There used to be several of these around. Now I think there are only a couple left in town? This is out of my way, but I was coming over this way and made a point to stop. Partly just because, and partly because I heard they had sugar cream pie. They do, and I haven't tasted it yet, but it sure looks like Wick's, which you can sometimes get in grocery stores. But still, sugar cream pie is rare enough that I get it whenever I see it. They also had a good selection of nice fresh-looking donuts. I got several, and some cookies. Service was super friendly and fast. Prices are very reasonable. The place is a fairly old school donut shop, which is a good thing. I would definitely be here often if it was anywhere close to me. read more

The sign on the highway said 24-hour donuts. So, I knew I had to pull in at 8pm on a Wednesday. We had dinner nearby and were looking for something sweet for the rest of the car ride. The door has the actual shop hours on it which indicated closure at 9pm on Wednesday. I was surprised by the variety of pastries on sale and even some fun looking shark donuts. Nothing had prices displayed, but the girl behind the counter was more than willing to share the info. I left with a small chocolate cream pie and a small chocolate chip banana bread. The cream pie was a little lack luster, but the banana bread was good! I paid $7 which I thought was high for the size and quality. The shop itself has some bar seating available and was clean and decorated kind of like a diner. I bet a fresh donut here is delicious. read more

See all

Food was Great as always, but apparently the management has really gone downhill and fast! They got an energy drink now, but you're not allowed to have samples! Talk about a bizarre marketing technique! Why advertise you got it if you can't give anyone a sample, unless it taste like dog water then I guess no one should sample it! Very confused as the staff is super friendly, but worried about getting fired over a sample of energy drink.... read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - JP Surge, the newest energy drink that no one can try to see if they like! - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Quick service. Order at the counter or sit at the bar for coffee. Tons of variety. Tough to just pick a few. Tasty and fresh. This donut shop has been a Grove City staple for years. I will be back! read more

See all

I've been following Jolly Pirate GC for a while now because they offer up more than amazing donuts: they're serving nostalgia. So when I found myself in the neighborhood yesterday, I popped in for a couple treats: maple long John and an apple fritter. Firstly, the young woman working the counter was *so* sweet! Instantly made me feel welcome (I wish I knew her name!) So many different donuts on offer, it was hard to choose. Went with my two faves because I was overwhelmed! They both were perfectly risen and fluffy, sweet and delicious. Now I'm mad I didn't buy a dozen! They have spots to sit inside if you're not on the move. I appreciate their Halloween decorations!! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Jolly Pirates is a family favorite. Not only do they have a wide variety of donut options to choose from, but they also have delicious coffee to pair it with. It's located right off of Broadway, and has some fun decorations at the front window that make it hard to miss! I've never had a long wait time, even though the store can get very busy on weekend mornings. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Half Dozen Assorted Cookies - store choice - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Good, authentic donut shop that I went to multiple times and always enjoyed! Good selection, reasonable prices, and an old-school ambiance that feels just right. read more

If you love donuts and you haven't been to Jolly Pirate what are you doing!? So so glad this place isn't close to me or else I'd be here all the time! There is truly something for everything, and they constantly have specialty donuts for the different holidays and seasons. My go-to donuts are probably cinnamon sugar and red velvet. They pair nicely with an iced latte AFTER having breakfast. These donuts are loaded with sugar and such a great treat, which is why I'll make the drive every now and then for my family. Looking forward to their fall specials! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

What happened??? Super disappointing trip to Jolly Pirate. I was in town after being gone for 3 years and really wanted some Jolly Pirate donuts. My husband picked them up and I was so excited, until I opened the box... the icing was separating the way it does after it's a couple days old. The donuts tasted stale. The buckeye donut had cream inside that tasted rancid. I spit it out and threw the rest of the box away. How do you have multi day-old donuts on the shelves at 7:30am on a Friday? These used to be the best donuts EVER. The ladies who used to work there would never have served that to a customer. So disappointing. read more

warning: not actually open 24/7. they are closed mondays, and as of 7:44 am on saturday, the place is a ghost town. no employees, no lights, and no fresh baking happening. it makes you wonder if the donuts they eventually sell are just yesterday's leftovers.go to buckeye on high street they are great and open update they posted on web site they are closed due to storm yesterday *****whynot put a sign in the window**** we all do not check the web before heading over read more

Horrible service. Rude workers snap at customers. Argue and bad mouth late or absent workers very loudly. Disgruntled and hateful attitude... Very unpleasant experience. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

Treated my office to some delicious donuts yesterday. As always, Jolly Pirates was a hit! I can always count of them to have a wide variety of donuts to choose from and they are always at peak freshness. I have been a huge fan of Jolly Pirates since I was a little kid. They will always be my absolute favorite! read more

Food: My daughter likes going here for donuts and a chocolate milk. We've stopped by a few times now. She enjoys the glazed donut w/ sprinkles and the carton of chocolate milk. I've tried a few flavors of donuts and to me they were just alright ( chocolate glazed, Boston cream filled, glazed with sprinkles& the star donuts). Not my favorite but not the worst I've had. They have a star donut that is only made on the weekends and every time I go its gone. So I would love for this to be made more often or made on both Sat & Sun. Service: The 1st time we went on a Sat afternoon. It was so empty I almost thought the store was closed. Once inside a few people came in as we were being served. Service was fine. The person helping us was young. We then came back again on a Sun before my daughter hd practice. This time it was busy. And we had to wait quite a bit which was a little annoying b/c everyone ahead us seemed to be buying multiples boxes full of donuts and the donut baskets were getting empty. We were only there for 1 donut and a chocolate milk for my daughter, who is only 5. Luckily we got through the line and made it to practice on time. But they def need more registers and a better system for large orders when they are busy. Ambiance: It's pretty dark inside. Nothing spectacular about the decor or setup. I think it needs to be brightened and a little better decorated. Floors and counters were dirty both visits. Seats look old and worn. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Box of donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

We stumbled across the Jolly Pirate and I could not resist stopping to try the wide variety of small donuts. This day and age of bigger the better these are smaller with about every flavor and decoration that you could imagine.. see a location need a donut fix stop and see the Pitate for your fix.. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

If you like fresh cake and lots of sugar, you're gonna love these donuts. They were fresh they were not over done they were not under done as donuts go. They were perfect donuts. read more

Their donuts are so good. Cooked properly and so delicious. Such a great variety, really satisfied the donut cravings! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

What happened?! I've had these for decades and now the donuts look like samples. Bismarcks look the size of a middle finger for the same price as ones that were more than twice the size a few years ago. I can't do it anymore, I turned around and walked out. RIP Jolly Pirate of old. read more

This is just a little "hole in the wall" classic type of donut shop and you know it's going to be good! They're opened 24/7 and they have a parking lot. Plenty of variety for their donuts. During the fall time they had this pumpkin donut and it was to die for! I tried their peanut butter cream, blueberry with frosting, and apple spiced donuts. Sooo good! It's moist and has lots of flavor. The apple spiced has apple filling inside which made it a nice surprise. It's $1.09 for each donut which isn't bad! They have lots of variety and some creative ones, such as their current Lucky Charms donut. Next time you pass Jolly Pirate, stop in and try their donuts! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

Really yummy donuts! The buckeyes are the best I have had. The staff is friendly and helpful.

When you have the best doughnuts in central Ohio, you sit back and enjoy your success, right? Maybe so, but not if you're Jolly Pirate. No, you increase your pastry offerings, as well as your doughnut choices. They might have to expand the store soon, to have room for all the goodies and the customers. I tried the yummy new chocolate overload doughnut, but I was only buying four, and not the two dozen I wanted to buy, so my other three were some of my long-time favorites. I prefer filled doughnuts, and they excel at those, but they also do a great job with the various unfilled raised and cake delights, frosted or not. Whatever your favorite is, they do it right, and you might find a new favorite (or five) in the rack or case. Oh, and there's the clever treasure chest that they pack your doughnuts in. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Ever since the pandemic, their donuts have been way smaller and the price for a dozen of donuts use to be $7.75. Now, they are charging $16.75. This a rip off. You are getting ripped off on the price and your donuts. Shame on y'all robbing people. This is unacceptable in every which way. We the community support y'all's shop, and y'all are going to turn around and ripping those who are keeping y'all in business. SHAME SHAME SHAME ON YOU!! read more

Not sure what the hype is about. Very greasy raised and dry cake donuts. Service is about what you'd expect from McDonald's. They did have some pirate stuff around. But for me and my daughter it's a pass read more

As much as I love a Pirate theme, these donuts did not really blow my mind. Got a half dozen and tried a bunch of different flavors. The cake donuts were really dry, but the chocolate frosted and the buckeye were yummy. If I lived closer, that chocolate frosted donut could be a problem. All in all, a good stop if you are in the Grove City area. read more

See all

Quality donuts for a good price. This location typically is empty when I come so you're able to take your time choosing what you want. On this day, the donuts looked really bad. They look like someone had been training or some thing but 90% of them were looking a little crazy. However, they're usually OK. The taste is delicious. I've never had a complaint about their donuts. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

They are not the old Jolly Pirate at all. They tasted wrong. The dough texture was off, the size was smaller than I have ever seen and even the icing and filling didn't taste the same. Were they edible? Sort of. Were they Jolly Pirate quality, or worth 13$ a dozen? Absolutely not. The staff are really nice, and the store is clean so I will definitely say it wasn't them. read more

I am such a huge fan of jolly pirate! The donuts are always delicious and the employees are lovely. The prices are more than fair, and I really like that they give you a 13th donut for free when you get a dozen! I drove out there this time specifically for the cheesecake donuts, and was sad to see that there was only one left. I asked the employee if there would be any more anytime soon and she said she was more than happy to make some up for me right then. I felt bad ordering a dozen of them but she was very pleasant about it and made me feel very welcome! For my 13th donut I got a cinnamon roll, and after I asked for one she remembered that they had just made some fresh ones so she went to the back to grab me one! Just 10/10 customer service. The donuts are absolutely amazing, it's so worth the 20 minute drive I have to make to get there. I'll definitely be back very soon and look forward to it! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Cheesecake donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

Extremely disappointed I've been going here on and off for a long time and I'm not sure what they're doing there but it seems like they change the recipe. The donuts did not taste the same tasted gross. Very small one of them was only half a doughnut because the half of it fell apart in the donut tray and she obviously didn't care to give me a full one.. quality has went down significantly read more

We stopped in on a Sunday around 2 pm. It was dead. The young man's serving us was great. But when we got home we noticed how tiny some of our donuts were. We were there months ago and noticed the same thing, that the donuts have gotten much smaller. Thought it was a fluke but I guess they are significantly smaller. I have seen peoples comment on their page saying they noticed they are much smaller and some say they aren't but I think they are. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Jolly pirate donuts. - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Stopped into here for Columbus Donut Week, and despite being in the middle of the Coronatimes, Jolly Pirate Donuts was here and ready to serve. They had a huge variety of donuts available, and the staff was really friendly and taking hygiene seriously. The location feels like its in a bit of an odd area, and the outdoor design of the building feels a bit dated, but the DONUTS. Let me tell you, these donuts are delicious. They have that "oil-friend" like taste that's hard to find from a lot of donuts anymore. The donuts are so insanely rich (especially the sweet varieties), and they're deliciously filling too. Employees didn't feel overly excited (which is understandable, given the times), but they were happy to answer questions and friendly. Feeling lazy? They deliver! read more

We have gotten donuts here several times. They tend to be dry like day old. Donuts are small and they smash a dozen into a box. Will not be going back there again. read more

The search will continue for donuts that match the high standards my taste buds have from being trained well by 2 of the best places in Michigan. I had HIGH Hopes seeing more variety of cake donuts as I walked into the old fashioned shop. But one look at the cases, hope started to die. Where was the icing??? Looks like someone was in a hurry and smeared as little as possible on the top of each. I chose 2 that I thought had the most and a iced sugar cookie that looked good. All totalled under $3 so the prices were fair. Service was excellent, but this late in the afternoon for a donut shop it was not busy. When I got a donut out of bag in car, I was SHOCKED how thick it was. 1 1/2 thickness of any cake donut I have ever seen. Looked like it was baked in donut pan, not normally fried in oil. Healthier, yes, but you don't CARE about healthier if you are eating a donut. YOU WANT the taste for the calories. So dry, I was glad to have that RT 44 diet Coke from Sonic. I tore off the bottom to eat it. I had to do the same for the other one this morning when I tried to enjoy it at breakfast. At least that one had enough icing and not as dry. The cookie was good, but how many ways can you mess up an iced sugar cookie??? It is not rocket science to make a great cake donut either and both EBS and I understand rocket science from Purdue - don't ask, but true from our younger days and mine 10 years younger than his. I even learned to run the donut machine at Wilmington College's food service when I was there. Made thousands of dozens of donuts just like Washtenaw Dairy donuts. Cake donuts are made just like the ones you see at Krispie Kreme donuts only different batter. You pick up the donuts after they come off the machine warm and place them in icing, turn OVER to plcae on tray to cool and allow icing to hardened. Told you not rocket science, so why is the search so hard. Curious minds want to KNOW??? read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts, cookie, and free pirate hat. Got hat from treasure chest asking for postings on social media for Jolly Pirate Donuts. Won't like it. - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

My love affair with Jolly Pirate is starting to dwindle. I first fell in love with their donuts in 2016. I love cake donuts, and this place had some fantastically delicious ones. I could be in and out quickly, even if they were busy. The coffee isn't anything special, just regular coffee from a pot, but it's not expensive so I drink it. Then they closed...boo hoo!...but then they reopened under new owners. Now I can stop by in an afternoon when there is hardly anyone there and wait 5 minutes to get served. And lately the donuts have been super stale-like "I can't bite into this, sounds like a rock when I throw it away" stale. Please Jolly Pirate...return to the way things were during our honeymoon period! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Lunch of champions-small black coffee and custard-filled & frosted buttermilk donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

I was in there this morning 9/1/24 and it was the worst customer service I have EVER experienced. We had a lady with purple perm like hair. We asked for a dozen and she was snippy I know where they are sir. When telling her the flavor. I asked if they had maple. Right in front of you mam. I would call this store angry pirates. Nothing jolly about it. One star because no other choice. Will not be back. read more

I have not been to Jolly Pirates in forever! Last night I decided I just couldn't go one more day without a donut, so I drove out and grabbed a dozen to go. The employees were super friendly, as usual, and the donuts were fresh and and delicious. I tried a few flavors that I don't remember ever trying and they were good as well! I was also very excited to see they are still 24 hours! read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

Jolly Pirate Donuts has been a staple in Grove City for years. We used to frequent this place when I was a kid, and to this day whenever I go back to visit family I try to stop in and pick up a box for the family. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Love this place. It's such a blast from the past for me. Like doughnut shops used to be ( except no cigarette smoke smell). The coffee is strong and hot. You can sit at a counter or little tables that have no way to hook up a device! Yes!! You eat your doughnut, you move along. The doughnuts are fresh and certainly a treat . Every time I drive past, the kids always mention that stopping at Jolly Pirate might be a good idea. read more

Food was very good, service was quick, the visit was very enjoyable. You know some people will whine and complain if you hung them with a new rope. read more

AMAZING donuts! They have so many different flavors but their chocolate custard one is definitely my favorite! The prices are also pretty good! read more

I had been burned all three times I went to Buckeye donuts after I bought six or so at a time and ended up nearly choking on every visit due to how dry the donuts were...SO I went to Jolly pirate determined to not be suckered again! I bought a single tester Honey Dew (plain glazed cake basically) and sat right in the shop and tried it out. For 11pm on a Tuesday, the donut was actually decently moist- not amazingly so but given the time and compared to a Buckeye's it was great! So I bought a couple more cake donuts of various flavors and they were all 7/10 moisture vs Buckeye's 4/10. Great improvement. It was a little over 6 bucks for four donuts and a $1.99 pint of chocolate milk. Not bad at all for a place open 24/7. read more

Jolly Pirate Donuts - Devil's Food Donut - Donuts Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

I visited the store in Grove city Oh today . I was looking for jelly donuts . They didn't have the ones I wanted but the clerk said he could make them for me and he did ! I didn't get his name but you should be able to find out who he is from the time and location . His service will make me return to that store any time I want donuts ! read more