[[HIGHLIGHT]]Pete and Jim are so helpful.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I had a bracelet repaired and it's perfect again. (Go LA.) Also, l was thinking of rendering a ring , but once Jim polished (free) it shined like new. I plan on visiting again next time.I have any jewelry repair needs. I highly recommend this business! read more

Kingsley Jewelry - My polished ring - Jewelry Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Not too long ago I messed up my finger and it ended up swelling up pretty bad. As a result I had to have my wedding ring cut off. (Too be fair it was a bit too tight even before my accident). Kingsley Jewelry cut it off at no cost. They suggested I give my finger some time to heal, and they would measure and resize my ring. Well, my finger is healed and I went back in and dropped it off. Less than 24 hours later and I have my ring back. It looks absolutely amazing and there is no way to tell it was ever cut. Remarkable work. read more

Built a fab ring for me out of stuff I had and a stone I brought in. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Awesome! There's a reason it's busy![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]

[[HIGHLIGHT]]I love shopping here. It's always a good experience.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The owner is very knowledgeable, passionate about his craft and generous with his time.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I have purchased several items from this business and have never been disappointed. The prices are the best in town. I believe the selection he carries will suit everyone's style and budget . Repairs are very reasonable too! I believe he even guarantees purchases and repairs. What more could you ask for ! Thank you Kingsley Jewelry, now I know why you have been voted "Best of Clay" for years. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Everything was great, but I don't believe this is the same one I was thinking of.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] However, [[HIGHLIGHT]]I'd give the jewelers five stars[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Needed to replace some watch batteries and the spot I used to use had closed. I've been by this store many many times but never stopped in. What a surprise to learn it's been here 30 years! Shame on me for not coming in before. Staff was very pleasant and gave me pricing range up front. They let me leave the watches there and called me when they were completed, which was very quickly, even though I had not made an appointment and they seemed busy with Christmas shoppers and other guests. When I returned I took in a ring I thought had a loose stone. Not only did they take a look at it they cleaned it for me as well. All at no charge. I feel very comfortable knowing I'll be coming back for some custom work I want done. They are closed from 12/31 - 1-11 for vacation. read more

Kingsley Jewelry on Kingsley Ave. in Orange Park is by far the best jewelry store in the area. I'm not sure of all of the names but [[HIGHLIGHT]]Mile was the main contact I spoke to when I went in to purchase an engagement ring.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It wasn't a standard engagement ring as she prefers a specific stone to diamonds, along with a specific non-traditional design. [[HIGHLIGHT]]They did have a ring similar to what I was looking for and Mike told me he had a couple more of the gems coming in and was confident one of them would be what I was looking for.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Oh on top of the specs of the ring itself I was also on a time crunch since we were leaving for a family cruise for Christmas and I wanted to propose on Christmas Eve.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] As it turned out the one gem he wanted did not make it in time but another did that was stunning. In just a couple weeks time and being the busiest time of the year, he was able to perfectly create the design I wanted better than I could imagine with the gem as a center piece accented with gorgeous baguette diamonds. Being it wasn't exactly what we spoke of he said that if I took this one and she says Yes, Of I wanted to still go with the original idea then we could bring it back and he would swap out the stones. Which she did and he did. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It was a particularly hard time but Mike and his team made us feel like we were his only clients at the time.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I simply had to share this story because it's getting harder and harder to find places that not only take a great deal of pride in their work which in this case was exquisite but also those extra steps to help you when you need it most. I will never use another store for any of my jewelry needs and I will make sure anyone I speak to know's as well. Being from the North East I thought I'd never find a place that could match the jewelers back there. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Kingsley jewelry in not only on par with those they exceed on their pricing of course but it's the customer service and attention to detail that sealed it with me.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I'm actually not one who writes reviews but the experience I had just needed to be shared. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I thank Mike and the rest of the staff for everything and look forward to more positive encounters there.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Sincerely, Scott K. read more

Lovely people. Typical mom and pop store with amazing customer service. Must go if you ever need jewelry or watch battery repair

Can't say enough good things about this business. Went to Shipleys jewelry store and got a run around about how long to downsize my ring. So I picked it up vowed never to do business there ever again. Went to Kingsley Jewelers and got my ring done in a day at 40.00 instead of 100.00 Shipleys was going to charge me. Outrageous! So happy I went to Kingsley Jewelers. They have a customer for life now read more

I had a deeply disappointing experience with Kingsley Jewelry that I feel compelled to share. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I dropped off six rings on December 4, 2024, and was told that they would be ready as early as December 7. After waiting until December 10th without any communication, I called to check on my order and was informed that my rings were third in line.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]When I followed up again on December 13, I was met with an excuse about being busy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I explained that I needed one specific ring for a wedding by December 17, and was assured it would be ready by 4 PM that day. When I arrived right at 4, I was greeted by the owner's daughter, who had a significant attitude and reiterated how busy they were.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I requested my ring back, but instead was told to wait as they would size it for me then. After a 30-minute wait, I finally got the ring. I made it clear that I needed my emerald and diamond ring done before Christmas, and they agreed to that timeline. Fast forward to December 24, when I went in to pick up my ring, only to find it was not ready. I was told the jeweler would work on it while I waited. After some time, the jeweler came out and explained that they had attempted to add white gold, but my ring was made of some strange metal and they couldn't put it back together. This left me without a present for my son's new wife on Christmas Eve--absolutely unacceptable. [[HIGHLIGHT]]While I was in the store, I spotted a pair of man-made diamond earrings and asked about a deal. The owner kindly gifted them to me, which was a nice gesture, but it didn't make up for the overall experience.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I left the remaining rings for sizing, and when I finally received a call that they were ready, I was given an estimate of 200 to 240 to size my rings on 12/4/2024. Here's where it gets really frustrating: I brought in 12.6 grams of gold, valued at $380 per the scrape they called it on my sales ticket. Now the estimate of 240 at the high-end now is you BROKE EVEN, they did not pay me the difference from the gold I bought in. After all the hassle, I ended up being ripped off by at least $100 plus a broken ring returned to me unwearable. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The man-made diamond earrings, which I initially thought were a nice gift, felt more like a consolation prize for the terrible service I experienced.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] In summary, my experience with Kingsley Jewelry was frustrating and disappointing from start to finish. I will never recommend or purchase anything from this company again. Save your time and money and look elsewhere for your jewelry needs. read more

Don't go anywhere else but here to buy, create or fix jewelry. Without a doubt the best in town or even the state of Florida. Highly recommended! Awesome staff! read more

Kingsley Jewelry - Restored vintage ring. FYI, my cuban grandmother, Abi, didn't look that scary in real life. She's kill me if she new this pic was posted. - Jewelry Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

I brought several items In to be fixed. I brought two necklaces, both my wedding ring, And a bracelet. Well not even two days after I got them back the necklace broke like maybe he fixed the wrong part of it. I had to get my wedding rings sized bigger. Now I've been married for 18 years and never had a problem. Like a week after I got it back one of the diamonds broke and feel out. This is a really expensive ring. I've called and left over 5 messages with the owner and he did not once call me back to rectify it. I will never bring my jewelry back there again!!! If I were you I would go somewhere else!!!!z read more

I don't have a lot of experience with jewelers or jewelry at all, but while searching for someone to help me incorporate my moms diamond from her engagement ring into mine, we ended up here. This was our third stop of the day and I was beginning to get discouraged as the other places we stopped, one being a Kay Jewelers, were unfriendly and just plain uncomfortable. I am so glad we did not give up, though. We were helped immediately and given great information (that was actually accurate). I immediately felt comfortable with the owner. The selection they have is great! I was given time to make decisions and not pressured at all. My ring is beautiful and We cannot wait to go pick out our wedding bands here soon! Please do yourself a favor and skip the chain jewelry stores and give this place a chance. You will not regret it. read more

Kingsley Jewelry - Jewelry Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Friendly people, service was awesome , we were in and out within 15 minutes, of course 3 watches need batteries and one new watch need some bracelet adjustment, simple work but we're impressed read more

I'm not the "leave a review" kinda guy but Kingsley Jewelry definitely deserve this 5 star review! Huge shootout to Mike and Robin for their amazing customer service and craftsmanship on my custom made engagement ring for my now fiancé. My fiancé absolutely loves her ring and the quality of the Diamond is incredible. I'm so glad I found Kingsley on Google and gave them a chance. All future Diamond purchases will 10000% go through them and highly recommended! read more

Thank you so much Kingsley Jewelry for fixing my ring that Zales messed up! The fastest most professional service I've ever received. Highly recommend. read more

Friendly service! Lots of unique jewelry. Highly recommend this long time local business

They got the job done but you know when someone is forced to help you out vice wanting to help you. Went there and the doors weren't locked for "everyone " coming in and out but when I went in with my husband and son all sudden doors were locked getting in and out but wasn't for everyone else. Hmm makes me wonder. Like I said they got my batteries replaced but weren't friendly at all except for the burnette female that was working there. read more

All I have to say is that the guy that seems to be in charge at Kingsley Jewelry has got to be the rudest individual I've come across in awhile. My wife and I went there for jewelry repair. We were dealing with a nice lady as we heard him telling a customer, "I gotta make some money here" and "if I give it to you for that price, I should've just started home." The lady we were dealing with had to answer the phone. She was on the line for maybe a minute when yelled at her to hang up and deal with the current customers. He was still talking about how he had to make money. We took our jewelry and left. This is actually the 2nd time I've witnessed his behavior. Needless to say, I'll never step foot in there again and I'll be telling folks I know not to use them either. read more

I love this place! Great service! Great prices! I have bought a ring, a beautiful diamond, a bracelet, two Rolex watches!! Mike is dedicated & loyal, remembers names, works w/ you, I can't say enough about this place. read more

Kingsley Jewelry - Jewelry Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Outstanding customer service. Today I went in for a new watch battery and they replaced it for no charge. I offered to pay her for her time and she declined saying that it was "under store warranty" . She even replaced a pin on my watchband at no charge. I sure hope that they stay in business because I never want to go anywhere else! Only place to go for watch batteries!! read more

I was really surprised to read the review about the owner being cocky. I have been in Kingsley Jewelry a number of times and the owner and younger guy are always extremely helpful and nice. Maybe the reviewer was having a bad day. It happens. Anyway, they have done everything from change a watch battery to tighten my watch clasp to giving me an estimate on a custom ring. Every time I go in, they clean my ring for no charge. I have experienced nothing but good service. Absolutely no complaints! read more

dropped off my rolex for repairs. left it for a week, was promised it would get timed by Tuesday and they would call me. no call, no work, they never did anything. I also had a rose gold chain that i needed 2 inches added. Again a week with them, no work at all performed. no phone call as promised, a complete waste of time.all read more

I absolutely LOVE the staff here. Went to have my engagement ring sized up because the original jeweler didn't size it correctly. I went in for a consult and told Robin that I absolutely didn't want to go a day without my beautiful ring. She went ABOVE AND BEYOND by taking down my number and calling me with a date and time that I could actually go in and have the ring done while I waited. When I got there, Mike allowed me to go sit in the back with Reuben and actually watch while he sized it. The process was SO COOL! I can't imagine any other jewelry store, ESPECIALLY big chains, doing any of those things! The customer service is absolutely awesome and the jewelry on-site is GORGEOUS! Definitely will be buying my future hubby's wedding band from here as well as any other future jewelry purchases! They have a customer for life! I LOVE KINGSLEY JEWELERS! read more

I came here to get a diamond replaced on hubby's wedding band. They were pretty busy when I entered just an hour or so after they opened, but handled the customers with decorum, patience and no sense of "why are these people all here!?" attitude. I looked at their merchandise before leaving and was helped by Mike. Honestly, I'm probably the antithesis of what most people think women should be about jewelry. I don't care if its real or fake, as long as I think it's pretty, I like it. I don't know anything about clarity etc. (That's all I know lol) Mike showed me a few rings that could match my hubby's band (They actually had an exact copy of his band at a far lower price than I paid. Hurts, but useful to know!) They deal wholesale. I didn't realize what experienced, devout jewelers could do with an existing piece. There was a ring that I loved except for this huge gem sticking way up. He explained that they could bevel? set it to make it lower and more in tune with my taste. (I like tasteful and elegant versus loud and flashy.) I decided to go ahead and get it with all the changes he talked about. Also, I only had one more errand to run and really just expected to pick up hubby's ring the next day, but they called before I was even done with the errand and said that it was ready. Reasonable price for repairs too!! Gotta tell ya, I fell in love with this place. The only stickler is that the parking sucks. It's right off the main road and to get out you have to back out into the road. Didn't seem too busy, but it was pretty early in the day for traffic. I can't imagine what it may be during rush hour. Add in the fact that I'm pretty awful in reverse. Helpful hint: Coming from Blanding to Kingsley, it's just past the railroad tracks on the right. It'll sneak up on ya if you don't look out for it. read more

Took an expensive watch for repair because it was losing 2 minutes a day. After leaving the watch with them for 5 weeks I was able to pick it up. The next day, it was not working correctly. Took it back and they kept it 10 days and said it was running fine. Not so. It still looses time and they charged me $375.00 for repairs. After posting this review, I was contacted by the business and given a total refund. For that, I give thanks. read more

Wonderful service, great prices, super nice people. I love supporting small businesses and the people here make it easy to keep Coming back. Thanks!! read more

Great little local jewelry store Michael the owner offers repairs, custom jewelry ,consignment and appraisals and his work is just beautiful Great prices well below retail. Or just coming to chat with him he's fun and entertaining read more

We moved to Orange Park 25 years ago and have used Kingsley Jewelry that entire time. Most often we needed ring sizing or a watch battery, but most recently I had something a bit more involved. I have a ring with a heart shaped pearl, in a very unusual setting that overlaps my wide gold wedding band. The pearl after 34 years had fallen out. Fortunately it was found and I brought it in to have it repaired. A few weeks after the repair, the pearl fell out a second time, found again, but before I could bring it back in, Covid 19 hit. When I finally did bring it back in, some 6 months later, the jeweler reinstalled the pearl and obviously knowing that a heart shaped pearl would be impossible to replace, added a simple gold wire loop on the side of the pearl, insuring that now I can wear the ring with confidence and that there is no chance it will ever fall out again. I did not ask him to do this and he did not charge me. It was such an inventive way to protect the pearl and was a pleasant surprise. That is the kind of old fashioned service that you just don't find very often. read more

I am so happy that I found Kingsley Jewelry!!! The staff is fantastic and their repair service was wonderful. After being disappointed twice at Jared's in St. John's Town Center for the work performed on sizing my engagement ring, I gave up going there and decided to take my ring for a 'make over' to Kingsley. WOW! what a wonderful job they did on my ring and how much easier it is to take my ring on and off with no pain as well as how much more smooth and 'finished' it looks. Thank you Kingsley Jewelers! you guys rock and I will be forever your customer!!! read more

Everyone is always so nice and helpful and they really take great personal pride in not only their craftsmanship but their personal service. We have always gone there for our jewelry but last week I took in a ring to be repaired last week that was really special to me. Its an angel ring my husband bought me after my son was killed years ago and I NEVER take it off. When dropping it off they said they would get it back to me in a day or two, as soon as possible. I was shocked to get a call 2 hours later. They knew how important it is to me and went the extra mile. Ty, ty, ty!!! And it looked amazing. read more

The best. The very best. Every time I'm in there for repairs they are wonderful. Nice having people you can trust with your things.

The customer service from the owner was heinous. He twisted my words and showed no concern for my service. He was rude and terribly angry for no particular reason. The rest of the staff were great! Still- I will not go back or recommend. It turned what should have been a great experience-buying jewelry into a bad one. Go elsewhere-and enjoy the experience! read more

Wow! Dropped off my wife's wedding ring on January 15 to have it put into another setting as she has developed an allergy to gold. I was told that their designer was out of town and would be back in 5 days. After 15 Days I called to check on the status of our ring. Was told the designer was delayed in getting back in town. They would call me in the next few days. 10 days later I walk into the store and ask about my wife's ring. First they can't find the order. Then the owner comes out and says he called my wife and there was no reply. Um wrong answer as I gave them my cell number not my wife's. So I tell him I understand that you had issues with your designer being out of town. But I brought the ring in 30 days before my anniversary with the plan of giving the new ring to her on our big day. The owner looks at me and says do you want your ring back? You can guess what my answer was to this cocky jerk!! Do not use this jeweler!! read more