Isthmus Roofing

(2 reviews)

We very definitely recommend Hardtland! Tom Degenhardt (the owner) was highly recommended by a…read morefriend of ours who is in construction. Tom came over within a day of our calling, looked it all over and gave a written estimate within 24 hours. His crew were super and they were able to tear off and re-roof our house and garage, along with installing gutter guards and larger downspouts in two days flat. We were worried about our garden but they protected everything and barely bent a single flower stem. This is a great little company! Deborah B

We strongly recommend Hardtland. They replaced our roof. The job was well done and fairly priced…read more The work crew was efficient and courteous. The owner Tom, was easy to communicate with and impressed us as someone who takes pride in his work.

High Point Home Restoration

(11 reviews)

We had a minor cabinet issue with our kitchen cabinets. The owner reached out immediately and when…read moreI got back to him he not only found the time to come over to check out our request, but fix and repair the cabinet as requested. Birch Restoration will be at the top of my lists for small projects that I don't have time or expertise to do in the future!

We hired Kurt to finish our basement and are thrilled with the outcome! Throughout the project he…read morewas responsive, patient, and very thorough. He also repaired some baseboards in our living/dining areas that were damaged when another company replaced our floors. This job was finished quickly and with great attention to detail. Highly recommend working with Kurt for projects both large and small!

J & V Roofing

4.7

(13 reviews)

J & V did a great job installing new roofing on my balcony. I had new black membrane and then…read moredecorative tiles installed over the membrane. They also installed a new railing. Jose is great to work with.

We needEd new skylights and we were immediately impressed with Jose knowledge of our situation so…read morewith a bid within a few dollars of other bids we hire J&V! Wow they did a great job, cleaning up both inside and out and matching the roofing shingle! it was definitely a great move to hire J&V they did a professional job and are definitely pros we are glad we hired!

All-State Roofing

(1 review)

Joe from All-state roofing was awesome. One of our metal sidings had come off a roof beam and I…read moreasked them to come take a look and give an estimate. Joe stopped by when I wasn't at home and put the metal plate back and didn't charge me for it. Very professional and great customer service. Thanks Joe!

From the owner: All-State Roofing is a family-owned roofing company serving Madison, Verona, and Dane County for…read moreover 48 years. We focus on shingle roof repair and replacement (CertainTeed Landmark, Landmark Pro, Northgate). We also work on EPDM flat roofs, skylight repair, soffit and fascia, and storm damage restoration. As a CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster, we offer a 50-year non-prorated warranty on qualified full roof replacements. Trusted for expert craftsmanship, honest service, and lasting results.

Sun Vault Roofing

We got four bids on our roof replacement and Sun Vault Roofing was not the lowest. I almost went…read morewith someone else, but thankfully I did not. Our house has a complicated driveway and parking situation which their crew was able to work around seamlessly. Our HOA had its own approval layer on top of the city permit, and Sun Vault Roofing helped us navigate a two-week back-and-forth over approved shingle colors (side salad: ridiculous that HOAs have this kind of bureaucracy). Despite the complications, Sun Vault Roofing kept us updated through every delay and milestone without us having to chase anyone down. That alone was worth the price difference. The crew showed up on time, worked two full days, and left the yard cleaner than they found it. The roof has now been through 2-3 major storms since installation, including the crazy hail in April and there is not a speck of damage. Everything looks sharp and clean. You can tell was done right all the way from the street. If you're getting multiple bids for a roof replacement in the Madison area, make sure Sun Vault Roofing is one of them. Just don't let the price be the reason you go somewhere else, if they are not the lowest. The quality they provide is worth it.

I am very happy with the repairs. I would highly recommend this company. They are very…read moreprofessional and reasonably priced.

Metal Roofing Systems

4.3

Excellent rapport and quality of work. Good up front education about pros and cons, value and where…read moreto save money. Worked with us to find a tile type that would meet the neighborhood roofing requirements (historic neighborhood). Repeatedly checked in to make sure that we were satisfied with the progress and product. Happy with the final roof and gutter guards.

We had Metal Roofing Systems do our new beautiful metal roof. We couldn't be happier with the…read moreprocess from start to finish, the quality and attention to detail. Would highly recommend this company. We are so happy with our new roof!!

Rodriguez Quality Roofing

4.2

(10 reviews)

On time and quiet. Barely knew they were there…read more I have a 2-flat and back after the hailstorm of 2007, had a new roof replacement. The roofers then nailed through the shingles when replacing the jump porch. And slowly over the years a minor leak became a major issue. They did a great, clean job with the roof repair. And replace the jump porch ( 20 yr old) with a spanking new porch for the same cost I paid 20years ago. And did I mention quiet? I have a dog who was cool with their presence.

We had a minor roof leak and since this company was well-recommended on NextDoor, we decided to…read moregive them a try. They came out the SAME DAY that I called them! Our leak was fixed in minutes and they proactively fixed a second potential leak area, then took pictures to show us what had been done. The bill was very fair and, after two heavy rainstorms, no more leak! I was very satisfied with Rodriguez Quality Roofing and would definitely call them again.

Ridge Top Exteriors

2.9

(15 reviews)

Super offerings and salesperson. Lindsey listens well and we really like what Pella has to offer.read more

We undertook a large remodel project that included a new roof, windows, siding, and gutters than…read moreran from July-November. This two-star rating does not reflect the quality of work performed by the individual sub-contracted companies, which final product was satisfactory after timely repairs. The low rating is due to a significant lack of communication with Ridge Top, and unfinished work. Sub-contracted crews showed up on-site unannounced or changed their work schedule without notice from Ridge Top. We were informed we did not need to be home on days only outdoor projects would be completed, and yet crews were ringing the doorbell asking for instructions about installation that was not provided to them by Ridge Top (window orientation, down spout locations, etc). This interfered with work-from-home meetings. During siding work, the doorbell circuit was closed by poor nail placement causing it to run continuously. This resulted in both the door bell and transformer to become overheated and melt the bell chime cover inside the house. This was replaced by an electrician in a timely manner. Significant work-site debris was left in the yard, and Ridge Top's project managers shared our alarm at the final walk through. Together, we picked up roofing brackets, pail-full of nails we have collected with our own magnet, trimmed pieces of fascia/soffit/siding, and whole shingles. When we signed with Ridge Top we specifically asked, and were assured, that the new window trim would match the existing size, eliminating the need for additional significant drywall and paint repair. After 2 separate measurement appointments before installation, the finished trim installed on 13 windows was significantly smaller. We raised this concern during installation and at multiple walkthroughs, but it was repeatedly ignored. At the final walkthrough, Ridge Top acknowledged the extensive repairs required to both drywall and painting, and offered to provide compensation if we could get a quote from our own painter. Unfortunately, 2 weeks after the quote was shared with Ridge Top and multiple un-returned phone calls, they reversed this decision citing generic contract terms. This situation would not have been an issue had Ridge Top honored their initial assurance of minimal repairs or addressed the problem promptly. Instead, the lack of transparency and follow-through has resulted in unnecessary additional expenses and frustration.

Infinity Exteriors

3.9

(7 reviews)

I heard Infinity Exteriors on the radio and decided to give them a call for a roof inspection. I…read morewas very pleased that I was able to book an appointment for the exact day and time I wanted. Jon came out to my house and was great to work with. He was very knowledgeable about the different roofing products and recommended a terrific solution at a fair price. I really appreciated the walkthrough, especially when he went into my attic and discovered a leak that I wasn't aware of. I also had the opportunity to work with Ricky, who helped me on the day the project started. He called ahead of time, was very professional, and kept me informed throughout the process. The crew worked from sunrise to sunset and completed my entire roof in just one day. When I'm ready to replace my windows, I'll definitely be reaching out to Jon and Ricky again. They are friendly, professional, and truly local. Be careful of storm chasers. I had more than four roofing companies knock on my door after the storms. Ask where they live and work. Infinity Exteriors has a local office staffed by people who live and work in the community. That gave me confidence, and I will continue recommending them to my neighbors.

Nothing but trouble with this company. Ordered 9/9/2025. It is now 1/13/2025. Workers came 3 days…read morein Nov. They failed to install kick plate at back door, and failed to install master blocks around one electrical outlet and doorbell (so cannot use). Kick plate was later installed, but not master blocks, even though they have sent people out several times (and once told me it had been done--I was sick and unable to check). The worst thing is that the color is not as shown on the manufacturer's website ( Cedar Knolls, "Cactus"). It is grey, not green. It also does not match the mock-up Infinity sent me via email so I could see what it looked like on my house. They did not have a siding sample on their wall when I went to pay my deposit (they had lots of others). The house looks terrible. They have sent different people out to look at the color on at least 4 occasions. They say it doesn't matter what the color looks like on the website or mock-up, the one the put on is called 'Cactus'. Today they came out and then called to tell me they were going to put a Lien on the house if I didn't pay the balance--and the job is not even finished! My husband and I are both vets and disabled and in our 70s (one of their big selling points was they "love" veterans). They told me Norandex would take $500 off the balance, or put up some kind of contrasting color on part of the front of the house--I can't even imagine how awful that would look! All I want is the green shown on the website and in the mock-up. This was a very expensive project for us. $500 would not make up for ruining the exterior of our house. EDIT: As soon as this Yelp review posted, ai got a phone call from Infinity saying a man 2ould be out right away to installl the blocks on the back wall and the doorbell. He installed only the block on the back wall. I have posted labeled photos from the Norandex website, the mock-up, and the actual siding. As I said, zi asked to see a sample of the siding when I dropped off my deposit, but they said they did not have one We had gotten 5 estimates and I had looked at dozen of swatches. No one be expected to keep them all straight. As to seeing it in different conditions, over the course of their several visits they saw it in sun and shadow. As to Norandex's offer of the batten stuff, I was never shown an example of even what that is, but i only want horizontal siding, as I ordered. I am not opposed to paying for satisfactory work, but we have not reached that stage yet. I am just very sick of being jerked around by them. If they or Norandex came up with a reasonable offer, I would consider it. $500 off a major project is a joke. Our house has depreciated more than that due to the horrible siding color. At the very least, both companies misrepresented the colors they are selling. Most companies want to do right by their customers because it takes at least 3 new customers to make up for one lost one.

Affordable Handyman Services

4.7

(11 reviews)

Did an excellent job in repairing and staining my deck this past summer. Also performed repairs on…read moremy garage trim. Very thorough and reasonably priced! I highly recommend his services!

Very personable and good at explaining things. I appreciated his explanations of how thinks worked…read moreand found his work was reasonably priced.

Hannacks Home Services

(2 reviews)

I have an older home and all the complications and surprises that come with that. I am really happy…read morewith Nathan's work. I don't know the full scope of what handy people can do and I kept asking "Can you do that?" and he kept saying "Yes." He replaced garage windows, repaired rotten wood, framing, door installation, etc. He also painted my garage. I have a cat tree that my dad made. It had become unstable. That cat tree has tremendous sentimental value to me and he made it stable and solid again. I'm not sure every handyman is willing to that kind of small job and Nathan said "Yes." He made my cats happy. Nathan installed living room shades. I've never had shades be so straight. I like the quality of his work so much I'm having him come over to do more work and install cabinets for me in 4-6 weeks. While he is busy and does book out I found his wait times very reasonable. One day my front door unexpectedly stopped working. Would not budge. I could not get into or out of my home. My neighbor had to help me break in through a window to get in through the side door. The next day Nathan came over and fixed it. Very impressive.

Nathan did an excellent job installing metal railings on our front steps. He's very focused and…read moremeticulous and reasonably priced. I highly recommend him.

Wil&co Painting

4.9

I hired Wil and Company to paint my garage walls and ceiling. Wil and his crew did an excellent…read morejob. The paint was beginning to peel on the walls and ceiling. I added a couple extra requests to paint in the garage at the last minute and Wil was very gracious in accommodating my requests. The quality of their work was great and the pricing was very fair. When I'm ready to have painting done inside my home I know who to hire for that. Thank you Wil and Company.

Excellent quality of work for re-taping drywall and providing touch ups with paint and caulking in…read morea house. Very attentive to the requests made by owner regarding project expectations. Respectful of property with full cleanup. Productivity was excellent! Started job within a few days and completed ahead of schedule.

Craig's Painting and Home Improvements

Craig painted nearly our entire house (multiple colors) before we moved in. Great value, fast, and…read morereliable. I liked his work so much I asked him to paint the house we were selling too!

I got numerous bids to have our front guest bathroom repainted from dark red to a fresh light blue…read more Craig came in with the most reasonable price and knocked out the project in 2 days, 2 hours each day. He is honest, reliable, and great to work with. I have already shared his information with numerous friends and am working with him to start another home painting project. I highly recommend Craig, you will not be disappointed!

Floor Coverings International Madison

3.8

(11 reviews)

The representative refused to give any details related to hourly rate or pricing of material…read moreestimates before an in person visit. This wasted my time.

Got new carpeting installed. While setting up the instillation was told there would be a $40 or $50…read morecharge for furniture removal and replacement. I asked if I had the installation area empty could I save that charge. Was told yes. Had the entire installation area empty prior to the install and was still charged the furniture removal fee. Called to inquire and was told a check would be cut to me as reimbursement for the fed. Two weeks later and no reimbursement has been received. Sent company an email and received no response. I would not recommend using these guys. The amount may be minor but it's not right to pay for a service that was not utilized and to not get any response when inquiring about it. A tad dishonest!

Isthmus Roofing - roofing - Updated August 2026

People found Isthmus Roofing by searching for…

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Isthmus Roofing also viewed

Ace Exterior Solutions

I hired Ace Exterior Solutions to replace the rubber roof on our sunroom after the ice daming that…read moreeffected so many houses this last winter. Not only was Benji and his team great to work with they took the time to explain the process, answer my questions, and even keep me informed through out the process from scheduling to installation. Benji even helped me navigate the insurance process (since this was my first home owners claim) and explained next steps to make sure my insurance company was kept in the loop and on board with our solutions. They were quick, clean and very nice. When they found some construction mistakes under the old roof, Benji talked through my options, explained the costs (which was very minimal) and made sure I was comfortable with proceeding with the repair. After the roof was replaced it looked nicer and more finished than the original roof I had when I bought the house. Ace Exteriors took the time to install edging that completed the look and hid the hardware underneath. Extra bonus! Overall this team went above and beyond my expectations. I've had many contractors work on my house (large companies and small) and Ace Exteriors was one of the best experiences I've ever had. I feel good about the work that was completed, and the cost was very reasonable. Super happy to work with them again.

I have called Chad Ace for several jobs over the years & he is always responsive, honest & fair. A…read morelarge tree limb fell on my roof puncturing 2 holes a few days before closing and he came right away & took care of it. He makes a stressful situation less stressful! I just bought my fourth house in Monona (lots of trees) so I'm certain I'll be calling again in the future. My dad & my brother have used him too - highly recommend!!

Diaz Roofing Company

3.8

had my roof and garage done in one day with this great group of friendly and hardworking crew gave…read moreme a time line of when the project would start and they delivered on time very prompt used high-grade material we're very clean and left my home looking beautiful very pleased. Also very fair pricing!! I will be recommending these people anytime. A roof conversation comes up.!!

I called them to look at my roof (two story) last year after the storm and when they showed up he…read morehad no ladder and said he'd be back but never showed up again mistakenly I called them this year to do the same after a bad storm and told them this is a two story house you will need a ladder two days later a man called and asked if they were here last year it was then I realized yes I did call but you guys never came he said he didn't have a ladder then question me why I needed it looked at I told him because of the storm and finding shingles he proceeded to ask me if I new they were my shingles I finally said I'm not going to convince you to look at our roof if you dont want the job just say so and stop wasting my time he said I don't want the job He was outside our house parked while this conversation was going on my advice if you have a two story home do not call this company

J & V Roofing

4.7

(13 reviews)

J & V did a great job installing new roofing on my balcony. I had new black membrane and then…read moredecorative tiles installed over the membrane. They also installed a new railing. Jose is great to work with.

We needEd new skylights and we were immediately impressed with Jose knowledge of our situation so…read morewith a bid within a few dollars of other bids we hire J&V! Wow they did a great job, cleaning up both inside and out and matching the roofing shingle! it was definitely a great move to hire J&V they did a professional job and are definitely pros we are glad we hired!

Gethsemane Roofing

Julio and his team did a fantastic job on my roof and gutters. He was easy to work with, and his…read moreteam was thorough on my roof and especially with the cleanup afterwards! We have a dog so we were thrilled with how much time he took to ensure there was nothing left behind in the yard. We're really happy with how our roof turned out.

We could not be more pleased with the work Gethsemane Roofing did for us. Julio is knowledgeable…read moreand skilled, providing great value. His recommendations for improving air flow in our unusually low-pitched roof were brilliant.

Carl Cure Roofing

3.3

(7 reviews)

I wouldn't recommend Carl Cure Roofing. They did our roof 2 years ago from hail damage...great…read moreexperience. Contacted them after damage again this Spring...he came out quickly and provided an estimate but since then he's been completely unresponsive. I've called and left messages at both the office and his cell, as well as following up via text. It's been several weeks and no response. I've resorted to looking for a new company and starting over.

Contacted them on-line May 18th regarding inspection and was called promptly. I was promised they…read morewould come out and look at my roof.. This never happened. Ten days later I texted them and left a message and they didn't have the decency to answer. This should speak volumes about him.

The Concrete Company

4.5

(15 reviews)

Matt was great to work with. He was very responsive and kept me informed each step of the process…read more All the people involved were very friendly and professional. The driveway turned out beautiful.

As my dog and I walked the neighborhood around N. Sherman Ave., I see lots of driveways that I…read moreadmire. I saw the work that Matt and The Concrete Company provided for home owners and I knew if I should need a new driveway that this is the company I would contact first! The time came and I hired The Concrete Company to install a concrete driveway replacing my old asphalt driveway. I can honestly say that the work, the employees, and the efficiency and professionalism of this great company was above top notch! I can't remember when I met such a great crew and wonderful people to work with. This was above and beyond anything I could have hoped for! Each employee exemplified excellence in doing a really great job and answering any questions I had, I am extremely satisfied with the whole project. If you are searching for an excellent concrete company to work with please contact Matt and The Concrete Company as one of the first to receive an estimate from!! GREAT CONTRACTORS TO DO BUSINESS WITH!

Paramount Roofing and Siding

4.1

After the recent hail storms in Madison (April 2026) I had Mike come out to take a look. I managed…read moreto get an appointment just a few days out. Mike did a thorough inspection of the roof and siding. Though there was some minor damage his recommendation was nothing needed to be done. I will definitely call them again should we need roofing or siding services.

I can't recommend Paramount Roofing enough! From the initial consultation to the final cleanup,…read moretheir customer service was second to none--responsive, professional, and genuinely helpful throughout the entire process. We love our new roof!

Swita Metal Roofing