Oyster and Shrimp Po' Boys are to die for ... Hurry the Oyster Po' Boy sells out fast! Clam Chowder delights every sensation of the taste pallets! read more

Went to the new Westfield location! Loved the ambiance, the food, and our server Jessa! Great addition to Westfield! read more

I had such high hopes for this place a seafood market in Indianapolis? Yes please. As someone who grew up in Florida, I am always on the hunt for anything that scratches that coastal seafood itch, so I was genuinely excited to try it. We ordered the lobster hoagie and hush puppies. Both were... fine. Not bad, but nothing that wowed us or justified the anticipation. The flavors were there in a basic sense, but it all felt a little underwhelming for a spot that's billing itself as a seafood destination. What really got me was the market side of things. The seafood on display just looked sad not fresh, not vibrant, not the kind of stuff that makes you want to throw something in a bag and take it home to cook. I fully understand we're landlocked in Indiana and truly fresh seafood is a challenge, but if that's your entire concept, the product has to be able to hold its own. Left feeling more disappointed than anything. I so wanted to love this place and will be rooting for them to level up but for now, this Florida girl will keep searching. read more

First and foremost, a moment for those dang shrimp and crab egg rolls!! HOOOMYGOSH! I gotta have those again. Not even negotiable. So flavorful, even without the sauce - which is also amazing. The grouper sandwich was good. Seasoned well. Generous amount of fish. Fish and chips were good, although not as flavorful as the rest - really good. And the in-house made tartar sauce was perfect. The oyster po'boy - good flavor but not so generous. A few oysters for a huge roll was disappointing. Otherwise, cute little spot. A few bar stools with seating outside. The owner seemed kind and the chef seemed passionate. They were teaching someone, so I was patient. The egg rolls. The egg rolls. The egg rolls. Okay bye. read more

See all

The reviews did not lie!!! This place is small but mighty. In usual Broad Ripple fashion, parking is a nightmare. However, if you can get past that, you're in for a treat!! Chef Mike was running the whole show (it seemed to be that way) and he is effective! He took our orders, made the food and checked in on us often. I love how fresh everything is! It's a bit pricey but well worth it!! I had the crab egg rolls which were absolutely sensational. The sweet chile dipping sauce paired perfectly. I would fight parking just for these!! I also had a pan seared grouper sandwich that was yummy. My friend had the chowder and said it was well seasoned and delicious. We loved it!! Seating is limited but there is some additional seating outside. Word on the street is that they are expanding (Westfield) so be on the lookout and go try them out!! read more

See all

Tried BRSM. Fresh and I mean fresh seafood flown in daily! Like im in FL but in IN. They supply fresh seafood to many restaurants in the Indy area. You can get raw fish to go or cooked dinners like grouper, chowder, fish and chips and more. We tried the grouper sandwich and walleye dinner. I wish the coleslaw was a little bit more but over all was good. Would like to try the fish and chips next time. The selection seems to rotate based on what they can get and probably the season. Note: The cost is a little bit pricey but keep in mind this is fresh and NOT Long John Silvers. read more

See all

Wow, our new fave place. We love seafood and so glad this place exist. Started with calamari and boy, lots of crispy tentacles, which made it very enjoyable. That's how any calamari should be served. Main meal were the fish tacos and Maine lobster roll. The tacos are served with whole fish meat which is how it should be, instead of fillers. The Maine lobster roll was overflowing with lobster meat. This has been an very enjoyable meal, Mike was very efficient and attentive considering he's the only one working. He even let us taste the fish chowder, which was very tasty. It's a very small place, it has one bar table to sit 3-4. It's mostly outdoor seating (which makes me wonder how it'll be during winter time). If coming with a bigger party, it's better to call the day before to let the chef prepare, in case of needing extra help. There's a bike rack across to park your bike. We definitely will be a regular to this place. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious! We tried the crab and shrimp egg rolls, blackened fish tacos, crab cakes and shrimp cocktail. So flavorful, packed full of crab and shrimp. You will not regret trying the Broad Ripple Seafood Market! We will be back and want to try the lobster roll! Service was exceptional. read more

I met up with my friend today for a quick bite to eat, so we walked over to the Broad Ripple Seafood Market. I've only recently begun to discover some of the many small businesses that are located in "The Village", and this one made the list for places I wanted to try due to their high star-rating. The shop is small, but mighty. Quaint, but efficient. You get the point. There was a person being served at the counter and one other guest that walked in right before my friend and I. The man behind the counter helped them with their purchase and moved along to the woman ahead of us. She ordered several meals totaling nearly $90. I'm including this detail because I'm not sure whether or not it was a contributing factor to the employee's... umm demeanor moving forward. This will read like an AITA subreddit from this point forward! Lol Once she paid, he began preparing her meals. He then popped his head up and asked if we were all together. I replied letting him know that we were not and he then asked if we wanted "fish or food"? I responded "Food." I think this stressed him out, because in essence, this was a "busy rush" for the one-man show. He sighed heavily and asked what we wanted. I gave him our orders: Boston-Style Fish and Chips for me and Crab Cakes for my friend. I asked what made the fish and chips "Boston- Style" and he said "recipe from up North" which I found to be less than helpful. So I re-worded the question. He then explained that they use a Boston lager. He said he'd ring us out momentarily. When it was time to pay he asked if I wanted any sauces or drinks. I said I'd like tartar sauce and would be purchasing a Mandarin Jarritos (w/ the proper Spanish pronunciation). After repeating myself a few times, I just raised the bottle to show him "this soda". I took pictures and checked out their other offerings until it became unbearably smoky (for me). So my friend asked if she could pay because we wanted to wait outside (we were dining in... well, outside on the patio). He told her it would be just a moment to which she replied "it's very smoky" and this man said "it's from the fryer". Now, I don't know if he was being smartellic, has a very dry sense of humor, or something else, but no freaking duh! Once we made it outside, we sat talking and he came out to retrieve a portion of fries from the freezer. He yelled over to us "did you get napkins and ketchup?" I ignored him, as I was on a phone call. On his way back, he repeated himself. I called back, "no, but we'll get them. " When I came in to get them, he stared me down. It was super uncomfortable and slightly maddening. Like dude, you just yelled for me to come do this. I held up the napkins and ketchup..."I'm just getting napkins and ketchup." I walked over to the counter to look at the business cards there and asked him if he was the owner. He replied that he was the manager, Mike. I tried to make small talk, but Mike kept making snarky remarks. He never once said I'll bring the food out when it's done. It was my first time here. I left him to his work. I was headed back in to check on our food when he rushed through the door with our meals as I held it open. I said "Perfect timing. " and after a brief delay, he said "thanks for holding the door". He later returned asking if the food had been worth the wait. Maybe he felt rushed, but we'd told him earlier on that we weren't in any hurry. Anywho... the food. Friend's crab cakes were plated beautifully. The flavor was good, but she said that she wished they'd had less cornmeal/ cornbread filler and more "lovely lady lumps" aka lumps of crab meat! Lol The fish had a light and airy batter, was fried to a golden, delicious hue and had the flakiest texture. The tartar sauce was extremely flavorful. The chips were crisp and salty on the outside and soft and fluffy on the inside. Everything came out hot and fresh. For that reason, I shall return. read more

See all

It was our first time here- this place came highly recommended and it did not disappoint. We both got the grouper sandwich- absolutely delicious. Couldn't ask for more from a grouper sandwich- fresh, full of fish, big tomato, lettuce and tartar sauce. Perfection- he warned us as he cooked our fish that we would be back, he wasn't wrong. Can't wait to come back to this little gem! I'll have to come back to try the lobster roll Limited seated inside but they have some outdoor tables as well. Highly recommend this place! read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Grouper sandwich - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

As a seafood lover, I was anxious to try this little locally owned seafood market in Broad Ripple after seeing glowing reviews on Yelp. The shop is tiny and immaculate, filled with fresh seafood, a small selection of local meats and cheeses, and upscale seasonings for preparing the fresh seafood. Seafood is available to take home and cook or they serve a number of in-house made options to eat outside on their patio or take to go. Their story was told in the Indy Star and hangs framed on the wall. Turns out, they provide fresh seafood to several high-end restaurants in the area. I ordered a cup of the seafood chowder, which was wonderfully spicy and thick, packed with various seafood, including salmon, and potatoes. This is one of the best seafood chowders that I've had (maybe the best). My husband had the Fish and Chips. The fish was hand breaded and fresh! The generous helping of steak fries were delicious. We sat out on the pet friendly patio at a shaded table and dined al fresco. There was one manager during our visit. He took orders, cooked and delivered the food. He came out to check on us, chatted a bit and encouraged us to try some fresh seafood to take home. There is a small dedicated parking area with a handicapped space. They are located on a quiet street less than a block off the Monon Trail. Broad Ripple Seafood Market is must visit and worth the drive to Broad Ripple. read more

See all

Great selection of fresh fish prepared expertly. Friendly fast service. A bit pricey but worth it.

I've been wanting to visit Broad RippIe Seafood for quite some time and I finally made it. I had the seafood chowder and it was delicious! My husband had the fish and chips and it was really really good. The fish (cod) was very fresh and perfectly fried (not greasy). The breading was flaky and light. I would definitely suggest BRS for the perfectly cooked fish. You can also buy the fish to take home and cook yourself. This is definitely a thumbs up place! Also staff and owners are great and very accommodating (made suggestions explaining different things on the menu, etc.). read more

Whole place is empty. Yet smells bad. We ask if there shrimp sandwich. A guy with weird attitude says "it's reservation only" when no sign says so and there were reservations available online meaning it's not fully booked as they claimed. Bad business, bad attitude, dirty, not recommended at all. They need to learn how to better approach the customers. read more

Recently had lunch with a friend on a cold Sunday afternoon before heading off to holiday shop in Broad Ripple. Mike, the man behind the counter, is very personable. He wanted to orient us to the market knowing we hadn't been before and made sure we knew about specials, upcoming menu changes, how people typically shop there, that they cater events, etc. We both ordered the lobster bisque and it was outstanding. Even after ordering Mike insisted we sample the clam chowder too, which was also amazing. So fresh and delicious. Lobster bisque at local restaurants I must say, have not--err--sat well with me the last two times I ordered it, so I was hesitant. But this time, I had no issues. Here I thought it was me! I guess freshness is the key. It's not a full-blown sit-down place per se, especially in the winter, but there is a bar with stools that can sit about 4 or 5. There is a lovely shared outdoor space too, when the weather is warmer. Any time of year, it'd be good for lunch or casual early dinner especially as a single person or pair, with just enough variety on the menu. Their market business it seems is their bread and butter. Catch of the day and specials are updated on their website. Prices are reasonable given the high quality. Cup of bisque was pricey at ~$14. I would have been better off buying a quart--hee hee. Next time! read more

Okay, let me cast my line by saying--I reel-y don't write reviews. Oh sure, I've penned a few, but we're talking maybe a school of five. I cod investigate where those are, but I'm afraid I'll flounder trying to get back here. I think I'm getting old? But don't tell my brain--it's still swimming in its twenties. Anyway. I'm rambling, like a mackerel out of water. For those with attention spans shorter than a guppy's memory, here's the bait: The Broad Ripple Seafood Market serves the best blackened grouper sandwich I've ever had in my life. There. I said it. And I'll swordfish-fence anyone who disagrees. KC, the magical mermaid running the ship over there? A total delight. If kindness were currency, she'd own half the ocean. I don't know what else to say. Reviews are usually just people carping on. But this sandwich? It's nuts. Better than anything I've had in Florida. Florida! How is that even possible? Unless they're farming grouper in the Broad Ripple Canal.* I've lived here for ages, and I'm embarrassed I just now discovered this hidden pearl. Don't make the same mis-steak. And if your taste buds do a happy little jig after that first bite, go ahead and call the shop back. Let KC know. She'll appreciate the ripple effect. *They did not get the grouper from the Broad Ripple Canal. We checked. That water's seen things. PS: I'm not saying there's something fishy in the coleslaw, but it's got me hooked. Creamy, tangy, addictive--it's coleslaw so good it should be illegal. **Probably not actually illegal. Please don't call the FDA. Oh, I heard reviews with photos get more attention. I don't have a photo of my sandwich, but here's a nice watermelon on my counter. read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pros: 1- Location- Broad Ripple Village ~ adequate parking, outdoor patio available 2- It's a vibe 3- Excellent friendly service 4- the food is fresh and fabulous Cons: none So ... I'm glad I stopped in. I thought this place was a fish market only, I didn't realize it was a restaurant too! My meal was perfection, I'll take fresh seafood over frozen always. Open 11-6 daily except on Monday. I'll be back! Keep up the great work, Mike read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Mike~ Manager ~ epic vibe, epic location, epic service, epic food. EPIC - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We popped into the market for the first time this afternoon for lunch, and wow - cannot believe we waited to long to visit!! We'll be back for sure, chef Mike took wonderful care of us and even let us try a sample of the seasonal soup while he was chef'ing up our lunch. It's the perfect market feel with amazingly fresh seafood and other grab and go products. The blackened fish tacos were made with queen snapper over fresh slaw and a remoulade sauce. 10/10. So incredibly fresh and homemade deliciousness!! These are by far and away the best fish tacos in Indy. My husband had the seafood chowder and wished he would have had a bigger bowl! Will be back....soon! We sat outside but there are a few (3-4) little bar stools to stay and enjoy. Thanks for making our first time a good one, Mike!! read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Blacked fish tacos - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Extremely fresh seafood. Well thought menu that is carefully executed. Also got to meet the kind, passionate, customer focused owner. read more

See all

I went here recently. It was my daughter's pick. We were very disappointed. The cook and cashier were both so stoned they could barely take our order and ring it up on their computer. I had a lobster roll. The lobster was overcooked, and had been cooked days earlier. The crab cakes were nothing great. I don't recommend this place to anyone. read more

Had a great lunch on a cold day. Tasted like we were looking at the intercostal not snow banks. The fish tacos were fantastic. The chef pulled a mahi filet from the sale counter for the tacos! Fresh! The crab cakes were delicious also. The hush puppies stole the show. They were so light and flavorful. It is a fish market that sells food to order so don't expect for white tablecloths. The service was fast and knowledgeable. We will return. read more

Great place to grab fresh seafood--many choices! Mike does a great job! Highly recommend! read more

This market has the freshest fish in town. The piece of fish we cooked was simply perfect. Our guests commented on how delicious it was. We can't wait to come back for lunch! read more

WOW! This place is amazing. My husband, kid and I went tonight for dinner and this is some of the best seafood I've had. We had the blackened fish tacos, main lobster roll, and the crab cakes. I'm very picky about my seafood especially because raised in the keys and this is top tier. What I really loved is that everything is made in house! Mike was very nice and accommodating and made us feel very welcomed. We can't wait to go back and also check out their Westfield location. read more

Best food I've had in a very long time. Never disappoints, always fresh and delicious. My favorite restaurant!

Soooo, the food smelled so good I forgot to take a photo. I have the jumbo shrimp and jumbo is an understatement. More like prawns, they were giant and delicious. My husband had the Boston fish and chips, also a big portion. The service was just as special as the food. The manager Mike was more than helpful and friendly. The building is small and decorated like a shop on The Harbor in Maine. There's no inside seating, but plenty of outside, seating to enjoy in the summertime. read more

We saw the FOX59 segment and knew we had to check it out - this place did not disappoint! Chef Mike took care of us with blackened grouper sandwiches, cole slaw, and hush puppies - all of which were fantastic! Looking forward to bringing more friends with us next time! read more

See all

Absolutely love this place! You can tell they are passionate about their menu. Mike made the best grouper sandwich I've ever had. This became my favorite spot in town, and I can't wait to come back soon. read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Grouper sandwich - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Freshest seafood I have had in Indy for a long time. Grouper sandwich and crab cake at lunch. This group supplies seafood to many higher end Indy restaurants. Chef Mike was laid back and friendly, from Boston. Definitely knows how to prepare seafood. read more

Our first visit and it did not disappoint! My husband had the blackened fish tacos, I had the fish and chips and it was absolutely incredible -the best fish and chips around. The Chef and GM Mike was so nice, fast service and a cute eat-in area. This is our new go to for seafood, both for eating in and to go fish, shrimp etc. to prepare at home (purchased a pound of grouper). read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Fish and Chips with a side of hush puppies. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

What a gem to have in Broad Ripple. Picked up some stone crab claws and they were superb! The seafood chowder is amazing. The selection of fresh fish may not be as large as Caplingers, but what Bardales has is curated and you can be assured that you are purchasing the highest quality. read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Stone crab claws -- perfection! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food was fantastic! Hot and fresh. Amazing flavor! Sauce on the fish tacos was delicious!

I am a seafood lover, and I have VERY high expectations. I found this place and decided to check it out. It's a small shop but packs a powerful punch with fresh fish selections of various types, as well as food you can purchase. I very hesitantly took a piece of salmon home, and I do not regret it. It's fresh and high quality. Even my fiance enjoyed his lunch, and he hates fish. We will definitely be back to try more fish and the food! read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Fresh salmon - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This place is awesome. Feel like I'm back in Key West! It's pretty fresh and really tasty! read more

Stopped in the market for the first time just to see what it was about. Had seen several adds about the place and was curious to see what they had to offer. In short, product was outstanding! Bought a piece of cod to cook that evening and it was delicious! Very fresh and high quality. My issue was with the customer service. read more

Everything here was really fresh and well done. My boyfriend had the grouper sandwich and I had the fish tacos, both excellent. Service was solid and the manager/owner was genuinely very kind. I only found this place right before moving out of state and was bummed not to get the chance to come back. Also, the Anthony Bourdain painting on the wall is a nice touch. read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Fish Tacos - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

A total gem right off the Monon Trail. We enjoyed clam chowder, crab cakes and halibut cheeks. All of it perfectly seasoned and prepared. Crazy good! read more

Broad Ripple Seafood Market - Halibut cheeks! Taste a little like scallops, only better. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Fresh seafood daily. Tiny but mighty venue. The owner is super friendly and outgoing--and a talented chef to boot. Comfortable outdoor seating, cramped indoor seating at window counter. Not an issue for me, but groups may feel squeezed out. I'll be back. read more

See all

This spot is perfect if you love fresh seafood. My partner and I love their chowder and feel like it rivals the chowder we get on the east coast. A cute walk up counter and a nice patio with friendly service and owners. Skip the grocery store seafood and check this place out. There is always something new and fresh to grab for dinner. I also appreciate that they make suggestions on how to cook the fish as well. A great spot in Indianapolis! read more

Great place that I just went to the first time today. Due to some kitchen challenges, I wasn't able to get any walkaway fish sandwiches but both the Ceviche and the Tuna were awesome. Service was great--friendly and knowledgeable. And the selection was pretty extensive given the size of the place. Clean, simple and easy. Will definitely be back! What a great (secret) addition to Broad Ripple Village! read more