Had the Catfish special which the Knob Hill Tavern is known for and it lived up to its reputation. Our server Cassidy (I hope got that right) was so sweet and courteous and made this quaint tavern on a rainy night live up to its name. Great staff working together was nice to see and Knob Hill is more than a tavern with separate dining area and an outside patio with patrons dining despite the rain but we went in to the bar area so I could watch the weather reports for my travels the next day on one of their TV's. Great cold fishbowl mugs available and my son even met an old classmate from high school and got caught up on their lives. He even got a peck (kiss) on the cheek from a lady at the next table who couldn't resist his "lure of the animal" and the red face gave us all a chuckle. Great night at Knob Hill Tavern and Thanks again Cassidy for all you do!! read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Their website for all that's offered - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

The service in the bar area at knob hill was excellent. Loved the wooden bar and booths and the food itself was phenomenal. The textures were perfect and the flavors were balanced. They offer fishbowls in frosted glasses and have a good selection of beer and bourbon. read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Catfish bites, side salad, Italian sandwhich with chips and coleslaw - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Knob Hill Tavern has the best Fried Chicken! Service with Ali was perfect! Atmosphere is wonderful. We love Knob Hill

Really Disappointing meal, After hearing about Knob Hill Tavern I have to admit I'm very upset about the quality of food and drinks for being a "Tavern". The menu is underwhelming and drinks are subpar... when I asked if they served cocktails I was told no and given a weird look. When I received my food it was the wrong order and then given the most unappetizing chicken wings (total of 5) for my meal. The atmosphere was great but could not make up for the most boring meal I've had in 2024. If you are looking for a quality drink and meal go elsewhere. read more

let's take it back to old school .. the restaurant is made from an old house the lower seating area seems to be the basement or what was a family room with a fireplace all done with wood paneling. The food selection is outstanding with a lot of seafood options they are known for the drinks in a fish bowl. With weather permitting they have outdoor seating available. The servers are on the go moving non stop to accommodate everyone with a smile. It was kind of hard to hear each other because the space is tight but still enjoyable like being at a large family holiday dinner read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Came here with friends, for a lunchtime meet-up before a round of golf. We sat on their outdoor patio, which was unfortunately overrun with flies. Their bourbon menu was extensive and impressive, but with 18 holes looming we did not partake. :-( I had heard good things about their fried chicken, so I decided to give that platter a go. It came with half a fried chicken, a dinner roll and two sides...I chose creamy cole slaw and potato salad. Their fried chicken was moist on the outside, a light crispy skin on the outside but had absolutely no flavor at all. It was quite disappointing. Both my sides, the creamy cole slaw and potato salads, were just average. Creamy, yes...flavorful, not so much. Locals here seem to love the place, but I just could not get behind the meal I had. read more

See all

good food! I got a pizza (thin crust) and my dad got a catfish and a filet mignon, he said both were good (although the steak could've been bigger/not worth $30, his words), coke products and reasonably priced alcohol. nice staff and cute tavern interior. very clean bathroom! food comes out very hot! beware, i burned the shart out of my mouth read more

GREAT food, great frosty fishbowl and a friendly staff! Every time I go there it is fantastic.

We have eaten a lot of their food, everything was very good. The service is very good and everyone that waited on us is very friendly and helpful. This is a pretty popular place so sometimes you may have a bit of waiting, it's worth the wait. read more

Cute tavern with a dining room and a bar area. I really enjoyed the fried fish. Super crispy and went well with the Tatar sauce. Corn sticks were a bit dry but the beer was probably the closest beer I've ever had. The goblet was frozen and turned part of the beer to slush! Yummm service was as great. Super friend place. Definitely stop by. read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Fiddler - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Always stop past to grab a fish bowl and food if I'm in town, Greek Salad is awesome, same for the fiddlers

Chicken livers and fiddlers are fantastic. Place is a little pricey so I can't do this every day. But very nice.

We sat at the bar and ordered to go. Had a great experience trying catfish for the first time! THE CHICKEN! I got a Greek salad with chicken and it was incredible. We also ordered a pizza & calzone-amazing. We can't wait to go back and try more food!!! read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Catfish bites - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Great Food, service is stellar. Fiddlers rock! Cold beer, good bourbon, good bar. I don't know what else anyone need! read more

Knob Hill Tavern - I come here for the fiddlers and have never been disappointed. I'll certainly be back. Great friendly staff, relaxed atmosphere. - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

I love the location and their Sunday special was on point. The price of their drinks was surprisingly cheap and a great quality read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Sunday special of fried chicken with sweet corn and mashed potatoes along with an old fashion - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

When we arrived, we went inside and waited to be seated. Our first impression of the cleanliness of the stairs and carpet should have been our signal to leave. The waitress came and told us to sit anywhere so we decided to sit on the terrace which was actually very nice. We ordered an appetizer of fried mushrooms. Once they arrived, we knew they were not fresh but frozen and something you could pick up from your local Sam's Club. The taste confirmed that. Since they were so bad, we decided to try the onion rings. Bad idea. The breading was not good and they were overcooked. Our salad came out next which included chopped lettuce and tomato and green pepper bits. Not impressed. They could have left off the green peppers and included larger slices of tomato. The blue cheese dressing was the best part. I ordered mango habanero mahi mahi and a baked potato. It was pretty good and cooked perfectly and the potato was good too but it is hard to mess up a baked potato. In the end, we spent $75.00 on appetizers, salad and main entrees. My husband was reading the reviews as we waited for our bill. Google reviews said it had an average of 4.5 stars. Not sure what they ordered or what other restaurants they have been to, but in my opinion, this was not a good experience. read more

The food was good but the service by Kellyn was outstanding. She was knowledgeable about both food and beverage menu. She made excellent suggestions and her service was so courteous and hospitable. We would go again on our next visit to Newburgh just to be seated in her secrion. read more

Neighborhood place for me, and I've been there several times now. For me the fish platter and the calzone were both excellent. My daughter almost always gets the tenderloin, which might be for her the best food item anywhere. Both of us think the hamburger is just okay, and the fries are delicious. Service and ambience are great as well. Personally I prefer the bar over the restaurant. read more

This is my neighborhood bar. Everything is great on the menu. The staff gets to know you quickly and is very inviting. Great place to eat/ drink in the actual bar. The dining area is separated by a swinging bar door. Outside patio in good weather. Fried chicken and fiddlers are always consistently great. My favorite is the French dip and chicken livers with horseradish dip. Revolving beers and bourbon are specialties. read more

I wanted to love it but honestly it's meh at best. Just because it's local doesn't mean it's good. We went during Mardi Gras because there were some exciting things on an otherwise absolutely ordinary regular menu. unfortunately, it must have been an off night for the kitchen and wait staff as we watched nearly every order that came out to the tables before us come out wrong. Should have been red flag number one. By the time the service staff got to our table, it was pretty obvious they were absolutely over it. We tried to be overly friendly and understanding. It didn't seem to matter. By the end of the meal both servers just came off as unfriendly and almost bordering rude ( if I am entirely honest). The food was incredibly underwhelming. if you are looking for a quaint local bar, this probably wont keep you coming back. Try just about anywhere else. read more

Great food, bar, service & ambiance. Our home bar/restaurant. Always very accomodating.

Great service and great food. The outside patio was perfect for a summer family dinner. Get the hot fiddlers!

Knob Hill Tavern is classic old school Newburgh. Food is good. I like the fiddler sandwich. Tried the crawfish and andouille sausage pizza tonight for Cajun Fest. Pretty good. Could have used some more sausage, but was tasty. read more

Stopped by this Newburgh classic for lunch while visiting family in Evansville. The service is great, our server was prompt and the food arrived quickly as well. The cocktails are a TAD strong so I would err on the side of caution ordering those - however our server did bring us extra limes for our cocktails which I appreciated. The onion rings are really delicious and a decent amount for a medium sized group of 6 people Really enjoyed fried pickles and I'm not even a big fan of pickles! I ordered the calzone with a side of wedges which were really good. My only issue was that the calzone dough seemed to be overdone so I mostly just ate the filling but it was definitely satisfying! Glad I got to check out this place because I've heard a lot and it's one of those "gotta try at least once" kind of places. I'd recommend it if you have a large party as there is plenty of variety on the menu. read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Sign - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

Drinking beers, beers, beers. Love this place. Pizza is surprisingly legit. Fried pickles? Yes, please. Knob Hill keeps a 3Floyds, Bells and Stone on rotation. This place is LOVE for beer drinkers. Totally a Newburgh local hangout. I frequent this place for legit craft beers. Join the party. #morewithmiller #newburgh #beer read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

Wow. I don't know how this place stays in business. Used to be great but the last couple years the food has been only fair and usually cold, the service is terrible, and the place is just dirty. No one takes the time to pick up the floor or clear dirty dishes. The bathrooms are what you would expect at a old gas station on US41. read more

Long wait as we had no reservations, the food was not as good as we thought it would be, most likely won't be back unless we feel obligated, with friends., I did like the atmosphere. read more

Service was good. 1/4 white chicken with slaw and broccoli Chicken Anthony - 3.1/10 1/4 white chicken with Greek salad and fries Chicken Austin - 3.4/10 One lady even said "you're going to need this" as she passed us the salt for the chicken.... read more

My first time to Knob Hill. My friends had recommended it highly. This evening was great--seated at the fireplace which was decorated really well for Christmas. Good prompt service. Great fried mushrooms and onion rings. I had fried chicken with slaw and cheesy broccoli. All was well prepared and presented. Prices fair and reasonable. I will return. read more

Cool old school place. Very comfortable and drinks and food were both awesome. Definitely will be back.

Came in on a late Saturday afternoon around 3pm. They had a Mardi Gras event going on so had a special menu along side the regular one. Spilt some oysters on half shell which weren't bad at all. I ordered the Crawfish Etouffee. Rice was really sweet for whatever reason. Taste was bland outside of that and the portion was small. Paid $19 before tip. Service was decent. Just an alright place from my first visit. I'm sure it's worth coming to drink beer though when we asked for the Zombie Dust which was advertised as on draft they said they had already rotated it out. I think I'd have to recommend Tin Fish more on this side of town if you are wanting some seafood. read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Crawfish Etouffee - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Cozy dining room and very nice outdoor seating. Great selection of beverages. The salmon is my favorite dish!!! The house salad is great too and always fresh!!! read more

We ordered the fried mushrooms as an appetizer and they were served cold and soggy. We told the server and she took them back and asked if we would like a replacement or them taken off of the bill. We elected for it to be removed from the bill as our food should be there shortly. When we received the bill after our meal, the server said that the manager wouldn't remove the mushrooms from the bill because we didn't like them. Worst customer service I have ever received from a restaurant. read more

Had Zombie Dust on tap, ordered wings they were over cooked and dry. Service is always good and help is friendly I'm from here so my 1st time back in 6 yrs . 4 stars is for beer or would have been 3 . read more

Great place for locals and visitors alike. Small but impressive selection of draft brews. Food is always good and menu changes often enough to provide great choices. Specialty menus to reflect Holidays...etc. Wonderful pizza! Plenty of parking and a really nice outdoor area for drinking and dining too. We often take our out of town visitors to Knob Hill, they never disappoint. Hard to go wrong! read more

Knob Hill has been a favorite for many years. Consistently good food with the occasional surprise. I enjoy the rotating brews on draft. Their deck is great for warmer weather. read more

Tonight marked my second visit in a 6 mth. period. I know it is a beloved Newburgh tavern for many who visit regularly-but I won't be one of them! And here is why: During my 1st visit I ordered Fiddlers (Fried Catfish for those non-residents). They tasted slightly "off" and I should have sent them back. Later I was sick with food poisoning. My friend wanted to go this evening because they were featuring Cajun foods for Mardi Gras. She wanted Fried Oysters, but was told they only had raw. I wondered why the kitchen did shuck some and fry them! She decided on a sandwich with Fried Gator meat. The meat was tough and chewy. I ordered a New Orleans staple - Red Beans & Rice. For some reason they served a Fried Chicken Leg on the side. It was tasty. However there was far more rice than beans. In fact, it wasn't anything like what is served in Louisiana! Instead of thick soupy beans, they were individual beans on the dry side with rounds of dried out sausage. The piece of French Bread served on the side was stale. The best part of this meal was the fried Potatoes and 2 mixed drinks. It will take some convincing for me to return for anything other than a drink. read more

Better than average pub grub. That pork tenderloin you remember from college - it's here! Huge salads, and great pizza. The house special is still 'fiddlers' which is available filleted boneless if your not used to native style with head and fins. Reasonable priced cocktails, wines, and beers. Free parking and al fresco available in season or Al Aire Libra for the Hispanic community. read more

Knob Hill Tavern - A happy, tasty place. Pork tenderloin you betcha! Best German made pizza North of the Ohio. - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Great food! Great service! Great beer selection! This is my go to location in Newburgh. Take out, sit in the family area, sit on the deck, belly up to the bar, no mater where you land you will have a great experience. read more

Knob Hill Tavern - Great beer selection. Enjoying a Great Divide Oaked Yeti Imperial Stout. - Bars Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

If you're looking for a place where "everybody knows your name and are glad you came" then Knob Hill is the place for you.