We really love the ice cream here. During our one-week trip in Siesta Key, we came three times and each visit we brought back multiple large tubs. The strawberry cream might be the best I've had, and my little one said it's her favorite strawberry ice cream ever. read more

After eating at a different location in the Village for dinner, we headed to Kilwins for dessert. Good plan. This was my first visit, although I'm familiar with the Kilwin chain. Although a fairly large place, they didn't have indoor seating but they did have elevated outdoor seating along Ocean Blvd. I counted roughly 30 different tubs of ice cream and probably some sherbert. The flavor I selected was their Sea-Salt Chocolate Caramel. Good choice. The ice cream was quite chocolaty with pieces of chocolate caramel candy mixed in. My serving size for 1 scoop was also generous. The ice cream was delicious. The appearance of the place could have been more appealing, more put together. If I understood correctly they are going through a change of ownership, so a fresh look may be coming. read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Sea-Salt Chocolate Caramel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

So yummy. Got the chocolate fudge brownie. It had different textures in there and the brownie was more like a cookie dough in the consistency. I'll definitely go back and splurge with a waffle cone. read more

We visited their location in Franklin Tennessee and found it very cute. So we were so excited to find a place in Sarasota Florida. They offer a Wide selection of Ice Cream and other tasty treats...your sweet tooth will be pleased. My only disappointment was...in the parking lot they offer pay by plate options, however it says complimentary if shopping at the shopping center. Not knowing if I needed a receipt to validate I asked a young man at Kilwin's how parking worked...he looked at me with a straight face and said "I don't know." I did later find out from a young girl how it worked but very disappointing to hear I don't know about something in your parking lot. We ordered our ice cream sat a little table outside and just enjoyed a nice evening in Sarasota. If you have never been to Kilwin's you need to visit it is DELICIOUS!!!!! read more

Wanted to take my children out for ice cream after a nice beach day, as we were deciding what flavor to choose from i see this !!! totally unacceptable! read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Who doesn't love Kilwin's for ice cream and candies? If you haven't tried them yet, then you should put them on your list. They have many stores all over Florida and the US now. We ordered a few candies and peanut brittle last night. It smelled so good in their store. It's nicely decorated, too. Our server was friendly and helpful. This store is wheelchair accessible. read more

See all

The new management is amazing! The service and quality is what you expect from Kilwin's. So happy they will be open consistently with all the sweet treats on the key! read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Milkshake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Kenny and Mario were extremely nice and hospitable. The place looked brand new inside as well. My recommendation is that the chocolate fudge there is to die for. Would definitely recommend trying if you ride the trolley through Siesta Key.! read more

Gabby and Zach are the best ever! So nice, accommodating, and funny! I love them so much! I work down the road and all my coworkers were craving something bad for us!! They made it happen! Round of applause for Gabby and Zach! My coworkers and I will be back. read more

Loved everything about our treats, ice cream, and the amazing service! The best part was reminding them that our UGA Dawgs will take care of the Gators this year!! We will be back every visit to the key! read more

Not a fan of this Kilwins location. We've tried it a few times, and each time walk away dissatisfied. When it first opened, the service was slow and young teens working were extremely rude. We also were surprised that the store seemed so dirty for a grand opening. Employees need training in the area of cleanliness and customer service. With so many other options for sweets in the area, we won't return again. Made in Rome has awesome gelato and Fudge Factory has the best selection of sweets and ice cream at much more affordable prices, and employees with a sense of humor and fun atmosphere! read more

I was a little sad that the Key had issues with their power going out and a transformer blew that caused our local businesses to have issues. FPL should really do repairs much quicker. We miss the peanut butter fudge and with these FPL issues we'll have to wait again. read more

New owners Mario and Zach were the sweetest and greeted us with the biggest smiles! Kilwins is always amazing and we will back every night we can during our visit to Sarasota on Siesta Key. read more

Met the new owner and his associate. So pleasant. Very glad the new owner has all the things that makes Kilwins so good. All the cases were filled and fresh please give this location another chance if you had been there before. read more

If you love sweet desert , try this one ! Great service and tasty ice cream !close to the beach ! Beautiful people and food around here . Will recommend everyone to try this ice cream ! read more

See all

I just took my family for ice cream including 3 kids, 2 of which have peanut and tree nut allergies. The staff went above and beyond in accommodating by washing hands, using gloves, using a clean scooper, and even better scooped from a brand new container of ice cream. Cross contamination in food service contributes to many food allergy reactions and I felt 100% safe in the precautions and steps they took. Much appreciated as I know it was outside their typical duties. read more

I love kilwins, and boy do I love this one more. There was a nice Kosh behind the counter, hair COMPLETELY covering his face (because he's alpha). The kosh guy gave me the ice cream and I sure did enjoyed the yummy frank. It was Chocolate chip ice cream, good! Very clean, splendid music, beautiful place tbh. Crazy fudge factory goin on too, wild. read more

Ok. There are a LOT of ice cream shops on Siesta Key... Kilwins is more than great ice cream. Kilwin's is so much more. You can watch the toffee being made, the selection of chocolatier items: chocolate covered Oreos, nuts, truffles, marshmallows!, the home made confectioners in small batches... it's hometown goodness and from scratch recipes. The people are 5-star too--greeted with smiles. There's a nice outdoor area to sit and relax, too. Can't miss this new store on Siesta Key - fabulous. A++. Oh! The fudge!! It's an experience -- family recipe celebrated since 1947. read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - a variety of chocolates - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

The kids and all of us were so excited for Kilwins to open in siesta key! We finished dinner in a rush and ran over there and got there at 9:54pm. Much to our surprise and disappointment, they had closed and locked their doors at 9:54pm. We knocked on the door and pointed at our watches asking them to please open. An older gentleman, walked to over to the door and instead of opening the door he twisted the locked to confirm it was locked and walked away. The younger teens working at the counter smiled in relief that the doors were locked. It was very disappointing that they closed early. read more

Tried to visit during their posted business hours (around 8:00pm) last Monday and Tuesday (7/29, 7/30) and they were closed. We thought the location might have been shut down permanently, but everything inside appeared ready for business and the POS screen was even on. Disappointing. read more

These people were rude. Kilwins post they close at 10pm yet they closed 7 min early and didn't care We arrived in time before they close. We weren't the only family either. We pointed out they were closing before 10 and just came to the door to ensure the doors were locked while thinking they were coming to the door to open. Extremely disappointed and rude of them. read more

Very unfriendly service. So disappointing for us considering we loved visiting Kilwins in other states. Came to our turn and the young lady behind the counter just stared and us, and when we asked if she was ready, she rolled her eyes, shrugged and said "well, yeah". No greeting, no "what would you like?", very rude. Will never come back. read more

Best ice cream in Siesta Key hands down. The staff was so friendly and knowledgeable about their products. One employee in particular Charlie, was very kind and she made us feel very welcome, we will definitely come back! The cake batter flavor is outstanding and their fresh homemade fudge is amazing. Better than any competitor in the area, you must try!! read more

Poor training, understaffed, and lack of management during the height of tourist season are the reasons for the one star.

Attend Kilwins Siesta Key Grand Opening on Saturday! Was welcomed by Kilwins Employees the second I walked in the door with a smile on their face. The aroma when you walk in the doors is like no other! The staff was very friendly and attentive! You must visit Kilwins Siesta Key! Ice cream is out of this world! read more

as a local, it's a huge bummer that this kilwin's does not have the kilwin's experience. since opening, this location has gotten worse and worse. I will no longer even try at this point. it's only a matter of time until this closes down. you cannot have a kilwins with empty chocolate displays and no fresh waffle cones being made. the employees are unmotivated and not helping this business at all. the kid that makes the chocolate is completely unprofessional in saying that he doesn't have time to make the chocolate. wont be going back and will take my business somewhere else. What a shame. read more

They make the best fudge, candied apples, popcorn, ice cream & everyone is so friendly & service oriented! I took my young grandson there & he loved watching them make fudge; he even got to taste it before we left & of course after the ice cream!! I'll be getting my Easter treats from Kilwins Siesta Key just as I did at Christmas!! Thank you all for making our search for the best ice cream a learning adventure!! read more

My boyfriend and I came down to Siesta Key from Tampa for a little staycation, we decided to stop at Kilwins for some ice cream and a caramel apple (which was fantastic!). Bailey was so helpful deciding on flavors, she was also so sweet and kind to everyone in line. It's so nice to see a young lady that knows how to carry a conversation all while efficiently taking care of all of the guests in the store. She made sure to be kind to every single person in there shining a little bit of light on everyones day. She made our experience at Kilwins so wonderful. Thank you Bailey! Keep being the cheerful person you are! read more

Absolutely the best place to go! Great location! Perfectly run! The best products!! Couldn't be any better!