oh my God favorite ice cream place ever I asked my parents to go there every time we go out to get ice cream. I always get something basic like chocolate and cherry. But I'm telling you this place is amazing. You have to give it a five stars if I could, I would it 100 read more

I like Jeremiah's just for a quick dessert! The people that work here are always very nice. It is just what you would expect in an ice cream place. It always is clean and the tables are wiped off. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Outside - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

I was at Jeremiah's and i got strawberry lemon with vanilla custrud and I took 2 bites and I noticed something black I thought it was just an air bubble but I looked closer and noticed it wasn't an air bubble it was an nat and I tried to ask for a new one and the woman said that she that it was in there because we were outside and I kept telling her that it was in the middle of the ice cream not the top were the bug can fly into it and she still didn't give me a new one so I called my mom and finally they said they would give me a new but i didn't cause there could be more bugs in the same flavor. the woman was blonde haired thats all I know I'm just a kid and I feel like I was unfair read more

Fun spot, quality soft serve ice cream. Jeremiah's is more than just "Italian ice" as thier name would indicate. The best items to get are the ones in which they mix both soft serve ice cream with the Italian ice to make what they call a "jelati" . Today I tried one of their specials which is the salted Carmel chocolate truffle which was fantastic. During the holidays pumpkin pie is soooo good. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Specials - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

I haven't been to this location in a while, but have always enjoyed stopping by! The staff is very friendly, the place is always clean & bright, and the location is very convenient. This time I tried one of their 'Candy Shoppe' flavors, the Blue Razz, a blue raspberry flavor with vanilla ice cream with colorful Nerds candy. It was delicious and a great addition to their menu! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Blue razz - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I didn't expect to love this place as much ad I do - the tropical flavors and the twist ice cream are fantastic! It's definitely sweet - i'm scared to know the sugar content lol - if you're craving soft and icy, this is the place to go! read more

I stopped by really quick to get a watermelon Italian ice. The small was only $3.50- this was the perfect treat before my date. This location is rather never busy only on weekends. I absolutely want to try to Pumpkin Pie ice- they've got is as a special for fall season. I definitely recommend coming here 10/10 read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Watermelon small $3.40 - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

This place keeps us coming back! Today I tried the Animal Crackers (not pictured because YUMM) and I think I have a new favorite! Always opt for gelati. The mix of the cream and ice is unique and delicious! The folks who work here are also super kind; the service is always great! You order by walking up to a window and can take things to go (ask for a lid) or take a seat at one of their tables and enjoy it here! It's outdoors but covered so nice for cooler weather. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Jeremiah menu - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Stopped by after lunch for a little birthday treat for our Mimi. We order 3 small favorite blends: blue razz, birthday cake and peanut butter. We like Jeremiah's over traditional ice cream because it feels less heavy with the icy texture. The blends are the way to go! You get a little Italian ice mixed with traditional ice cream. They also have add on toppings available. Little pricey but good for a treat! The smalls are big and shareable! read more

See all

I have to say that I am a fan of Italian ice and have also been a fan of Jeremiah's Italian Ice. The company was started by Jeremy Litwack, who got his start by selling Italian ice in front of the Philadelphia Mint when he was still in high school. While Jeremy was studying marketing at the University of Delaware, he continued to build his pushcart and ice cream truck business. Jeremy headed to Florida in 1995 and in the summer of 1996, Jeremy opened the first Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Winter Park, Florida (which is part of the Orlando, Florida area). This particular Jeremiah's Italian Ice was an overall pleasant experience. I would definitely recommend this particular location. Jeremiah's Italian Ice is definitely a good option to get something cold and delicious for a treat or a dessert. Overall, I am going to give this particular Jeremiah's Italian Ice location five stars and my recommendation. Go give it a try, I am confident that you will like it. read more

I absolutely enjoyed Jeremiah's on a warm Spring evening. The flavors were fun and refreshing and a must! This is a great treat at the end of a date or date night in general, or just because. read more

Staff at this location are always nice and generous - I've always been treated well and able to sample some flavors before ordering it. To my own disappointment, 3 out of 4 times it get the same thing: a small mint chocolate chip shaved ice/soft serve (?) + chocolate soft serve. Next time, I'll try their new coffee combinations (they have 3 in the menu, but it looks seasonal). read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Sydney took care of me today. She was an absolute doll. Can't wait to get home and eat my pumpkin ice cream. I love this place for a quick treat. There are so many options! Great location with out door seating to enjoy your snack before it melts! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Pumpkin gelati - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Forever a favorite of mine. This place is LEGIT. To start, the staff always offers free samples of the different flavors. The dames aren't just little tiny things, they're a little cup that consists of both the custard and the italian ice. I get the gelati when I go.. a mix of custard and italian ice. The custard is some of the best I have ever had. I usually get Scoop Froggy Frog which is a mint chocolate chip italian ice (to die for) with vanilla custard. Tonight, I got Bahama Freeze with vanilla custard. There is no indoor seating, you just walk up to a window and order! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Bahama Freeze w. Vanilla Custard Gelati - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

KUDOS and thanks to Spence for providing supreme quality customer service! He saw I was a disabled military veteran and offered me a sample of strawberry ice! The ambiance is amazing with the and oldies music! I highly recommend all to come and visit to support this local business here in Windermere! read more

Very bad. Asked for vanilla twice was handed chocolate twice. I didn't feel good going back and being rude to the worker but BEWARE!!! Uneducated children. read more

I'm dinging the place because the girl on duty just after the noon hour was rude rude rude and the person behind me in line agreed. No one was available, I called in to see if a person was working. The service girl did not make eye contact, did not great me , nearly could not bring herself to ask what I would like simply acted like it was a chore to wait on me. Which it is that's the job. After paying I told her that I would not tip her because and I explained exact,y what she did and how I was treated. She said she was by herself and was in the bathroom. Did not say sorry for the wait. Instead continued with an attitude as as much as said I don't care if you don't tip me. Must be hart if not impossible to get good service help. BUT THIS WAS A FIRST Every other person at your establishment has been gracious, helpful and with a great attitude. read more

I enjoy going to Jeremiah's to get a tasty treat after dinner or when I am in the mood for Ice cream! Staff are friendly and will help you on deciding what flavors are yummy! I usually get cherry but they didn't have any and opt for the black cherry, which did not disappoint! I will be back for more tasty treats! They also have an App with a reward program! So make sure to sign up before heading out on your next visit! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Black cherry! - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Every time I come back to Orlando, I always make a stop to Jeremiah's. This is my FAVORITE Italian ice place. The Ice cream: they make the best combination is Italian ice and soft ice cream, the Gelati. Perfect combination for hot Florida days. The Space: its all outdoor seating in square tables that can get sticky if they don't clean it well, so watch out for dirty spots! Worth it? YES, $3.65 for a "small", which is pretty filling for 1 person. A medium for $4.45 can even be shared (depending on how much each person eats) read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

SO delicious amazing go here for dessert it's good if you haven't had dessert here before then I recommend you should

Since this location opened it's been a hit with our family. Everyone loves the flavors the staff and the location. We've placed many orders for pick up and are always greeted and given great service. Aaron is fantastic!! read more

Great service! The cashier was super enthusiastic when I told her my girlfriend & I haven't been here in a while! They had made new flavor combinations and the ambiance was a great aesthetic. Perfect location in Windermere to have a delicious treat. We decided to get the Animal Cookies flavor combo with the whipped cream, vanilla ice cream swirl along with my favorite the cookie butter Italian ice.. it was to die for ! Totally recommended always stopping by for a sweet treat read more

Italian ice meets soft serve ice cream and you get a nice treat. First time. In the area for drs appt. Quick service, clear and concise explanation. I was going to just order a soft serve vanilla but the lady's explanation of the mix was cool so I decided to try it. First bite you could taste the creaminess of the soft serve and the tart of the Italian ice. I chose strawberry . read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Good choice for first time - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Jeremiah's is a go-to during my Orlando visits, simply because my nephews are OBSESSED with their Italian ice. Ironically, I'm beginning to become obsessed with their frozen offerings, too. On a hot day, there's nothing better than dusting off the sweat with a cold cup of frozen ice or custard. The Mango/Vanilla combo is my favorite concoction, and one I've been ordering more frequently. The sweet mango ice paired with creamy vanilla custard is a match made in heaven! This location can get a little wild and the lines are often backed up during peak hours. The girls behind the counter ring up the orders and make the mixtures, so if you give them the benefit of the doubt, they'll make your visit worthwhile. Plus, the prices are incredibly light on the wallet. Dessert has become a special occasion treat for me, since growing up in an ice cream shop for 18 years has admittedly turned me off to the genre. However, Jeremiah's is a win-win situation year round in Florida! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Mango Vanilla glory! - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

This Jeremiah is the closer to the Dr Philip Way near Orlando. My friend was craving for a Jeremiah Italian Ice. The original store is far away and decided to visit this one. It is located on the nice plaza. Very close to LA fitness. I can see they get a lot customers from after work out. I have small cup with three flavor. Top with cotton candy, middle lever with black raspberry and the bottom layer with banana. My friend have single or double combo. Sometimes I have too much ice to swallow and create Brian freeze. It is too much ice in one time. It was great to have the Italian ice with light dessert. Healthy choices. The outside seating is nice. We beat the closing time by 10 minutes. We enjoy till it last. Thanks to the store keep the light lid after 10 pm. We have a good time here. read more

See all

We remain huge fans of their tasty treats, and appreciate that they've remained opened for carry-out. The counter is clean and employees are as friendly and efficient as always. They have markings on the ground where customers should stand so they remain 6-feet apart. Most people are respectful of the distance, some are not. They pack your order to go since their tables are cordoned off so customers aren't gathering. There are plenty of nicely-spaced benches if you do choose to stick around. One thing to note, their current hours have changed to 12p-9p daily. They should consider covering their regular business hours, we waited around a while last week because we didn't notice the new hours on their temporary sign. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Store front - bench & picnic table seating - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Not your Normal Italian ice stand Go for the medium size, they're huge! We stopped for Italian ice after dining at a burger joint nearby. The line moves quickly and they still allow you to sample flavors before you make your final order The lemon basil is delicious on its own. It's even more delicious with the vanilla custard cream. But go small because both are rich. The strawberry pairs well with the vanilla for a strawberries and cream delight. They have limited seating but there are benches in the same plaza that you can sit at too. Delicious! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Sea salt caramel swirl and the p-nutty with chocolate - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

I did not know that this delish gem was located in this shopping center, next to BurgerFi. While we are only able to order at the window to go, we were given samples of tons of delish options. We tasted mango with canilla, cake batter, and piña colada. They were all really good but the clear winner was the piña colada! You could taste real pieces of pineapples Ed in. The sales person at the window was friendly and I formative. Definitely worth a stop, specially with little on read more

See all

I love it I go almost 2-3 times a week. You should go there if you love anything ice cream or Italian ice. They have the best blend of the two of them or you can get them separate. read more

The best Italian ice out there! No wonder they are voted "Best Frozen Treats" and "Best Frozen Dessert" in Orlando via the Orlando Sentinel! This location was pretty popular since I went on a Friday evening. The employees are very friendly and are so nice when you ask to sample a flavor. They have three different treats that Jeremiah's offers. The first treat is a Gelati which is a scoop of Italian ice topped with a swirl of soft serve ice cream topped with another scoop of Italian ice and so on. There are about 6-8 layers of this total. The second treat is just their delicious Italian ice and the third is their soft serve ice cream. read more

See all

What's not to love? This place is amazing! Outdoor seating and affordable, delicious, generous portions of Italian ice layered with soft serve ice cream. Is there anything better?!? read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Strawberry and cream. - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

My boyfriend was raving about Jeremiah's since our first date and so I had to try this place out once and for all. Let me tell you, the reviews don't lie and if I could give Jeremiah's 6 stars I would! If your looking to cool down from the Florida sun, go to Jeremiah's and get their famous Gelati. The Gelati is basically soft serve ice cream with Italian ice. There's 40 flavors to choose from and they are more than happy to give you samples so you can try before you buy. I decided to get the small vanilla and mango Gelati combo after trying a sample of it. The small size feels like a medium since your really getting a lot. I have to say it was absolutely amazing. I devoured the Gelati in seconds not caring about the pounds I may gain and the extra workout time I'll need to put in the gym. I am now dreaming about my next visit to Jeremiah's. God bless you Jeremiah or whoever came up with the Gelati. Not all heroes wear capes! I hope you guys expand to the west coast one day especially Cali! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Vanilla soft serve and mango Italian ice. So delicious! - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Jeremiahs Is one of my favorite stops for dessert. The only place in Orlando that offers Italian ice, let alone over 40 different flavors to choose from. The prices are awesome and if you sign up for rewards you get random deals like Bogo. It's walk up style, you go to a window, pick a flavor and they have a few tables up front to sit down and ENJOY! You can keep it classic and tasty with just the Italian ice or make it a gelati and add some ice cream. I love all the Italian ice flavors but my favorite are Bahama freeze, key west tropical, black cherry and mango. I also love the froggy frog which is mint/chocolate chip with chocolate icecream. Service here is excellent!! The Jeremiah team members are eager and friendly to help you try all the flavors. Don't be shy trying flavors because among all the delicous pairings and flavors they will let you sample away. The lines can be long but they always have three windows or more open and they take orders quickly. I'm super excited about all the locations they've opened everywhere but they location remains my favorite. read more

See all

Um wow how have I not had gelati before?! Their term for Italian ice and soft serve mix. What a great combination and they generously offer a plethora of samples! Cookie butter is my absolute favorite! I love how they do something so simple as mixing their Italian ice with different soft serves and yet it makes such a beautiful combination. My first time going and I bought a quart to go LOL I don't know how it will taste refrozen so I'll update after I try it! This is definitely a store you want to take your Florida visiting friends who want something unique we have to offer! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Cookies and cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

The best Italian ice I have tried so far ! We tired three different flavors. All very tasty read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Great ice cream ! - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

(UPDATE) it happened again!! It's 10:32 and we arrived to find 2 employees using bleach to scrub the floor while customers were trying to eat and then left a mop on the floor when they realized they were getting a line. If you close at 11:00... let your patrons enjoy their food and feel welcome until 11:00. I decided to surprise my boys by taking them to Jeremiah's because I know they love it here. We walked up at 10:47 and asked if they were still open and the group of employees gave one another the look of "oh great" and said yes, I guess. And the kind one young lady dumped an entire bucket of water in front of us and began to mop. I'm really disappointed that we were treated so poorly. I understand that you want to leave but then please don't list 11:00 as your closing timeq read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Freshly dumped mop water. - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Perfect summer treat-- lots of good fruity flavors for the Italian ice, the peach and the strawberry were fantastic. The soft serve ice cream is easily the best soft serve I have ever had-- would definitely suggest the gelati option where they layer the ice cream and the Italian ice. read more

This place is fantastic! I don't know how I've lived in Orlando for two years and not known about it. They serve a ton of different flavors of Italian ice, all of which can be served alone or swirled in with vanilla, chocolate, or both flavors of soft serve - called a gelati. They let you sample any flavor or combination of flavors you want to sample, so you can't really go wrong. I personally went with the cookies and cream and mint chocolate chip Italian ice mixed with vanilla soft serve, and it was amazing. The Italian ice has a wonderful smooth consistency and goes fantastically with the soft serve. A medium is more than enough to fill you and everything is well priced: Since this is on my way home from work, I'm sure it'll become a frequent stop for me on the future. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - On the left is mint chocolate chip and cookies and cream, and swirl ice cream. - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Jeremiah's is one of my favorite treats! It's so simple, and it's not overly sweet. This one is located in The Grove- a plaza located in Windermere. We came here with my boyfriend's son. It's set up like your typical Jeremiah's, a la order at the window. Menu is still pretty standard with all the classic flavors. We were greeted with friendly service, and she even offered suggestions for us. My boyfriend's son asked for a sample of bahama freeze, and she even included a bit of vanilla soft serve with it. She was super sweet! We ordered 2 gelatis- one with blueberry, lemon, and bahama freeze for my boyfriend's son. We shared one with cookie butter and mint chocolate chip. Odd, but if you're a fan of cookie butter, highly recommended! I'd probably pair it with strawberry or raspberry next time though. After ordering, there are tables available to sit at, or you can grab a bench from around the plaza. Or even better, walk around and burn the calories that you're about to eat. Lol read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Gelati with blueberry, bahama freeze, and lemon. - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Happy to have a Jeremiah's a little closer to home! This location is part of a growing plaza called the Grove at Isleworth. Recently this complex also added a Dexter's location and a BurgerFi is set to open soon. This area is definitely becoming a hot spot! Jeremiah's features such a wide variety of rotating italian ice flavors, so there is always something new to try. As is typical of Jermiah's, this location is counter service only, with no indoor space for patrons, which I think works fine for their business. This location had a nice covered outdoor space, which featured several picnic benches and some counter space as well. I visited on a Sunday evening and the place was hopping! They were well staffed though and the line moved fast. The main items you can enjoy at Jeremiah's are vanilla/chocolate soft serve, italian ice, or gelati, which is a layering of italian ice and gelati. This trip, I enjoyed the gelati- vanilla ice cream with some cocount and horchata italian ice (you can get up to three different flavors in a small!). Loved the mix of the icy and creamy textures and the interesting flavor choices. Yum! As a bonus you are also encouraged to try samples of flavors that are new to you! For me, that helps a lot with my indecisiveness! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Delicious and refreshing gelati! - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida