I completely loved the tuna sub and it honestly made me wonder why I don't order tuna subs more often. The flavor was what was really excellent. The way they did the lettuce, tuna, tomato, and whatever sauce they use was really good and very flavorful. It's definitely better than Subway. The only issue was that parts of the bread were a little soggy. It wasn't the whole sandwich, just certain spots, so in a few places I avoided eating the bread and I ended up with a clump of soggy bread in my little hand. I did love that they put cheese on the top for part of it though and I thought the cheese they used really complimented the flavor of the tuna. I also think the cheese helped protect the bread from the moisture in the tuna salad so the cheese for me was nonnegotiable for ensuring the quality of the sub. If anything, adding a little more of that cheese and layering more of it so it fully protected the bread from the moisture in the tuna would have likely prevented the bread from getting soggy. Lightly toasting the bread first might have helped too. Other than that small issue, I was really impressed with this tuna sub. It smelled amazing too, honestly better than most tuna sandwiches I've had. I would definitely order it again. read more

See all

I tried to be efficient today and placed an online order. Picked up the order and the bag was stained w dressing, when I looked inside, the salad had been sitting and leaked out of the "cardboard" container. I asked the guy at the register why they would put the dressing on it and leave it sit there, He was clueless, put the salad in a new bag and gave it back to me. So, now I get home to eat it and it is a total train wreck. Please dont put dressing on a salad in cardboard and let it sit for pick up.... seems common sense? read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Soggy salad - maybe they should put the dressing on the side when using cardboard? - Sandwiches Near Me - Peters (Township of), Pennsylvania

See all

Some times this place is great and other times it's not so great. Tonight was one of those not so great times. When I order my sandwich on the app and then pick up in the store. I don't typically open the wrapping to make sure they did it correctly. Wish I would have tonight. They screwed up my order something terrible. The ONLY thing they got right was it was on a gluten free bun. But the rest of the sandwich was wrong as was the dressing and all the add ons. read more

If you want a fresh sandwich, Jersey Mike's is the place to go. It's that simple. I walked in, was helped right away, and had my sandwich ready in under five minutes--made with fresh meats and bread. Fast, friendly, and delicious. read more

See all

Tried to order at 5pm for a pickup at 5:45 and said the location wasn't taking orders for pick up. Who shuts off their online orders? Ridiculous. Will choose a different place from now on. Plenty of places to get a sub. read more

Italian sub Mike's way, my absolute favorite The mcmurray store is always clean and the crew friendly. I highly recommend this store and Jersey Mike's products read more

I will not be going back to Jersey Mike's after they sent me an email for a free sub for my birthday and then reneged on it by saying I didn't buy enough subs this past year meanwhile I did I just didn't use my point card all the time because I forget it sometimes as far as I'm concerned it's too many other sub shops around here to deal with idiots like this I won't be wasting my money there no more The other sub shop right next to them are better anyway! I think it's a pretty sick joke doing this to someone at my age thinking you're going to get a free meal for them just to r renege on it! I got more excuses from one person today from this business than I have the rest of the year put together read more

Jersey Mike's is always a good choice! What I really like about this sub shop is the plethora of options!! Hot subs, cold subs, salads, wraps, and even breakfast sandwiches! Not only that, they have lots of meats, cheeses, and breads to choose from! They have a gigantic meat slicer on the counter, and slice the meat right there for you! Super fresh!! Ok but that's even not the best part.... Actually, I can't decided which is the best part: the red wine vinaigrette sub dressing or the the hot pepper relish?!? All I know is that you must get BOTH! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Peters (Township of), Pennsylvania

See all

Horrible. I had to ask three times for them to change their gloves after touching the register. Then the person who was remaking my sub went into the back, did some things in the kitchen. Came back and finished my sub with the same gloves on. I just spent $10 on a sub. I'm not going to eat. I will never come back here. Or to any other. read more

My absolute favorite sandwich shop! Why?! Because they are amazing!! This is my first visit to one in Pennsylvania, and I wasn't disappointed at all! I always get the exact same thing, salami, white bread, provolone cheese and mikes way plus spicy mustard. I noticed immediately how clean this place was and the friendly staff. I get what I always get a salami On white mines way. I will be back here when I go back to Bobby Rahal BMW:-) read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - A salami on white, mikes way with spicy mustard. I recommend some mayo I forgot to ask. Best.sandwich.ever. - Sandwiches Near Me - Peters (Township of), Pennsylvania

My husband ate his first sub at Jersey Mikes. He loved it. Said it had alot of meat on it and it held him for hours. He works long hours and needs enough food to hold him. He got an Italian hoagie and loved it. read more

Horrible customer service! Two times in a row that they messed up our Door Dash order (missing sub and wrong subs) and they refused to send the sub back out. Going to Primo next time! read more

We were given a gift card by a parent in Peter's Twp thanking Daryl as a bus driver one Christmas. It was clean and the food was really fresh. read more

One of my go to, favorite hoagie and cheesesteak joints. Using the app is fast and painless

The one in McMurray by the Panera is pretty typical of the service and product that you find at any location. The food is pretty fresh. The ambiance lacks any flair. read more

Always great subs, fast service friendly service and tastes amazing. ............,,................!!!!!!!!

Have been eating subs from here for years now. Always the freshest breads meats and vegetables to go on your made to order sandwich. Love the Daily lunch specials, probably one of the best sub places around Id have to say. Anyways if your in the waterdame area stop in and grab a sub you wont regret it, id suggest to get your Sub mikes way too ! read more

Jersey Mike's always does a kick a** job, sorry there just aren't other words to describe it! Also, this location has phenomenal service from management all the way to the guys that were making the sandwiches. So friendly and welcoming. 10/10 would recommend read more

Went to Thai jersey mikes for the first time in awhile but every time . We eat here we love it they are such a clean restaurant. The staff our wonderful and they are polite. We always look forward to our sandwiches the mike way. I do not have a complaint one other than we could have used a little more vinegar, which is more so of a taste preference. Other than that I highly recommend this jersey mikes wonderful food and friendly people. read more

I like their subs, but on more than 3 occasions, they screwed the order up. I am always very clear because my kids are HATE cheese. I always ask for NO CHEESE!!!!!!!!! More times than not lately, including tonight 7-30-2020 at 545 pm when I ordered, i was very careful to say NO CHEESE! My family will not eat the expensive sandwiches with cheese! I paid almost $62.00 for 4 sandwiches and they were wrong! This was supposed to be dinner. I am a very fair consumer, and I usually dont review but Im tired of the mistakes. Its not that hard! You can do better Jersey Mikes, Mcmurray PA 15317! Disappointed Dad! Paul P. read more

The freshest lunch meat makes the best subs. This place is awesome. Three sizes of subs to choose from. I go here often and the bread is as fresh as the meat. Order it your way or "Mike's Way". read more

I love this sub shop! Great subs, the ingredients are always fresh and very tasty. This is my favorite sub shop in the area. The only problems I've ever had were parking in the lot as it's always busy in that plaza and sometimes (at lunch) there aren't enough seats. read more

excellent sub. i come here once a week. on purpose. i don't cry on the drive home. good. thanks ND read more

I first tried Jersey Mike's 3 years ago when I lived in Minnesota and have loved it since! I don't like to eat a lot of bread, so the sub in a tub is perfect for me. And Mike's Way is so tasty! Simple, but really good. This particular location has been great the two times I've been there. I like that they have two turkey options. The deli that I've had at other locations and the roasted turkey which I've never been given the option to get at other locations I've been to. Anyway, if you've never tried Jersey Mike's before you should! And this location would be a good one to try for the first time! read more

Best cheesesteak in the area. The sandwiches are delicious even the most basic ones lol. This is my to go place for subs :)

Have been coming here for quite a while. I used to live close by, but now take the long way home from work to grab a sub. I live closer to the new Bridgeville location, but the quality is way better at this one. The owner is present more often than not, and a while ago, even offered to let me in before they open so I could get a breakfast sandwich and still be on time for work (not sure if they still have those). Always very fresh ingredients. I have never had a bad experience at this location with quality of service. Worth the higher price tag. read more

Quick and easy, awesome subs. Definitely much better than your typical sub shop. Club supreme, mikes way is my favorite.

The sandwiches are fine, though the tuna has a bit too much mayo. The biggest concern I had was the inflexibility of the staff on the kids menu. I wanted a veggie sub for my son with the kids meal, but they said I could only have the ham, turkey, or salami even though the veggie is the same if you take off the meat. This isn't my first such experience at a Jersey Mikes and it is agitating every time. read more

Stopped by here for a hoagie on my way home from work because I was starving and I have nothing to complain about! Filling, made to order and quick. I ordered the veggie and it was good. Plenty of parking. read more

This is a great choice. Delicious fresh subs with fantastic customer service. I come here often and have never had anything to complain about. Even when they are very busy they work diligently and have never gotten my order wrong. read more

Very fresh food one of the best subs I've ever had. Very friendly, clean and best of all they honor our military with an excellent discount. Just wish it was closer to where we live. read more

Best subs ever. I highly recommend trying the buffalo chicken. It's amazing. Their Italian and Turkey are also very good. The oils and spices bring the subs to another level. Friendly staff. 5 stars all the way. read more

The ingredients seem to be decent quality but they put very little meat in your sandwich. Also don't care for the very dry and crumbly bread. read more

Ate here yesterday and it was so good it was busy but they worked as a team to keep the line moving and the sub (13 no pepperoni #thebestsub) was on so good tons of meat thinly sliced everything on it was fresh, Dillon made it mine and carefully chose the best tomatoes for me even discarding one that wasn't perfect that's why I'm writing this review, I've never seen that before it was like he was making a sub he would want to eat!!!! Donate 2 bucks to hurricane relief and get a free reg sub good through end of 2017. I love this place! read more

My daughter stopped at this store on her way home from work and bought a chicken , provolone, and bacon hoagie. Two hours after eating it she became violently ill. Five days later she is in the emergency room for the second time trying to recover from a staph infection that must have come from your sandwich. Are you willing to cover the hospital bills. We will never eat there again. read more

Today was my first time going there and I will be back. It was lunchtime so the store was busy but the staff was friendly and very efficient. I got a Reuben and it was tasty. I'd like to try some other items too. read more

Awesome food consistently. Great leadership/owner is no doubt the secret behind this location's success. Quality food served quickly & professionally! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE! read more

Jersey Mikes is my go-to sub shop and has been since I can remember. They can do no wrong.