One of my favorite and one of the best pizza and sub restaurants, not just in Wilson, but all over. The food here is fantastic! The NY slice is large, with a fresh and crispy crust and great tasting sauce and cheese. No toppings are needed to enjoy a slice or two. My personal favorite though is the Sicilian pizza. This pizza is thick, cheesy and with a great tasting & crispy outer crust. My go-to topping is pepperoni & I've never had a bad slice. If you aren't wanting pizza, do yourself a favor & get The steak & cheese special. It's a steak hoagie, with cheese, onion, mushroom & green pepper. It's no lie when I tell you, it is the best tasting hoagie I've ever had. Loaded with steak, melted cheese & sautéed onions, mushrooms & green peppers, the flavors are phenomenal, you can't go wrong with this one. Finally, the owner is kind, hardworking & very generous. He's always there, greeting myself & family with a smile & providing us & the rest of Wilson with some of the best pizza, subs & food you'll find on the east coast. read more

Italian Pizza & Subs - The Sicilian pizza. Hot, fresh & delicious. - Italian Near Me - Wilson, North Carolina

The folks here are not the friendliest, but I'm not here to make friends. We are new to the area and we've been there three times so we could get a good profile of their three major categories of offerings: pizza, subs, and pasta. For pizza, we tried one with red onions and olives, and a sausage pizza - excellent pizza, fantastic prices. Subs were inexpensive and delicious. Now to the sad part: pasta dishes. We had lasagna and manicotti, and neither of us were happy with our meal. There was a ridiculous amount of cheese and little flavor to the rest of the dish. The sauce was meh. I was raised on east coast Italian food (NY/NJ) and had Italian grandparents. Something is definitely missing with their pasta game. It is affordable and likely good enough for the neighborhood, but their pasta dishes disappointed. We will be back for sandwiches and pizza. They have a large dining room and a robust takeout business. Their prices do not break the bank. There were several large tables with happy families chowing down. Dudes at the counter: pretend like you want us here. Mumbling and rolling your eyes at customers is not welcoming. You should smile more! You'll wait a long time if you don't call and order ahead, so don't be dumb like us. read more

This used to be our go to for pizza and hot sandwiches. Our last 2 orders have been incorrect and had no flavor. The guy taking orders and running the register needs better customer service skills. Taking our business elsewhere. read more

By far the best pizza in Wilson. Great local establishment. Might be busy at times, but it's worth the wait.

Food was hot and fulfilling. The owner was pleasant and welcoming. I would come back and try the pizza.

The food is always hot and I feel like I get my moneys worth. Staff is always nice and greats you when you walk through the door.

Customer Service is horrible. I called to place a order and got the rudest response asking simply how much a certain dish would feed a certain amount of people. To be told to "hurry up and order" or even being told that "I don't know how much people eat" was very unnecessary. I will never put my money or time into this business again. If you want to be talked down to as a customer be my guest, if not STAY AWAY. read more

We wandered in here after seeing good reviews. Thought they had table service but realized you order at the counter type place. I was a bit surprised that the food wasn't served hot, even after waiting awhile for it to come out. Tasted the pizza and while it tasted ok, would've been much better if served hot rather than luke warm. The eggplant was mushy with an over abundance amount of cheese making for very messy eats. If this is the best of Wilson, I must've hit it on an off day, or they sorely are in need of better. read more

Italian Pizza & Subs - Decor - Italian Near Me - Wilson, North Carolina

See all

Pizza is great! But.. the roast beef sub wasn't at all what I expected. I thought they'd put the beef and cheese on the grill or something. It was instead microwaved and the beef then had a weird texture/taste and the cheese wasn't even melted cause they wrapped the beef in it. Bread was hard/crispy read more

Great food at a great price! Friendly staff and quick service. Reminds me of the old style pizzerias from childhood.

We love Italian Pizza and Subs. They have become like family and we dine there every week. Affordable food that tastes delicious!!

Great food and service Try the chicken Stromboli and chicken wings. They also have turkey pepperoni! read more

Amazing food and service! The NY slice (my personal favorite) came out and was massive, as you can see from the paper plate comparison. Perfectly thin with light sauce, lots of cheese and quality pepperoni. The crust was airy and crisp, perfection. I would highly recommend coming here for a good dinner! The owner is so kind and even gave us these delicious powdered sugar covered delicacies. I honestly don't know what they were called, but we couldn't get enough of them! read more

Italian Pizza & Subs - NY Slice pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilson, North Carolina

The pizza & subs are so good and the service here is always good too! Lots of great options on the menu!

This is hands down the best New York style pizza I've found in NC. The crust is chewy but crunchy on the bottom, sauce has flavor without being overpowering, cheese is plentiful and melted perfectly, and the toppings are fresh. Yum! read more

My claims that it tastes like real New York pizza! ... and not just a marketing buzz word.

I live near this place so I go every now and again. I've always found the food to be okay, not great but certainly not bad. My low rating is primarily because the service is so bad. The other day I called to order a sub for takeout. Knowing that it sometimes takes a while for an order to be ready I asked how long it would be. The owner seemed annoyed and said "25, 30, maybe 40 minutes". To make a meatball sub. I showed up after 40 minutes and quickly paid. I then watched them make my sub, put it in the oven, and then finally I got it 50 minutes after I ordered. I won't go back again. read more

food and service always great. usually get pizza or pasta. the servings are large and well priced

Classic West Wilson staple I've been eating here on and off since the store opened and regardless of how many years or months stand in between my visits, the food quality never wanes. The stromboli and chicken parm are THE BOMB! While the service is a little "eating at somebody's house so help yourself" -- the food and taste make up for the less than stellar atmosphere. Authentic flavor is DEFINITELY here! read more

Got a italian sub and it only had ham on it filled to the top with onions lettuce and tomato. Couldn't even eat it. The pizza was not good either. Stay away. read more

I love everything about this place, the food and feel of this place is great! Highly recommended if you love NY style pizza and large subs.

I love their pizza, subs, marinara, and the spaghetti with meatballs. They have great food for reasonable prices, and the owner is very nice. We eat there quite a bit, I have never been disappointed. I would definitely recommend them. read more

Food is great! Service not so much. They need to update their antiquated to-go order system and quit messing up orders! Take the phone away from the owner would be a start! read more

First time at this restaurant and actually decided upon them as a result of Yelp reviews and glad I did. I highly recommend this location and will definitely patronize it again when in town! I am into town to celebrate mama's birthday - ordered pizzas & wings and everyone absolutely loved the food. The pizza was piping hot, very tasty, the wings were amazing. The pizza wasn't like the bigger chains soaked in tomato sauce but made like authenticate pizza should be. The atmosphere inside was spacious and located in a desirable location. And most importantly it was clean! The staff was friendly as well - one of the staff graciously took my boxes of pizza to the vehicle for me :) Thank you Italian Pizza & Subs for helping to make my event a perfect evening!!! read more

This is my favorite pizza place in Wilson NC. The food here is amazing and they serve big portions also. Pizza is like NY and if you never had NY pizza and live in NC you must come here for a pie. Food is very good I love the chicken parm dish with pasta. This is a place you must go . try the pizza and food, they have a menu with all your italian dishes and the staff is so polite , this will be your new spot to go and eat. Stop by for a pie and eat inside while watching a race or a game.i am from Brooklyn NY ans when your from Brooklyn you want good pizza and Italian sauce to be 100% and this place says it all. Best pizza in town and in NC. NY loves this place. read more

The best pizza in town. The subs are delicious, especially the steak and cheese. The salads are always fresh and huge. The wings are great. Very fair pricing. The owner is extremely friendly. I come here every time I'm in town. read more

Pizza is delicious. Cheesesteaks were delicious. Unfortunately I had a bad experience with their wings, they were rotten-expires or soemthing. We told the staff but nothing was done..kind of just like ok. But not rude. read more

This is my favorite pizzeria in eastern NC. Great pizza, sandwiches, wings, everything. My wife and I love getting their stromboli, wings, and fried mushrooms. This is a true New York style pizzeria with a great staff. Enjoy. read more

If your looking for a good cheese steak that tastes close to a real Philly Cheese Steak then this is the place. I'm from Philly and this place is close to home. read more

Whoever answers the phone is a nasty person. My brother called and asked was this the location on 301 and the guy hung up. Sir we will never eat from your restaurant ever again. Your food is nasty that's why we don't deal with you or your restaurant at all. You should learn some customer service skills. read more

This is a fun place to go! It is delicious reasonable priced food, with friendly people! There is an interesting mix of people in this restaurant each time I go. Recently, there was a table of 25 or more ladies that meet there once a month, and having the time of their life. The sandwiches, calzones, and pizza are made right out in front of you and are delicious every time, at a very reasonable price. I meet a girlfriend there once a week to catch up with each other. I enjoy going to a place that remembers me, and takes great care of me while I am there. Thank you, Italian Pizza and Subs. Patty Holt read more

Best pizza place in Wilson by far. Good customer service but excellent pizza. I recommend the Italian special (pepperoni, onions, green peppers, sausage and mushrooms). The stuffed pizza is good also; best way I can describe this one is like a New York adaptation of Chicago style pizza. This is the best pizza I've had since New York. read more

This is an excellent pizza place to go to in Wilson. I can't attest to it being the best because it is the only one that I have tried. But the good news, I have had it like 4x and it is spectacular every time. The wings are great too.. read more

Good NY style pizza that tasted just as good reheated the next day.

Best pizza in Wilson, NC! I am a true New Yorker so I can say that this taste as good as pizza in NY! It boggles my mind that people down here eat Pizza Inn and Pizza Hut when this pizza place is right down the road. Excellent pizza and I highly recommend it!!!!! read more

ALWAYS Good! Good people that work there also, never a long wait. Stromboli's, pizza's and subs are great. Steak and cheese Stromboli is where it's at! read more

This place is awesome. Stopped in while driving back from Florida. I visit Manhattan often and this is as close to NY flavor as you can get in Southern US. Truly great pizza, fresh sauce, and towner is always around. Staff is nice too, kind and helpful. read more

Italian Pizza & Subs - Italian Near Me - Wilson, North Carolina

This is the best pizza! They also have great subs and plates. The service is phenomenal - this is old school customer service where they actually care if you come back! Super friendly, clean, & delicious! read more

Best pizza and subs in Wilson period. I travel and the food here is as good or better as any I have found. Thumbs up!

I live in the area and go here almost once a week. The pizza's are great, subs are fresh with great tasting bread and the calzones are delicious and big! Everything is pretty much prepared as you order it. I've never had a bad meal. It is basic and not fancy however, but a good reliable local restaurant. Most of the staff and owner are nice but not overly helpful but think that just may be their personality. Basically you place your order and it comes to your table when ready. It is not the best pizza I've ever eaten but I really like it and for this area it is hard to beat. Go there at least once!! read more