I finally found a good pie in the area. Please eat it in or pick it up. The delivery service is TERRIBLE!

My weekly pizza spot! Both locations in this area are great and consistent. Owners are really from New York, which is a plus!

Abbondanza! This place serves authentic NY pizza. Must visit if you are in The Suwanee area. read more

See all

Found this place looking for nearby pizza restaurants while at a Lowe's. Never heard of it but it was close by and decided to give it a try. Quite possibly some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. It was fantastic! The ambiance was a typical pizza parlor, but oh the pizza! I would give Grandma's Pizza Suwanee 10 stars if I could. Give it a try. You won't regret it. I just had 2 slices of plain pie, but it so good. Definitely going back first chance I get! read more

Pizza was like cardboard and the chicken roll was beyond dry. Very disappointing, won't be back

I ordered online, 3 large pizzas for a work lunch. All 3 pies were well constructed and had great toppings. The white pizza was delicious. Crust has a slight sweetness and a great crisp to it. Service was fast and friendly. Great place in a busy location. read more

Great pizza for a reasonable Price. I come here for my lunch and never had a problem with the food. Honestly best pizza around.

The real deal! From the slice to the pie this pizza is authentic New York style pizza so happy to find this spot.

Chicken Cesar Salad pizza is amazing! Best when fresh of course. They have very good spaghetti and the spinach and feta pinwheels are a treat. read more

Garlic knots taste fresh and sauce is delicious. They were devoured in minutes by my grandchildren. The pizza crust is crispy and delicious! Calzone loaded with cheese, good choice and great food made Brooklyn style!! Mangia!! read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - Sausage and Margherita Slice - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

See all

Great thin crust pizza. Very clean and carry out was ready right on time The sauce is fresh and prefect balance to the toppings. read more

I order takeout from here fairly regularly. I ordered a baked pasta dish that was supposed to include meat in the sauce & there's no meat to be found. I'm a girl who needs her protein & meat & was starving by the time I got my order. Probably will be again later due to lack of meat in my pasta. Also, was supposed to come with garlic bread, which it didn't. They tend to be very inconsistent with that. Sometimes they include it & sometimes they don't. I just think the menu should be accurate (or the food to the menu) & they should be more consistent overall. read more

Amazing service and Super friendly staff. This is are go to pie shop. Real authentic NY style pizza. Always ask for well done!!!

Food was not of the quality and taste expected. Items are pricey as well. Overall not worth it.

Amazing place! Family owned and run. The pizza was delicious and the pinwheels were also really good. During quarantine, they're offering more delivery's up to 5 miles radius. Give this place a try. Support your locals read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

See all

Finally found a pizza place that taste close to NY pizza. I really enjoyed the pizza but then I think the salad we got was bad because me and my husband started getting stomachaches and it's been about 4 hours already and still have an upset stomach. Stick to the pizza and don't get the salad! read more

Went for the location in Horizon Village on 5/16, hankering for a hot sausage and pepper hero. First, I found solidly positive reviews on Yelp by others regarding this sandwich (as well as others), used the on-line ordering system which was easy, and it even gave me an exact ready time for pick-up (and it turned out to be ready @ 5:58 exactly as predicted!). When I got home I found the sandwich was one of the best examples of a sausage and pepper hero I've ever had, and it also had fries included to boot! read more

Now that was some really good pizza. About eight of us decided to grab dinner here before heading to the movies. Grandma's actually had a table set up for us before we arrived. There seemed to be only one woman holding down the fort, but she managed to maintain the entire floor in good style. Including the handling of a steady stream of folks picking up to-go orders. And whomever was in the kitchen was doing their job with alacrity. The pizza itself was fantastically good. We had a pizza with mushrooms, olives, and meatballs. The meatballs were a winner. Spiced to perfection and sliced across the pizza--the whole thing just came together in all the right ways. And the crust was just right--not overdone and not chewy. The pizza came out hot and fast, with melty cheese that was stretching over a meter to the plate. Delicious. We won't hesitate to return. Holler if you're coming with. read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - Pizza with mushrooms, black olives, sliced meatballs. - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

Went to get a couple slices and it seems like they always have the same cheese slices no matter what time you go. I think they want you to always buy a whole pie. I asked what time do you close, he stated he stops taking orders at 8:30. I asked again what time you close and he stated "whenever I want to". I asked because I was going to come back after my movie was over, but with that attitude I wasn't motivated to buy anything or return. read more

Fantastic grandma pie! I got there as they opened and got the experience of seeing them put out fresh pies for slices but I opted for an entire grandma pie! It didn't disappoint, atmosphere and pizza screamed a NY Style joint. read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

See all

Food is great, service is horrible. I got one simple order of zepolies The guys kept saying 5 minutes but 30 minutes went by and nothing. I think they forgot to even do it even though I checked in twice asking for an update smh read more

It's a small place that's better suited to take out. What I had tasted fine but one thing I had a bit of issue with is that they don't bring your order to the table you're at. They make you go back to the counter to get your stuff, so why am I expected to leave a tip. A tip is for service, not the cooking of food. That's what salary is for. I doubt I'll go back since I don't live around there and just happened to be in the area. read more

ITS DEFINITELY WORTH IT THE HOMEMADE SAUCE IS TO DIE FOR.......... We love this place we were in Atlanta back in December and January on business my son being a pizza connoisseur by right suggested we go well needless to say we had pizza for lunch and dinner for the rest of the trip I had to return late January so I brought one back to Louisville Kentucky as a surprise ( ya know dad points) he was so happy..... so when we were heading to Lady Lake Florida we stopped in Atlanta for a pizza it's the owners Grandma's recipe from Sicily and it's only at this particular location 2855 Lawrenceville -Suwannee road it's the only place we will get pizza from when we're in Atlanta ‍ read more

This is a small shop within the Tavern plaza and it's my go to place whenever I crave New York style pizza. Their margherita pizza is somewhat of a reverse and has more cheese than sauce. Service is quick and hasty. read more

Very tasty pizza, fresh and yummy! Taste better than many brand name pizza! The supreme is my favorite! read more

Absolutely amazing! A nice cozy spot for date nights or to hang out with friends! There's also a nice bar and TVs to watch sports. Being greeted with a warm smile and welcome-in when you enter a restaurant usher's you to your seat. Great service and great food keeps customer's coming back for more! The staff at Grandma's NY Pizza is attentive, friendly and just all-around awesome! Grandma's NY Pizza catered my friends 60th birthday party July 8, 2023. Wendy and her staff were AMAZING! The large pans of food were individually boxed, labeled, and loaded into my SUV. Did I mention that they we waiting for me to pull up to the door? We had so much food! Here's our order: Fettuccini Alfredo, Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Parmigiana, meatballs, sautéed mixed vegetable, steamed broccolI, plain pasta, garlic knots, and salad. The meatballs were unbelievably tender! Everyone at the party thoroughly enjoyed the selection of entrees. The food was phenomenal!!! So good in fact, we ordered meatball subs last night! On behalf of the birthday girl and all of her friends, Thank you Wendy and staff at Grandma's NY Pizza, 2855 Lawrenceville-Suwanee Rd., Suwanee, GA 30024, (678) 765-8886. We'll see you soon! Have Grandma's NY Pizza cater your next event! Yelp, my lower-case "I" keeps being replaced with a capital "I", as you can see. read more

The food was good. Service and staff were mediocre. I try to rate places mostly on quality and taste of food as I know service can have off days. However, the staff could work on their interaction with customers and be more pleasant. read more

Not a bad pie! I placed a pick up order for a large cheese pizza, baked ziti (on another Yelpers reco) and some side salads. Paid $41. All the food arrived home kind of hot. I ended up nuking my ziti for a minute. The food was tasty. The pizza does remind me of the NY taste. The salads were pretty big, probably one salad was enough for two. I would say the pizza was the best part of the meal. A large pizza is about $16.00 here so would go occasionally to get pies. Still hard to beat Cooleys at $8.99 for a large pizza. read more

I LOVE PIZZA!!!!! (Thincrust) I'm cheating for lunch. My breakfast was a green smoothie so now I want PIZZA. I walked in and was told by John that I could sit anywhere I liked. Waiting on my eating partner to find a parking spot. I already knew what I wanted so I went for the 2slice special and drink. Eating partner(Hubby) had a taste for the chicken marsala. We also had GRANDMA'S salad and 2 pinwheels spinach& broccoli and pepperoni. During this time another waitress was getting off I believe, cause Poor JOHN was running around making figure 8s trying to keep up with orders and drink refills!! He forgot our straws, 2Times and it took 15min before he came back to tell us that the drink we ordered was out so we opted for sprite/coke. The pizza was GR8!! The chicken Marsala was missing something but it was still edible. The pinwheels were also good. I will definitely come back for a slice or a whole pie of Grandma's piping hot pizza! Had it been better service they would have a extra star. read more

See all

Grandma 's is close by and food always on point always fresh quality food fast when kids are hungry and I don't have time to cook

This place is fantastic! We ordered delivery through Uber eats and the food was still decently hot when it got here. We had a small chicken Caesar pizza and some Buffalo wings. The pizza was incredible and the wings were pretty good too. read more

WE used to get grandma pies probably two times a month. The whole family enjoyed it which is hard to do. Last couple of times the pizza was droopy not floppy. Not sure if I'm the only one with the problem but unless they fix this problem I will not be going back. It is too bad because this was our favorite place. read more

The cashier was hella rude by slamming a stack of pizza boxes in front of my face and next to my ear. It was very loud and abrupt. He did it twice. He didn't even say excuse me and didn't apologize. They didn't have any pepperoni slices ready and didn't offer to make anymore. The whole vibe in this place was awful. read more

Wow great pizza! Just right thin crust, fresh ingredients. 1000 times better than your chain pizza place. The real deal!!

Sometimes everything in Atlanta looks the same to me, esp. in this part of town, like some repeating background in a TV driving scene: homes, gas station, mini-mall, park, repeat. Looks can be deceiving. Even though I walked up to a passionless strip mall storefront, when I walked thru the door I was transported back to every pizza place in NY. Not what I saw, rather what I smelled. The delightful simple smell of that pizza oven and I was back in every beloved pizza place from New Haven to New Jersey. While not a completely authentic experience (they say it's due to the water) the pizza from Grandma's was as close as you can get to the real thing. By the pie or by the slice (even Sicilian) enjoy! If you are a NY Ex-pat, I highly recommend this place. read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - By the slice at the counter - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

Just ehh. Ordered a main item that they apparently ran out out of which seems crazy since the place was empty. Ordered a "crispy" pizza and as you can tell from the picture it was definitely NOT! To say this is New York pizza is kind of a crime. We're from the northeast and this would qualify as dollar slice stuff. I'm sure long time locals that don't know the difference find it adequate. Can't imagine we'll be back unless desperate. Just boring and typical to the south. read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

NY style pizza, with some twists. Available by slices. Today I had a plain slice and a square slice (in ny, we called it sicilian). Both very ny taste. Last week, I had I white pizza and a tomato flavored. Both with real mozzarella slices. That's the twist, I was referring to. Both of these were as good as I have I had outside of ny and Italy. Nice service. Very friendly Great lunch special on weekdays. Two slices and fet free fountain drink. read more

Good flavors, soggy and soupy pizza (got the veggie). Not super friendly for a place called "grandma's." Expected better.

One of the closest to authentic NY-style pizza I've had since moving to Atlanta area! The staff is incredibly nice and helpful also!

I am hoping to revisit this review after the restaurant has a chance to redeem themselves. We have been on an 8 month hunt for good delivery Pizza in The Lawrenceville area. We still haven't found it. For a pizza and salad the cost was $35! And the worst part was that our pizza came without sauce on it. The salad was meh-ok. Nothing exciting. Louie said he'd take care of us next time, we'll see how it goes. read more

Grandma's N.Y. Pizza Suwanee - Pizza with no sauce. We bought 2 toppings and only got 1. Pretty disappointed and felt overcharged - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia