I can't believe I didn't take pictures. That's not like me!…read more I ordered the English toffee with coffee on a waffle cone. The ice cream was really creamy with lots of toffee chunks and a delicious coffee flavor. The waffle cone was crunchy and was a little thicker than one's I've had in the past. I liked it because it didn't get soggy and stayed crunchy to the very end I only have a couple of complaints. The ice cream had some coffee grinds blended in the ice cream which added some bitter flavors. My second complaint is the menu board looked like it was written by a fourth grader. Spend some money on a proper menu board or learn some hieroglyphics.

This place blows my mind with the new flavors. Usually u can only get flavors this wack/obscure in…read moresome $15-a-scoop costal tourist trap, or a cold stone special promoting some dumbass kids movie, and it doesn't really even taste like anything when u eat it?? But wow this place consistently has the biggest variety of flavors from hot honey to lemon poppyseed. Great place, nice people, even better ice cream

Ice cream was great and you can't beat the $1 per scoop. Girls were friendly. We will be back!read more

We stopped in after a less than impressive meal elsewhere. They serve Farr ice cream, which is a…read moregood brand. Cash only, no cards. Service is really prompt and prices are reasonable. I'd go back often if I lived in Pocatello.

Well I love ice cream so naturally I love this place…read more I think that Coldstone does a good job at creating great cups of happiness. I mean when you put ice cream and delicious toppings and mix them all together... how can it not be delicious? exactly. There are so many choices! They have signature items (which are more pricey) that have lots of great toppings and are just super good concoctions. I love the german chocolate cake one the best! Or you can make your own. I love getting vanilla with peanut butter and bananas! Or if you are really feeling lame, you can just get a scoop! They also have lots of other options for desserts, if you want more than just ice cream. The girls working here were very friendly and great! They let us stay and eat after they were closed. If you sign up for email, they will send you coupons all the time!

Very disappointed with our experience. We ordered two ice…read morecream cakes online 5 days in advance, requesting "Happy Birthday" messages along with our daughters' names to be written on top. When we got the cakes home, we realized the writing was spelled incorrectly, was very messy, and our daughters' names weren't even included. We called the store and simply asked if the cakes could be exchanged for two blank ones so we could have the messages written correctly. Unfortunately, that request was denied, and we were told the only option was to bring the cakes back so they could be fixed. We returned to the store, and the employee attempted to correct the writing. Unfortunately, the cakes ended up looking even worse than they did originally. For something we ordered well in advance for our daughters' birthdays, this was extremely disappointing. We expected the order to be completed correctly, especially with 5 days' notice. Sadly, we will not be ordering from this store again in the future.

Great workers unfortunately management was clueless on coupons and refused to give us our free…read morecookie.

POOR SERVICE Cookies are always great but customer service…read moreis poor! No one acknowledges you when you walk in, or even says anything if you make eye contact. They all look miserable to work there. Even a little hello would go along way. It's uncomfortable and makes you want to get in and out fast.

Great Icecream with a very friendly knowledgeable clerk. We also got a couple milkshakes and a root…read morebeer float. They are set up to do a variety of floats. We didn't try any nuts or popcorn, but they also looked great. We'll stop again when we're in the area.

A favorite stop when we are downtown grab a cone and comb through the vinyl collections. Owner is…read morealways friendly and helpful.

Glad to see they exist in what feels like a dying downtown. The service was good after I found…read moresomeone to help us in the music store next door. The ice cream is not homemade but purported to be local and portion size was good. I went for the Big Daddy flavor because I love chocolate, caramel and nuts but it felt gritty. There was a strong odor in the shop but maybe it was a cleaner of some sort?

When we ordered drinks the girl helping us was giving us patronizing comments. She wasn't kind to…read moremy grandma who was just trying her best to say some of the words. When we ordered cookies she got our order wrong and she didn't care. We aren't planning on coming back because of how bad the service was.

There was plenty of space for parking and they have a drive-thru window for ordering. This place…read moreserves ice cream, cookies, very limited appetizer food options, and off course an array of soda/energy drinks with flavored mix-in options. Tried a few different items including the huckleberry ice cream and the Harry Potter soda drink. I had asked a few questions prior to ordering a soda drink about the flavor options and the cashier could not really answer them since she had not tried the drinks I asked about before. Overall, the items were just okay. I do not think I would go out of my way to stop at one again.

Underrated! My wife and I stopped in on a Friday night when…read moremost other places were closed. We were greeted by a friendly cashier, and the "Reeses Royale" frozen custard we ordered was super tasty.

We always stop when we see a Freddys. We don't have them where we live. So reasonable and…read moredelicious. The staff is so friendly and service is always fast. The interior is clean and large

This place can't be beat. Once you try the pastries you will be back over and over again. Most…read moredeserts you get in restaurants are too rich. These are not that way but just sweet enough to tickle your tastebuds. Everything we have tried has been best in class. This place has become a regular stop when I am in town to see my grandkids.

We were so happy with everything we ordered. Wish we could've tried everything. Since we live in…read moreCalifornia we did our best to try as much as possible. But failed. We ordered the huckleberry macaron ice cream sandwich which was perfectly soft and crispy and delicious. There is no extra charge for their homemade waffle cones or bowls for their delicious hand dipped ice cream. My husband got the chocolate marshmallow ice cream and it's great if you really like marshmallow cream. They were generous with the marshmallow cream. The carrot cake was perfectly moist and not too sweet, including the cream cheese frosting. The coconut cream pie was delicious with lots of coconut in the filling. The chocolate eclair style cream puff was divine. Service was very friendly.

Our first choice, because of location only, was IHOP. After leaving there with horrible experience…read moreof food and service, my wife and I decided to go try ButterBurr's. So glad we did. OMG!!!! The greeting was excellent! The service from Reese was above and beyond waitressing. Our food was nice and hot. Served in a timely fashion. Coffee was always filled. Upon finishing our meal, Reese asked if there's anything we would like or anything that we think she (Reese) can do for us ? Absolutely not! You have been an excellent waitress. Above and beyond! She smiled and said thank you! We brought our leftovers back to our room where we're staying. Gonna eat this delicious food later for lunch! OMG!!! I can't understand how we got the worst and best restaurants I. Pocatello in one morning! . Thank you so much Teese and ButterBurr's for making us and I'm sure many other patrons full, content and happy! PS: we were in awe after we received our order and began to eat and most of our meal was eaten before we thought of taking a photo but, trust me, ButterBurr's is extremely wonderful to eat. The price?? Very reasonable as well! Loved our visit! Definitely our new 'go to' place, regardless of distance, is our place to go. Thank You!!!! Highly recommended!!!!

My daughter and I were visiting Idaho and stayed overnight in Pocatello. The hotel staff…read morerecommended Butterburrs. We were exhausted after 12+ hours of traveling to get there and so happy that we could DoorDash. The food was delicious. We got pancakes, a Cobb salad, and hash browns. The salad came with a cinnamon roll bread that was really good. If we find ourselves in the area again, we will definitely go to the restaurant to try different things and have some pie!