I stopped by Horseman Bagels to pick up a Too Good To Go order. The very nice man handed me two big bags of bagels. Wow! They share space with a Carvel there and everything was very clean. Now, these bagels toast up very light. This bagel will not lay heavy in the tummy. You get an airy, crisp bite if you toast lightly. Different from my usual type but flavorful and great if you want a light bagel without scooping out all the dough. I don't do this, but for those that do, I think you will find it's so light you might not need to. They had a nice pumpernickel bagel and rosemary sea salt bagel. You don't find those everywhere! read more

meh, not the best. over 5$ for the usual (bagel W/ schmere) so thats a little off putting, but i know the world we live in now. The bagel was bread city, big as a plate and thats not a quality im looking for, so im afraid i wont be back to horseman bagels, not in this part of the state, too may options to be fair. gidde up read more

They have been good in the past but don't go later in the day because it's pretty much like they are using up what didn't work out. The bagel I got with bacon and egg was terrible and the bacon was so burnt. Waste of money. It was takeout so it was too late to go back. read more

Horseman Bagels - Burnt bacon. Totally unappealing - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Evening treat and pickup breakfast for the morning. Horseman Bagles and Carvel Icecream an interesting combination in Historic Sleepy Hollow. Looking for an evening Icecream we came across Horseman Bagels. Lots of traditional Icecream soft serve and hard Icecream but also a non dairy option made with oatly. On the other side you can pick up bagels and bagel chips. Very nice staff can assist with both sides. read more

See all

The reviews are so high because they're the only game in town. The food is fine. But don't except anything above average. And service is insanely slow. Expect to spend an hour here if you get in line at 8:30am or later on a weekend. The bagel selection was limited, but the bagels themselves had a good texture. The everything bagel was so salty I couldn't eat the top half. The bagel sandwiches don't have any condiments. They're just plain egg and cheese. A little mustard would go a long way. The service was plenty patient and friendly, especially given how busy it was. The worst thing is how slow it is. There were only maybe 5 orders ahead of us in line, and it took 30 min to order. The problem is the person who takes your order is also the person who makes your food and checks you out. 3 people were working. It was inefficient. There are only a few tables inside and out. But since it takes so long to order, there'll likely be empty tables by the time you are ready to sit down. Lattes on the menu but no lattes. Bummer. TL DR: everything bagel too salty, get a sweet or plain bagel with schmear not a sammy; plan to spend an hour here on a weekend morning. read more

Horseman Bagels - Bagel with Egg and Cheese. Everything bagel was too salty. Sammy needed a condiment. - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

See all

Was in the neighborhood saw this bagel place so went in, looks clean, got a everything bagel with bacon egg and cheese friendly service and fast, bagel was good. read more

I found this restaurant on my Too Good To Go app. I decided to try it out because I like bagels and I like sandwiches. I went one morning after work. I wanted to see what the hype was about. The entrance it pretty confusing if you don't live in Sleepy Hollow. This restaurant "appears" to be next door to the Carvel Ice Cream Shop. You actually have to enter through the Carvel Ice Cream Shop. I was immediately greeted and given time to think about what I wanted to order. I grabbed a Snapple Fruit Punch from the open fridge. I ordered an Egg and Cheese on a Bagel. I requested my plain bagel be toasted with butter and then spread with grape jelly before topping with the egg and cheese. I must say the sandwich was good (not like I make my egg and cheese bagels at home). The bagel was toasted a little too much to my liking, so the bottom was hard to bite and the cheese was not mixed into the egg. My sandwich was wrapped in aluminum foil and placed into a bag. They had no napkins available at the time (which is crazy because they had been open for almost two hours before I arrived). There's not much seating inside, but they also have some seating outside. (Which is nice for a sunny day or when the weather is good). Not too many inside, so it was nice and quiet when I placed my order. Will try again and next time ask that my bagel not be toasted too much. I spent like $8.50 for the bagel sandwich and drink. read more

Horseman Bagels - Bagel with Egg and Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

See all

Been an active TooGoodToGo user recently and love trying new spots! Though this bagel place has been open for a minute, was glad to pick up a bag that I was able to store in my freezer (tip: slice your bagels before storing!) These bagels are fairly large, they almost didn't fit in my bagel cutter! Not really a fan of the rainbow bagels but all the other flavors were perfect! Definitely will be back, especially to pick up a schmear! read more

Horseman Bagels - TooGoodToGo order - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Back again for bagels now they are re-open. Carvel also carrys many ice cream cake options. They currently offer gift certificates for any one interested in gifting local treats. Sayeed helped me today and is friendly and warm and happens to be one of the owners. read more

Horseman Bagels - Store front next to the Carvel! - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

See all

delicious bagels, and the staff paid attention and prepared it perfectly! large selection, very fresh. They also have fast breakfast items and ice cream. Parking was small, I don't live in the area but suspect I would figure out a close but easier place on the street. Wish they were near us! read more

I ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese but got another kind of cream cheese. I think it would've been 5 stars if it was just plain cream cheese. Never tried this cream cheese before it's not too bad but does leave your breath stinky hehe. read more

Horseman Bagels - Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Carvel and horseman bagel is in one building. They have parking behind the place as well if there is none in the front. They have no restroom. The ice cream cakes that they had were soo nice. I would have bought the hello kitty one but it would have melted with our 2 hrs ride back home. We ordered the garlic bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese. They ran out of the rosemarie garlic bagel which I wanted to try. It was crowded when we went. read more

Great stop for a bagel and coffee. The bagels are so fresh and the cream cheese options are decent. Said is friendly and serves you with a smile and efficiency! Eggs everything and pumpernickel everything bagels recommended read more

Great bagels and breakfast sandwiches, they're also generous with the toppings. Guys are friendly and quick to get your order out. We stood and enjoyed our food inside, tables were clean and shop was warm which was great with the cold outside weather. Tourists note: this place also carries a few headless horsemen souvenirs! read more

My bagel aficionado boyfriend from Jersey has finally found an acceptable bagel on this side of the bridge! Horseman has decent sized bagels with some unique flavors of both bagels and cream cheese. We tried the pumpernickel with olive and rosemary garlic with plain cream cheese. Good texture and crust, friendly quick service. read more

Horseman Bagels has the most incredible bagels I've ever had! They are hot and fresh with the most perfect soft, doughiness while still having the perfect soft, yet crisp outside! We devoured plain bagels and rosemary garlic bagels. They were out of this world! The flavor was amazing. The tuna salad and nova were very good, too. The customer service is top notch! The whole staff couldn't be kinder, especially Saeed. They are personable, helpful, and patient. I highly recommend Horeman Bagels!! I would give it 10 stars if I could! If I lived nearby, I would come here for breakfast every single day. read more

Horseman Bagels - Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Stopped here on a Saturday morning in October. Got in and out within 7 minutes at 10am. The bagels are definitely all that and a baga chips! We went with the everything bagels (yes, they are pretty salty so keep that in mind). The shop is so cute and worth the wait if there is one. I know it's the only "option" for this fare but they do a great job and the customer service is definitely on-par. read more

Exceptional service & great tasting bagels! Split with a Carvel creamery and easy to access. A+ read more

Horseman Bagels - Perfectly cooked Sausage, Bacon, Egg and Cheese on an Onion Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Fantastic bagel shop! Come hungry! The bagels are massive! I really love all the options here for a bagel! Staff is great at getting people in and out quickly! Would definitely return if I'm in the area! read more

This was the best food I had during our weekend trip to Sleepy Hollow. I am not a bagel expert (where I live, we get our "fancy" bagels from Panera), so do with this review what you will.... The parking and ordering situations at 8-ish on a Sunday morning were not the greatest. There was some confusion over who had already ordered and where the line began, so service wasn't super fast. BUT! Once we got our order (everything with veggie cream cheese and plain with scallion and lox)-- these things were SO good. The bagels were large and perfectly chewey. The veggie cream cheese had real chunks of veggies, not just veggie "flavor." I don't even like salmon that much, but I tried a bite and it was really tasty. If anything, maybe they were a bit heavy-handed on the cream cheese, but better that than too little. Again, I'm no expert, but I really, really liked these bagels! read more

I had a really frustrating experience at this bagel shop. There was only one person working, handling everything from taking orders to making the food, which led to an extremely slow process. While he was busy making bagels, a long line of customers--including people who just wanted a simple coffee or a plain bagel--were stuck waiting. It took me 30 minutes just to get a single bagel. The management here is clearly lacking, and the inefficiency makes it hard to justify coming back. I do not recommend this place. Owner, you need to fix the inefficiency. Hire more staff, separate order-taking from food prep, and set up a quick-service line for coffee and simple bagels. Consider online ordering and train your team to work faster. If you don't, you'll keep losing customers. read more

Shout out to Pierre for giving us the best bagel sandwich in the fastest time. The cheese was melted perfectly. Said is also awesome too. If you want amazing food and ice cream come here! read more

Growing in Brooklyn I feel makes me qualified to judge a bagel. There's lots of great places still in NYC. Not so much in Westchester. There's a place down the block from me that's part of a small chain. Very good, but long lines and honestly I don't feel it's very clean. Anyway, I went into Horseman ready to be very judgmental. Especially based on the reviews. Went in around 7 am this morning and got me a tuna on sesame bagel. I can tell by looking the bagels are well made. Taste was perfect. Tuna fresh. Friendly service. It's a longer walk, but I know where I'll get my bagels from now on. read more

The best pumpernickel bagels around! And the rosemary-garlic are amazing!! Worth going out of the way for these!!

Love this spot! Nothing more comforting than the stag's friendly smiles, their incredible Pumpernickel bagels (I love them with Lox and scallion cream cheese), and the big bright windows. Simple and sweet. read more

Horseman Bagels - Menu - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Amazing bagels. Patient & helpful staff. Even offered samples of the cream cheeses when we couldn't decide. They even had a pumpkin bagel which was spot on in flavor! read more

What a great bagel shop. Bagels were perfect texture and delicious and the egg salad was very good. I also love that they did not skimp on the amount of salad they added to the bagel. My friend got an egg and cheese on a bagel which she thoroughly enjoyed. A++. read more

Best bagels on the Hudson! Great staff. Love this place! The bagels were perfect and there were cream cheese options that felt new, innovative, and locally sourced. What a great place!! read more

After growing up in the Bronx and living in Manhattan, it's hard to find a great bagel. Thus far this is my favorite in westchester - tried the everything and the rosemary garlic, both which were great and fresh! I ordered via delivery and they were still fresh so I'd imagine they're even better in store. read more

They have the best bagels! And they're super nice and friendly! You can't go wrong with them, but I strongly recommend the zaatar bagel!

Good bagels but they have never once gotten my order right and don't appear to care to. They do not know which ingredients they have or are putting on bagels - unable to tell the difference between American and cheddar cheese and will tell you whatever you want to hear to make a sale despite the fact that you will instantly find out what was actually served to you. read more

Great bagels! Please sample their Rose Cream Cheese, it's homemade and really amazing!!! read more

Horseman Bagels - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Bagels Near Me - Sleepy Hollow, New York

Simply put, THE best bagel I have ever eaten. Located on with Carvel ice cream. Highly recommend the egg and cheese breakfast sandwich with a latte! read more

The best bagels in town! FAST and friendly staff. Great addition to our community. Blows B.E. out of the water and you don't have to wait in line for an eternity. read more

Great bagels! Very fresh, taste amazing. Very nice service. The only problem was finding it- had no idea its INSIDE CARVEL.

Good bagels. Biga and chewy. Cooked well but not overdone. Good service. Finally theyre open!

Snotty and overpriced. They must think they're the only bagel game in town. I like my bagel moderately toasted. I don't think that's too much to ask for a bagel and coffee that cost roughly 9 dollars. The smiling jack at the register couldn't be bothered and decided to get cute with me instead like I was asking too much. I'll know better than to turn into that crapshoot again. They're not H&H. read more

The woman at the front helping us was not hearing us well, got our order wrong and then we believe over charged us. First time here and certainly the last time here. Main Street Sweets is worth the extra 2-3 minute drive read more

Awesome bagels (my WW everything was the perfect amount of chewy and absolutely COVERED in topping) and friendly service. Their egg salad was delicious as well--peppery and not too much mayo. My only complains slash wish is that they had tofu cream cheese along with the rest of their awesome spreads and salads. Fingers crossed that'll come soon! read more

Our new go to bagel store. The only problem is the construction that is going on. Once this is solved it should be your stop for bagels & breakfast sandwiches. read more