My favorite ice cream shop in Edgartown! You should try the peanut butter pie ice cream! It's the best! Lots of flavors to choose from and a great addition is the candy section. read more

Fudge is the only decent option on the island outside of the farmer's market with Murdick's closed, but SO MUCH AI SIGNAGE. We did okay with 3 kids getting candy for under $20, but I hate seeing the AI everywhere. read more

cute place and good candy. my sister loved the swedish candy (and so did i). they give you a LOT of ice cream for what you pay for as compared to other places nearby. great service too! read more

Cute ice cream shop on the harbor. Lots of ice cream options in town but this one has the added benefit of being a candy shop. Lots of ice cream flavor options and a lovely view of the harbor from the back porch. read more

See all

Sweets Shop by the water in Edgartown [Martha's Vineyard MA] This is a cute little shop both inside and outside. It actually looks like a house with horizontal wooden siding (they call them clapboard houses). The backside has benches where you can sit and enjoy your ice cream with views of the waterfront. This is your one stop shop for your sweet tooth. Their 2023 season opened on May 5th. How fortunate that we were able to support! Their candy shelves are well stocked. They have candies of all sorts, truffles and chocolates, and, of course, ice cream! Coffee ice cream for the hubby and chocolate chip for me. So creamy and delicious with lots of chocolate chip flakes. Nom-nom-nom! Of course, when available, I always get milk chocolate peanut clusters. One of my favorite chocolate to munch on. Have a fantastic 2023 season! Review #3026 read more

See all

so expensive for a small. didn't even fill the small cone. ridiculous, go to any other ice cream place in the area.

Great ice cream and quick service. We recommend phantomberry and s'mores flavors. Place is quaint and the staff was really friendly. We also bought candy because they had pretzel m&ms which are really hard to find. read more

See all

This small place is HOPPIN. You want candy? Chocolate? The sucker you had as a child? This is your spot. And the cherry on top? All the ice cream flavors you could want. Not a ton of non-dairy options, but great spot to cool down. read more

It's odd that such an institution on MV only has 13 reviews! One of us has been coming here since she was a kid and this spot really is a family favorite. it's not as famous as Mad Martha's (which has gone DOWNHILL, esp. the Oak Bluffs location), but it is so sweet and charming in its own way. No frills, no fuss--just a lil ice cream institution by the water. We came here after dinner a few nights ago with some family and everyone enjoyed their sweet treat. Our daughter got cotton candy which looked too disgusting even to taste, but we loved the black raspberry oreo and the peanut butter caramel swirl we each got on cones. The ice cream was a *bit* too melty but the flavor is definitely there. They've also got old school candies and junky kind of stuff for the kids (like stick-on earrings that we got suckered into buying). Yes, it's a bit pricey, but at least the quality is there and the staff is friendly. Four happy stars and we'll be back again next year, like always. read more

my family loved this ice cream shop! they've got ice cream, candy, chocolate and plenty of souvenirs. we got the mint ice cream - it was delicious. there's a huge variety of flavors and toppings. portions are generous. only one con: cash only. service was efficient and servers were friendly. the shop is very small so it can sometime be hard to find where the line begins and ends. there's outdoor seating behind the shop with great views of chappaquiddick and the water. overall rating: 8/10 read more

See all

We came here for ice cream but was able to browse some of the candy offered. What a nostalgic adventure. Some of the candy are ones I haven't seen since my youth! Of course, the price was crazy high but hey, you're probably on vacation and can splurge a bit if you are on the Vineyard. As for the ice cream, I got a Waffle Cone with Moose tracks scoop and a Heath bar crunch frozen yogurt scoop. Absolutely delicious and super creamy ice cream. I'm usually not a fan of getting ice cream from a parlor since it is often priced up and you don't get too much bang for your buck. I will say, the price of 2 scoops was similar to other places where you'd otherwise get one scoop. The flavors I tried were excellent and the staff were friendly. It is so interesting how easily missed this shop can be because it just blends in so well with the rest of the buildings. Definitely a must try if you are feeling something sweet! read more

Ice cream is the way to go at Martha's Vineyard! The view outside was too great and worth the drops of melting ice cream. I got a SMALL: phantomberry ice cream (raspberry with chocolate chips and brownies) on a sugar cone! *** Locals If you are a Massachusetts local, you have so many choices around, but you have to get ice cream here. If you're from Martha's Vineyard, they have 32 flavors and lots of candy and trinkets, so even more options than others! *** Travelers This place is closest to the lighthouse beach that you see in Google Images when you look up Martha's Vineyard. They also have candy, chocolate and souvenirs as well! *** My Recommendation Definitely visit. There is nice seating everywhere, huge portions of ice cream. It is CASH ONLY, though, so be prepared. While I went on a cold and rainy May day, this place is THE place to go in the summer if you're here for the lighthouse. IG: @foodisseur read more

Yes just yes. Ice cream is perfectly creamy and sweet. Candy is delicious and they always have new candy! People are so kind and helpful. Location is easy and the inside feels like being in candy land! read more

Overpriced and terrible service! I should not be paying $5 for a minuscule "scoop" of ice cream!

We were recommended to check out this ice cream shop by one of our waiters at dinner. He said that the ice cream is just as delightful, and that you get to eat it without the hour long wait that Mad Martha's had. This being my first night on the vineyard, I decided to take some local advice, and choose the road less taken. The Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar is super small inside, but a precious little building. It makes me wonder what this building used to be back in the day...because it's located right on the docks. There are shelves of candy in jars, where your sugar loving friends can make mixed bags out of their favorite novelties. On the other side of the store are the ice cream servers. The store has about 20 different ice creams, and they are more than happy to let you taste them. I tried the peppermint stick, as well as the chocolate peanut butter. Both were delightful, but the first choice won. The serving size was average, which my waistline will appreciate, and the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. $4.50 for a small ice cream, about $5.00 for a large. The building is small, a bit crowded, and doesn't really have a system of who orders, but everyone is pleasant because they are getting their sweetie :) Enjoy, avoid the lines, eat drink and be merry! read more

Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

So so so goooooood They did a great job on the ice cream and it was so fast !!!!!!!!!!!!! I recommend this for ice cream and candy 1000000/10 read more

Loved their death by chocolate flavor! It was any chocolate lovers dreams. Brownie bits, chocolate chunks and chocolate drizzle (oh my!). And a plus, at least for me, was that they actually did kiddie sized scoops. Every place we went to would serve huge scoops for a small. So it was nice to have a smaller portion that was easier to finish. read more

Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar - Death by Chocolate flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

When you're fronting harborside seating in Edgartown, you don't necessarily have to scoop the best ice cream in town. That said, my double stacks of peach featured a healthy sampling of fruit, but a bit too much crystallization to warrant a return trip amidst a sea of options. Two scoops in sugar or cake cone nears $5 after tax. The swarms of kids raiding the candy half of this parlor, throwing bows and stomping toes? Absolutely free. Cash only. read more

I love coming here. Friendly staff as best selection of ice cream flavors in Edgartown. Phantomberry and Maine Black Bear are my favorites. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I love ice cream, and no flavor more than rum raisin. So when the shop owner suggested to me the frozen pudding, which sounded like some bizarre New England amalgamation of rum raisin and tutti-frutti, I was hesitant. I shouldn't have been--it was absolutely delicious. My fiancée had a black raspberry with chunks of brownie swirled into it that was just as good. Their chocolates looked amazing as well, but those will have to wait until a repeat visit. read more

Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Good ice cream but Ben and bills is much better. They are very friendly but there are better options.

The store was cute, and the staff was nice. However I paid 5$ for an ice cream cone and got the smallest cone I have ever received in my life. It was one bite at the most. Don't go here. Sorry read more

Great selection of candy, and the ice cream is really good! My favorite part is the chocolate, so many different kinds and they're all sooo good! read more

Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar - Ice Cream and Candy Bazaar sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

This might be unpopular opinion but this has the best ice cream on the Vineyard. After trying other more crowded places earlier in our visit, I can safely say the ice cream here was way better (not to mention cheaper). Definitely go here if you want great ice cream. read more

Even though I had already consumed a pint of ice cream that day, I caved. Moose tracks called my name! The fudge in that ice cream was divine! Also the candy there is pretty cheap all things considered. read more

I was a frequent customer until yesterday. I came to town from Katama specifically to pick up some ice cream and candy for my nephews that are visiting the island. I walked in to the shop and it was empty of customers and there were three youngish ladies behind the counter. I waited for them to notice me, two of the girls looked at me and kept talking. So I said excuse me, they kept talking. At this point I asked, "Is the store open or are you not serving anyone?" Still nothing. So I walked out. As I was walking out a lady was walking in. I said in passing, "They aren't serving anyone, or maybe it's just me" and what do you know, she walks out before I meet up with my friend with her purchase in hand. Another place that is rude and disrespectful to a year around resident. Yay! read more

Ice Cream Candy Bizarre is the best and a must for your Martha's Vineyard vacation! Ice cream counter has a great selection of flavors and the staff will let you taste test! My kids love to go in and get their baskets of penny candy and I love the selection of fine hand dipped chocolates. Yum! I also like the fact that I can sit on the porch and watch the boats go by! The staff is friendly and kid friendly! They have fun little gifts, toys and witty items! read more

Probably my favorite sea salt Carmel truffle ever and I'm extremely picky!! Don't miss this ice cream if you like Carmel!!

A staple of my childhood! This place is the best of the best. Penny candy, great location on the water, wide range of candy options. Prices cannot be beat. Will love it forever! read more

Fantastic customer service on an island where customer service is rarely top notch. We go there all the time. The crew is always patient and polite as our too young children make their selections. We take all of our friends to this overflowing shop. Everyone in the group will find something they love: fudge, ice cream, freshly made cookies, handmade waffle cones, and candy, candy, candy! For those opposed to sweets, the back corner is part toy store. You'll find Usborne Activity books, stuffies, and trinkets. read more