Our cake was so delicious I had two slices at the wedding. Julie is also just the sweetest!! We loved her style of tasting where it is simply mix and match. It makes for such unique flavor mixtures and a completely customized wedding cake. We had 3 flavors - almond cake with white chocolate and strawberry frosting, chocolate cake with peanut butter and vanilla frosting, and lemon cake with raspberry, pistachio, and champagne frosting. Our little cake was decorated with fresh lavender buds and sprigs - it was beautiful!!! I'm only bummed that we didn't have more left over! I guess we will just have to order cakes from Julie again in the future :) read more

Julie and Jaime are the BEST in the business. They take time to hear what you truly want, are patient and kind. The shop is beautiful and elegant to match the beautiful work they do with cakes. The cakes taste amazing and look amazing. I've ordered a few cakes from them and I'm always amazed by the detail and care put in to each cake. Plus they sometimes have popup cupcake events! So follow them on social media! read more

See all

Stopped in for their Valentines Day Pop Up event. Did not disappoint. The brownies & cookies are so good!!

One of my biggest silver linings I have been able to find during COVID-19 is that Julie is doing small cakes while weddings are on hold!! She delivered a cake to my mom in Harvard, and the process was so easy! Lines of communication were super clear, and she was very responsive. My mom definitely loved the beautiful, tasty surprise during her work day! I had the cake delivered, and my mom mentioned that she appreciated how professional Julie was when she dropped the cake off! She was able to feel super safe and excited about the cake because of how safe she felt that Julie was wearing a mask and taking health/safety precautions. Julie did a great job of making her feel at ease in the current situation! Now to the best part--the cake!! My mom LOVED it. I ordered her vanilla with salted caramel filling. She spoke so highly of it that it made me want to order some of Julie's cake mix for myself to have on-hand at a later date when the craving hits! If you plan to order, I would highly recommend checking out Julie's social media accounts for inspiration on what you would like! She is capable of more awesome designs than I could think of on my own, so her Instagram was very helpful to me in that regard! I could tell you about how beautiful this cake was, but I think it is best to let the pictures speak for themselves! read more

See all

THE BEST!!! Julie Michelle made my sisters wedding cake (unbelievably gorgeous and delicious), my dads 60th birthday cake and his 65th birthday cake. Not only do her cakes look too pretty to eat, the cake is incredible. Also, Julie Michelle and her husband are the sweetest couple!!! Must have for your next event! read more

Julie Michelle Cakes - Pictures don't do this cake justice! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Purchased for cakes of separate occasions all amazing! This is the real deal!! Cheers

I attended a wedding in the fall of 2022 on a picture perfect day in Harvard, IL. They served a JulieMichelle cake that was the best cake I had ever tasted . . . and I'm getting old so that's a lot of cake tasting. Problem was there was only enough cake for the entire crowd of 300-350 people to get one slice each. Many of us were deeply saddened that we couldn't have a second (or third) serving. Yup, it was that good. read more

Julie and Jaime are THE BEST! I ordered my Easter cake and cupcakes on her website and picked up in Harvard! Made to order and FABULOUS! Get a cake from her for your birthdays, or Mother's Day, or shoot-any special day...like Tuesday! read more

Julie Michelle Cakes - 6" Easter cake Lemon w/Raspberry Filling and Vanilla cupcakes w/Vanilla and Lemon Buttercream - Custom Cakes Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Wow. That's all I can say! Working with Julie was not only a pleasure and so easy, but my guests STILL talk about my cake when they see me almost 4 months later. The tasting was so delicious and they made our decision hard because all the cakes and fillings were beyond tasty. We thought we wanted to try something non-conventional for our fall wedding and went with pumpkin spice and her butter pecan cream cheese frosting (WOW). We thought after our tasting there's no way it'll be as good and fresh as it was there at our wedding serving 160+ people right? Wrong. The cake tasted just as amazing as it did during tasting and we had EVERYONE at our wedding talking about it- I even got texts the next day about our cake! What!? That's how amazing Julie is. Not only is it the best cake I've ever had, but Julie was beyond responsive and helpful when making my cake my ideal color, style, and helping even with the right cake stand to have the day of, reviewing my sizes before purchase. Can't recommend enough- please work with Julie you will NOT a regret it!! Thank you for being such an amazing vendor and person to work with! read more

Julie Michelle Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

If you haven't experienced Julie Michelle Cakes, you NEED to. We ordered a cake for Easter and every bite was incredible. Wedding, birthday, cupcakes, any special occasion or....just because! Julie Michelle Cakes will exceed every expectation, every time. read more

See all

My 'go-to' for every occasion... Julie makes beautiful and delicious cakes. I have purchased 3 cakes from Julie and they have all been wonderful. My wife and I still (2 years later) receive compliments on our wedding cake. Julie created a custom, ultra-dreamy pattern of pink hombre sprinkles - this made even myself a fan of sprinkle cakes. Over the past 2 months, we've needed cakes to celebrate my wife's birthday and my mother-in-law's birthday. Julie did not disappoint. To our surprise, she recreated a 6 inch version our wedding cake. How truly special and personal this was. And for my mother-in-law, Julie flexed her skill and care with delicate nests, as this coincided with Easter. I am grateful for Julie's awesome expression in her craft, and will always purchase cakes for special occasions from Julie Michelle Cakes! read more

Having seen great reviews for Julie Michelle Cakes & wedding cakes in the Lake Geneva area, I reached out to Julie to see if she would be willing to do a cake to serve about 18 guests for my daughter's baby shower. She was willing, & was so easy to work with. The cake was beautiful and very, very delicious!!! All my guests commented on how fabulous the cake was, and that the filling & frosting were also. I highly recommend Julie Michelle Cakes. She made my daughter's baby shower extra special. read more

Julie Michelle made our wedding cake and I CANNOT say enough about it. It was the best cake my husband and I have ever had!! She was so easy to work with and had many many options on cake flavors and fillings. We had a 6 tier cake. The flavors consisted of chocolate cake with an espresso filling and cream cheese filling. Another tier had almond cake filled with a Boysenberry filling and cream-cheese filling. Our guests LOVED the cake. Thanks Julie!!! We will definitely be repeat customers for other events!! read more

Julie Michelle Cakes created an awesome wedding cake for my daughters wedding at The Maxwell Manor in Lake Geneva, Wi. The cake was created from scratch including from scratch fondant. Each layer of the cake was a different flavor. Red Velvet cake with creme cheese frosting, almond cake with hazelnut buttercream, lemon cake with raspberry buttercream and vanilla with champagne cream cheese with fresh strawberries. Julie Was very professional and a very talented baker. Her studio is a cool venue to visit. read more

Julie is an exceptionally gifted baker and made an amazing birthday cake for my wifes 30th birthday. She was able to decipher what my wife would like even though I know nothing about cakes or what would seem impressive for my wifes birthday. Without doubt the best cake that I have ever seen or tasted and my wife has ordered other cakes from Julie as she did such an impressive job. Julie is very easy to work with and she will surpass your expectations with ease. read more

I would highly recommend Julie Michelle Cakes! We went in for a tasting and completely fell in love!! My now husband is not huge with sweets, so it was hard to convince him or get him excited about cake. When we went in for the tasting, we were both blown away! We got to choose any combination of cake and frosting that we wanted, which was amazing. She had the standard cake flavors, but she also had available more frosting flavors than you could think of! (YUMMM) We had each tier a different flavor and cake combination which our guests loved! The cake tasted AMAZING and everyone at the wedding raved about it! Julie was also so wonderful to work with. Due to COVID, we ended up going from 300 guests, to 55 guests. Julie was so accommodating and we ended up going from sheet cakes to a four tier cake which turned out beautiful! We had some leftover cake to bring home to eat for a week and we even got an anniversary cake that we can't wait to dig into next year! I cannot say enough great things about Julie Michelle Cakes & I cannot wait to order another cake from her!! read more

See all

Julie was an absolute delight to work with! My fiance and I fell in love upon meeting her at her adorable studio. She is responsive and organized, and overall a creative and a fun upbeat personality. Our guests RAVED about our vanilla cake with salted caramel and Nutella buttercream frosting. The cake was just as beautiful as it was tasty! We wanted a rustic design to match our barn venue and Julie aced it. And did I mention she has a cotton candy cart?! We opted for this as our late night bite and it was a huge hit!! Julie showed up later in the evening to spin fresh cotton candy for our guests. She offers a wide range of flavors from margarita lime to pink champagne to blue raspberry, there was something for everyone. It was such a fun touch and everyone loved it, each time I glanced over there was a huge line waiting for her cotton candy. I would HIGHLY recommend Julie! read more

Julie Michelle Cakes - The charming and delicious rustic buttercream cake Julie baked for my wedding. - Custom Cakes Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

I recently ordered a small wedding/bridal cake for my wedding last week from Julie Michelle Cakes. Not only was it beautiful and extremely yummy but the whole process was so easy. The customer service that Julie provided was excellent having completed the transaction and planning all remotely. This was very much appreciated especially in light of my busy work travel schedule. If looking for a fantastic cake vendor - it is worth checking out Julie Michelle Cakes! read more

We had them make a "wedding" cake for my parents 50th wedding anniversary. It was beyond our expectations. You will not find better.

Julie did a great job capturing exactly what my husband wanted in the wedding cake. This was his "area of expertise" and he was so proud of what was accomplished. read more

Julie Michelle Cakes - Even though we had 3 cakes, we hardly had any left. According to our coordinator, she has never seen cake get eaten so fast! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

YUM! Julie Michelle Cakes was our vendor for our wedding on October 11, 2014. My husband and I got married at the Maxwell Mansion in Lake Geneva, WI and were looking for something different to impress our guests. I LOVE desserts and after our tasting, I knew that Julie knew what she was doing! Everything was delicious; the cakes were tasteful and moist and the frostings complimented the cakes so well that it was extremely difficult to narrow down our choices. For our wedding cake, we decided to go with a brownie cake since I love brownies more than cake. Julie didn't hesitate or question us when we had our odd request and came up with a beautiful, simple brownie cake for us! Our next request didn't shy her away either; a cupcake station for our guests! Desserts can be overlooked at weddings and we wanted to make sure it was a focal point. Julie manned the cupcake station and created desserts made to our guests liking. For example, a guest could choose between a red velvet cupcake, chocolate cupcake or almond cupcake, then choose their frostings or fillings and add some fruit or chocolate shavings to top it off! The best part was that no desserts were wasted! People were invited for seconds (or in some cases, thirds!) since others were also helping themselves to the brownie tower. Our brownie tower consisted of a variety of brownies, which were all gone by the end of the night! WHAT A HIT! Julie, I can't thank you enough for creating a memory for all our guests and for baking the most delicious cupcakes for us and our guests! Thank you! read more