Delivered within the time stated. Young man was courteous. Food delivered hot and neatly packed.read more

3/5 fries- too oily & mushy, needs to be crispy…read more 3/5 pizza - basic Didn't try the chicken tenders

I finally tried Nick's Pizza for the first time and I must say that I am hooked. The restaurant was…read morepacked when we arrived on a Friday night, but thankfully did not have to wait as we didn't need a booth. We ordered a large pie with pepperoni and a calzone with sausage. Both items came out together like we asked and was far too much food for two. My first bite of the pizza was hot, crunchy, and delicious. I love fresh oven pizzas with a crispy bottom crust. The chefs did an amazing job cooking it just right. I also loved the fresh mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. It really elevated the pizza to another level. The crust was great all around with a slight oven char. Lastly the calzone took me by surprise as it had no sauce and was filled with ricotta cheese as opposed to mozzarella. It came with a small cup of hot marinara sauce for dipping/pouring. It was definitely an interesting calzone but don't think it was worth the price. Overall, I really enjoyed my experience and Nick's and would highly recommend it. I do wish the pricing was a bit more fair when it came to full vs half pie toppings as well as the calzone.

I have to say that I hardly review businesses in this neighborhood because I live in the area and I…read morealways fear writing a review is too premature if I'm going to be a customer in the long-run, but I really have to give Nick his flowers, especially for a recent visit. My friend has a newborn and we were trying to find restaurants in the area that would be stroller-friendly (which actually isn't an easy task, to my surprise) and finally landed on Nick's because we had gone there together when it reopened. And it always seems very family and kid-friendly. We definitely went to the right place. I'm not a parent and I've never pushed a stroller without some bumps here and there, and I was so worried about helping get the stroller through the 2 doors. One of his staff saw us from the inside and immediately came out to help as soon as we reached for the door. Nick's paternal instincts definitely came into full effect because he looked out for us and wanted to give us the best seats so that we can have the stroller beside us. The pizza is excellent and I absolutely would come here over again and again, but the warm service from Nick himself and his staff is what truly makes this place so special in the community for so long. I didn't get a chance to come here during those formative years before the fire but when the restaurant finally reopened last year, it was incredibly sad to hear Nick explain how the fire and rebuilding devastated him and the business for over 2 years.

The pizza was so good! Cru why and flavorful. The vodka slice was just perfect with the amount of…read moresauce and cheese. The pepperoni with the ricotta and hot honey was my fave. Just the perfect amount of kick and the creaminess of the cheese just balanced everything out. The place is small, a few seatings, but perfect to grab a slice and go. Everyone was friendly.

5/5 pesto margherita $4.75- crunchiest crust ever, loved it, love pesto, so good…read more 3/5 truffle $6- truffle taste & smell too strong, ok otherwise 5/5 service- very friendly & informative

I was here about a week ago and the staff was incredibly rude! It was such an upsetting experience…read morethat I left in tears after eating and my husband had to chase after me. Do not go!!! P.S. The food was decent

Haven't been here in ages. Parking is rough in this area for sure. Since I couldn't find parking I…read morehad it to go. The chicken parm pizza was good. The Hawaiian was just okay. Service was fast.

I shared a slice of regular pizza--well done--with my dining partner (see photo below). The crust…read morewas a little too charred for me, but it had good texture and flavor. There was a good amount of tangy sauce, which is what I like. The mozzarella cheese tasted nice because it was fresh and had good body and stretch. Lastly, the pizza was piping hot, right out of the oven. Wait time for my slice was about five minutes. The pizza shop is located in cosmopolitan Forest Hills. Next time I am back in the area, I will try Dante's Grandma pizza, which I heard is their most popular slice.

Old school joint. Requested a slice well done. Thin and crispy. Really good! I'll be back!read more

My friends and I have ordered from here for pickup numerous times. We've tried a lot of their pasta…read moredishes, soup, salad, and pizza. Our go-to is the grandma pie. Nice thin, crispy crust and loaded with fresh garlic. You don't need to add any seasoning to it because it's so flavorful. The food is always fresh, hot, and tasty. Had an occasion to eat there in person recently. Got a grandma slice and an eggplant slice. The slices were pretty big. I had never had the eggplant one here before. It had (from what I could see) thin slices of fried breaded eggplant, ricotta cheese, tomato sauce, basil, and garlic. I felt that this was a slightly thicker crust so that the toppings wouldn't make the pizza soggy, but the crust was still nice and crispy. This slice wasn't as flavorful as the grandma, but it was more filling--overall a solid choice. All the guys who work there are friendly and quick to get your order out. The restaurant has plenty of seating and it has a homey feel to it. And on a cold day, it's nice to be in a warm place from the oven and where there's the aroma of cooking pizza.

Great pizza place, friendly staff, and the pizzas are delicious. It's not too noisy, and is cozy.read more

Still the best Pizza in town ! And the eggplant parmigiana is delish ! Thank you Ritchie the pizza…read moreguy

Slices are very good. The mozzarella sticks look really good but not worth $12. All of the rolls…read moreare always fresh. The only reason why I'm giving one less star out of four, is for two reasons. Every time I go, the tables are always disgustingly dirty from lunchtime and when I sit outside multiple people who either work there or are affiliated with the business love to chain-smoke (or try to, who smokes their cigarette backwards ?) next to or in front of people who are trying to eat and not inhale disgusting cigarette smoke. BFR

**HALAL ** Dropped…read morein on a Saturday night for some quick dinner. We ordered veggies slice and a beef patty with cheese & beef/chciken/turkey pepperoni. Total was $11. Beef patties were Tower brand, and even with the additional stuffing it was meh. Won't get it again until. Veggies slice was good, just thinner than expected - I guess shrinkflation! Great part is almost everything is apparently HALAL (ask which meats). Overall a good default, especially when nothing else is around for pizza

Smiling when I walked in to see the variety of Pizza. Friendly warm Service, Crispy hot slices,…read morenice clean environment. Definitely want to try the combo pies, half penne Ala vodka half caesar,(wow) I don't usually write reviews but this place deserves recognition! I'm coming back for sure.