don't go here!

The fish and chips are delicious at this restaurant. We ordered the 6 piece halibut and chips meal…read morewhich was prepared fairly quickly. The portions are quite huge, although the coleslaw came in a tiny container that was probably only good for one person. I would definitely order from them again.

Great food haven't visited in several years went back it's still great. Highly recommend if passing…read moreon highway 9 or 27

Worst fish and chips / seafood platter we have ever eaten. Your oil needs changing. Small portions…read moreand overdone. The waitress serving us was rude and unfriendly. I would not recommend this restaurant. Highly overrated!

Amazing food, family friendly restaurant. Highly recommended I will go again. This is a hidden gem.read more

This is our go to fish and chips place. We get takeout a lot. Our older son loves loves everything…read more Only on one occasion did I find a bone in the fish. But after so many times doing takeout it only happened once, so not bad at all. Halibut: 4.75/5 crispy and then soft inside. Yum. Sometimes could be a little more tender but most times we have ordered it was perfect. Chowder: 6/5 So good. So much flavour. Mushy peas: 7/5 How do they make it like that?! Never will peas taste that good. Chips: 5/5 Great chips! And excellent gravy to accompany. Onion rings: 4.5/5 Pretty good! Sometimes the batter is a little consistent but they are good overall. Highly recommend!

Finding a good fish & chips spot can be tricky at times when you think about balancing price,…read moreportion size, the batter, and the chips. This spot did a pretty good job overall. The batter wasn't too thick, greasy, or salty, and the fish filet was thick enough that it retained its structure when eating (instead of becoming a flaky mess). Chips were decent, but not the standout for me. Even their seniors portion size of fish & chips is quite filling. I also really enjoyed the seafood chowder, though it was on the saltier side. Shocked at how large the bowl of chowder was for the price, and they did not skimp out on the ingredients. No one wants a chowder that's 80% roux/cream base and 20% veggies with canned or frozen seafood mixed in. Be forewarned that finding parking on Main St Newmarket can be challenging during events and busier times/seasons!

This was an old haunt of ours back when we lived in Brampton. However, we stopped by after…read morevisiting family. This place is known for its Halibut & Chips. At $23 a plate it is a tad more than the Haddock & Chips at $17. And while the Haddock is good too. The halibut is the best I have had in the GTA. I also had onion rings while the wife at chips. The meal arrived with a large portion of Halibut. The rings were tasty just add a bit of salt and a light drizzle of ketchup. The halibut was a good cut of fish and the batter whole crisp held the tender flakey white meat. It was so satisfying. The place offers other seafood and I saw many plates of their calamari with Tzatziki sauce. Maybe next time. Oh if you have a sweet tooth or just miss a few of the British standards ex HP sauce, mushy peas or any of their chocolates. Then there is a nook where you can buy those too. Worth the trip up the 410. Service was fast and the servers were busy seating, plating or clearing the table for the next family.

This restaraugnt is very clean and the service is fast. When you walk in your immodestly greeted by…read morestaff and seated with menues. The washrooms and dinning area are both very clean. As for the food this place is serving up lots of traditional British dishes. The menu is large with plenty if options to choose from. Typically I get the haddock and chips, the tartar sauce is very fresh and has a nice tang to it. There Greek salad is delicious and a great balance to a fried meal I recently tried there grilled calamari and I wouldn't say it's my favourite but it was nice to try something new it was well seasoned I added a little more salt just to cut the fresh fish taste but the texture was good not rubbery and it paired well with the salad.

Came by for a quick dinner and was pleasantly surprised. They make it to order and everything is…read moresuper tasty. Fish and chips piping hot I think I burned myself. But service was quick and there is seating. It's not the nicest place but value was excellent and I will come try the shrimp or scallops next time.

I haven't been here in like 1-2 years now and came on a whim because I was craving fish and chips…read more Amy's hit the hunger spot though. I ordered 2 of their specials (Haddock and chips including a pop) for $12.50 + tax each. I was a little hesitant about the haddock being fishy? And was debating on paying more and getting their halibut. I was worried sick all the way home. But Upon eating the haddock, I was truly genuinely surprised at how good it was. Honestly, I couldn't tell the difference between this and halibut which is saying a lot about fish and chips. When my food was done, I saw the cook ( a lady ) and it was the same one from my previous visits a long time ago. Oh boy, I hope they don't change as the lady cook is a keeper! I know that this place was up for sale a while back and that is why I was hesitant to come here recently. But, after seeing that the cook is the same, I will be sure to make a few more visits and into my regular rotation of take out food. To all the yelpers out there. This is by far the best haddock I've tried and is comparable to halibut at a portion of the price. It's an easy recommendation.

I have no words! Hands down one of the best fish and chips spots I have been to!…read more Fish is fresh, never dry. Batter is super crispy never overdone or greasy. Portions are generous and the coleslaw and fries are amazing and complete the fish so well. I can eat just a plateful of their fries. Service is great, all the servers are so incredibly nice and friendly. It is always packed at lunch & dinner. Def a local favourite because everyone there knows each other. We tried the haddock, halibut and breaded shrimp! I wish I could have shared more photos, but when the plates are brought to the table I can't resist digging in right away! The menu options are great where you can get 3 pieces of haddock or halibut with 2 orders of fries. Lots of parking and plenty of seating inside. Takeout orders are 5% off. The menu is great with so many options! We first tried Joy's 6 weeks ago - we have been back almost every week since our first visit. When it's time to pay they give you a scratch card with your receipt - everyone is a winner. To redeem the card, spend $35 on your next visit for the free item. Some of the items you can scratch and win are , haddock & fries, halibut & fries, Joys feast special, large plate of fries. I'm sure there are more as these are just the items we have won. Options for fish and chips are very limited in Markham, so I love the option of visiting Stouffville nearby for Joy's Fish & Chips. Until next time...

Not bad yet not phenomenal. Ordered the Joy's Special for takeout. Good fry but portions were not…read morethat big compared to other fish and chips locations. Perhaps we'll try dine-in next time. Quite spacious in the restaurant with good parking outside. Fairly pleasant service. You get a bit of a discount if you pay by cash.

Amazing fish and chips, got it to go via Too Good To Go and was surprised to see that they make it…read morehot and ready to go. We've done this twice now and the deal is amazing! Each time so far we've gotten whatever soup, salad/side that they needed to move and also the fish and chips is fresh and hot. The pickup/wait time is about 20 mins. They are a popular spot in town, always someone picking up and/or enjoying their meal in the restaurant. What we typically get (two orders of fish and chips 2G2G): - two full fish and chips (w fries and mashed potatoes) - two soups - four sides (2 coslaws, 2 salads) Everything reheats great in an air fryer/oven. Highly recommend enjoying this local staple. If you are hesitant, get the 2G2G and decide for yourself.

June 25/2025: This was kind of disappointing. This was a takeout only meal…read more I ordered the scallops (8 small scallops) & chips ($18.99). I realized that there was an up charge of $4.00 for the fries! Very small scallops as well. Also ordered a deep fried battered pickles ($6.99). This was a good size order & they were tasty as well. Also had a side order of oil & vinegar coleslaw ($1.50). This was absolutely terrible & inedible in my opinion. The staff was very nice & the owner has been there for at least 35 years! I'd go here again but I'd adjust my order & I'd dine in!

First time trying Broadway Fish & Chips. Called ahead to check hours and even though they were…read moreabout to close the gentleman took our order anyway! Got the meal home.. Still popping hot nicely packaged good portion size not overly greasy great tasting fish! (We had the Cod) good fries great gravy Will definitely go back again! Definitely recommend!