Consistently missing items on delivery and pick up orders. Sometimes I call and sometimes I order online, but almost every time there are items missing. Mayo packets and chips are the common missing items. It's annoying that someone takes my order correctly (I can see it all rang in on the receipt) but no one is checking the order before they staple it closed. read more

I dont have a jimmy johns so when i came to OHIO IT WAS DEFINITELY ON MY LIST GOOD EATS! And when i say me and my one year old tore that sandwich dowwwwwn!!! I miss jimmy johns so much! Plus you can never go wrong with the barbecue and jalapeño chips, they are must grabs! But those kickin ranch chips literally tase like salty sunflower seeds and i wasnt feeling it! My service was amazing considering i literally got to jimmy johns 2 mins before closing! But the attitudes and energy were still good! Which i really appreciated! read more

Jimmy John's - KICKIN" RANCH CHIPS - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Delivered the wrong sandwich, called asked for the right one, the lady on the phone said okay and hung up .. 30 minutes later nothing had been delivered, I called them and they said they never made it and didn't plan on it when I said that's awful service I hate to leave a bad review but this really calls for it so other people know about the awful customer service at the pickerington location, the manager responded "oh well we get bad reviews everyday".. read more

Walked in and they had no bread just sliced wheat that looks like wonder bread kinda wild

Super great customer service! Bent over backwards to make our order when we accidentally placed it for the wrong day. Will recommend to everyone! read more

First tried this place in Kansas City and became an instant fan. Since then, it's one of my favorite sub shops and a frequent order of mine while working in Hebron. I started with the largest, the JJ Gargantuan and find it hard to deviate when I visit. I did have the tuna sandwich, which was delicious, but I have have trouble ordering something I can make at home. Give me the JJG! I'm a bread eater and I can't resist their fresh-baked French bread. It "chews" perfectly and truly compliments the meats within. They're definitely one-up on the other sandwich shops in this category. They also have an incredible gourmet cookie in their Oatmeal Raisin. Soft and yummy, dude. You HAVE to get one. read more

See all

This is our favorite Jimmy Johns locations due to the fact that every-time we order here the order is always correct. They always put the meat to the end of the bun and the topping are always exactly how you order them. The constancy is the key to a great rating for us. We normally order around 1-2 times a week due to the kids sports schedule. We keep coming back and will continue to utilize this location. The staff is always super friendly and they always know that when I come in I order a loaf of bread and a side of bacon for our oldest so. This was an odd order at first but they always accommodate me since he is a super picky eater. Definitely a go to location if you're ever in the area. My other favorite thing is that all of their veggies are fresh/local and they cut their meet fresh. Perfect! read more

Quick service but not my type of sub. Went with friends and had the Italian sub.,The bun was soft and fresh and the flavor was okay. It would be nice if they offered a 4 inch sub as well. Nothing to exciting about this place. read more

Jimmy John's - menus and prices - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Ever had that feeling the food here isn't as good as it could be? That the store itself isn't as clean as it could be, or that the staff wasn't as welcoming as they could be? We'll it's probably because it wasn't as good as it could be. I've seen first hand how this store is run, what kind of people manage and prepare the food here. I've witnessed workers pick food off the ground and use it, or be in the back washing dishes, then just throw on gloves to start prep without washing their hands. I've seen them use only cold water for washing dishes, and a bunch of bleach marks all over the tubs they use for holding food. If you take off the nozzles on the soda machine, there's black mold that the workers refuse to clean on a daily basis. The slicer has a thick layer of green old grease that the workers clean with only cold water. The slicer smells like old grease and metal, and I've seen the workers not clean down the machine inbetween slicing different meats. I've seen the manager cuss at his coworkers on the clock, I've seen the GM saying derogatory comments about women that come in to buy food, and I've heard the workers say things like "since when did we start caring about people?" Do yaself a favor and look for literally any other sub place, or even another Jimmy John's in the area, and avoid this one. The people working/managing do not have the decency to try and do the bare minimum in a food service environment. read more

Unfriendly staff tonight and stale breadth top it off. Found all this out after driving home and hoping for good food. Lesson to check food before you leave. read more

Friend of mine told me how good the sandwiches were so wanted to give them a try. I'm a real fan of Subway, this did not change my mind. The service was freaky fast. The sandwich was freaky boring. Nothing that I couldn't make at home. The bread was just Ok. It was fresh, and toppings were also fresh, but still not up to the level of Subways bread and toppings. They do not deliver to my neighborhood, they only offer one kind of bread and do not toast or heat the sandwich. Ii see no reason to return. read more

Awful experience.. I ordered Jimmy Johns through doordash but apparently they have their own drivers. I specifically put "HAND IT TO ME". My neighborhood is not the best and people take and break things here all the time so I never have food "left on the porch". Nobody handed me anything and they said they knocked. I didn't hear anything and at the very least they could've called. And again if they did leave it on the porch it was definitely stolen and wouldn't have been a first time that's happened in my neighborhood. So they clearly didn't follow direction. They tried to tell me they delivered my order twice after I called in about the first order not being received. Mind you I ordered around 5:30pm and didn't receive my food until an hour later. Yet of course I didn't receive my drink I ordered either. They coped an attitude with me on the phone when I tried to explain the situation too. AWFULL.... Only nice thing I have to say is the driver that finally got me my food at least apologized and was nice about it. read more

Really enjoyed my sub! The employees were friendly and fast. If you are in a hurry and want amazing food this is the stop! One thing is certain: I will be back! read more

Not Freaky Fast! How do you run out of bread during lunch rush? I was told they were out of bread and it would take 15 mins for it to come out of the oven. I went back to my car and waited 15mins. When I came back in they told me that it still wasn't out of the oven and when it comes out of the oven it has to cool down another 15 mins before they can make sandwiches with it! Very frustrating! read more

Me and my family went to Jimmy Johns for lunch at 1:30. We walked in to order and they were out of bread! How does a sandwich place make sandwiches with no bread??? Very disappointing. We went to Subway instead. I am pretty sure they will have bread. read more

This Jimmy Johns is great however ordering from the website is misleading to those not real familiar with the menu. But that's corporates fault and corporate expects corporate fault problems to be reimbursed by the franchisee which isn't right. And I wouldn't expect. read more

One of my favorite JJ's to go to. Customer service is always on point and their subs are delicious. Staff is friendly and helpful

Love your sandwiches but this location is run by a bunch of rude kids. If your to go bags and napkins are "self-serve" perhaps take them out from behind the counter. This might help with your staff's rude remarks and customer confusion. read more

Can I just say, I love this location! Great service, always get the orders right, but their delivery is anything but freaky fast. I've had fast delivery from jimmy Johns. And considering this one is just down the street, the delivery time was called into question. But if the food was right, that's not really important to me. read more

This is the first Jimmy Johns I've ever had and I love it! The subs are definitely filling and delicious. I always go in and order but they do have "freaky fast" delivery! It's safe to say that this is my go to when I want a sub. read more

Love this place. Service always fast and friendly. It's always clean and of course, the food is always great. Vito on multi-grain is amaaaazing. read more

Very glad you all decided to find a place in Pickerington! We used to drive to the one downtown so when I saw the sign I was elated. My husband loves the Pepe and I usually get the Vito. Meat and condiments are always fresh. Love the crisp shredded lettuce and your Italian dressing is great! Hope Pickerington embraces you!!! read more

A basic sandwich and sub shop that delivers. The fixings are fresh, the delivery is quick. What is not to love.

Oir favorite sub shop. The service is always SUPER fast. My subs have always been made right and usually before I have time to pay and fill my drink. Check out the optional free toppings. I love the tuna with added sprouts, cucumber, and onion. The jalapeno chips are pretty tasty, too. read more

Went to order from Jimmy Johns and was told my neighborhood is no longer available for delivery I live in Pickerington don't understand that at all. No explanation. I ordered from them last month with no issues what's up with this Jimmy Johns? read more

I have eaten at many Jimmy John's and have always been impressed with how fresh everything was until I ate at the Pickerington Jimmy John's. The bread was so stale I couldn't even bite into it. The tomatoes were mushy and the lettuce was dark green and slimy. This is the second time I have been there and the second time I have been burned. I threw them away they were so bad. 14 bucks I won't get back. Called for the manager and the girl who answered yelled "who wants to be the manager". Fool me once, you know, twice I am just an idiot to ever go back. Too bad as they are a great franchise. read more