I was a student at Hillel 10 years ago. I was fortunate enough to see the transition of administration, so I can still give you an accurate picture of what Hillel is.
Here are my grievances with the school:
1) Back when Rabbi Shinerman was one of the administrators of the school, he would call home telling my parents to put me on dangerous stimulant drugs not far from the molecule of methamphetamine. I understand this was a fad of the late 90s, but he was not an MD. Who was he to diagnose a child with ADHD, and wouldn't a professionally trained educator recognize gender based differences in behavior? He would also send people to a personal friend of his who was a psychiatrist. Countless numbers of parents complied and many kids are permanently damaged as a result of him pushing Adderall or Ritalin.
2) There was and (according to sources of mine) STILL IS a huge bully problem at Hillel. A bully problem that had me hospitalized for a severe concussion, and left me with years of migraines and seizures. I was kind enough to not file suit at age 18 because prominent members of the Jewish community in LA told me what a horrible thing I was about to attempt (to which I still regret today!). To make a very long story short, I can prove my claims with labeling theory. Teachers will pick their favorites, and some will not have their own favorites. Labeling theory suggests that the teachers cause primary deviance calling a student out for being slow, incapable, or dumb (yes I was called dumb here). Secondary deviance takes place when peers internalize labels created by teachers and the student also internalizes them as well. This environment created by the staff feeds a vicious bully cycle.
3) It was all about the money... If you could cut a check large enough, your child would get away with any kind of shit they wanted to pull. Think about it... Look at some of the plaques on the wall downstairs as you exit from the parking lot. Think about why they are on the wall?
4) I would venture to say that a significant amount of the staff is not trained professionally as an educator, and landed a job at Hillel after undergrad. If they are trained, I find it hard to believe that they are utilizing their teacher credential training to its fullest. There were anomalies within the school, but most lacked experience in classroom control and proper teaching techniques. Here were some of my favorites
Chaim Friedman: Told my parents I was "dumb". Oh how wrong he was, and now my education level most likely surpasses his highest level achieved. I'm getting a degree in public health, what was yours in again?
Judy Goldberg: Was my English teacher for two years. Talk about labeling theory, it might have been born in her classroom. She lacked patience to deal with learners that did not fall neatly within the bell curve. Reminiscent of Louise Fletcher or "Nurse Rached" in one flew over the cuckoo's nest.
Judy Reed: Totally awesome no complaints, and a total sweetheart. Worked well with me to get over my fear of math. She was a credentialed educator in Florida and go figure what a difference it made with my education experience.
To sum things up, Hillel was the wrong choice for me on so many levels. I was educated by unprofessional staff who were not equipped by any means to deal with a multitude of different learning styles and abilities. Yes I did have a learning disability, but with capable teachers I would have done extremely well. I found this out immediately when I left the Jewish school system. The teachers at Pacific Hills did an excellent job working with me, as well as the teachers at Fairfax High School. Why, you may ask? They all had formal training in education! Im sure you parents pay lots of money in property taxes which all go to fund the education system. The public school system is not awful, and your kids will have more opportunities to go to better universities in the long run. Teachers have to meet bench marks, and are kind and passionate enough to go out of their way to help you. I'm arguing that there are better places in Los Angeles to send your children for a quality education. read more