FRESH!! Super fresh! You walk up to order, and there's a deli case with whole roasts and a meat slicer. You order your sandwich, they grab the giant hunk of meat out of the deli case, place it on the slicer, and slice it up right in front of you. Impressive! After pondering the menu a bit, I chose the turkey mini sub. The mini is about a 5-6" sub. The guy sliced my turkey, placed it on the bread, and passed it down to the man in front of the fixings. He asked if I wanted it "Mike's way". Hmm.. I'm intrigued. "What is 'Mike's way'?" It is: lettuce, tomato, onions, vinegar, oil, salt & pepper. Sounds good to me! I also added some hot relish. Yum! The sub was very tasty, but a tad pricey. The mini sub is $5.25. The regular size is $6.95. Seems some of the other sub chains in the area are cheaper. read more

You guys make a good sub, but when you put them in your brown bags, can you please not squish the sub by making a nice tight bag? I'd rather have a loose bag and an uncrushed sub. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #6 Roast Beef and Provolone - Sandwiches Near Me - West Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Jersey Mike's is always a hit. I like the super sub with the pepper relish! I ask for it on the side so I can add as much or little as I want. Also the mini cookies are so good too! read more

It's freshly sliced in front of you. The bread is baked there and they put on the sandwich what YOU want and not what comes with. To me that is exactly what I want in a subway shop. And they wear plastic gloves while slicing. I love it. read more

Missing part of my order from door dash. Rude and unapologetic on phone upon calling to resolve. Food prep unappealing and missing meat. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - A sad sad sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - West Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I order online a few times a week. They get it right every time and all of the employees are always polite. Even when they are in the middle of a rush or short handed they always get my order out quickly. read more

We ordered a box of mini subs with all the extras on the side for a Brewers Game tailgate. They had everything ready exactly on time right when they opened and carefully packed it all up for us. Sandwiches excellent. Well done. read more

I don't know if someone new is working there, but every order I get seems to be wrong. I ordered no tomato, no oregano...it's all over it. I order Mountain Dew and get diet or Pepsi. ALWAYS, it's always wrong in some way, my orders come through Door Dash, I can see what I ordered, it's never right! Back to Cousins for me...this oregano crap is not even edible! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Ordered no tomato no oregano...guess what I got! - Sandwiches Near Me - West Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This location is in a strip mall on Miller Parkway, near National Blvd. Entering and exiting the parking lot is easy and there is plenty of parking available in the lot. The store itself is bright, new and very clean. This was my first time visiting a Jersey Mike's. I was glad I came here. Jersey Mike's sandwiches are definitely superior to those at Cousins or Subway. The quality of product rates with Pot Belly, but it is different and better, IMHO. At Jersey Mikes, all orders are built with fresh cut meats; literally; i.e., they take a slab/roast/brick of your choice of meats/cheeses on a slicing machine and cut it up, fresh, for your sandwich. For sure, they put a lot more meat/contents on the sandwiches than any of the aforementioned competitors, a reason that the price maybe as much as a buck or two more expensive. They have "add chips and a drink" specials and the beverages are "help yourself." I really like this place! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - West Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

So I came in about 30 minutes before close and Monica greeted me immediately. I had been with extended family due to a death in the family and had been driving a long way, hungry. Just wanted something light to tide me over til breakfast. I have crazy dietary needs called a low fodmap diet. Monica told me upfront that they only had wheat bread, wraps and one small gluten free. Yay! I've been craving a sub with bread and the gluten free bread here fits my dietary needs and is delicious!! She was friendly, funny and accommodating making sure she was careful to avoid cross contamination. The #8 with mayo and no onion never tasted so good. She also told me about a gluten free cookie you sell that I'm looking forward to trying! She turned my whole day around!! Thank you Monica and Jersey Mike's. read more

2nd Jersey Mike's ham & provolone I've had in a week in Milwaukee, first one at this location. To me, Cousins is the king of subs and a good Jersey Mike's is a close second. I like Jersey Mikes for portion and juiciness. They are usually dripping with flavour from the vinegar and oil. Kinda their trademark. Mikes way is the only way to go. This visit let me slightly disappointed. It seems they missed the mark for what a standard Jersey mikes should be. It lacked the juiciness they are known for. Everything was there, it just didn't pop. Perhaps the lettuce was a bit past it's prime as well. Place was quiet. Store was clean. Staff was nice. read more

Probably the only pastrami sandwich I haven't liked. Overall, I don't think Jersey Mike's is good. Pastrami is my favorite deli meat of all time and I still didn't enjoy my sandwich. I don't know what it is...maybe the bread, maybe the quality of meat, but jersey mike's is not for me. Of all the sub places, I would rank jersey mike's below subway and cousins...and FAR below Jimmy John's, if that puts it in perspective for anyone. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Pastrami Reuben - Sandwiches Near Me - West Milwaukee, Wisconsin

the lady working was very rude. She completely forgot one of our subs. Then when we were waiting to pay she almost gave all of our subs to the door dash lady. She was even rude to the door dash lady when she asked for a bag for 3 subs. My boyfriend stepped in and told her we just watched them make those subs and they're out and when she tried to ask the lady working behind the counter she said those are for Brandon. we took the subs and opened them up and yup, they were ours. Sadly, we are no longer going to be going to this location. read more

Just went for my first time. ABSOLUTELY the worst service. NOT by one but but BOTH. Working counter. They didn't try to sell me anything. When I asked questions about what was in a sub the guy didn't know what the meat even was. She acted like it was asking her to run down the street. Total attitude. I was going to order two more sandwiches but I guess it's only 1 sub per customer because neither one wanted to stop the personal conversation long enough to ask me if there was anything else I would like to have. Went to Cousins next door instead. BUT...there was ONE saving grace. There was a young girl, employee of your store, she was on her break. She stopped her break and was able to answer my question, excellent positive attitude. She is wearing braces, and had her hair up on here head. I wish I could have got her name.. RECOMMENDATION - Fire the two behind the counter and train and PROMOTE the young girl. I'll never go back for food. May go back and find the young girl and offer her a job. read more

I called this location at 8:44pm to place a takeout order and the individual that answered spent more time telling me that they closed at 9:00pm than trying to get the order correct. After she finally took the order and stated that I had to be there by 8:55pm, another individual in the background yelled, "That's some bullsh*t!" I had no idea why was so upset doing her job during their standard posted business hours. I arrived there at 8:51pm and they were in the process of making the sandwich so I was able to see what they were doing. It was not a customer-friendly or professional experience and I will not give them my hard-earned money in the future. read more

Get the Italian sub "Mike's Way" and you won't be disappointed. Ingredients are super fresh: vegetables are the correct color (no brown lettuce) and meat is sliced to order. Despite the great food, this particular location gets 3 stars because the franchise owner has for whatever reason decided to hire a cadre of sloths to both make the subs and ring up orders. From start to finish our (take out) visit lasted 35 minutes, 10 of which were spent by our sandwich artist carefully arranging tomato, lettuce and onion on the sub, the way I imagine a dude who puts little ships inside glass bottles would do. I'm definitely all for bomb presentation but this was totally excessive for a sub. read more

This is our stop however things have change recently !!! We go there o ce or twice every week !!! Everyone recently there's a problem our bread ; out of bacon etc etc etc !! The service has gotten terrible !!! Very disappointed especially when there prices are high !! We luv them but rethinking I'd be wr going back to them !!! I'm tried wasting my money and don't get what I paid for !!! read more

I was happy that they finally came to Milltown. They slice your meat to order so it's really fresh. I have only had the turkey sub but I highly recommend it. This is going to be more costly than a Cousins or Subway visit but I think it's worth it. This tastes as good as a sandwich I would make at home. I really like their iced tea. It actually has tea flavor unlike most fast food places. I have never had an issue with the service. It's always been fast and friendly. read more

I had been craving meatball subs for a week. Like I would wake up and instantly desire the warm feeling of mozzarella melted over juicy meatballs in my mouth. But other things got in the way. First it was Bel Air, then Leff's Lucky Town for Fish Fry, and somehow seven days passed and I didn't fill this urge. But then it was tonight. Saturday. At 6:30 my partner and I decided to indulge in subs. Subway? Nasty. Cousins? For nostalgia purposes I only eat ham and provolone there. No, what I wanted some amazing giant meatballs at Glorioso. I can drive across town for meatballs. Yes, let's do this! Wait. Closed at 6? On a Saturday? Whatever. Ok, so we'll just do the Public Market. Hard to get in and out, but we're dedicated people. What the hell. Closes in 30 minutes. Don't places in Milwaukee want money on the weekends? I'm literally trying to hand someone my money and I can't. Businesses: just because you want off on the weekends doesn't mean the world stops eating. So I come to trusty Yelp and I look up "meatball sub near 53208" and the first thing that comes up is Jersey Mikes. And woah. It is even closer than Culvers which = quicker time to get home and stuff face. Go there. Get greeted awesomely. And meet Ray, who provided the most caring and genuine customer service I have experienced in a long time. Everything looked clean and fresh. My partner got a roast beef giant of sorts and a got a giant meatball sub with onions. The meat tasted amazing and I was happy for exactly what I craved. And I have more for later. But back to Rayven, who made my sub, and Ray, the guy working the register. They were really great and seemed happy to work with each other and be at work in general. It made the experience really great. My partner is going back to tip them right now, actually. I don't carry cash and he only had so much and we want to make sure those two employees know they are appreciated. I'm a happy, meatball sub stuffed lady. read more

I just Noticed a jersey mikes subs on miller park way and did a u turn. I had this once years ago in IL. and thought it was good. There is three sizes sm,med and large so I opted for the med for around $7.00. Well a med is 13 inches and this was a big sub. First off when you order a sub you will notice a meat slicer next to a glass deli meat case displaying all the meats and cheese. When you order your sub they will take the meats and cheese out and slice them right in front of you and then it moves to the fresh toppings section. I had lettuce tomato and onion on my Italian sub and finished it off with a drizzle of vinegar,oil and spices. The guy finishing the sub was a fan of cocktail because he was tossing the bottles of vinegar and oil in the air and pouring them on the sub. The whole experience of this place was kind of hip and cool which I don't usually see. The sub was very good and I might just have put at the top of my sub list. Subway look out there is a new sheriff in town and the big guns are out. I don't go to subway or blimpe because I didn't think they are that good when you have a cousins and jersey mikes in the area that serve a better product. Two thumbs up. read more

I really root for this underdog, of local Jersey Mike stores. Their consistency in making me a perfect #43 with a side of buffalo and ranch, has been unmatched. Whoever the cook is, 9 times out of 10, they know how to deliver a great sandwich; generous stuffing, balanced, and fresh! Thank you for restoring my faith in subs, JM of WM. read more

I've been here a handful of times and I'm surprised I haven't posted a review for it, but there's a good chance I have a review for a different Jersey Mike's location. I love Jersey Mike's. The only thing I've found that I don't like is the fact that it's BYOBO.....Bring Your Own Black Olives.... They cut the meat right in front of you, same with the cheese. Ask Subway to do that for you, then just laugh as they pull the meat out of the processed bag. Based on that alone, it makes it just feel fresher than Subway. Don't get me wrong, I like Cousin's and Glorioso's too, so I'm not just trying to make a knock on Subway.....but everything at JM just seems to be better. Crisper lettuce, fresher tomatoes, more tasty bread....I dig it. The people don't seem to hate their jobs here either, and that's a bonus. So, thanks Jersey Mike's, I'll be back. read more

Bad customer service tonight. Put bacon on sub did not ask for or want. Sub was not even very good (California Chicken). I've had the sub before at a different place and it was much better! Place was too hot. Not a good experience for a Mike's I've had much much better. Not sure if I'll be coming back. read more

I find myself favoring Jersey Mike's subs over Jimmy John's, Cousin's, Subway, Firehouse, and any other sub chains I forgot to mention. I like the variety of hot and cold sandwiches; I like the abundance of meats and veggies; I like the texture of the bread they use; and for the most part, I like their approach to great customer service. Some employees are better at it than others. Get your sub "Mike's Way" for the additional oils and seasonings that add major flavor layers to your sub. read more

Fresh bread. Nice amount of meat. CRISPY BACON! I'll be back! Lettuce was a bit brown though. Other than that, nice sub shop!

Food's alright. Nothing special... The drinks, however, are terrible. What's wrong with your drink machine? Why does everything that comes out of it taste like acid? Is it your water or does it need to be calibrated or what...? My wife likes to eat sandwiches, so we come here for lunch sometimes. I go with it because it's food and not something gross like McDonald's, but when it comes to getting a drink, I'd rather get a Gatorade from the cooler because, as I said before, the drink machine is putting out some atrocious beverages. Why should I be forced to pay more for a drink because your store is defective? Get your shit together, guys... It's a business. How about you try giving a damn read more

What amazing costumer service. The team that was working tonight was so friendly and nice. I walked in at 8pm and while making my order I mentioned that my family and I are driving 15 hours to Dallas. The staff was so friendly and they also individually packed all the veggies and condiments so my order will not get soggy while on the road. Honestly I wish there were workers like this who actually care. Also, the store and area where they were making my sandwiches was very clean.. read more

First time being here and definitely won't come back. At least not to this location. Walk up to the counter and order my food and wasn't even done with my sentence before the guy rolled his eyes and walked away shaking his head. Comes back and stands there so I repeated my order of "reg cheesesteak with no onions and peppers". Simple enough. One thing that really bothered me is that they weren't preparing the food on any cutting boards or anything that would show its clean/has been cleaned. Just the metal counter that had shit all over it. Then to make matters worse, didn't even get my order right. Still had peppers on it. Whatever I ate it anyway since I didn't wanna deal with the guy again, but then he repeated to mess up my 3 friends orders, as well as 2 people behind us. Clearly this dude has no fucks to give and no business being in the service industry. read more

Wow. I had never heard of this place until today. Now, its my favorite sub shop. The cheese steak subs are killer good. Freshly grilled? Yes please. Freshly sliced deli meats and cheese? Yes please. Chips. Soda. Simple. Delicious. read more

I have eaten at Jersey Mike's all over the place. The glow in the competition with their sandwiches service and cleanliness. This particular location is the dirtiest location I have ever seen by far and the customer service is the worst . The Kahuna is My FAV and it was as delicious as always. This particular location wasn't busy there was one guy standing there not doing anything. instead of getting my meat going on the grill right away they waited. Until they finish the order in front of me. When I finally I was able to sit down all the tables were filthy there was debris in the corners on the floor. The tables and chairs were sticky and unclean. I recently moved here from California so I am not sure if these conditions bother others. But I have never seen a Jersey Mike's this filthy I'm actually quite surprisedthey can carry the name. read more

I like Jersey Mike's, but I'm never coming to this location again. The guy at the counter is extremely rude. He seemed more interested in his friends that were hanging out in the lobby rather than taking my simple order. read more

Love Jersey Mike's. You might pay a little more but it is worth it and their rewards program is outstanding. Best fresh sandwich shop around. read more

I live just down the road from this place and when I saw it was finished I was anxious to give it a try. My fiance and I went for lunch just after it opened and I was impressed by the interior but still decided to takeout. Their menu was easy to read and had a great variety of subs ranging from cold-cut to hot sandwiches. I decided to get their featured sub which was the Chipotle Turkey and my boy got a hot sub. I thought their bread was delicious and was surprised to see them cut the meat as they were making my sub. I'd recommend Jersey Mike's to anyone who is looking to upgrade from Subway and is bored with Jimmy John's and Cousins! read more

Last night after shopping for new cell phones my family went to Jersey Mikes. The tables were up on 1/2 the tables at 7pm last night? Made us uncomfortable especially because they don't close until 9pm. I ordered the Cheese Steak. It was just ok. The description said smothered with onions, peppers, and mushrooms. No mushrooms, 3 little pieces of peppers, and barely any onions. For the price, taste, and value. Cousins is speaking to me pretty loudly. The Cousins Cheese Steak is substantially better. I read more

Jersey Mike's is my favorite sub place by far. I just wish it wouldn't take so long to get a sub. 2 people were in front of me tonight already having their subs being made and it took about 10 minutes just to get asked what I want. I've never seen more than 2 employees work at the same time. It's a little pricier so I think they could hire another person. It tastes delicious when I get it though. read more

Great food! However the employees are another story. While they're all very friendly, they are always confused! They can't seem to grasp the thought of making a sub without it being overly complicated. Every time they ask what if like on my sub, I say no tomatoes, or onions and they ask over and over if I would like tomatoes! That needs to be fixed. I would still recommend trying out the food tho. read more

We go there at least once a week !!!!'Outstanding service !!!! WERE AN ,long long time fan !!! The food was Excellent fresh ; taste outstanding club With bacon.!!!! AWESOME PERFECT VISIT !!!!! read more

First time I was here it was fantastic. However, this time was a little disappointed. No salt or pepper or mayonnaise on it. Hate going back and having something corrected. read more

Subs are great, I love the deli style service...employees could be more friendly. Biggest knock against them is that the amount of meat on the subs seems to vary greatly. read more

First time at a Jersey Mike's and I was very happy to have made the stop. Food was great and the staff here was awesome. After we mentioned it was our first time in they were quick to make popular recommendations and were very welcoming. Too often the negative comments come through and today it was a fantastic experience. Staff was great! read more