Every Memorial Day we like to seek out new hot dog places to kick off Memorial Day. We went with the Italian combo of hot dog and sausage. **warning** come hungry! I got the single combo with hot dog and hot Italian sausage, onions, potatoes and peppers. I told them I didn't care for the green, so they gave me red only. It was comfort food to the max! Delish, but I couldn't eat the whole thing. Took some sausage and potatoes for later. Hubby got the double which was too much food for one human but he used a fork to eat the potatoes, onions and peppers and work his way down to the meat. The people were super friendly and accommodating. Basic setting with no frills, but simply delicious food. They also have American style hot dogs and plenty of sides, but we will have to come back for that another time. read more

See all

I have wanted to come here for forever and finally had the chance to. As soon as we walked in we were greeted by the gentleman behind the counter. My boyfriend soadbhebahs been there for years. He was very nice and attentive. I've never had an Italian hit dog before so this was the day. I ordered a single one and bean was that enough. My boyfriend ordered a double veggie and it was huge. I'm so glad we didn't order a side of fries. My sandwich was loaded with potatoes. It is definitely an interesting combination that I never wouid have come up with on my own. The hot dog itself had snap, the roll was soft, the onions and peppers were soft and the potatoes were cooked perfectly. I'll definitely be back but I think I will just have a plain dog next time. read more

See all

Just had this for lunch today, I've never been to Kenilworth before, but its food has already impressed me. Food : I end up ordering an American hotdog, which was practically as good as Rutts Hut, which surprised me. They also had some amazing curly fries and sold C&C soda! Aesthetic : classic hot dog / burger spot. Simple and clean, nothing more. Service : I unfortunately, did not catch the name of the woman who worked up at front, but she was very nice and kind to every single person that walked in including myself. It's definitely the place that seems like a hometown favorite and I definitely intend on coming back here sometime in the future. read more

See all

Long time costumer, not happy with the different types of food not handy cap friendly

Jimmy buff classic double with everything is my go too... 9 outta 10..the food product never fails with flavor, explosions, juicy potatoes, spicy sausage, and a great hotdog dog snap.., unfortunately, in this location in Kenilworth, the gentleman behind the counter was very dead with emotion ordering wasn't fun or pleasant. The ambience. Was dead, almost like people were afraid to smile. Such a big place with an empty heart good thing the food made up for the day. I just had to take mines to go. Great pictures on wall , great history.. read more

I was in the neighborhood, and since I had been familiar with this place for a while, I decided to give it a try. I got the mixed sandwich called Matty's special with the works. It was good, it had all the different things in it. It came in a giant bread with tons of mixed meats, which are combined with various flavors (hot dog, Italian sausage, ham, cheese steak, etc.), topped with green peppers, potatoes, onions, etc. It was nice. I just ate most of the inside and some bread with a fork and a knife. I don't know how one will eat that whole sandwich in one sitting. The price of the sandwich was around $17, which is very reasonable for the amount of food provided. The person behind the counter provided me with good service and was friendly. The ambiance of the place was clean, but there wasn't much to mention in terms of decorations. They had some historical pictures of the place. Try it if you're looking for a nice Italian-style sandwich. I saw this on TV and others, and I finally got to try it; it was decent with good food. Satisfied. read more

See all

In the heart of downtown Kenilworth, NJ is Jimmy Buff's, a hot dog emporium originally from Newark that has been slinging popular sandwich sausages since 1932. So, although something of a drive from Bucks County, when the urge for a frankfurter struck, I chose Jimmy Buff's to scratch my itch. I love Italian hot dogs from my days in Trenton (Casino Dogs). It was on the menu, and that's where I went. The restaurant looked like a typical pizza shop; clean with tables and booths along the walls and ordering done at the cashier in back. But, no tomato pie here, just a long list of toppings for the dogs. I had a choice of one or two at the base of the creation, followed by a mix of sautéed onions and peppers, topped with a load of thin sliced potatoes grilled in XV olive oil. It was all stuffed into a pizza dough pita and wrapped in aluminum foil to hold the heat. Although the hot dog looked thinner than the Hebrew Nationals I have at home, and was deep fried rather than boiled, it was a tremendous delicious fun meal for a Saturday afternoon. The round coins of potato were slightly crisp on the outside and soft within, lightly salted and black peppered. Just excellent. The onion and pepper mix was pleasantly savory, although there should have been a better balance of the two. The hot dog itself was well garliced and had a good bite sound. Service was friendly and patient with my first visit decisions. Serena and Tom answered questions and engaged warmly with me. All in all, a strong and inviting first experience. But for the distance, I would become a regular. read more

See all

The food here is great. Well worth the visit. The ambiance is no frills which is fine because you come for the food. I can't wait to go back. read more

Haven't been to Jimmy's since we moved, walked in today and got the Monday special $5 cheesesteak single. WOW! I will definitely drive back for this on a Monday!! And of course the Italian hot dogs, and everything else on the menu. Crew was super friendly and the tables were all clean. Must try, if you're in the area. read more

I just walked in today with my girlfriend, and walked up to the counter to oder--there was a young angry dude with a chip on his shoulder, who just stared at us when we walked up--no "hi what can I get you?" or any greeting whatsoever for that matter. Teach your staff to be friendly and courteous to patrons--it would make the experience so much more enjoyable. read more

I've tried jimmy buff in east Hanover over 10 years ago. I didn't really like it because it's a big vat of oil cooking all the hot dogs, potatoes, and veggies. the bread soaks up all the oil and it's a big greasy mess. I tried this location with a work place associate so he can check it off his bucket list. the food was the same as experienced. it just not my type of food anymore. I have to watch my salt and cholesterol :( the guy taking the orders. he should try voice acting. if you know you know. CC accepted and bathroom is clean. plenty of street parking. if needed a big shared lot nearby. read more

Jimmy Buff's - chili - Hot Dogs Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

See all

If it's not broken don't change it!! They understand the concept and have been making the best Italian cheeseburger and hotdogs for years. Bread is always fresh and soft. Potatoes cooked well. Peppers and onions seasoned well. The guys there are amazing as well. read more

Jimmy Buff's - Hot Dogs Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

This was my first time here and it was really good. The service was quick, and the food was seasoned well & big portions!! read more

See all

Waited for over 10 minutes, no one was in restaurant, then get two out of five burnt chicken fingers and ask for two regular ones, well I finished all my other food and stood around 10 minutes nothing ever came and told them never mind I need to leave and the guy behind the counter had a smart remark to say!! NEVER AGAIN LOST MY BUSINESS!! read more

Great hot dogs especially with chili and cheese. Friendly staff and quick service. Ample seating, but not the cleanest restaurant. Other than that, very good. read more

J B's, an iconic hot dog emporium that makes one helluvagood Italian hotdog. A delicious soft roll similar in shape to a half pita bread but thicker, and much more tasty with a sabrett hotdog, smothered in fried potatoes, onions, and peppers. The potatoes are soft, perfectly fried, along with the peppers, and make this heaven on a bun. Come get some. read more

Fabulous. Had the Italian Hot Dog Double, and an order of Zucchini sticks. So, I have lunch for tomorrow too.

They were out of spicy sausage so I took a pass on that. Got 2 normal dogs and they were good. Not DWD and no snap, but flavor was nice and the buns were super soft. Overall a decent dog when in the area. read more

See all

First time visitor to the Original Jimmy Buff. The originator of Italian Style sandwiches. Ok they say so. I do not know!!! But what I do know is if you want a really good Italian Hot sausage sandwich. Make your way to Jimmy buffs. The hot sausage was really favorable tasty. And you will find yourself wanting some more bread. The bread is soft and firm if you can understand what I am writing. To say you will not be disappointed is an understatement. The place is very clean,warm and welcoming. The counter lady was all smiles and friendly. Bathroom equally as clean. This is easy to get to off the parkway. Street parking in the front which at11:30am was easy to get. There is additional parking in the back. I'm very sure they need it at these prices. Definitely to be continued because I will be back. read more

See all

So I've been wanting to go to Jimmy buffs pretty much my whole life because my grandma talked about it all the time. She ate there growing up in the 30s and 40s all the way till the 70s when she moved away to Florida. She went to the original location in Newark, which I think is closed down. I finally found my way there. The restaurant was clean and They had a typical menu of hotdogs, hamburgers, chicken, fingers, fries, etc. We ordered an Italian dog and a double Italian dog with a side of onion rings and a cup of chili with cheese. The Italian hotdog is served in a roll made out of pizza dough topped with fried onions, peppers and potatoes. The bread was very soft, which was surprising because I expected it to be crusty on the outside like pizza, but it was still good. The hotdog was extremely tasty as it was fried and oil so you can't go wrong with anything fried of course! however, my dog was missing peppers. I only had a few onions and tons of potatoes. It was more like I was eating a potato sandwich with a little bit of hotdog and onions in it. My dad got peppers in his but he also thought there was way too many potatoes his and we both picked off quite a few potatoes. Onion rings we're good, large and crunchy. The chili was very uneventful. It tasted like hot dog chili that you get out of a can. The cheese was a slice of American cheese cut in half laid on top. Overall, the hotdog was tasty, but I definitely wouldn't go out of my way to eat there again. Maybe in my grandma's day it was a lot better! read more

See all

I could not wait to write this review. I've been a customer for over 60 years as I would frequent the other Jimmy Buffs located in West Orange. They were absolutely fantastic as all of their sandwiches were great. The Jimmy Buffs in Kenilworth should follow the same methods for food prep as the other one. I ordered a single chicken cheese sandwich. My wife had the single veggie sandwich. First of all, the bread was a soggy mess and failed to hold the potatoes, peppers and onions. The chicken sandwich had a thin slice of chicken cutlet that tasted old and rancid. The cheese on the sandwich appeared to be imitation cheese (Kraft food cheese). The peppers and onions were not sliced appropriately as their sizes were too thick and clumpy, thus giving the appearance that minimal to no effort was made in selecting them and slicing. Also, they were overcooked and had no crunch. The white onions they used were tasteless and slimy (red onions would have been better). The potatoes were excessive and overwhelmed the sandwich to such a degree that I barely noticed the chicken. The whole ratio of chicken to potatoes to onions and peppers were insultingly OFF. Both sandwiches were haphazardly thrown together. THIS PLACE IS GIVING JIMMY BUFFS A BAD NAME. THEY SHOULD CLOSE FOR A MONTH AND HAVE THE OTHER JIMMY BUFFS IN WEST ORANGE TRAIN THEIR COOKS. The only good thing about this place is that they offer parking in the back and their bathroom is clean. I will not patronage this place anymore as they seem to be going straight down the toilet. I really wanted to like this place. read more

Used to go to the West Orange location for Italian hot dogs for my evening job. Returned there recently and the food is still good. Now there's a second location in Kenilworth, which is closer to home with a comfortable sit down space. The service is good: both via online and in person. read more

So my DennisBernard.com, client was leaving after three days to go back to New Orleans through Newark Liberty. She asked me if we could go back to Dicky Dee's like we did arriving. Pressed for time I suggested Jimmy Buff's Kennelworth and we stopped. I had my usual double dog mustard on the bottom, potatoes, onions, peppers and ketchup on top and it was perfect as usual. My client was amazed loving hers as she did the Dicky Dee's stating she wants to come again soon to New Jersey for another. read more

Finally got to try this place. I called in and they require you to order and pay over the phone. It cost about $7 for the two hot dogs. They do this so you can just pick up and go. The man that took my order was really nice and informative. Only street parking is available. When I got there all I had to do was tell the man my name and they had my food packed and ready. When I got home I dug in and the chili dog was ok. The hot dog with kraut and relish was really good. It wasn't too much or too sloppy. I will be back. read more

See all

It's great. It's Jimmy Buff's, been making Italian hot dogs for how many years? 90 plus!! Why people order anything but the Italian sandwiches is beyond me. A great sandwich, made on great bread, with quality hotdogs and sausage. Plus the potatoes, onions and peppers. Delicious! Wish I lived closer so I could have them more often. Can't wait to be back in the area for another. I recommend the combo, some hotdog, some sausage. A marriage made for a sandwich. Go get one! (or two!) read more

Jimmy Buff's - Hot Dogs Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

First time visiting and it was pretty good. Service was quick as we went early on a Saturday. I could imagine this place gets packed quickly. I tried the combo which is a hot dog, italian sausage with potatoes. Flavorful indeed. We also ordered onion rings. Next time I am in the area I will make sure to stop by to try more on the menu! read more

Had the worst double hotdog ever!! The cook here should really go take notes from the Jimmy Buff's in Orange New Jersey!! So disappointing after waiting so long to be back home again. The Founder of this great establishment would be disappointed as well. read more

I've been a Jimmy Buff's fan since I was a kid living in Irvington...That shop had the signed photo's of Rocky Marciano and Sunday mornings had the group of senior Italians with their fedoras sitting around their favorite table while the cook sweated over the hot oil serving up mammoth sandwiches that have no peers. The Kenilworth location is upholding the tradition!! Vegetarians and vegans are warned to stay away... ;-) read more

I remember Jimmy Buffs when I lived in Scotch Plains and it was next to Bowcraft. I loved it back then so I figured I would get some for my kids to try. Just in case you've been living under a rock for the past...idk....80 years or not living in New "Joisey" (haha) you may not be familiar with Jimmy Buff's. They are a hot dog establishment founded in 1932 in Newark- you guessed it- NJ. If you're even vaguely familiar with an Italian hotdog, then Jimmy Buff's is technically not a stranger to you, even if you've never been there. The reason being- they are the original inventors of this famous sandwich. It's their creation of hotdogs, fried onions, green peppers and potatoes inside an Italian pizza roll that has garnered them worldwide attention. Jimmy Buff's has been featured on food channel after food channel and named the "20 best hotdogs in the U.S." by Yahoo Food. Looking at the menu, I was surprised to see so many new favorites that I wasn't previously familiar with. The Jimmy Buff's I remember only served hotdogs but some newer sandwiches versions were on the menu like hamburgers, sausage, steak and even veggie! I ordered a combination hotdog & sausage sandwich for my daughter and a hamburger sandwich for my son. I chatted a bit with the man behind the counter who was both friendly and funny. He seems like he enjoys his job. :-) Each sandwich was around $10 and change and if the whole sandwich was too large, You have the option of choosing a half for a few bucks less. In my case, I know my kids can eat AND I knew they'd love Jimmy Buff's! So ordering the whole sandwich was a no-brainer. I brought the sandwiches home and just as I expected, they were a hit! Those sandwiches were devoured in no time. I will certainly come back to Jimmy Buffs; only next time, in addition to ordering the meat sandwiches, I'll order myself a veggie sandwich. Btw, if you don't live in Jersey, you're still in luck. Jimmy Buffs actually ships nationwide. You can check their website for ready-made meal kits complete with all the fixins to find out more info. read more

See all

Drove by this place a few times and decided to finally try it. Had a regular chili and cheese dog and a red hot with the same. The regular dog was ok and the chili could use a little something extra but is good. The star to me was the red hot which had a good snap and nice heat to it. read more

Jimmy Buff's - Regular chili cheese and a red-hot with chili and cheese. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

Bought a single veg and a single chicken. The peppers and onions were over cooked. The potatoes were not peeled thus, resulting in a chewy tough exterior skin. However, the the potatoes were over cooked. The whole sandwich was one big soggy mess that required dissecting just to eat. I think I'm done with this place. I'll just make my own sandwiches. I can do better even when severely intoxicated. read more

Excellent stop for some great burgers and dogs. Cheese potatoes are out of this world!!! Great service and reasonable prices!

Just as I remember as a kid growing up in Newark best Italian hot dogs peepers and onions on that split roll

I know what you're thinking, "5-stars...for a hot dog joint?". This place isn't JUST a hot-dog joint. They make a mean Italian Hot Dog Pita with potatoes fried to perfection. You can tell them to go easy too, so that it's not so overwhelming, but I opt to just through any overage on the plate and eat 'em separate with ketchup. I enjoy a good chili and that's what I use to distinguish one place from another or a stand-out hot-dog spot. Jimmy invented the Italian hot dog in Newark and the site is still there. He is the OG and Jimmy Buff's in Kenilworth and West Orange make it the same way to this day. Joe was at the counter serving us with great hospitality and a gentle attitude. Some places might make you feel rushed, but not here, he was great to both myself and my wife. The place looks very old fashioned and I REALLY cherish this environment. I want to be taken back in time when I sit down and this place will help you feel a little of the past. Head on in, there's something on the menu for everyone. read more

Went to Jimmy Buffs an all time favorite of my childhood in Irvington but it definitely wasn't what I remember or expected. Don't remember ever paying $10 for a double Italian hotdog. So we ordered via the phone and ordered 2 double Italian hotdogs 1 with just ketchup and onions and the other with mustard, ketchup and onions. NO PEPPERS. Pay the $21, get our order and drive 40 mins home and open up the sandwiches and low and behold the 1st on has mustard (which shouldn't had any mustard) and a little ketchup on the top of the potatoes. The 2nd had the same thing which was ok but BOTH had PEPPERS which we clearly told the guy on the phone. Wasn't like it was busy and don't know how he got it wrong. If I was closer to them I would have brought them back. 2nd they had way too many onions and not enough potatoes. Again not the way I remember them making it in Upper Irvington. As much as I like Jimmy Buffs I may have to stick with Dicky D's when I'm in the area. read more

Jimmy Buff's - Double Italian Hotdog with way too many onions and not enough potatoes - Hot Dogs Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

Don't see what's the hype about. Wasn't horrible but wasn't spectacular either. I had the chili with cheese dog.

Yes, I did try Jimmy buffs and it was delicious. I enjoyed it and I will be back again. I had the red hot double dog with the peppers and onions the ketchup, the bread was nice and soft. The potatoes were cut round and circle. I enjoyed it. And I will go back again. read more

I haven't had jimmy buffs in 10 years, I got the craving on Sunday on my way back from the American mall and just had to stop. I was absolutely amazed how immaculate this restaurant is. The people were kind and friendly. Ordered an Italian hotdog and a chicken steak with the works. They were both fresh delicious and just excellent in every possible way. Still the best Italian hot dog in the tri-state area. read more

The hot dogs are good...BUT I wait 30mins for 3 hot dogs and fries! Ridiculous They were friendly read more

Great Italian Dog with Rick. Must go to if in the area, get the hot pepper relish on the side