Exceptional service from start to finish. The owner was warm, knowledgeable, and offered appraisal…read morerates well below competitors. He cleaned all ten of my pieces at no charge, they looked brand new and even gifted me a jewelry travel case after hearing I travel frequently. Genuine care, great value, and impeccable service. Highly recommend.

Came in for a watch repair and it was so quick and easy. Amazing people and great service…read more Definitely recommend!

Maddy Jewelers is a SUPERB Jewelry Store. They are located in Syosset, NY and they treat each…read morecustomer like they are a beloved family member. They know their customers by name and they take real pride in presenting themselves as a small town, non commercial run business.I have personally had both my engagement ring and diamond stud earrings reset in beautiful halo settings and my daughter just had a beautiful non-engagement halo set diamond cluster ring made. The workmanship that goes into all their pieces is second to none !!! They also sell beautiful vintage jewelry pieces at very good prices. I have several friends who have come on board after seeing the quality and artistry of my special pieces. I would greatly recommend making Maddy Jewelers your new stop for the highest quality of diamond and gemstone jewelry pieces !!!! It is very worth making a drive in from Manhattan and the other boroughs to experience the high quality of the jewelry created at Maddy Jewelers .You will feel proud to wear their creations !!!!! Holly Sigman from Syosset, NY

Updating that it wasn't after 3 years I brought back my ring in, it was 6 months after I had the…read morering and it wasn't worn daily. The material is cheap, and you refused to repair it.

I have never been to Maddaloni Jewelers before and went there because Tag Heuer told me they were a…read moretrusted authorized dealer. I was taken back by the beauty of the store and the quality products. I found the Tag section and saw the watch I have been thinking about since November. Marco, a sales man came over and took the watch out for me as well as a similar one that had been confusing me as which to pick. Marco had me wear the watch and he put it on as well which was great since he was well dressed and I could see how it would look in formal clothing. I asked the price which was a bit more than I hoped for but Mr Maddaloni came over and realizing I was serious offered a better price that made us both happy. I have to say that this was an extremely pleasant experience, Marco set up the watch , called TAG to activate the warranty and went over the proper care of the watch. I will certainly be returning in the future , the professionalism alone was enough to make the sale a happy one for me.

This is the only place on Long Island I trust to service my watches. They did a "resurrection…read morerepair" on a Ulysse Nardin piece that two other watch repair 'experts" told me to scrap. I have also purchased two fine timepieces here and am very pleased with the service and value received. Louis Maddaloni himself is usually on site and treats all customers with warmth and respect. I have shopped in watch boutiques around the world and Maddaloni is on par with the best. All of the elegance with none of the snobby BS.Amazing to find such an establishment in a small shopping center on Long Island.

I highly recommend this jewelry store. I wanted to have…read moreantique old mine cut diamond from my husband's grandmother reset into an 18k gold bezel setting. I showed Kevin a picture of a setting I loved. He replicated it to perfection. The ring is gorgeous in its new setting.

I stopped in for a watch band adjustment and he handled it quickly while I waited. It looks great…read more Very courteous and offered some guidance about how the watch works.

Great experience, overall. David was easy to work with. He is friendly and trustworthy!read more

Custom made necklaces for me and my brother's birthdays, requested by my mom…read more Clean, precise, unique and different! David Lloyd's work is true art. We get nothing but compliments when worn. I highly recommend David Lloyd.

I bought a few coins here in the early 1990s when I resumed the hobby of coin collecting. While I…read morehaven't been back in over 20 years I rate them highly for longevity and for still having a retail coin store, which are both positives.

Do not take your gold, silver, or jewelry here to sell. Don't be fooled by the overpriced items in…read moredisplay cases, you'll be lucky to receive 20% of pawn shop prices at Whitman's. I've taken the precious metals I come across at auction and estate sales to Diamond State Coins & Currency and for good reason. They will give you top dollar without negotiation. I only brought what I had here after reaching out and sending pictures of some vintage jewelry. I was assured that because it was antique/vintage it was worth more and they would pay more than their melt value. Whitman's lied to me. Upon arrival, I was offered melt value for the same pieces I was told they would offer more than melt value. Save yourself the time and go to Diamond State Coin and Currency. Whittman's was a waste of time.

Love the service and honest pricing.... you always get market value.... see Shawn in Melville…read more.. Pluse a nice selection of goods to purchase.

Great customer service !!! Always professional and honest will definitely recommend this locationread more

I had a great experience with sam.. he has answered all my qs whenever i reached out. I got a gold…read more18k white gold bangel.. it came beautifully in a blue box. He answered all my concerns with honesty. I paid in a few increments and he trusted me even after sending out the bangel. I also got an incredible price on it. Others charge alot more and price gouge. Sam charged me for the price of gold at that present time and some for labor etc. I got a great price for 37-38 grams of nice white 18k gold

I brought 2 items in for repair and when I went to pick them up, my solid gold chain was missing…read more They claimed they never received it. Stay away from this place! I will sue them in small claims court. Jean and Sam are crooks.

Huge thank you to Candy's for making my son's experience a memorable one and in the best way…read morepossible. My six year old came to me just before Mother's Day and expressed his desire to get mom a gift. Wanting him to take ownership over the experience rather than me just buying whatever i suggested we go shopping together and he asked could we make it a jewelry store. The great reviews lead us to Candy's on a quiet rainy afternoon. The only ones in the store he was made to feel like a king, asking all sorts of questions as kids his age do and wanting to more or less see everything. Candy was beyond patient and helpful, letting him see the pieces in the price range I'd mentioned and put them side by side so he could make his choice. In the end he picked out the necklace he like best and was thrilled that we walked out with it giftwrapped, bagged and ready to go for mommy. She of course loved it because it came from him and he now has a memory he'll always treasure. Highly recommended, we will definitely be back.

I have been a customer here many times and found the work average. Recently I brought Two gold…read morerings into Candys Jewelers to be sized up. I was quoted a flat fee price, the shop sized my finger for the rings, when I received them they were too big! I was informed there was an additional fee to "re size" the rings. I also sold several rings with stones in them for scrap, Candys did not pop out the stones which I later found out reputable jewelers do, nor did I get itrmized bills of jewelry I sold her. Expensive lesson learned. My message here is know your jewelry and shop around.

I have always had great experiences at Garçon! Gary spent extra time and energy on making sure…read morewatch battery was done perfectly!

Great jeweler. You won't find anyone more honest and Gary's deigns are beautiful! Been using them…read morefor over 30 years.