Perfect large and thin crust slice. Love it! The teens working there are very polite and professional.

My daughters and I were visiting from Charleston, SC and this was our first time trying Italian Pie. We ordered a large half cheese/half bacon and ham and my kids said it was the best pizza they ever had in their life. I thought it was great, but I will think about the garlic knots everyday until the day I come back. Those were the most amazing, fluffiest, perfect ratio of flavor, and hands down the best I've ever had. Whomever makes them deserves not only a raise, but a hug. Seriously. The young gentleman that brought out our food was so respectful and nice, he even let us all sample the gelato at the end and I wish I had gotten some. Cash, thank you for the recommendations and the upstanding service. We cannot wait to come back! read more

See all

I ordered a "THIN CRUST" BbQ pizza. It's supposed to have creamy bbq sauce , cheese, red onions, etc. Guess what?? Absolutely NO onions, almost no sauce, very sad situation. The owner's / manager's excuse is that they have 2000 orders for superbowl Sunday & there is nothing they can do!!! Manager yelled & angry too that I addressed my concern. Sadly I can never order from them again. Neighborthat recommended them will not order pizza from Italian pizza pie Buford ever again. Here's proof! read more

Great pizza and god prices. Where else can you get a non chain pizza and it taste good and the prices are also good. Nowhere!!

Was downtown and craving wings and saw this place and thought I would grab some wings to go to eat on my way to Atlanta. Neat little pizza place, easy to order, got me some hot wings and a Coke and hit the road. I didn't get any pictures, but these were fantastic.!!! They were nice and hot and hit the spot perfectly. Will come back to Buford to try this again when I get a chance, but really glad I stopped by.!! Highly recommend!! read more

When eating at a restaurant, food is not the only factor in determining its worth. Service, ownership, location, ambience, and quality all play a part in making a restaurant great. Being a regular here for over 3 years has given me dozens of stories and memories with my friends and family. Live music on tuesdays and the dinner rush on Fridays, its focus on local hiring and the owner, Ralph's, wonderful menu diversity. Having had everything on the menu I can safely say that Italian Pie never disappoints, whether it's pizza, wings, subs, tacos, or pasta. Employees like Moe are another reason for Italian Pies pleasant atmosphere. He's constantly running around tending to everyone's needs and putting a smile on for everyone who comes to enjoy. My personal favorites are their Margarita Pizza, stuffed shells, and chicken Parm Sub. They also have an amazing packaged tiramisu however it is a little overpriced, I always find myself coming back for more. Right in downtown and open late, Italian pie is a perfect example of an all around outstanding restaurant. It is a must try read more

See all

Italian Pie delivered to Elixir Brewing at no charge. I liked the pizza slice & it was affordable. The garlic rolls were the star according to my 8 year old son, who never met a pizza he did like. He devoured 2 rolls & only had 2 bites of the pizza. Then asked for another roll please. And delivery only took 10 minutes. Those slices are monsters. Less than $14 for all that. read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - 2 slices w/ pepperoni & sausage & garlic rolls - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Shrimp Fettuccine Alfredo With Side Caesar Salad! Amazing! The Shrimp Cooked To Perfection With Flavor That Comforts The Soul! Next Time I'll Take A Picture read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - Personal Pan Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

This authentic pizza and gelato restaurant is such a gem for the Buford community! Their pizza is great. It's not too heavy but still has a good amount of toppings in it. The crust is light and tasty, the sauce has the perfect amount of acidity, and they don't skimp on the cheese! The gelato they have is a mix of old school gelato flavors and some more updated ones too! Besides the food, everyone there is very nice and it feels like being in an old school Italian restaurant. This is the only place we'll be getting pizza from now on! read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

Amazing pizza every time and always great service. Love the location in a quaint historic town.

To go order... orders wings and fries. Missing dipping sauce. Ceaser chicken salad missing dressing. read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - Chicken ceaser salad - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Italian Pie... where do I even start? This place is a beacon of light in the Buford community, a second home to many. A wonderful place to gather and break bread with friends and family. The food is phenomenal, as is the customer service. Serene is the word I'd use. The weight of the world lifts off of your shoulders the moment you step inside, always greeted with a smile. It's truly perfect. read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - Gathering to break bread with friends :) - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

Used to really love this place. I suspect, due to inflation, they are struggling. All of a sudden it tastes off; probably changed to cheap ingredients. Tried to give them benefit of doubt but have been disappointed last 3 visits. Save your money and go to Italy's in Buford. I-85 and Hamilton Mill. You're Welcome read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - Cheese pizza undercooked and dripping with cheap cheese grease - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

So I went and got Italian pie on Main Street In buford yesterday was pissed because my pizza was burnt.. not only was the person who took my call rude but when I went today to get a replacement the man who is probably the owner came out .. I put the burnt pizza on there counter he gave me the new pizza .. I told him look at it, that piece of shit told me " I don't need you to lecture me on how to make pizza I been doing it for 40 years, now go home and eat ur pizza.. no apology nothing he just did not give a shit but this is ok because that 60$ I spend 3-4 times a month will not ge going th them ever again this is what I got @Italian pie in Buford read more

Door dash delivery isn't great. The driver stopped along their way.So the pizza was cold when it got here. Also, the way we ordered our pizza is not the way that it came.And it says that because it is through door dash, we can't do anything about it. I was charged in full for 2 toppings but only received them on half. read more

This place just opened. The five stars is for the pizza, service, and cleanliness. The Chicken Parmigiana and Salad are just okay. On the Garlic Bread, they took the garlic off for me (or never added it), but they didn't have any regular butter, which was odd. However... The pizza is Top 2 out of about 12 I have had in this area. If you're looking for excellent pizza, go here! read more

See all

Best pizza around, today, we tried the calzones, and they were just as delicious. Huge selection of wines and on Tuesdays. They have live music and a beautiful selection of gelato. read more

See all

Food is great. The pizza is delicious. The pasta and subs are huge and the rolls are exactly what you hope for. Great family spot. read more

Delicious food with large servings and a nice atmosphere. I highly recommend. Cheese Pizza was crispy and delicious, salads were extremely fresh and the garlic knots were AMAZING!!! read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

I drive a long way just to eat their food! Even though I get full fast when you want what you want and crave it!!!! I will drive 1 hour to get it! I love the atmosphere. I love where it's located. I really really enjoy being there and it's perfect for a little quiet hidden date night. Food is absolutely amazing. read more

See all

I've been going here a few years. Great food. Last week I ordered $90 worth of food for delivery. When it was received, only received 7 wings instead of 10 and they were super tiny and thrown into a to go box with bbq sauce thrown on them sloppy. Very unappealing. The two large pizzas were oily and cold I called and spoke to manager Brian who rudely stated he was not giving credit or remaking anything. It was my problem with uber eats. They didn't prepare the food you did!!! I won't go back they lost a customer read more

Great pizza at a very reasonable price. This is my second time here and you can't be the se humongous slices of pizza and a drink for $8.49.....Sweeeeeet! read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - One slice of pepperoni and mushroom for lunch special - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Best pizza I've had in this area. Reminded me of Mamma Mia in NJ circa 2000s (when I lived there) The garlic knots are worth trying. It is garlicky- but that's how I like my bread. You have the option of ordering these flaky delights without the garlic (I've heard). They remind me of brioche to be honest. The spaghetti with meatballs were great too. The sauces on both the pizza and spaghetti are just on point - which is what defines a good Italian restaurants for me. The pizza was simply amazing, and what I want to have on my next visit. We came in the middle of the day on the Saturday and received excellent service. Make room for tiramisu and gelato. I particularly liked the pistachio. Come hungry; I regret that I didn't. I will bring a healthy appetite when I come back. read more

See all

A nice little hole in the wall that makes you feel out of Georgia! As someone who moved from the north as most people have in the past year it was hard for me to find a good pizza pie. Not only does this place make me feel like I'm in New York or New Jersey but it has the service like them as well! Great spot for good food. Not just pizza but pasta, lasagna, wings, and subs. If you're from the north I would bring you here. Great great spot. read more

See all

Everyone who works at Italian Pie is super nice, and they always remember you when you come in to eat or pickup. Their pizza is as close to New York in the area. One of the only places that my Brooklyn born husband will eat. read more

The wings were delivered to the table in a bowl of soup. The wings tasted awful, the only way I could eat them was to take a paper towel and wipe off all the souce. My boyfriend said he has had better supermarket frozen pizza. The dough was flavorless and the sauce was just tomato puree. No other flavor. Now we both feel awful after eating there. read more

First of all, we had a great experience both times we ordered pizza from here through DoorDash. The pizza was really good.. That's the only reason for the second star. Our attempt to dine in the restaurant tonight, however, was weird and awkward. It was the least welcoming experience I think I've ever had in a restaurant. The two young boys behind the desk just stared at us when we walked in and didn't greet us or offer to seat us. This was our first time in, so we weren't sure if we were supposed to seat ourselves or wait to be seated. They kept making eye contact with us, then whispering to each other behind their hands. Super weird. At one point, one of them delivered something to a table less than two feet from us and still didn't acknowledge my family standing there. After a few minutes of being stared at, we left and went to Mellow Mushroom. I really want to support local business, but that will be our last time supporting this particular one. read more

A family owned restaurant run by a lovely family. Great tasting food, excellent service and chill ambience. A great friend introduced me to this gem and I will definitely return very soon! read more

Can't find any other pizza place in the area that sells pizza by the slice and quick! I work down the road and have little time for break, this place is great read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - the outside of a restaurant - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Best Italian food in Buford! Ralphael does an excellent job. I love Buford restaurants!

Wow! This is about as authentic NY style pizza as you can get! Perfect chew and sauce. We'll be back for more. Very nice ambiance too!

They may be great, but if you order on Grubhub (where they feature prominently), they will not fulfill your order and you will be left high and dry, read more

I LOVED the shrimp fettuccini I ordered, along with the garlic knots, OMG!, sooo delicious. I will be eating here often! Go get some good grub! read more

Terrible experience! Called in an order at 6pm for a medium pizza and 2 calzones, and was told it will be ready in 25 minutes. I got to the restaurant at 6:50pm and told it would be ready in 10 minutes. Waited until 715pm and walked out with a refund and a hungry family. Will not be returning here. read more

Gelato is Great!, the pizza is good a little greasy all the other dishes are good including the wings. Been there a few times now. Will be going back. read more

We stopped in because we were in the area for senior portraits. It was a super hot day and they had gelato. We had a couple beers and gelatos and the smell was unreal. We decided to come back two days later to try the food. It is simply delicious. The calzones were huge and stuffed, the crust was well seasoned and just a tad crispy. The slice of pizza we ordered for our daughter was huge and delicious. This is a 13/10 I would recommend it time and again.best pizza experience to date in Georgia. read more

Pizza and meatballs were good! It's hard finding a tasty pizzeria once you pass the Buford exit. For the location and the price, it's worth trying! I would order to go food from here again! read more

I'm shocked to see the contrast between what other customers are saying they got vs what i received. The food was awful. The sauce tasted like it had some kind of chemical in it while the pizza was burnt. Couldn't eat it. Just awful. read more

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings - Burnt calzone and pizza. What kind of cook, expeditor, or manager would look at this and send it to a customer? - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Best New York style Pizza in Buford. Reminds .e of the Brooklyn Pizza I was raised on.

Closest to a legitimate New York Pie without being in New York. Italian Pie is the one of the best pizza places outside of New York and New Jersey. They have a great crust, nice taste and leave me wanting to come back. I would recommend getting the prosciutto and arugula pie or the calamine if you go there. It's worth the trip read more