I was out exploring the darling Broad Ripple neighborhood this past Tuesday, hunting for a proper…read moremid-day bite, when I stumbled upon this absolute treasure of a restaurant. Now, to be entirely candid, the building itself looks a touch weathered at first glance but once you step inside, the décor is absolutely flawless. Being from Orange County, I have been on an absolute crusade to find genuinely authentic, coastal-caliber seafood since arriving here, and let me tell you, the search is officially over! The arrival was completely seamless, thanks to a sweet little dedicated parking lot, and the exterior of the venue is just as cute as a button. The moment I crossed the threshold, the lovely cashier greeted me with the warmest energy and elegantly walked me through the day's catch. What truly blew me away and frankly, brought a little tear to my eye was the sheer depth of knowledge and passion they share about their sourcing. They explained exactly where the fish came from and how it was caught with such beautiful, undivided commitment. That level of bespoke service is precisely what turns a first-time guest into a lifelong devotee. I opted for a Fish Taco prepared with a brilliantly unsalted catch, and it was an absolute revelation. The fish was incredibly soft, delicate, and practically melted in my mouthnot a hint of chewiness in sight. It was simply bursting with that clean, ocean-fresh flavor. A flawless, five-star experience across the board for the taste, the charm, and the beautiful soul of this place. I shall most certainly be making this a regular stop on my lunch rounds!

I had such high hopes for this place a seafood market in Indianapolis? Yes please. As someone who…read moregrew up in Florida, I am always on the hunt for anything that scratches that coastal seafood itch, so I was genuinely excited to try it. We ordered the lobster hoagie and hush puppies. Both were... fine. Not bad, but nothing that wowed us or justified the anticipation. The flavors were there in a basic sense, but it all felt a little underwhelming for a spot that's billing itself as a seafood destination. What really got me was the market side of things. The seafood on display just looked sad not fresh, not vibrant, not the kind of stuff that makes you want to throw something in a bag and take it home to cook. I fully understand we're landlocked in Indiana and truly fresh seafood is a challenge, but if that's your entire concept, the product has to be able to hold its own. Left feeling more disappointed than anything. I so wanted to love this place and will be rooting for them to level up but for now, this Florida girl will keep searching.

The food is always great every time I go. Service is always great as usual. The smell is just as…read moregood as the food is so don't hesitate to go in!

This place was interesting to me. I would say I'm a bit of…read morea seafood snob being from Maryland and just moving back to Indy after being there for the last 10 years, soooo... here we go. The lobster roll was soggy and honestly? Too much. I prefer a classic lobster roll - warm, lobster, bread that still has a little crunch to it (just the tiniest bit), butter - but not too much. This was soggy and the celery situation took away from the essence of a lobster roll for me. I've never liked the lobster salad rolls, and I did make sure there would be no mayo - but I think this was a bit much. Too much butter. Too many toppings. The flavor wasn't amazing. My dad really liked the perch. So much that he didn't let me try it. Lol but it looked good! The fried okra was solid. Kinda hard to mess that up, so no complaints there. Same thing with the fish tacos as the lobster roll. They're very busy. I like tasting my food - not piling the toppings on so things get lost. So, I scraped pretty much everything off. The fish was good! I got my mom the fried oysters. No complaints. Her meal came with two sides, so I got greens and Mac and cheese. I didnt try the Mac, but they said the greens were top tier. They had a nice flavor, but they're spicy - so avoid them if you can't deal with a lot of spice - probably red pepper. They threw in a crab cake for free and I thought that was really sweet of them. I didn't like the way it looked on the inside, so I only nibbled at it. Definitely not what this Maryland girl is used to... the winner is still Commisson Row on crab cakes in Indy so far. Anyway! Cute little tucked away spot, small parking lot, but spacious inside. Quite a few tables and chairs and fresh seafood in the cases. I'd go again and try some different things based on other reviews.

Great sandwiches! There are two great vegetarian options. I ordered a different sandwich with no…read moremeat and it was also good. They have a wide sandwich selection (hot and cold) with quality breads, meats, and cheeses. Their deli sides are also varied: broccoli salad, egg salad, potato salad, cole slaw, and others. The shop is well stocked with fresh meats and vegetables. It even has offerings from local businesses such as Amelia's and 4 Birds Bakery. There is a space to eat inside. Employees were friendly.

Though we live in Carmel, this was our first time visiting Joe's butcher shop in Fish market. We…read morecame in search of fresh fish for dinner. Trying to eat somewhat healthy is in part due to New Year's resolutions and in part due to my wife's health. We are going to give it a try! Hope we have some success! I was impressed with the butcher shop and fish market. They had a good selection of beef, pork, chicken, and fish. They also had a nice deli area. In the middle of the store, they had limited supply of groceries needed to cook the protein items they sell. There is also a prepackaged fresh and frozen area with ready to take and eat meals. It had a small grocery store type atmosphere. The individuals behind the counter were very helpful and knowledgeable. They cut our fish fillet for us. He also provided a good recipe and means to cook the fish at home. That was very much appreciated.... Particularly since we are new to this whole healthy eating concept. Wish us luck! The prices here appear to be a little more expensive than your average grocery store. However, we are hoping that the fish is better quality and fresher in nature. We will definitely be returning.

We are regular customers. Food will never let you down. Everytime we call in a order, it's done…read morebefore we get there. I'm 52, and have been going there with my father since the 70s. Catfish sandwiches rivals any in town

I haven't had a lobster roll since Caplingers closed the location north of Zionsville. I wanted a…read morelobster roll today so I drove over to the east side. This location is 1/4 or smaller the size the one was up north. It really could use a facelift and a deep cleaning of the floors and walls. They were busy since I arrived toward the end of lunch time. Sorry to say staff not overly welcoming or friendly. I ordered and waited. The Pepsi machine was out of co2 so I opted for tea. I was happy they had sweet and non sweet tea available. Got my Lobster Roll, it looked nothing like what I've got in the past. Much much more filler than lobster. Tasted like a mass produced lobster salad. Fries were ok, not waffle fries but crinkle cut chips. Over all just kinda disappointed. Just didn't have the same flavor I came to expect from Caplingers and a 30$ meal.

Fresh seafood prepared anyway you prefer. The service was…read morespot on and friendly. Will be back.

Easy, quick oysters on half shell surprisingly good. Jumbo fried shrimp not that jumbo. Water…read moregood. 8-))

I was skeptical at first because it says it is also a fish market. The doors looked older. However…read moreit is very clean with no smell of fish or anything. The portions were decently. Call them directly because even if you pick oup, Yelp charges more for the order

I love their service. l ordered the whole catfish and it was good as well as the fries. It's not…read moreWilliamsons fish market good, but it's good!

Ordered a 4-bone Prime Rib for Christmas. They separated the bones and trussed it together!! We…read morehave never cooked one before and were very excited!! This was a Choice cut and came out delicious!! Thanks guys!! You made this a great experience!!

We got catering trays for a graduation party: brisket, potato salad, coleslaw, baked beans,…read moreassorted individual bags of chips, and a vegetable tray. So delicious, great service. There were so many wonderful looking things in the shop-my only sadness is discovering this place as my kid is graduating and leaving Bloomington!

Well priced fresh fish option. I have not been disappointed yet. Choice and price could vary…read moredaily. I would advise calling ahead for availability. It is off the beaten path in the Park Fletcher office park near the old airport and right next to post office.

I had a desire for Ethiopian food and my daughter has been moving more and more to vegetarian…read moredishes, so had to find some spices as well as injera bread. Looking through Google, Asmeret was the closest to me as I live on the northeast side. Asmeret is small market on 16th street near Pasquale's pizza. If you blink you'll miss it. The guy who owns it is so nice and he was so surprised to see someone America...especially a black American looking for real spices. But he was great, he got my straight! Nice big bag of berbere, the special butter, and other special spices. Prices was great! Only downside was I was late and they were already sold out of injera. Otherwise a great little spot for purchasing authentic Ethiopian spices and products.