Food: I only eat pizza from Iccara (Margherita Pizza)! Always made to perfection. Sauce and cheese ratio is spot on and the basil is fresh. Crust is delicious. Price is reasonable. Service: Not overly friendly but efficient. Ambiance: Small, family owned, whole in the wall type of vibe. read more

Iccara Pizzeria - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Coatesville, Pennsylvania

See all

New to area and always looking to try new places.Ordered a large pie and fries . Both were good . Pizza had a good crust with good sauce. Not to friendly .Coke refrigerator top had dust from 90's.Maybe they should clean it .Probably will not be back because of that being dirty and so easy to clean than I can imagine what else needs to be cleaned . read more

I was in the area on biz and stopped in to order a pizza. This is a small place designed for carry out as there are no tables for dining in. I decided on a Ricotta, Spinach & Cheese (add sausage) calzone-- it was yummy! The crust was chewy and the cheese was gooey! The marinara sauce that came with it was also tasty. If I lived in the area I would definitely make this one of my 'go to' pizza joints. read more

Great food, great prices! The best Italian hoagie and fresh salad. Location is fantastic too

Ordered 4 meatballs, no sauce. These were the blandest meatballs I have ever tried to eat!! Zero seasoning on them, literally no taste at all. Vastly overcharging $3 per meatball on what is essentially ground beef rolled into a ball! read more

Cheesesteak was blah no seasoning hardly any cheese. Hard pressed to try a pizza if a cheesesteak didn't pass the Chester County/philly burb test. read more

We ordered cheesesteaks, chicken tenders and pizzas, and everything was excellent. The delivery was quick and the cost was very reasonable.

Pizza and pasta are consistently well made. Their Cobb salad is the best I've had in the area- fresh grilled chicken, REAL bacon, avocado, hard boiled egg, blue cheese- SO YUMMY! read more

Amazing food food is good. Local great place . They are so friendly. The pizza is so good. We had chicken fingers they were good . It's perfect local spot . read more

See all

We have eaten here many times and have high praise for their salads and sandwiches. However, the pizza is nothing special and way too greasy for our taste. I know that pizza, especially, is very subjective but,like it or not, should be decided by yourself. read more

Great pizza great calzone great hoagies! Absolutely delicious! Next time I order for them I'm getting some cannolis and I'm going to get try one of their salads probably chicken Caesar! Their Google reviews are very accurate because every time I order for them everything is always perfect. I think they have some disgruntled ex employees or maybe their competition I don't know why they have a couple negative reviews because in my opinion it's completely inaccurate! read more

My family and I love Iccara's! The food is always fresh and the place seems to be very clean. We love that they are a family run business and seem to take pride in the food they make. read more

We tried their pizza a few times now and can honestly say it's one of our favorites. Even the cheese pizza has so much flavor that it tastes better than others we have tried. Tonight we got two of their entrees (chicken parm and baked ziti). Now I'm posting this review because they deserve to be recognized. The food is very delicious and the price is less than other competitors in our area. For the people that complained about the prices fluctuating, get one of their menus that are in the restaurant. I would highly recommend Iccara Pizzeria read more

Sadly we ordered a pizza from this place and they pretty much burnt the whole entire thing. Not quite sure how they didn't care that this is what they were serving. It's also a shame because we live not even two minutes down the street so that would've been years of business. read more

Iccara Pizzeria - Burnt - Pizza Near Me - Coatesville, Pennsylvania

See all

We recently moved to then area and ordered the grilled chicken Ceasar salad and pizzas and both were really good! It will be our go to locally owned pizza place. read more

Everything we have ordered has been consistently excellent. From the homemade soups to the fresh sandwich rolls and delicious cobb salad. Much thought and attention to detail in the menu. Highly recommend . More than just a pizza place. read more

Great pizza, great prices. You are making a mistake if you don't give this place a try

We've ordered from Iccara pizza many times since they've been opened -however, we think we are done ordering with them. Each time we order, the pizza is so inconsistent. There's no special taste, and it's very mediocre pizza. This weekend, we ordered a large pizza, and it was super small, not even enough for full size pieces (see photos - of the difference of the two large pizzas!). When we get it delivered, the cheese is never on the pizza and they are always 25+ minutes later then they say. We are always told 45 minutes, but very rarely does the pizza come before we reach an hour and 15 minutes after. The portion sizes for their hoagies and especially their salads are terrible for the price. A handful of lettuce and 4 croutons for $7+ - no thanks. They need to make some kind of quality standards. read more

Iccara Pizzeria - Large pizza? I think not... the slices were so tiny! - Pizza Near Me - Coatesville, Pennsylvania

See all

They suck!! They mess up a order and when you call they treat you like it's your fault. It's not that hard to make fries and Stromboli to order. Wake up and take care of your people!! They suck!!!!! read more

Saturday we had a party (sssshh) Anyway, I happen to like Iccara Pizza and my daughter inlaw said its not that good (just by reading some reviews) Anyway, I purchased two large PLAIN cheese pizzas from Iccara Pizza and she purchased all kinds of bacon, peperoni, chicken top pizza from dominoes pizza. EVERYONE PREFERRED MY PIZZA FROM ICCARO. They ate up ICCARO and we still had leftovers from dominoes on Tueday that we ended up throwing out. In fact they called it the good pizza. AAAAAAA++++++++ PIZZA I should have taken pictures of the Pizza but it was a party. The Pizza was baked perfect and LARGE read more

We had a pizza and cheese steak and a salad delivered and was extremely disappointed. Pizza was greasy, cheese steak was burnt and salad was a premade salad mix and the delivery driver was extremely rude. read more

We order their pizza 2 or 3 times a month and it is always delivered fast and it is very good. The only complaint that I have is that the pizza has a consistent quality 90% of the time. 10% it seems like it is from a different cook and not as good as normal. Besides chicken fingers, I have not tried their other stuff. read more

Oh my goodness I am so stoked this place opened! We lived in the are for about 2 years and been dying for a great pizza. We had to settle for Dominos because they were close and offered delivery. Every other pizza place around us has been disappointing so we gave up the search until Iccara came around. I believe the owners are husband and wife and have been amazing every time we order. We just get pizza from here and they have it perfect every every time. I even tried their rice pudding and cannoli and they were delicious. I'm not a huge fan of rice pudding but the fiancé is and we were both pleased. I've never gotten a burnt pizza from them or an under cooked pizza. The sauce isn't too sweet but not too bland. We order once a week, 2 large cheese pizza special with extra sauce on the side, since they opened. The one time they messed up, we ordered the pizzas and went to pick it up and they lost the order. We waited a little bit, not more than 10 minutes) and they made us 2 fresh pizzas on the spot. They are a lovely couple and love their pizzas. read more

I really like the pizza here, the cheese is exactly right. I am surprised that there are so many poor reviews. It looks like delivery might be a problem for some but we always just go pick up our orders. The husband and wife who run the place are very pleasant and are always working very hard when we are there. The previous owners had terrible food and rude service so I really appreciate these owners. read more

Growing up around the cheesesteak capitol of the world I aways like to try new places and considering this place is one mile from my home I was certainly eager to give it a try. Without getting involved in the never ending "Best Cheesesteak" debate I will say this place did not disappoint and will be my future go to for a good local cheesesteak. On one occasion while waiting for my order the owners saw me eyeballing the pizza and kindly offered me a free slice to try. It was exactly how I like it. Not greasy with a perfect crust that was slightly crusted on the bottom. Although Pete's Pizza Joint in Old City still remains my favorite...Iccara is in my opinion the best I have had outside of Philly. I am happy to have them in the neighborhood. I would give them 5 stars but it would be based only on the cheesesteaks and pizza. read more