Ordered fish and chips and waited for it for it to arrive and then to notify us that there was no tartar sauce! Super disappointed!!!

Beautiful location in St. Thomas however service was extremely slow. No one seemed to have any sense of urgency. After traveling all day, I was ready to eat and go to bed. I ordered something that seemingly should be foolproof and quick to prepare. I ordered a chicken quesadilla with no sour cream. 40 minutes later my quesadilla comes with sour cream drizzled on it. I scrape it off and proceed to take a bite. ALL TORTILLA SHELL!!! Hardly any chicken at all. How hard is it to fill a tortilla shell with the protein ordered??I sent it back and didn't dare place another order. Thankfully hubby's fish and chips were good and plentiful so he gave me some of his. Staff was not eager to serve and menus felt dirty ( no on else noticed?). My husband ordered a Pina colada which he said was good. I came back later in the week and had a nice salad with grilled shrimp which was very good. I ordered it twice during our stay. Glad I found something good since it was the only restaurant at the resort. read more

We went for dinner and had a great meal! The nachos were delicious and a large portion for four of us to split as an appetiser. The seafood chowder was tasty, the cheeseburger, and the cobb salad with chicken were all delicious too. Wayne our server was very professional and efficient. We will definitely go back! read more

When me and my wife got here it was empty maybe two tables eating we waited 10 min for the server to come and get drink orders he was very unfriendly, didn't even look at us and talking under his breath I got the burger and my wife got the chicken quesadilla it was obvious the burger was microwaved and the fries were probably from yesterday under a heat lamp it was honestly the worst burger I've ever had the quesadilla wasn't bad though none of the tvs were on it was a dead environment not fun or friendly whatsoever this was on our first day here we will be venturing off for food from now on read more

Waiting over 20 mins to be waited on before leaving. Been on island for 12 days and this was by far the worst service we experienced. Will never go back and won't recommend read more

Good was good, service was on Island Time. Ambiance was nice, great breeze and beautiful view

Staff has no desire to work or put any effort into caring about service. Food is decent if compared to middle school cafeteria food. Ambiance is good just brace yourself for the automatic 18% gratitude charge they do their best to hide. A black eye on the margaritaville experience. read more

Genuinely the absolute worst restaurant I've ever been to. The resort is fine, but the food and service at the restaurant. Service is incredibly slow with the time between sitting down and getting our order taken being around 15 minutes and the wait for food itself even longer. At one time we waited an hour and thirty minutes for our food. This ruined our whole trip with the horrible food and service. We should've gone to a different resort because this place sucks. read more

We stayed at Margaritaville and ate there several times. We feel the low ratings are unjustified. We had some of the better food here on our trip. Service was generally good and the wait staff was very pleasant. My wife had the seafood Mac and cheese and really liked it. I had the ribs and they were quite good. We both had burgers and they were very good. My advice is give it a try and ignore the bad ratings read more

Came specifically to eat while visiting the island and overall had a great experience. Drinks were yummy (Pina Colodas) and our server kept our waters filled. Our server was also sweet and pretty attentive. Food: Had the grilled chicken salad with black beans and corn, and it was delicious. Lots of grilled chicken and toppings. The fried tortilla chips were amazing, and added a fun crunch to the salad. Husband had the cheeseburger and I stole a bite and it was cooked the way he had told the waiter and was a very good burger. Fries were also yummy. Nice view on the patio overlooking the ocean, We enjoyed our lunch there. One thing to note as of the date we went they automatically add 18% gratuity to your check no matter the party size. read more

We have had ample time to check out this restaurant as well have spent over three weeks at the resort over the last 5 years. I honestly didn't think it possible for the experience to get worse. Wait times have grown to a ridiculous level. Over an hour each time for really very mid food at not mid prices. If you do have a choice, choose elsewhere. read more

No stars. Okay maybe one, but that's for the guys who drive the golf carts. Where do I start. The food and service are horrible. The staff is lazy because there's an automatic 18% tip on your check. We waited two hours for our breakfast. It was a glorified Applebees. Walk next door to the Sea and Sun restaurant just to the right of the resort as you look at the ocean. There your drinks will be half the price, the food is much better and the service is excellent. We were here for our birthdays and had fun because we're fun people. We did our best to make everyone laugh. We did like sitting on our deck and reading. Sapphire Beach was nice but gets crowded because of the cruise ships. Magens Bay was nice but it's $16 to get in with a car and two people. You'll still need to rent chairs. The best day we had was off St. Thomas. We took a ferry to St John, had a great breakfast when we got off the ferry then went to Maho Bay beach for the day. You take a taxi which costs $12 each way. Next trip, I'd go to St John's. Definitely never setting foot on this resort! read more

Nice vacation resort in St Thomas. Great time, 2 pools, restaurant and bar near the pools, employee driven golf cart to get around. Store on the resort. Vans to take you to beaches. Close to Coki Beach and Red Hook. read more

See all

Food is mediocre. Rooms are great! Perfect view and clean! There are two nice pools with bars and plenty of good restaurants near! There is a store where you can rent chairs and get beach gear. Plenty of taxis available out front! read more

See all

This was solely a "meh" experience for me. After traveling all day and never had time to eat at the airport, we were starving coming here. The waitress was nice and helpful; she recommended the Turkey Club, and my drink (I forgot what it was called) had Cruzan Rum, Mango, Pineapple Juice, & sour blend in it & became one of my favorite drinks on this trip. We waited over an hour for our food while our group that was separated into different tables received theirs before us and finished, while we STILL had yet to receive our food. The sandwich was good, but definitely not worth the hefty price tag it carried. The drinks came in a small plastic cup and were $11, of course I expect that going to a tourist drawing restaurant.. Let alone an island where everything in price is higher. We were a charged for the plastic cups, silverware, & plates that are thrown away afterwards. Understandably because of COVID, but that was a first for me. Kinda sad about throwing away a lot of plastic on the island. Our ticket was $90 for 2 plates of food & 3 drinks for two people, and they added the gratuity on there...but we didn't catch that until after we gave an extra nice tip. Wish we seen that earlier. My experience was toward the end of 2020, so maybe things are different. read more

Jimmy Buffets Margaritaville Restaurant - Rum, Mango, Pineapple, Sour Blend - New American Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

We love Margaritaville the Resort, but the restaurant in St Thomas is horrible. The smell is unbearable, the food is indigestible, and the Service is so slow. The servers are rude and while you spend and hour waiting for a cheeseburger they are busy talking and joking around with the manager Toya. Order Senor Pizza or walk to Chester's Chicken! read more

Decided to catch a quick bite after a sunset tour from the area. We were happily surprised with the food and service. We were seated immediately and our waitress came to our table right away. I ordered the Fish tacos: they came with a side of seaweed salad and avocado. They were tasty and filling. I washed them down with a frozen bushwacker. Parking is available on site and free They have a few resident cats that love a little bit of your food as a snack read more

See all

Food was typical bar food. Service slow ambiance is great with the views Hubby had fish tacos said were pretty good I had a chicken quesadilla a little skimpy on cheese and chicken. Ordered the strawberry lemonade that was terrible Tasted like strawberry syrup with a little lemonade. Couldn't drink it and let them know they didn't take. It off the tab Disappointed read more

The view here was beautiful-right on the beach. The food was good. The plates come out super hot so watch out for that!They serve an excellent margarita-best I've had on this trip. Both outside and inside seating available. We went at lunchtime...toddler and family friendly. There is a kid's menu. Casual. Located in Margaritaville Vacation Club by Wyndham. Just let the attendant at the gate know you are going to the restaurant. read more

See all

There are several things to review in this listing. Margaritaville has a restaraunt, bar and seperate coffee shop/ snack shop. I am sure that the atmosphere of tjeir restaraunt is probably the same at all outlets. It is low key and did not feel any different than most sportsbars. I had anticipared more of an island party feel. We went to eat here and drink at the bar several times. We enjoyed ourselves but went there more to chill than party. The food was typical bar food. Some items were inconsistent. The greens in the salad were one time soft and wilted the next fresh and crisp. The nachos were good and filling ( a gut bomb) the ribs were tender and flavourful but could have been considered overcooked. Our experience at the bar was also good. Of course the pina coladas, margaritas and other frozen drinks were all great. However drink strength varied on different days. Prices were comparable to the US mainland. I was a little upset to learn that all tabs have an added gratuity of 18 % listed as a service charge and I had been adding a 20% gratuity on top of that. My fault for not reading everything on the cheque. But no one offered the information when i added the extra gratuity. Some of the inconsistencies could be due to the fact that produce is shipped in. Also staff changes were noticable in the 3 times we went to the bar there was a totaly dfferent crew working. This may also be true in the kitchen. read more

See all

I really want to give them more stars but it's terrible. Came just after opening on Sunday but had to wait to be seated as they were trying to stagger the seating. During the wait for a table I started reading other reviews and saw a pattern. People complaining about slow service and slow food. Well...they were right. After finally being seated and placing our order as quickly as we could we started "the wait". After 30 mins I asked where our food was. Our server assured me it would be right out. 15 mins later her update was that it would just be another minute. Finally after a total of just under an hour we got our burgers and salads. We quickly scarfed them down so we could head to the airport. Having been to other Margaritaville's across the mainland I can assure you this one is missing the mark on quality. Nothing special in their burgers here and definitely not worth the effort. read more

See all

Another 1st on my trip home. I'm glad they were open even with a limited menu. We enjoyed a delicious Father's Day meal on the patio. There is nothing to say because the photos speak for themselves. However... I ordered the wings as an appetizer because I love chicken. They were delicious and my parents also enjoyed them. My parents ordered the 2 sandwiches pictured. After eating a couple wings, they had to share one and take home the other. They were each a nice size. My Margarita Pasta with chicken was AMAZING!!!! Very flavorful with a scrumptious cream sauce, enough chicken and lots of pasta. This was certainly a dish for 2. I'm proud I didn't stuff myself. This, I'm sure, is a favorite. We saved room for dessert so my dad ordered the flourless chocolate cake. Kudos to the chef. Very decadent. It was more than enough for the 3 of us to share. I'm so glad I got to experience the food and relaxing atmosphere of Margaritaville. The ribs another table ordered have me wanting to get back soon. read more

See all

We stopped in for just drinks during the week. The bartender was friendly and the view was AMAZING. The drink prices were decent - $10 per drink! We didn't have any issues here. We will be back! read more

Jimmy Buffets Margaritaville Restaurant - Bar view - New American Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

This was a planned outing due to the fact that my sister works here. I was able to fine on the deck feet away from the water as most in door seating is reserved for larger groups due to COVID. It was a cool and quiet nite and I had a great dining experience. The drinks were good. I had a few Painkillers and a Dark and Stormy. I had the Calamari as an appetizer and the Lobster Mac n Cheese as my main. They were both outstanding and I would definitely try them again. The view can't be explained as you are literally on the beach. read more

Jimmy Buffets Margaritaville Restaurant - Calamari - New American Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Jimmy Buffet's Margaritaville Restaurant & Beach Bar at the Margaritaville Vacation Club by Wyndham Resort of the Virgin Islands in St Thomas Island is an awesome place to unwind while enjoying a large array of amazing tropical frozen cocktails, listening to tropical Jimmy Buffet vacation themed island music, surrounded by Jimmy Buffet wall art, incredible Jimmy Buffet theming with beautiful views of the beach and nice views of the huge wrap around resort pool, a buzz with people having a great time! Jimmy Buffet's Margaritaville Restaurant has seperate breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus, offering resort patrons with a large variety of different food options. The Mahi Mahi Burger came with grilled blackened Mahi Mahi, coleslaw, tomatoes, Cajun remoulade sauce, with fries and a side garden salad. The side garden salad was a much bigger portion size than u was expecting and the Cajun remoulade sauce tasted tangy and complimented the burger perfectly! 9/10 The Turkey Club Sandwich came with layers of sliced turkey, stacked high with Swiss cheese, smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo with a side of fries. 8/10 Pain Killer Frozen Cocktail 10/10 Pina Colada Frozen Cocktail 10/10 Bushwacker Frozen Cocktail 9/10 Tango Mango 8/10 Loco Mango Margarita 9/10 5 o'clock Somewhere 9/10 License to Chill Margarita 9/10 Amazing Tropical Signature Drink options included Pain Killer, Bushwacker, 5 o'clock somewhere, Why dont we get drunk, Hurricane, Cruzan Confusion, Strawberry Chill, Breezin Pina Colada, Tango Mango, Banana Me Crazy, Don't Stop the Carnival, Strawberry Margarita, Loco Mango Margarita, Manna Banana Margarita, Who's to Blame Margarita, Perfect Margarita, Gold Cadillac Margarita, License to Chill Margarita, Havanas Banana, Incommunicado, Bahama Mama, & Island Farewell. The Poolside bar service staff was so friendly, skilled, and such a life saver! If you're visiting the Virgin Islands, definitely visit Jimmy Buffet's Margaritaville Restaurant & Beach Bar at the Margaritaville Vacation Club by Wyndham Resort! read more

See all

Happy hour is superb - 2 for 1 drinks from 4-6. Calamari was tasty. View is nice for sure. Just don't stray from the deck. The beach is in terrible condition and they don't seem to be doing anything to keep it clean or prevent it from deteriorating more. Also, they automatically add gratuity to everything so watch out. read more

See all

Great spot right on the beach - food is reasonably priced, fresh and delicious! We loved the Lava Lava Shrimp, Seafood Max and Cheese, Cheeseburger, the Caribbean Shrimp Salad, and the turkey club! read more

See all

Came here first night at the resort, having been to other locations before where I had good experiences, but not here! This was terrible, slow service, no friendly welcomes, bland overpriced food and drinks, waitress came by twice, once to take order and drop bill off.. had to go flag other people down since we couldn't find her after food came despite our efforts to flag her down for condiments and drinks. Ok, thought just maybe a weird night, stopped in 3 nights later (tonight) and after 25 min of sitting down and nobody coming over realized it was just how bad this place is. Safe your money and go anywhere else. Drive to a restaurant or The short walk to the restaurant to the right of this place is worth the money. Walking back from it tonight ran into a dozen other margaritaville customers walking over having all sat down with zero service. Not sure how this restaurant stays in business. read more

This place was such a pleasant surprise for us (food wise) when we were staying here!! It literally surpassed some of the $$$ and $$$$ dining we had in St.Thomas. But one thing common of all places is the service we received on the island. They don't care about giving good service for tourists so be prepared for crappy service. The FOOD THOUGH- amazing. We ate here multiple times the whole entire weekend we stayed at Margaritaville. The crab cakes was my FAVE, the mango pico that came with it was fire. Their calamari is great, the quesadillas were good, had the Caribbean jerk wings also which were awesome, the frozen margaritas were also very tasty!! We also had breakfast here lol, it was decent and you get some nice breeze and views in the morning! Overall decent experience here, if you don't pay attention to the lack luster service :) read more

See all

If I could give this bar less than 1 star, I would. Jimmy Buffet would be disappointed. The service is awful, the wait staff appears annoyed with your business, it takes way too long to get a drink from the bar and the food is mediocre at best. The beach views are honestly not great either. Would not recommend this bar/ restaurant to anyone. read more

Extremely slow service. Took almost 2 hours to get our food. The table next to us said the same thing and all they ordered was a salad. Food mediocre at best. read more

This is probably on my list as worst customer service ever at a restaurant, HOWEVER, the food is amazing. (From what we tried). Both times I went, I got the grilled mahi mahi, and I highly reccomend it. (If you're a veggie lover, because 50% of the dish is veggies) My boyfriend got a burger the first time and the second time got a jerk burger, which is his new fav. Tip is included in the bill automatically which may have something to do with the service. If you can ignore the not so welcoming employees, they do have some pretty yummy food. read more

Jimmy Buffets Margaritaville Restaurant - Grilled mahi mahi - New American Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Well sorry to say this was the worst dinner ever. HEATHER the manager was the worst ever. The pictures are of a salad I ordered and as you can see it's old lettuce and spinach. When we sent it back Heather came back and in her exact words "the lettuces is cut fresh every day when we open so I won't be replacing the salad". Now there is not going you can lose from curing a lettuce to serve fresh to a guest. We requested to speak to the chef and he made himself unavailable but we saw him walk out for plastic bags for a to go order. I would NEVER recommend this place to anyone with such service. Its during COVID times where the amount of guests are low and you have more of a 1 to 1 with your guest and this is what we had to experience. On the good side the server was awesome. She made us feel welcomed and treated us great. read more

Jimmy Buffets Margaritaville Restaurant - Cobb salad - New American Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all