I love the atmosphere here. The wings are the best I have ever had anywhere. Highly recommend the…read morewings to anyone. I got BBQ horsey.

Clean inside. Beer was cold…read more A little pricier than I would have thought for a small town WP bar... $5 for a southern tier ipa draft and $3.50 for a coors light draft. Would go back but not sure I would have any preference between choosing here or Sparkey's.

GREAT MEMORIES!!!! An absolutely wonderful place! I worked…read morethere in the summers of 1958 and 1959 when I was in high school. Art Rohman still owned the place and tended bar seven days a week. I used to set up pins in the bowling alley when there were bowlers. My mother and grandmother knew Rohmans probably for about fifty years back then. Wonderful people to work for and with. Art Rohman must have been in his seventies at the time and a font of history. He provided us free lunch, although he did not serve food to the public then. The hotel had stopped functioning as a hotel by then. Mr. Rohman lived in one of the rooms as did one of his bartenders.His nephew Nick lived in the house left of the front of the hotel and worked as a bartender. Before I arrived, Mr. Rohman had had his own barber living in the hotel. When that was discontinued, he would drive across to Barryville to go to Trevor's barbershop (on River Road) who was also the Justice of the Peace. That and going to funerals were the only time he left the building. He never waited at Trevors. John Trevor used to ask the person whose hair was being cut to leave the chair so that Mr. Rohman could get his shave. Sometimes there were three or four people waiting for a haircut. Mr. Rohman always paid for the haircuts of those he cut in front of. I do remember the great baseball pitcher Smoky Joe Wood coming in periodically for a case of beer which I would carry out for him. There was also the mail car on the train which went around 4:00 every afternoon. A six pack (cost a dollar then) was run out to the mailcar every day. They never tipped. Sundays were a spectacle. PA. had Blue Laws which prohibited bars from being open on Sundays. Rohman's was exempt. The Catholic Church was a few hundred yards away. When service let out, most of the attendees walked down the street and into Rohman's. On that day Mr. Rohman was known as Father Rohman. I was told that Rohman's was open all through prohibition. Politicians then were no different than today, although it was probably cheaper to bribe them. The boarding house trade was going strong back in the 1950s. There were many in the area. Pre-lunch cocktails were a regular routine for the boarders. I used to bus tables and restock the bar (only fresh fruit in all the drinks). At around 11:30 AM the place would fill with boarders. I would guess that there were more than 100 patrons crowding the place. Then it would empty as they went back for lunch (12:30 I think). Kids were welcome. My parents used to take me there when I had to stand on a chair to play one of the two pinball machines. Rohman would often come over and throw a bunch of nickels onto the machine for us kids to use for additional games. Nighttimes were crazy. Whatever the capacity of the bar, you couldn't get another person or table into the barroom. There were five bartenders on at night and often the customers were five deep at the bar. Friday nights were the worst. Husbands used to come up from the city on the train after work and walk right across the tracks into Rohman's to join their wives. Busing tables was difficult because you couldn't navigate around the room. There were three doors across the front (railroad side). To get to the other end of the bar I would go out the nearest door, walk to the farthest door and re-enter there. Getting back with a tray full of glasses and ashtrays retraced the route. A great place! I am tempted to come up from NC to revisit the old times. The name I use is a pseudonym. I have a website at www.economicnoise should anyone want to discuss this part of my youth further. I had many good times in the Barryville -- Shohola area and good friends. I considered Art Rohman a friend despite our considerable age difference.

Great place. Old time charm. You have to look at the register when it was operating as a hotel…read more Some great old names!

If u have never been to the callicoon brewery put it on your list. All is good there. Feels a…read morelittle last century charm and great food and drinks, a must 5 star

Service was excellent. Reuben with fries was good. Meat on sandwich could have been neater placed…read moreand even on both halves of sandwich. Fries were good. Fish sandwich was good. Table cloths should be freshened up; they were old looking

Passing through on the way to the finger lakes. First choice restaurant was closed so walked in…read morehere. Great choice and great food! Bartender was excellent and food spot on get the Pub Burger if you are up for a food challenge.

Review Post Date: 6.30.2026 I am a casual out of town patron…read moreof the Pub and it had become a favorite of mine for their food and neighborly / friendly feeling. In the past several years it has been my go-to for great burgers and other food they offer, especially the burgers. My most recent visit was very disappointing as I ordered carryout for myself and my brother. He ordered the Ruben sandwich and I had the Jalapeno bacon burger. For the first time in several years neither my brother or I could eat the sandwich. They were dry as sawdust. We had to through them away. To say the least I don't think we'll be back.

From the friendly, accommodating staff and the delicious food & mixed drinks to the eclectic…read moreinterior & beautiful courtyard area in the back (including a fire pit and babbling brook), you'd be hard-pressed to find a more welcoming local tavern! Bonus: equally friendly patrons, daily blackboard dinner specials, and live music most weekends! Easily one of my favorite bar/restaurants around, hands down.

subpar food, subpar service, over priced. Too bad. We were looking forward to a good eatery. This…read moreis also not the original danas place, it's a new place and they are taking credit for the good reviews the old place had gotten. That's kind of low but then again I can understand why.

PICC'S PUB has always been a favorite - when in Delhi New York -come in and have a slice - or a…read moremeal - great food all the time - I want to say hello to you all - from your long ago friend Hollywood Joe in Hamden New York

Food was very good and reasonably priced. All food was fried; which is what we expected from a…read morebar/ restaurant. Will go again!

The food was delicious. I had the Mezzo plate and a spinach salad. Both great, but what was even…read morebetter was our server! He was attentive, funny and accommodating. The ambiance was typical pub/tavern. Nothing fancy, just what I was looking for. Highly recommend.

Food quality/price (value) 9. The atmosphere in the rear bar area is totally different than the…read morefront dining room overlooking the street. I assume the menu is the same. I had the "Pita Plate" that was kind of a charcuterie plate with grilled chicken, toasted pita triangles, plenty of hummus, rolled grape leaves, and Greek salad. It was excellent. The service by Ella was delightful. The noise level was pretty high as there was a lot of boisterous laughter occurring. Woodstock, NY is a tourist town with plenty of shops and a very walkable Main Street. There are still remnants of the Hippie lifestyle left over from the Woodstock concert of 1969 (which occurred fifty miles away) due to a lack of available space in Woodstock. A great way to spend a day!

Well isn't this a well hidden treasure!! By that I mean pull into the Rainbow Inn and head to back…read moreparking lot!! Food is a combo of typical pub fare (I did a serving of wings (hot sauce and chimi) and French fries) and some more exotic specials (pork belly Cuban, mussels fra divalo and crab cakes!!) Beers were varied and on tap from a dry cider to stout to IPAs. But the true treasure...was the whiskey selections.. From traditional whiskey (yea I mean you Jack) to my favorite bourbons (eagle rare, buffalo and blantons...all your missing is Pappy!!) and finally as a final tribute to the whiskey family ...a peated Irish some highland friends and even a speyside cousin!! Alas...and my heart was shattered!!! No islay or isle of Skye .. This spot is truly a treasure and the name is appropriate as I felt like I wandered into my best friends fathers pub :D

One of the leading candidates, I think, for the best burger In Oneonta...There are usually a few…read moremore specials. As many people are quick to point out there are few college aged patrons here. The calamari fries are not homemade but I don'r acre much, I am still a fan.. Maybe the best beer menu in Oneonta too !