Outstanding Bakery I lived in Tarrytown most of my life. They made the best Boston Cream Pie I ever ate. I wish I could get the recipe. I live in the Buffalo, NY area now. Mike Leyendecker read more

Lovely girls that work the counter very sweet gave me great opinions. They made me a great cup of hot cocoa. My girlfriend had a lovely iced coffee and everything is fresh. I can't ask for anything more. There's plenty of parking in the back and a nice area to go walk around and have a delicious pastry. read more

I've been looking for a good Italian bakery, and didn't realize that one was right under my nose. As generically named as possible, Tarrytown Pastry chef is fair nondescript from the outside. Walk inside, and it reminded me a lot of a stereotypical Italian bakery in the 5 boroughs. Opens at 7 too just like one. Baked goods are more American than Italian, however there are the obligatory cannoli and the like. Service was friendly, and prices were on par with a local bake shop. Seemed a little high to me but I guess I'm an old fart now. Upon ordering the rainbow cookies I was not excited. They were very big (squares), color wasn't very bright, and they looked more cakes than cookie. I'm glad I didn't change my mind, as these were much better than I anticipated. They were clearly fresh, with the right consistency (if a bit thick), good quality chocolate, and they were very balanced with the apricot jam. I'm more of a raspberry guy as the apricot tends to fade into the background, but there was a judicious amount here. Not sure why they don't use a more bold food dye as that would largely solve the aesthetic issue. Got chocolate covered cannoli which was a solid rendition of a classic; their cream is not as sweet as some others, but with the chocolate covered shell it's a non-issue. Would like to try a plain one sometime. I'm damn happy to have this place nearby. One of the biggest fears of leaving the city was not having a good Italian bakery nearby. Generic name aside, these guys deliver on that. Will be here often and ashamed it took me so long to try. read more

I went in and the woman in the front did not greet me but instead went straight to the back. When she did interact me, there was no greeting just a clear what do you want with a tone of voice that conveyed she did not care and wanted me to know it. I ordered, got my food, and paid and she did not say thank you. My cookies were the same type of cookies in literally every single bakery and supermarket. The supermarket is better because the self-checkout machine is equally uncaring, but its excuse is it is not in its programming to care. read more

ambience: old-fashioned neighborhood bakery. I got there late in the day so the Pickens were pretty slim, but even so, I left with a beautiful cheese, danish, half a pound of assorted cookies, and a few croissants. Maria was my service and she attended to me with a big smile and a lot of patience. Do you know what it's like to try to find that perfect assortment of cookies? Food: the pastry and cookies were gifts so I can't vouch, but they did look fresh and delicious. I had half of the chocolate croissant and found the flavor to be quite nice. It was not a flaky pastry, so I'm not sure if I would purchase it again. A bit heavy. all in all, the experience was a good one, especially since I recognized upon reaching my home that I forgot my sunglasses on their countertop. A quick call to Maria this morning and she assures me. She will put them aside for me. My trip is over an hour , so I can't get back until next week but she assures me she will hang onto them. Gracias Maria.! read more

Amazing mini pastries and fabulous biscotti as well as cookies. They also have a great assortment of breads and very good coffee to go. The service is friendly. Nice clean old-fashioned bakery space tucked away on Broadway. Helpful hint: order their cannoli chips and dip platter in advance and bring it to a party! read more

Very accommodating team of pastry chefs. They delivered a Xmas tray to Northwell Hospice team with great style and efficiency. I will definitely call them again. read more

Breakfast pastries for my family. Cookies for colleagues and students. Birthday cakes for family and friends. There's always a good reason to stop in at Tarrytown Pastry Chef, and over the past several years they've never failed to delight me with their baking. They have a wide variety. The typical spread of breakfast pastries includes all manner of traditional Danishes, croissants, muffins (cappuccino is my favorite), and donuts, as well as surprises like Portuguese custard tarts and lobster tails (sfogliatelle). When I bring a box home for family and friends, we end up dividing up each item so that everyone can try everything. Their food is delicious. In pre-pandemic times, my go-to treat for my students was a box of assorted cookies. The delight on their faces as they chose between the beautifully decorated cookies was matched only by their joy in wolfing down the treats. They offer good value. Even after going here for several years, I am always surprised by how low the price is when they ring me up for a full box of pastries. This is true for cakes and everything else on offer. Their competitive pricing really leaves no excuse for passing them up for the supermarket. They are reliable. We've done special orders here for cookies, cakes, and cupcakes on several occasions, and the orders always are accurate and ready on time. read more

See all

Amazing laced cookies. Great service, nice people, nice location. Good coffee. Easy ordering.

I would like to state that years ago I loved this place however recently whenever I go or someone I know goes they say same thing not very friendly you walk in say good morning they just blankly stare at you as if your bothering them not the same service I remember however same great taste but they do need to better train their employees I don't spend money places where people aren't friendly read more

I've only came here to purchase cakes for special occasions. They do a great job with the cakes but they seriously have to work on their customer service, especially the lady the picks up the phone. Every time I've called she answers as if I'm bothering her. She also gives half ass answers and doesn't like to help. For example, I asked if she can do a certain design on a cake and she tells me she doesn't know if they can do it, like okayyy? Why don't you find out if you can. After I tell her she's not giving me an answer she then tells me to email her a picture of the cake but never gets back to me. She seriously has to work on her tone and customer service. At least act like you want to help. After this experience I had to get the cake somewhere else and I didn't want to because I love their cakes! The other place that I went to asked me to email them a picture of the cake, took my name and number down, and actually got back to me. The lady even spoke to the manager to inform me about the correct pricing. This is what I call going above and beyond to help a customer! read more

Tiny and unassuming place in a small town selling delicious cookies and baked goods. Located on Broadway in a row of stores and businesses. There are a lot of different desserts to choose from - cookies, pastries, cakes - all beckoning one to eat them. Coffee, cappuccino, and a few small tables to sit at if wanting to hunker down and enjoy on-site. Helpful and friendly staff that offered good suggestions. Some tasty Italian cookies and anisette toast made their way back to our hotel room. No complaints at all. Would definitely hit them up again if in the area. read more

There are not many places left that make fresh homemade doughnuts. For that 5 stars alone. Doughnuts are fresh and delicious!! read more

Tarrytown Pastry Chef - Bakeries Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

They have been making my daughter's cakes for five years and they never disappoint. Always so beautiful and delicious.

The owner is absolutely wonderful and items are fresh daily. We have ordered custom cookies and cakes for various family events and they never disappoint. Will not go anywhere else :) read more

Best Bakery in town. Lovely Staff and outdoor tables available as well. No pics this stop in since I house whatever I buy immediately.

Can't speak for anything other than their rainbow cookies but they are fantastic and worth every penny (and calorie). Very nice people there too. read more

Very friendly staff..I was looking for Black Forest cake for my friend and they did not have any in house..but,I will surely stop in for one of their beautiful treats next time we are town.Thank you ladies for your assistance! read more

Excellent Bakery. I especially enjoy their pastries.

Seemingly a lot of other bakeries in the area are closed on Monday, except this place. I got the Strawberry Shortcake Cake for a birthday and everyone enjoyed it. The icing/frosting was not too sweet, the cake was definitely moist and not crumbly, and the strawberry fruit filling had a nice amount of sweet and tart and was definitely not from a can. Each slice seemed to have several pieces of strawberry in it. Everyone who had the cake enjoyed it - so I would definitely be back. I've never really been a fan of Italian butter cookies, as they always seem to be dry and crumbly with almost no taste at all - likely enough their selection seemed to meet my expectation. read more

Italian Creek puff was so amazing. Super sweet and creamy. So delicious. I should have ordered coffee with it as well. This place has so many different desserts to choose from, all looking so incredible. Staff was also very helpful and friendly as I made my selection. Can't wait til I try the cookies later read more

Tarrytown Pastry Chef - Bakeries Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

This Pastry store is one of the finest in Westchester. I haven't brought any pastry yet which wasn't simply fabulous. Maria and staff her helpful and greet you with a smile. I've gotten a 50th Birthday Cake Im October which was simply marvelous and decorated so beautiful. I was amazed on the detail and the filling was super! I highly recommend this pastry store to all of my friends. I included a picture of my fabulous cake! read more

Tarrytown Pastry Chef - Bakeries Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I've never reviewed on yelp before but my experience here has been so terrible that I feel compelled to leave a review for Pastry Chef. This place should be called Moldy 2-Week Old Pastry Chef- the food they serve isn't just bad, it's hazardous. I ordered a pineapple turnover and, as you can see in the image, it was filled with thick, dark patches of mold. The owners and staff should be ashamed to serve this, and I am especially upset by the fact that most of their customers seem to be elderly individuals who may not be able to taste the mold and whatever else is growing in their pastries but are more susceptible to foodborne illnesses. Please keep you friends and family away from this place as they obviously have little to no regard for your health and safety. read more

Tarrytown Pastry Chef - Moldy pineapple turnover- employee said it was made "one day ago" - Bakeries Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

So many thanks to say to the fabulous staff at Pastry Chef. I ordered over the phone and simply told them I wanted all white for an engagement party. She went over every filling and icing option in white and finally suggested Cannoli filling with white and chocolate cake for the main cake. I didn't feel rushed or as if I was annoying them with my questions. It was something I couldn't imagine but was so pleased she did!!!! What I didn't expect was intricate almost lace like details, edible sparkles and pearls! I was blown away. I added the 'love' and rings to the cupcakes. They could work on their penmanship but honestly overlooked it because the cake was soooooo delicious and the decorations were impeccable. The cupcakes were just as good and over the top! read more

See all

I really love how Pastry Chef makes their Napoleon cake. The flaky layers are always fresh and the cream is neither overly sweet or too custardy. I have tried a few of their other items and they are pretty good too. It's hard for me to find a good pastry shop especially after tasting some amazing desserts in Europe. Even 'authentic' bakeries in the Bronx just don't make things the old fashioned way anymore. This place, however, really does live up to high standards. Please try them out, I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. read more

Tarrytown Pastry Chef - Flaky and fresh Napoleon. - Bakeries Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

These people are rude. I called to see if they deliver cake since it was my grams bday and she turned 73. I life out of state and wanted to surprise her with a delivered cake. The girl who answered couldnt speak English. She was rude. No customer service skills at all. Instead of putting the phone on hold to ask if my request could be delivered, she puts it down and I hear the whole conversation. I will assume she was talking to a manager or owner who also said in a rude way " We don't deliver. Only to places of business" I hung up. No need to waste my time with these people. read more

I've been here 5 times for my brunch gatherings - we've had the coffee cake, crumb loaf, pecan loaf, blue berry loaf, apple anchor and assorted bagels everything has been DELICIOUS and fresh. Used to get a couple to taste now we get them all. Will keep coming back to sample other pastries!! Great value too!!! read more

Stumbled on this place by accident while looking for pastries around the White plains area. Bought a lot of items: cookies and other pastries. Everything was a huge hit with the whole family. Maybe the best flavors we have had from any of the other bakeries we have tried around Westchester county. Fresh and the right of sweetness! Great food and friendly staff. read more

I had friends and family who were planning a party in the surrounding area from out of State and needed ordered a Red Velvet Cake from Tarrytown Pastry Chef. This is a local Mom/Pop business and it seems like the local community supports them. We arrived shortly before the party on Sunday (06-16-2013) and were able to locate Tarrytown Pastry Chef with no problems. We walked into the establishment and found this business to be quite busy on a Sunday morning. People from the area were lining up out the door to get fresh Italian pastries from this place. Everything smelled so good but there were no Vegan options=( I guess us California folk expect to have everything out way. The Red Velvet cake was decorated beautifully and was a total hit at the party. I wanted to thank the staff at Tarrytown Pastry Chef for making the day extra special. There were no problems with the ordering, presentation or taste of the cake. It is always nice when a plan is executed without flaws. If you are looking for a professional Bakery in the business that will satisfy all of your needs no matter where you might be planning the party from, definitely give Tarrytown Pastry Chef a shot. I highly doubt I will be in need of another cake while in the area but if I was without question I would come back here. I do wish they had a Vegan / Gluten free option. Metered street parking is available right outside of the doors of this business. read more

I have visited this bakery shop now for 4 times and each visit was a let down. Maybe my expectations were bit high. Just moved to this area three months ago and been in search for a good bakery since then. It is taking forever and so far no success. Pros: the cookies and cakes looks really good. The people working in shop are all smiles and highly polite. The coffee is much better as compared to many surrounding coffee shops, except one. More on that in another review. Cons: oh boy, the pastry and cookies taste bad. Tried most of the cookies and few fruit tarts and they taste like it had been made for weeks. Cookies are so tough to bite in and I got the feeling the butter used in the ingredients are more like vegetable oil. Fruit tarts are soggy on bottom, like it sat in there for long time. Croissant is ok. The soda bread is mediocre. Well I will keep on searching for a better bakery. read more

En route to my wife's grandparents for dinner, I needed some Italian pastries and maybe some cannoli. I asked at the coffee place around the corner if there was an Italian bakery, and they pointed me here. I wasn't too encouraged by the name, but walking in, it looked and smelled like an Italian bakery. I was ready to walk out when I didn't see canolli, but I figured they make them fresh, and I was right. I picked out a selection of mini-pastries, a box of cannoli, and snatched up four of these italian cheesecakes I've been obsessed with for years (I ate one on the way out, it was not super fresh but the taste was spot on). Prices were a little high, yes, but the dessert was a big hit at dinner, and both grandparents remarked on how good the cannoli were. read more

Located in the heart of Historic Tarrytown, (yes, it is close to Sleepy Hollow-headless-horseman-Ichabod story, my dear Manhattanites), this unobtrosive bakery seems to have every conceivable pastry that my fickle taste buds have ever encountered (ah, now I know why I've gained 5 extra pounds. Curse you, buttery Italian cookies!!) Try the chocolate rugelach and Italian cookies. The cookies seem to dismantle and unite with your tongue. If rainbow had a flavor, I would point to the cookies - (talk about FRESH BAKED!!) I would go here for sweets every day but I would also have to run ten miles each day to balance my caloric books. If you are passing through town, stop by and grab a bag of cookies/pastries, say hello to the owner "Patsy" -- and take a brisk walk to Caravela for some cappuccino! read more

One of my top 3 favorite bakeries! With not always enough time to whip up a cake this is the spot to go Maria and her staff never disappoint! I've been getting their cakes for years and they are delicious! read more

I'm trying to give this place the benefit of the doubt. Mistakes happen. In the past, I've always been satisfied with the pastries and I prefer to support local business. However, I ordered a cake for my graduation party to be delivered, I checked in with the business the day BEFORE the delivery and was assured (with attitude) that it will be delivered, only to find that my cake never came. When I came the next day, I was refunded my money and given the cake (that I could no longer share with my guests), and the owner's daughter tried to blame the place that was hosting the party. Hopefully this mistake never happens again. But when mistakes do happen, own up, don't place blame, and ensure that it won't happen again. Simple. read more

The best St. Joseph sfingi I have had in years. Chock full of cannoli cream covered with flaky pastry. Even better than the ones I purchased on Arthur Avenue. Lovely staff! Another fabulous confection prepared by the geniuses at Pastry Chef. The Napoleon, precut, half sheet cake was such a hit that there were no leftovers. The cake was a perfect combination of flaky layers filled with filling and decorated beautifully. Definitely a "go to" for any special occasion! read more

Do you like cookies, cookies with perhaps some butter in them? Well you've come to the right place. Being a frequent connoisseur of Italian butter cookies I think I can safely say that the size and flavor variety here is top notch. They also had quite a selection of cookies and cakes that all looked tempting. FYI-the prices are a little steep (for some cookies anyway) and we found this to be true of most places in Tarrytown. read more

If you're looking for buttery cookies, this is the place to go. They have very fresh, tasty, buttery Italian cookies that are consistently good. They also have an excellent coffee/crumb cake with cheese inside that my grandmother loves. Their other pastries and cakes though, aren't as great, at least in my opinion. I bought a chocolate cake with white buttercream that tasted like it had pepper in it. The buttercream had a strange consistency and taste - it was neither sweet or fluffy. The small pastries are okay, but nothing spectacular. read more

My decaf cappuccino, ordered extra, extra hot arrived just as ordered and was delicious. The mini pastries (and Yule log that my husband had) were equally delicious. Their cheesecake is to die for. Am definitely considering ordering the black and white cake for an upcoming birthday. read more

Tarrytown Pastry Chef - One of the cookie displays in the bakery. - Bakeries Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Wow wow wow! If you want delicious fresh consistently amazing bakery products you must go to this one of the last fabulous privately owned bakeries around. They never fail or disappoint. Good old fashioned coffee cakes, specialty and occasion cakes and breads - all delicious. No processed products here! Just fresh ingredients and cakes and cookies baked fresh with love and care every day. I'm in love and so is everyone I've steered in their direction. Go!!! read more

Only had the carrot cake mini pastry. Very fresh, cream was light. Absolutely loved it .