This was a pleasant surprise. They don't have a toaster but before you think it's not worth it, this was a very good bagel. I'm not someone who loves cream cheese but that was the best cream cheese and plain bagel I've ever had. The bagel is amazing! Soft inside, slightly crispy on the outside, little shinny, and perfectly boiled. Mine was still a little warm because of how fresh it was too! I'd totally stop again for a $3 bagel and probably take some extra home next time! read more

A really small spot I just found recently. Bagels are on the smaller end but really good. They do not toast the bagels here and it's cash only. read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Everything bagel with veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Pretty unassuming place with a simple menu but went in after It was recommended to us. So glad we did because It was fantastic. They don't toast the bagels here - I'm a toasted bagel kind of girl so at first I was worried but wow, there's a reason they don't toast: It doesn't need It! The bagel was hot and fresh, the dough pulling apart & spongy, soft and chewy. They also placed the perfect amount of salmon (not too much, not too little). It was also thin and melted in your mouth. Delish! Definitely give this place a try! read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese & nova lox - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Tiny little place - cash only - but bagels are delicious. They are smaller than the standard bagels, doughy on the inside and slightly crunchy on the outside. I tried the cinnamon raisin bagel and then everything bagel with lox spread (had actual chunks of lox in it!) and was very happy. Definitely a friendly and pleasant experience. read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

I made a trip to NYC to see a concert and on the way home planned on seeing family in White Plains. I wanted bagels so I went on Yelp and this place was the place to stop based on reviews. Was not disappointed! Easy to get to. Lots of parking nearby. Such a cute little area with lots of shops. The bagels were fresh and delicious! Staff was very helpful! read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

After our early morning run/walks & hikes we like to stop at Scarsdale Bagels occasionally and reward ourselves with their fresh warm ready-made bagels. Bagels are best enjoyed fresh baked hot from the oven! They have an array of flavors, plain, pumpernickel, sourdough, rye .... We like the Sesame and 'Everything' flavors. Then we go home, add smoked salmon, capers, etc or just toast them with a little butter and strawberry preserves. Yum Missing the days of our group breakfasts at the diner. Hopefully things will change so we can dine indoors again. Until then, we will enjoy our Take-away bagel cravings here in Scarsdale. Stay safe and well. read more

See all

Fresh and very good bagels love the tast old school ,service fast and people are nice plenty to choose from .

Great bagels with smaller size for the carb conscious. Cream cheeses available in a variety of flavors. Got a dozen +2 are free! Love the onion and everything bagels read more

The best old time bagels in the metro area. Excellent quality, always fresh and chewy.

This place has my heart. If it werent for budget eats like this i wouldn't be able to survive. $1 bagels of any variety is a solid gem. Do me a favor and buy the lox from the freezer and your own cream cheese, be blessed and merry. Solid quality manhattan bagels that garth rd can't afford to lose. Support this place by all means! read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Garlic bagel - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Love this place! A must go to in Scarsdale! I love the little plastic goose they dress up in the window it hilarious! And has new outfits every week or so! Great bagels and coffee! I like the cinnamon raisin and plain bagels. My only negative interaction was years ago when this employee refused to put cream cheese on my bagel and insisted I had to buy an entire tub from the mini fridge. I know they have cream cheese to put in customers bagels it a bagel place. But that was years ago so whatever, all my other experiences have been amazing and all the other staff I've met are super friendly! Great place for coffee and a snack, or a lunch. Closes a little early but it a breakfast kinda place so I get it. Great place read more

Still my favorite bagels of all time!! Tasty !! It's quick and easy . The cash only thing could be inconvenient.

Best bagels in town or anywhere for that matter, small little neighborhood place that we love and are willing to stand in line when necessary on the weekends! Always fresh and steaming hot read more

Good NYC bagel, nice people, good service. Please remember to bring cash only. read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Everything with scallion cream cheese and Plain with smoked salmon and cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Listen to me very carefully. I am a middle aged man that grew up and lived and worked all around Queens, Brooklyn and Long Island for over 40 years. Don't try to tell me about bagels because I will tell you about bagels. These are the best bagels around. Do they live up to a hot bagel from a Queens bagel shop via 1985? Your Mom sends you to the corner shop where you get a baker's dozen for 3 friggin bucks. Then as you walk home you start eating one of the warm ones right out of the bag like a savage. Do they live up to that moment in time where you can still taste the perfect crunch of the outside mixed with sesame seeds and then doughy deliciousness and that smell....ohh that SMELL!!!!!! NO!!! ....they can't compare to that bagel in that moment in time you nutcase. But they are one of the best bagels in Westchester that you are going to find post 1985. Some people say they have great coffee. I don't trust those people anymore. However for a bagel shop they have very good coffee. read more

I have dropped down my rating one star because of one reason: bagel density. The last few visits, the bagels have been smaller and a bit dense. Not sure if the dough is new or the yeast is missing something, but I am calling on them to up the ante and get them great bagels back up to snuff. The taste are fine but last batch was TINY! NOt just one particular but ALL. read more

Pretty good bagels! Fresh and steaming hot early morning. The home-made cream cheese come in a variety of mixtures. This is your basic no-nonsense New York bagel store with a counter, a till which only accepts cash (there is no indication of this and the first Saturday in Scarsdale after I arrived I walked over to be disappointed as I only had my credit cards with me). Suggestion: offer Tofuttti (dairy free) variety and also get a toaster - they told me "no we don't toast our bagels for you" read more

Meh. Had the bagel and nova. Tomatoes were cold from the fridge. Everything was cold so not much flavor. Really expensive too. It wasn't terrible but for the price and location I expected better. Was average at best. read more

Really great bagels !! Made the right way with the right crunch on the outside. Thanks

Nic been here for yrs. Fresh bagel made with love and passion daily. He Carry's a large selection of bagels. You can add the lox deluxe or the white fish portion in the bagel. The staff are awesome ppl , friendly, polite, serving bagels with a smile. read more

I live in Scarsdale Village. Bagels doughy and not crispy on the outside. Beautiful store though. Will not be back!

They are open but as a result of Hurricane Ida, their phones are still not working! I was there this morning and I was told by one of the owners that their business has suffered since people assume they are closed They happen to have the nest bagels in Westchester! They are in Garth Road and open from 6am to 2pm every day! read more

Been out of town for some time, but Scarsdale Bagels is perhaps the best bagels in town. I thought so over ten years ago, and I still think so now. It's a small shop on Garth Road, nothing flashy or fancy about it. But the bagels are good, and they have many options to customize your order, from different cream cheeses, most major types of bagels (including, but not limited to onion, garlic, everything, rye, etc.), and my personal favorite, the bagel with lox. Of course, they have coffee and other drinks too, like Snapple, etc. Try it for yourself, ideally from a freshly baked batch in the morning; you'll see why I and many others endorse Scarsdale Bagels so strongly. I am a big fan of lox, so I like to order their lox bagel. But the true value is in their bagels. They are chewy and tasty while maintaining the firmness of a bagel, especially on the outer layers. Next time you want some bagels, go get yourself a dozen or so from Scarsdale Bagels and let me know what you think! read more

This was a pretty bland bagel. It wasn't so bad I couldn't eat it but it was really chewy and more difficult than most. It was also insanely small. I could barely taste any of the cream cheese and when i did it surely didn't taste like vegetable cream cheese. For $3.80 I'd rather go to Brook Street Bagels. read more

Scarsdale Bagels - Plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

I did not happen upon this place. I searched for it in my quest for a real NY CHEWY BAGEL with that crisp outside. They nailed it! A bit farther than my local place but worth the drive! They have Acme smoked lox and fish salads prepackaged. The best. One stop shop. I'm done. read more

Cash only, ATM available. Family owned and run. No frills-- just excellent New York bagels, and ONLY bagels, hand rolled, kettle boiled, and baked in several batches all morning long. (There are three flavored cream cheeses and lox available as well as a refrigerator case of smoked fish, dairy and juice to take home but you will not find any muffins, etc. here.) Get there before 1pm for best selection, expect the shop to close by 2pm. There is really nothing that warms my little carb-living heart in winter than pulling up at dawn and seeing the neon light through the sweaty front window... read more

Scarsdale Bagels - The iced coffee is decent, too. - Bagels Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Best bagel in the area. Crunch on the outside, soft inside. Not sure why you'd go anywhere else.

Best bagel around . NYC level good . Cash only, very authentic , homemade bagels , always super fresh.

GOAT - greatest of all time because the only Bagel Shop I know in a 50 mile radius outside of New York City that makes handmade bagels. and the coffee is to die for! read more

Moved to Westchester from the UES and of course, missed our weekend morning routine, bagel, NY Times, east river park. But guess what, these bagels are the best of Westchester and even better than some of NYC spots. they are fresh and delicious, the cream cheeses are great, the coffee traditional. Keep in mind, Cash only and do NOT ask them to toast,, won't happen .. read more

The bagels are so delicious,fresh and soft,compared to other bagel stores and the service is excellent, specially from Miss Miranda.

Just meh. A perfect example of a business that with just a little effort could really kick up things a notch. Sesame bagel was fine but unremarkable. While not dirty the shop was also not squeaky clean. There were two employees that I saw and two customers--me and someone else. The employees were neutral about our being there...no expression of hospitality at all. Big bummer: they don't toast bagels. Strikes me like a pizzeria that doesn't put cheese on its pizzas--why bother? Lastly, they short changed me. I didn't notice until I was gone. Won't be stopping here again. read more

After seeing these reviews I'm wondering if I got a fluke bagel. Came here on New Year's Day and was served easily the worst bagel-place bagel I've ever gotten. It was rock hard, not even soft on the inside. It made a Thomas' store bought bagel taste good. The vegetable cream cheese tasted sour. The iced coffee tasted dusty, if that makes sense. Poor excuse for a bagel, poor excuse for coffee. Will not be returning any time soon. read more

Basic selection, chewy, don't toast bagels and not generous with cream cheese. Not worth it.

Very good bagels! Don't come here and plan I'm getting the works. All they have are the staple spreads: butter, jelly, and a few cream cheese flavors. You can watch them make the bagels too through window. The earlier you come, the Better they taste! read more

The best bagels in NY! Still doing it after all these years. Great crust on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Add your favorite schmear and your morning is off to a perfect start read more

I am loving the bagels here and happened upon their location when I was looking for the Dunkin Donuts that used to be there. I was a little annoyed when I walked in and the gentleman at the counter started to take my order and then bypassed me to take one of his regular customer's order. He basically pushed me onto the next staff member who was not even ready to assist me and on top of that, he started to take the order from his regular customer that came in AFTER me and then proceeded to pawn off her order on another employee. I was tempted to walk out because I have little patience for the inconsiderate but I decided to finish up my order and glad I did because they went over real well with the family. read more

Best bagels I've found in the Westchester area so far . I'm a bit of a bagel snob in that I've grown up on Long Island and NYC. (If you're ever on LI go to hand rolled bagels in New Hyde Park...you won't regret it). I tend to eat a bagel just about everyday! I buy a dozen at a time and freeze um. They hold up and defrost well. Good selection also, my fav there is the whole wheat everything. Def recommend. read more

In the affluent village of Scarsdale, you would think that there would be at least one really good bagel place. This tiny hole in the wall has had a foothold in the community for quite a while but the bagels are as basic as they get. You won't find any special varieties of cream cheeses here. You won't find anything too crazy as far as bagel selections. No seating. No bathroom. They don't even have eggs here so forget about getting a typical breakfast sandwich on a bagel. I had an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and it was more like a "barely anything" bagel. Not many toppings on it. The bagel was decent enough but it wasn't as tasty as it could have been. At least it felt soft and fresh. The bagels are made here on the premises so that was one saving grace. In a place like Scarsdale where they have more than their fair share of upper crust types, you would think they would demand the same quality and extras that go into a lot of the fine bagel establishments in NYC. Even some of the less well-to-do parts in NYC have bagel places with more bells and whistles. It's one thing to not bend to current bagel status quo based on rep, it's another to not bend based on location. I guess when there is no other competition, "good enough" cuts it over here. read more

See all

The price was nice compared to those in the area but I wasn't thrilled by the bagels. The everything bagel had barely any seeds and it was so small I would have needed another to fill me up! The service was quick. read more