So we searched this place out because we heard they truly make the best key lime pie in the area... you know, everybody says they have the best one... But, this pie is outstanding. Not only do they sell key lime, but other flavors, as well as cakes and candies... The English toffee is thick and oh so tasty. Cute shop, friendly staff- Find this place- hidden off of 41 south of Siesta Key.... You won't be disappointed! read more

Flo's Bakery & Gifts - Bakeries Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

The best key lime pie in the area, hands down! Definitely stop in here and take a moment to enjoy the pie. Sit outside on the porch or even just enjoy it in your car. Either way, you will love it. The cookies and cakes are great also but, key lime pie and the guava cake ... please just go! read more

It's so hard to find gluten-free and or gluten-free and dairy free offerings in any area, but I found the most delicious Keylime pie here at Flo's bakery. I ordered a piece on one trip along with a delicious scone and then returned for a whole pie to serve for my friends visit later on. Happily I wound enjoying most of the incredible pie for myself. I live 30 minutes away in Englewood but will return for sure. read more

Amazing Keylime pie and other bakery treats. A handful of gluten-free options and one dairy free option as well.

When we have company from out of town or other special occasion we like to splurge on a key Lime pie.. it's amazing! Waaay better than Detwilers or Publix but of course there is a significant price difference too. Highly recommended and used by us since 2015 read more

Amazing! Everything was fantastic! It's truly a hidden gem! The key lime pie and orange cake are delicious!

Ok yall just buy pies from here. Seriously best pies ever. Like ever. I'm actually a really good baker but I can't justify even spending the time baking one when theirs are so insanely good. read more

Incredible service and the best key lime pie outside of key west! As a native key west resident this is the only place I'll go to get my fix in the Tampa area. The owner and staff are wonderful. 10/10 recommend!! read more

I'm a fan of Key Lime Pie and this bakery makes the best KLP I've ever eaten: the perfect balance of tangy sourness and sweetness as well as texture, proportion of crust, pie filling and topping. Crust was crumbled graham cracker and not plain pie crust. Friendly service too! read more

Flo's Bakery & Gifts - Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

My favorite bakery in Sarasota!! Best Key Lime pie I've ever had. Adorable shop if you need a gift, too.

My husband and I had mini key lime pies and key lime bundt cakes from Flo's for our wedding! We sampled all the key lime pies in Sarasota that we could find and these are hands down the best!! She also custom made the bundt cakes for the rehearsal dinner and they were absolutely amazing. read more

WOW - their key lime pie is incredible. We were at a friend's for dinner and that was my first taste of heaven. It was light, tasty, smooth and oh so good. We were in the area and picked up a pie to bring home. The nice thing is you can keep it in the freezer and bring it out, cut a slice, put it back in the freezer and let your piece thaw to eat. I'm looking forward to trying her other beautiful looking pies and pastries. Oh the smell, when you walk into the bakery, is incredible. read more

The best Key lime pie I have ever tasted. And the orange cake ruined mt LDL numbers but was incredfibly delicious

Came here from out of town, and this was some of the best key lime pie I have ever had!! The texture, flavor, crust, EVERYTHING was perfect. They also have a variety of other desserts that looked amazing. They sell a whole key lime pie, but also slices for anyone who just wants one slice. The cashier was also very helpful and recommended some restaurants for us to try in the area. 10/10 recommend this place! read more

Flo's Bakery & Gifts - Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Believe it. The key lime pie is incredible. Not pictured: me eating the last piece out of the pan, in the airport on the way home, so it doesn't go to waste. Pies come frozen to thaw and eat. Yum. read more

Recommended as having the best Keylime pie in Sarasota. I concur. Be aware that it is a little hard to find. It is at the backside of the strip mall. One walks on the sidewalk from the parking area in front back to where you will see a sign for the bakery read more

We bought a Key Lime pie, and it was delicious! Plus the folks who worked there were very friendly.

Key lime pie was amazing, had football party and pie was great ending, even though the game wasn't what we wanted

The best key lime pie ever! So clean tasting and the crust is perfect! Don't hesitate to buy 2 pies. The 1st one will go fast.

Best key lime pie ever. Tried a lemon meringue mini pie and that was also outstanding. Highly recommended.

The best key lime pie in Sarasota area. So creamy and just tart enough to bring out that authentic key lime flavor.

I've heard about Flo's Floribbean for some time now. They are famous for their key lime pie. I would agree it's the best around. I picked up a pie for an event recently. It was loved by everyone. Would definitely be back for the key lime and perhaps the peanut butter. The pie was frozen which was perfect for me as it allowed me the flexibility to purchase and thaw prior to the event. Five stars. Delicious. Nice and tart first, followed with a dash of sweetness. read more

THE BEST KEY LIME AND HONEY ORANGE CAKE! The Keylime pie is the freshest and most delicious keylime pie I have ever had in all of Florida, the honey orange cake is super moist and taste like freshly squeezed oranges with a touch of honey. Apart from the obvious dessert masterpiece, the owners are incredibly nice and welcoming. This is a must visit place in Sarasota! Thay have a customer for life now! read more

What a lovely little bakery with lovely people running it. I saw an article claiming that this bakery has the best key lime pie so i had to try it out. Now i don't even like key lime pie but this was probably the best I've ever had. It was the perfect balance of sour and sweet. I throughly enjoyed it. The lemon poppy seed cake was a little too sour for my taste but overall i liked it. read more

Wow! I finally found passion fruit pie! My hubby and I love the flavor of passion fruit. Our search is over! They make them here along with their most popular key lime pie, coconut pie, and a lot of other options. They also make fruit baskets and gift baskets, and sell some fun Floridian stuff like decorations, jellies, dressings, sauces, etc. This is a very small store and most likely you will miss it. You may not even find it if not for Yelp. Check this place out. They also have sandwiches from what I see as well as some beautiful delicious chocolate truffles. read more

See all

Very overdue review, but this place was great for delivering a special holiday present to my family in Florida! They made it so easy to place the order, my family said the order came beautifully wrapped. Most important they said the Key Lime Pie and cookies were AMAZING. read more

Best Keylime pie in Florida! We used to think Publix was good, but Flo's will knock your socks off!

Best key Lime pie I have ever had! I've tried over 100 key Lime pies and flo's tops my list by far! read more

The absolute best key lime pie Florida has to offer. Homemade, and amazing. There's no better key lime pie for purists than this!

This place is slightly hard to find (it's tucked around the corner in a small shopping center), but it's worth it! You'll find a small selection of gifts as well as an array of Floridian candies (nice to take home!) The biggest draw is the bakery; cakes, cookies and more are available, and I'm here to tell you that you can't NOT try a Limey cookie -- basically a key lime pie in a cookie form. Flo's also makes gift baskets, which seems to be a large chunk of the business, and they have enough tropical goodies to make a fabulous "Greetings From Florida"-type basket yourself! A nice place to stop for a Floridian treat! read more

Flo's Bakery & Gifts - Business card - Bakeries Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

When you hear great things about a place, expectations are higher. I wasn't wowed, especially since I didn't receive what I ordered. Disappointing. Many of the baked goods are frozen, which for a bakery was surprising. The chocolates looked great, but since the bakery items were frozen, I wasn't sure how long the chocolates had been there and I didn't buy any. read more

Products tried- Rum Bundt and Honeybell Bundt. Both are moist tasty. A little on the sweet side. Rum Bundt a little too Rummy for my taste. Other people might like it this way. Honeybell Orange Bundt- is good. Pies tried- Keylime and Passion fruit. both taste more like cheesecake pie. A little on the sweet side. Key lime pie is so far the best I've tried in FL. Passion fruit is also good. All Bundts and Pies are $30 each (must be the inflation). If you can't decide and can't commit on a whole pie or cake, try a slice of each then get the whole pie/cake you like. A slice per person goes a long way and satisfying. Great piece for holiday or house warming treat. The owner seems nice not as chatty/friendly. Maybe it's at the end of the business day and she is exhausted. It's a one woman shop. I drove 50min to try this place and brought back 2 key lime pies to California for peeps to try. It's worth coming out to try. Gave it 4stars because they were a little on the sweet side (and I love sweets), a bit pricey, and owner can be a tad friendly. read more

Excellent Key Lime Pie, best in Sarasota! I was lucky to find this place on the Nextdoor app, Floribbean Flo's was highly recommended. Not only do they have delicious pies, truffles, cookies, olive oils, and lots of other gifts, I also met a very sweet lady behind the counter and she was extremely helpful. I will be returning many times for goodies and gifts! read more

It's true - best key lime pie ever. Can't wait to try all the other goodies. Just the smell of the place is divine!

Truffles were very good. I was a little put off when I asked for a coconut macaroon and the woman pulled it out of the freezer. I had to let it thaw before I could enjoy it: I have to be honest, it turned out to be very good. I'm giving it 4 stars because everything was delicious. I knocked off one star because I've never had to wait for a pastry to thaw that I bought directly from the baker...... read more

If you're looking for key lime pie, this is the place to come! I come from Maryland every summer and spend my birthday at the beach. Instead of cake, I get a Key Lime Pie. Sooooo good! The coconut cream pie is also good, and we love the almond toffee bars. Keep in mind the pies are sold as whole pies, not by the slice. $20 per pie. Not cheap, but worth it for the best key lime pie in Sarasota. read more

Delicious, fresh, light...I never liked key lime pie before I tried Flo's REAL key lime pie. It's the real key lime that makes all the difference. OUTSTANDING! You have not tasted key lime pie until you try Flo's. read more

We had read about the key lime pie and orange cake and could not wait to try both. We did and definitely NOT disappointed. They were both wonderful. We savored every last crumb! Don't walk to Flo's...run! You won't be disappointed read more

Was really hankering to try some authentic Key Lime Pie...and these reviews convinced me! NOTE: I HAVE NEVER TRIED KEY LIME PIE BEFORE, SO I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING TO COMPARE THIS EXPERIENCE TO. Upon entering, we were greeted...but not so enthusiastically. The front of the shop had many knick knacks, and the back of shop was a display of truffles and cookies, as well as the counter. I expected the lady at the counter to inquire whether we had been here before or ask if we wanted taste...but nothing. She just stared at us. I asked her how large a key lime pie was and how much. She said a 9" was $15. I asked if they offered a smaller size, since I didn't want to pay for something I had not tried before. And she curtly replied that they offered slices for $3.50. Perfect! I asked for two slices and asked if I could pay with card, since I did not have cash. She said probably not...okay...so you don't know? I ended up purchasing an entire pie so that I could pay with card. Cut myself a nice slice...and it was just SO sweet. I understand that the pie is made with condensed milk, but WOW just SO SWEET. I tried to pair it with a glass of milk. But one bite of the pie is really enough. Not so happy with their lack of customer service and I wasn't a huge fan of their key lime pie... read more

Flo's Bakery & Gifts - 9" Key Lime $15 - Bakeries Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Came back and ordered more passion fruit/key lime pies to bring home. And these other goodies are worth a try. They're pricey but the taste is worth it imo. The pies went up a dollar in pricing. They offer shipping to their other goodies but not the pies. read more

Flo's Bakery & Gifts - Other goodies besides their awesome pies. - Bakeries Near Me - Sarasota, Florida